[00:00] Where would you live? What would you wear? And what would you eat? Something like bread, pottage, or this 14th-century recipe for fried beans and onions. [00:17] So thank you to Wildgrain for sponsoring this video as we try to eat like a medieval hermit this time on Tasting History. [00:29] Well the short answer is a monk or a holy person who has decided to remove themselves from society in order to live  a solitary life of quiet contemplation. [00:41] The long answer is something we'll get to a little bit  later because, frankly, it is not so simple.   Sometimes actually, it was a little too simple. [00:53] Like in the case of the Anglo-Saxon hermit Saint Guthlac, who lived in a hut on top of a burial mound in 8th-century Lincolnshire, he "... ate no food of any kind except that after sunset, he took a scrap of barley bread and a small cup of muddy water. [01:05] For when the sun reached its western limits, then he thankfully tasted some little provision for the needs of this mortal life." Granted, he did die around 40, so maybe taking dietary advice from him is not the best idea. [01:23] Perhaps a little wiser would be reading the 13th-century Ancrene Wisse, which was a set of rules meant for anchorites, a particular type of religious recluse who committed themselves, ideally for life, to living in a small enclosed space, often attached to a church. [01:39] Seems rather strict, but in many ways it was less strict than Saint Guthlac.   "You shall eat no flesh, nor fat, except in great sickness whosoever is infirm may eat vegetable pottage contentedly; and accustom yourselves to little drink. Nevertheless, dear sisters,   [01:54] it has often seemed to me that your food and drink  are less than I would wish. Do not fast on any day on bread and water unless you have leave." Now most of the accounts of medieval hermits and their diets focus on herbs, vegetables, and beans, [02:13] and that is why I have chosen this 14th century recipe from 'The Forme of Cury' for fried beans, or "Benes yfryed. Take beans and seed them almost till they bursten. Take and wring out the water clean. [02:26] Do thereto onions and salt and any minced and garlic and therewith, and serve it forth."  So essentially, it says to boil some beans  until they e-bursten, till they break apart,   [02:40] and then you're going to add some garlic and some  onions and fry it all in oil, and then you can add some sweet powders, powdered douce, like cinnamon or sugar or nutmeg or mace. [02:52] And these would not have been on the table of any decent hermit, at least. Technically, the recipe is written for a king, so that's why they're in there. So since I'm making this for a hermit, I'm going to swap out the sweet spices for some common herbs. [03:07] Something else that would not be on the table of a medieval hermit would be chocolate chip cookies or croissants Wildgrain is simply one of my favorite parts of the month when I get my Wildgrain box because [03:21] they are the first bake-from-frozen subscription box that gathers breads and pastries and pasta from small bakeries around the country. And so, when you want to make fresh bread, you don't have to spend hours and hours making the dough and letting it rise, etc., etc. Instead,   [03:36] it's 25 minutes in the oven and your house smells  like a bakery. My parents were visiting last week and I wanted them to try some of the pastries and my favorite chocolate chip cookies from Wildgrain,   and it turns out, of course, they loved them,  and now I know what I'll be getting them for Christmas. [03:52] Yes, Wildgrain does make an excellent holiday gift, and it makes a great way to So if you want to try it for yourself, you can get $30 off of your first box plus free croissants for life when you use my link in the description, [04:08] wildgrain.com/tastinghistory, or scan this QR code and use my code TASTINGHISTORY to get $30 off of your first box plus free croissants for life. Now unfortunately, I would not have been able to be a medieval hermit because I needs my cookies. But, [04:25] for today, I'm going to give it a shot by making this recipe for beans yfryed, for which you'll need 1 lb or 450 grams of dried fava or broad beans. All the other beans that we think of are New World beans. [04:42] Then one small onion, one to two cloves of garlic, three or four tablespoons of olive oil, and then some powder douce or herbs. And if you want to use that powder douce, sweet spices, which is what the recipe actually calls for,   [04:54] then maybe a teaspoon of a mixture of cinnamon and nutmeg and mace and whatnot. If you want to use herbs, then you want a couple tablespoons, that's what I'm using. Then, it's time to soften your beans by putting them in a pot of water and bringing it to a boil. [05:12] Let it boil for a couple minutes, then turn off the heat, set the lid on,   The next morning, you can drain them of their brown water and rinse them with clean water, [05:24] and then put them back in the pot with fresh water and bring again to a boil. This time, you're going to boil them for 1 to 2 hours or until they begin to burstin. Then drain them and rinse them again, and now you can remove the skins. [05:37] Now technically, you don't have to remove the skins.  