---
title: 'Volkswagen VS Subaru Rivalry in Pennsylvania'
source: 'https://youtube.com/watch?v=XJw0uOeocqs'
video_id: 'XJw0uOeocqs'
date: 2026-10-26
duration_sec: 441
channel: 'Regular Car Reviews'
---

# Volkswagen VS Subaru Rivalry in Pennsylvania

> Source: [Volkswagen VS Subaru Rivalry in Pennsylvania](https://youtube.com/watch?v=XJw0uOeocqs)

## Summary

This video explores the unique automotive rivalry between Subaru and Volkswagen in central Pennsylvania, a phenomenon not seen elsewhere in North America. The creator investigates the cultural, historical, and practical reasons behind this regional preference, touching on immigration patterns, harsh weather, and the shared culture of car modification.

### Key Points

- **The Unusual Rivalry** [00:02] — In central Pennsylvania, the car rivalry is between Subaru and Volkswagen, unlike the rest of North America where it's typically Subaru vs. Mitsubishi or German vs. Japanese brands.
- **Giveaway Announcement** [00:41] — The creator announces a giveaway for a 2007 Subaru STI, ending today, encouraging viewers to visit fanofthem.com/regularcars and buy merchandise to enter.
- **Ethnicity and Immigration** [01:34] — One theory for the rivalry is Pennsylvania's history of German immigration, leading to a cultural preference for Volkswagen cars, with a disproportionate number of VW dealers in the area.
- **Harsh Weather Conditions** [02:30] — Pennsylvania experiences extreme weather in all four seasons, requiring cars that can handle everything from brutal heat to heavy snow, making versatile vehicles like Subarus and Volkswagens popular.
- **Performance and Practicality** [03:13] — Subaru and Volkswagen emerged as the dominant, fun, cheap way to get performance and a vehicle that does everything, fitting the evolutionary state of the terrain.
- **Street Racing Culture** [04:07] — The creator recalls street races between Subarus and Volkswagens in Schuylkill County, highlighting a culture of modifying cars to look 'disgusting' with fart pipes and rusted panels.
- **Commonalities and Conclusion** [05:51] — Despite being German and Japanese, Subaru and Volkswagen share similarities in affordability, all-weather capability, and excellent air conditioning, making them a natural rivalry in Pennsylvania.

### Conclusion

The video concludes that the Subaru vs. Volkswagen rivalry in central Pennsylvania is a unique cultural phenomenon driven by German heritage, harsh weather, and a shared car modification culture, making both brands ideal for the region's needs.

## Transcript

Pennsylvania between two cars and it's a little bit odd. It's between Subaru and Volkswagen. Little weird, isn't it? In most of the nor In most of North America, the rival
rivalry has always been between Subaru and Mitsubishi, right? STI versus Evo. Or it has been between Volkswagen and
well, maybe Audi, but BMW, you know, German versus German and Japanese versus Japanese. But in central Pennsylvania, something odd happened from the mid-90s
into the mid-2000s. It was Subaru versus Volkswagen. Now, why? Why was that a thing? be doing my job if I didn't tell you that this beautiful STI
can be yours. The giveaway is ending soon. So, ending on Monday. In other words, today. Today is Monday. I just farted. Today is Monday. The giveaway is ending today, like now, like in a few hours, like now,
now, now, now, now. Anyway, back to other me. This is a 2007 Subaru STI manual transmission with a bigger inner cooler and about 320 horsepower. Go to
fanofthem.com/regularcars. Buy some merch and someone's going to be entered to win this. I'm having fun with this and you will, too. But back to I've talked to other automotive
enthusiasts in Pennsylvania and tried to figure out why this is. Some people have said it's because of and just come with me on this, ethnicity. Pennsylvania was mostly settled by
German immigrants. Well, I mean, we have Polish and here, but primarily it's a dramatic state. people tend to like cars from the homeland.
And there's a lot of Volkswagen dealers, almost a disproportionate amount, in Pennsylvania, particularly in central Pennsylvania. my mom drives one. My brother drives one. Um lots of my
friends drove Volkswagens growing up. Granted, I know it's the GM equivalent. Granted, I know it's the GM equivalent. It's Volkswagen is Germany's GM. But there's something else that's going on in Pennsylvania.
Horrific weather. Pennsylvania has four seasons, and every single one of them is raging. Our summers, Our summers, brutally hot. Our winters, bitingly
cold. And every winter, we get at least one big dump. I mean, yes, in Pennsylvania sometimes we get small amounts of snow, but generally there is one day where the state shuts down. Sometimes it's just the east east side,
sometimes on the other side of the Susquehanna where sodas pop. But we need cars that can do nearly everything. do. Everything and also fast.
So, by nature of the almost evolutionary state of our terrain, Subaru and Volkswagen emerged Subaru and Volkswagen emerged as the dominant, fun, cheap way to get
performance and to have a vehicle that does everything. Doug, my camera person, is your GTI all-wheel drive? &gt;&gt; Front-wheel drive. It's the Golf R that's all-wheel drive.
&gt;&gt; Yes, thank you. Now, obviously the all-wheel drive Subaru will dominate this in the snow because this is all-wheel drive in the front. But to be honest, front-wheel drive and a good set of snow
front-wheel drive and a good set of snow tires will get you through almost almost everything but the worst of weather. But,
in my time doing regular car reviews, and it seems that Pennsylvania is the only place that has this Volkswagen Subaru rivalry. And I remember growing up specifically in Schuylkill County and seeing street races between these two
types of cars all the time. Because there's something else about these the culture surrounding Subarus and Volkswagens. And that's acting like a complete douchebag and making your car look
disgusting. I like everything about this one. I would have never done this, but I recognize that many people love the fart pipes. And so
and so on the Volkswagens as well. They love that as well. love that as well. Volkswagens in particular, they liked making their cars fast, but also making them look like piles of garbage. There
has been this Volkswagen thing and this goes back to the '90s of taking the quarter panel off here, sanding it down to bare metal, urinating on it, so it rusts, putting it back on.
See? This is the almost in a sort of Limp Bizkit way, like, "I don't give a fuck." That sort of thing. Subarus as well. We all know about straight-piped WRXs
and STIs. Just simultaneously making wooshing sounds and farting sounds at the same time. So, it seems that this German car and this Japanese car have a lot more in common
than the rest of the country would you know, ascribe to them. And they're affordable. And they work in all weather. the air conditioning on both of them is very, very good.
I have to hand it to Subaru and to well, Volkswagens Their air conditioning and heaters are pretty That that in all the Volkswagens I've had and I think uh Doug or Cameron can
&gt;&gt; Yeah. &gt;&gt; It is cold instantly. This uh needs a little bit probably cuz you have this big inner cooler right on top. Kind of heat soaking stuff in there. I know it really doesn't matter cuz your your AC
condenser is down here, but still yeah, that the Volkswagens get hot faster and they get cool faster. This one not as much. But I hope you enjoyed this little insight into rural Pennsylvania.
Now, which one do I choose? Well, I'm partial to Japanese cars and plus this said this, but I cannot deny the popularity and usefulness of Volkswagen for a car that exists in all weather, does everything
you want it to, and has a wide aftermarket support base. that's central Pennsylvania for you. Come visit. We're more than just Philly. Come visit. We're more than just Philly. Even though Philly rules. Go Birds.