They are edible, but depending on the fava bean,   they can be kind of bitter and really tough  to chew, so I just take them off.   Then you can simmer the onions for a couple minutes if you want to soften them up, but they're going to soften quite a bit when you fry them. [05:54] So you can also just add them to the beans along  with the garlic and mix everything together. Then heat the oil in a pan over medium-high heat and add the bean and onion and garlic mixture and start to fry. [06:07] Also, if you do see that something is starting to burn  or they just look dry, you can add a little more oil. Let them fry for about 10 minutes or until the onions have become nice and tender, [06:21] and then turn down the heat and add in the herbs or the spices, whichever you choose. Stir them in and let them cook for another 3 to 4 minutes, and then they are ready to eat. But before we eat them, I want to let you know that just like last year, I am signing a bunch of the Tasting History Cookbooks [06:36] through Diesel, which is an independent bookstore, but they ship all over the world. So if you want a signed copy for the holidays, I will put a link in the description. They are closing their orders on December 10th, so definitely order before that [06:51] And now, let us take a closer look at the diet and life of a medieval hermit. The idea of the hermit, at least when it comes to  Christianity, dates back way before the medieval era. [07:07] Tradition has it that the man who started it  all was Paul of Thebes or Paul the Anchorite.   He was living in Egypt in the 3rd and 4th century,  and he claimed to have lived alone in the desert   from the age of 16 until the ripe old age of 113. [07:21] He kicked off the lifestyle of going out into the desert and living alone eating nothing but dates,  wild lettuce, and uncooked lentils. Those are the specific diets of the hermits Onuphrius, Heron, and Hilarion, respectively. [07:33] These men, and indeed many of the early hermits, were desert dwellers. That's actually where the word hermit comes from. It comes from the Greek eremos, which meant wilderness or desert. [07:45] But for the medieval hermit, eremos was rarely a literal desert and more of a spiritual desert, though they would sometimes often actually go out into the wilderness to live. And they would have read about the lives of these early hermits, and they would have modeled their own life after that. [08:02] How they dressed, how they lived, and of course how they ate. Though these ancients were usually far more ascetic, at least according to the tales. Hilarion only ate uncooked lentils for 3 years.   [08:14] This was followed by 3 years of bread, salt, and  water, 3 years of wild herbs and roots,   and then 5 years of barley bread and vegetables cooked without oil, and only at the age of 35 did he add olive oil when his health dictated it. So, that  sort of strict regimen was seen as the ideal. [08:32] But why? Why was it desirable to remove yourself from  society and eat so meagerly? Well part of it had to do with recreating the 40 days that Moses went up to Mount Sinai and ate no food and drank no water. [08:47] A similar 40-day desert fast was also part of Jesus' story. But it was also because good food and drink could be seen as a distraction from the contemplative monastic lifestyle. In the 14th century, an English hermit known as Richard Rolle, who I like to think his friends would have called Rick Rolle, [09:05] he wrote a letter saying, "Some are deceived with too much desire and delight in food and drink. They exceed moderation and proceed to excess, and take delight in it.   And they believe that it is no sin, and so they do not reform themselves, and thus they destroy the virtues of their soul. [09:22] Some are beguiled with too much abstinence from food and drink and sleep,   and is designed to make them fall in the middle of their work so that they may not bring it to its conclusion... [09:34] There have been many, and there still are, who think they are doing nothing at all, unless they practice such great abstinence and fasting that everyone who knows them talks about it." but you also didn't want to starve yourself, especially if it was just so other people would see how pious you are. [09:54] After all, the whole idea of being a hermit is to go away from people, Now, if a hermit is living out in the wilderness in a hut,   [10:07] how are they feeding themselves? How are they  getting food? Because food ain't free. Hermits actually had a number of ways to get their food and drink and other things paid for them. [10:22] Now the best way, of course, would be to get them via miracle like Saint Cuthbert. He was living on a hut built on a rock on an island with no access to fresh water. So he dug a hole in the rock and the next morning it was filled with pure clean water. [10:34] As for food, at first it was the monks from his former monastery who would bring him bread,   but he didn't want to be a burden, so he  decided, well, I'll make my own bread. So he got some wheat seeds from them and planted the wheat, but it didn't grow. So, then he decided,   [10:49] okay, I'll do barley. And if this doesn't work, I will move back into the monastery so you all don't have to feed me. Well, despite it being way too late in the season to actually grow barley,   there was a bit of a miracle and  the barley grew like gangbusters,   [11:04] but then a bunch of birds came and ate it all  before he could get any. So frustrated Saint Cuthbert went up to those birds and said, "Why do you touch that which you have not sown? Have you more share than I in this? [11:16] but if not, get you gone, and do no further injury to that which belongs to another." Well no sooner had he finished his little speech to  the birds and they flew off never to return again to his field. [11:30] Unfortunately, Saint Cuthbert does seem to have been the outlier   because most hermits had to rely on the kindness  of strangers for their food. Begging was kind of the number one way to to get their stuff, [11:46] but even then, there were rules specifically laid out in the rule of Celestine, which says, "A poor hermit who lives in a borough, town, or city, or near to one, where he can readily beg for his food every day, should distribute what is left of his food, if there be any left, [12:01] But if he lives a long way from the said places... or in a deserted place, one or two miles distant from other people,   then he should get supplies for exactly one week,  that is from Sunday to Sunday... [12:15] The author also wants to make sure that while you are living the simple life as a hermit, you need to make sure to still take care of yourself. So that means your clothes should be basic, but they  shouldn't be dirty. [12:28] As Saint Bernard said, "I have loved poverty, but never filth." The text also says that while clothes shouldn't be too comfortable, no fine linens or anything, they should also not be so uncomfortable that they distract the hermit from their true purpose. [12:43] So, yes, a hair shirt, which was an uncomfortable shirt literally made of coarse goat or horse hair, was okay sometimes, it was not an every day garment. "If, out of devotion he wants to wear a hair shirt against his flesh, that is certainly permitted, [12:58] except when he is engaged in contemplative prayer, when the biting of the worms that come out of the hair shirt might hinder him from his contemplation, and thus make him think more about the miseries of his flesh than the contemplation of his spirit. [13:11] And so, we leave the question of the hair shirt to his conscience." Now, begging could also have its pitfalls because you were entirely reliant   Take the case of Stephen of Obazine, a monk in 12th century France, who decided to become a hermit along with a priest named Peter. [13:29] They went into the forest, and they had no survival skills, And it was only when a peasant woman came by and  gave them some bread and milk that uh they were able to not die, [13:45] but from there, word of their presence in the forest spread to nearby villages,   and so other peasants would come and feed them and  take care of them, until an interloper arrived, another hermit set up in their same forest. [13:59] This hermit told the villagers that he would say mass for them if they brought him food and gifts and clothes and whatnot, which they did. But then, when they came to hear the mass, he  was gone. [14:14] And unfortunately, the people were upset and took their anger out on poor Stephen. And so, they ended up not giving him any more food, and they had to live off of roots and bark and yeah, wasn't great. [14:31] Perhaps a safer course of action would have been, instead of begging from peasants, to have begged from the rich. In King Henry VIII's personal expenditure accounts, he made regular gifts to a number of hermits. [14:43] In May 1531, it says, "Item, the 6th day paid in alms to a hermit upon the way, 4 shillings, 8 pence." Many other hermits, instead of living out in the woods, would live in a hut or a small house [14:56] on a large estate and be taken care of by the lord of the manor. In fact, Richard Rolle, Rick Rolle, he was taken care of by a squire. Then there was Julian of Norwich, who was not only supported by wealthy members of the town, [15:11] she even appeared in at least two of their wills. Thomas Edmon left her 12 pence with another 8 going to her servant Sarah,   and John Plumpton left "... forty pence to the anchoress in the church of St. Julian's Conesford, in Norwich,   [15:24] and twelve pence to her maid, [and the same amount to her] former maid, alice." Now, when you think of a hermit, you don't usually think of someone who has a maid or several servants sometimes. [15:36] But it was actually rather common. And those servants would usually be paid in extra food and clothing.   And there were several reasons for this necessity  laid out by the rule of Celestine. "A hermit should never go out alone, if he can readily have a companion or servant with him. [15:52] but he should send his servant as a messenger to do the things he needs doing - so that he doesn't derive too much bodily enjoyment from illicit wandering about." [16:04] Then there were those who needed servants to literally survive. These were the anchorites, like Julian of Norwich, who  was the one who was mentioned in those wills. Now the term anchorite or anchoress changes depending  on the time and location, but in general,   [16:22] it was someone who was like a hermit, but they  were set in one spot and would not leave that spot Now men and women would do this, but in the 13th and 14th century, it became very popular with women mostly [16:38] who just chose to live this extremely solitary lifestyle. Essentially, what you had to do was you needed to convince a church to let you become an anchoress. [16:50] They wanted to know that you could withstand the solitude and that you could   pay for yourself or have someone else pay for  your upkeep, and then you would have a cell or small room built usually alongside attached to the church where you would live for the rest of your life. [17:08] Ideally, an anchorite cell would have only three windows. The first was the church window,   which looked in on the church so that they could  watch the Eucharist. And this was never meant to have any talking. There was no communication through that window. [17:22] The second window, the house window, this was where food and other goods could be passed through to and from the anchoress,   "When an anchoress has not her food at hand, let two women be employed. One who stays always at home, another who goes out when necessary,   [17:41] And you better hope that those women knew how to cook because if the food sucked, you couldn't complain. "Do not grumble on account of either food or drink, be it ever so stale; if it may be eaten, let her eat, and devoutly thank God for it; [17:58] and if it may not, let her grieve that she must ask for  more palatable food." Other than these two women, the only companion an anchoress was allowed to have was a cat, Now if they did need to talk to someone from the outside world, [18:14] maybe a patron or their family members, or if they were a nun or a monk, their former brothers and sisters, then they had to do so through the single window that went to the outside. [18:28] This was the parlor window, and it was meant to be very, very small and kept shut at all times unless actively talking through it. This window was not meant to be used for gossip, romantic trysts, or preaching, [18:41] all things which were called out and so must have been an issue with some anchorites. And of course, it is not to be used for sharing a meal with someone. This is too much friendliness... for an anchoress, who is dead to the world. [18:58] One has often heard that the dead have spoken with the living, but that they have eaten with the living, I have never yet found." Now these seem like trivial rules to break, but they  do seem to have been broken rather often. However, I think a bit of gossip does not preclude someone from being a bad hermit or or anchoress. [19:18] In the 14th century poem Piers Plowman, it talks about the two types of hermits. There was the pious, holy hermit, and then there are [19:31] "...hermits that hang around by the highway and in towns among tavern-women, and beg in churches... They're nothing but beer-swilling layabouts: no breeding or education..." There are tales of hermits preaching and gathering a following, which then they would take advantage of. [19:47] In 1310, Thomas de Byreford, the hermit of Cripplegate in London, was  hearing confession, administering the sacrament,   and advertising indulgences should you visit his  hermitage and give an expected donation.   [20:00] All of those activities were absolutely forbidden  to hermits, but he pales in comparison with "John Benet, hermit of St. James, Chester, [he] is a receiver of common criminals and maintains such miscreants in his lodging etc., [20:16] and that he keeps a common brothel within his aforesaid dwelling..." But at least these guys were real hermits. Hermits  behaving badly, but real hermits all the same.   What you really needed to look out for was the  false hermit, like William Blakeney who in 1412 [20:32] "...was brought unto the Guildhall... barefooted and with long hair, under the guise of sanctity,   and pretended to be a hermit, saying that he was such and that he had made pilgrimage to Jerusalem, Rome, Venice, and the city of Seville in Spain; [20:45] he had and received many good things from divers  persons, to the defrauding and in manifest deceit, of all the people.... And therefore... William should be put upon the pillory for three market days,   [20:59] there to remain for one hour each day... a whetstone  hung from his neck." was to tell people that you were getting ready to go on a pilgrimage and that you needed food and donations and whatnot. [21:14] you'd just spend it on booze or whatever. That was the modus operandi of Edward the Hermit, real name Robert Beckworth, [21:27] who in 1402 would dress up like a hermit to gain entry into people's houses,   and then he would take them for all they were worth, take all their jewels and their cash and absolutely everything. [21:41] It was also said that he was part of a gang of highway robbers. But those, of course, are the false hermits and their dealing should not concern us. What concerns us are the true eating habits of the true hermits. [21:55] Richard Rolle talks about the ancient hermits and their diets of leaves and roots. Saint Germanus mixed ashes with his bread, that he should feel no pleasure in his mealtime. [22:09] So, I suppose you can be glad that I'm not making a meal of leaves and ashes,   but rather taking a page from the somewhat  less ascetic medieval hermits with this dish,   [22:21] And here we are, benes yfryed, a simple meal fit for a medieval hermit.   This is not a fancy meal. I mean, it's not supposed to be, but it is [22:35] pretty basic, but let's get some onions and  beans and give this a shot. [chomp] [22:48] I mean- If I added those spices, it would definitely really liven things up, make it just more interesting. [23:00] Would be an odd combination, too. You know, sugar and cinnamon, and nutmeg, and things like that with As it is,  there is flavor. You're getting the flavor of the  onions and the garlic and, you know, a little bit of the herbs. [23:19] But it's just so simple, and frankly, I don't like fava beans all that much.   They are hearty food. You definitely want to  cook them enough to where they are nice and soft.   [23:32] It is kind of nice, though, that the onions, while  they are nice and soft, still have some texture to them. You don't want to cook them so long that they're just mush because the beans are mush. So-   [23:44] you want some texture there. But frankly, that is  exactly what you want for a hermit meal.   You don't want it to be too fancy. You want it to be  basic. You don't want to be wishing [23:56] Now, the hermits, at least in England,   sort of died away following the dissolution of the  monasteries uh by Henry the VIII, but they made   [24:09] a comeback in the 18th century, but they  weren't religious hermits. They were ornamental   hermits. Essentially, the rich people of England  had these huge gardens, yards that were acres and   [24:22] acres, and they wanted to have a little  hermit living in a hovel somewhere on their   property kind of as a way to entertain guests  either just by looking at them and they would   [24:34] dress them up in robes and give them a wizened  beard and whatnot. And sometimes they would have   them giving advice and everything like that. And  then sometimes they wanted them just to be silent   off off in the wilderness. In 1797 a Mr. William  Gell who was a traveler described a particularly   [24:52] unusual job offer from a Mr. Pocklington who  was going to pay a half crown a day to one   of these ornamental hermits and he laid out  what he wanted. The hermit is never to leave   [25:05] the place or hold conversation with anyone for 7  years during which he is neither to wash himself   or cleanse himself in any way whatever but is to  let his hair and nails both on hands and feet grow   [25:18] as long as nature will permit them. Now it seems  that Mr. Pocklington was never able to fill this   this post. Surprise there. Um and so maybe that's  why in the 1840s garden gnomes ended up becoming   [25:31] a popular thing. I don't know. Anyway,  signed Tasting History books available until   December 10th. Link is in the description and I  will see you next time on Tasting History.