---
title: '"Permaban is too harsh"'
source: 'https://youtube.com/watch?v=Ns7WDNiQv-I'
video_id: 'Ns7WDNiQv-I'
date: 2026-11-17
duration_sec: 165
channel: 'Xaryu'
---

# "Permaban is too harsh"

> Source: ["Permaban is too harsh"](https://youtube.com/watch?v=Ns7WDNiQv-I)

## Summary

The video discusses a gold-farming exploit in the Blackmaul Hold dungeon in World of Warcraft, where players could earn over 100 gold per hour by killing non-elite mobs. The creator argues that Blizzard's response should be proportionate, advocating for removing the gold and issuing a temporary ban rather than a permanent one. The video also touches on the broader implications for the game's economy and Blizzard's credibility.

### Key Points

- **The Blackmaul Hold Room** [00:01] — A room in Blackmaul Hold contains 30 non-elite mobs that only auto-attack but drop lots of loot, making them a prime target for farming.
- **Efficient Farming Technique** [00:17] — Groups can make the run efficient by mounting through the first area and using a large fall to drop aggro. Mages can solo this area using locations where mobs cannot path to reset the run.
- **Loot and Gold Drops** [00:43] — Each mob drops 25 to 50 silver in raw currencies, plus vendor items and greens. Mobs also drop Motes of Unstable Magic, valued at 13 silver each.
- **Blizzard's Hotfix and Player Gains** [00:58] — Blizzard hotfixed the mobs to no longer drop any loot, but some players had already made thousands of gold, with some earning 100 gold per hour.
- **Punishment Options** [01:39] — The creator argues that a permanent ban is too harsh. They suggest removing the gold as a bare minimum, and propose a one-month ban to let exploiters miss raid opening week.
- **Fairness and Credibility** [02:05] — The creator emphasizes that Blizzard must handle all players equally, whether streamers or not, to maintain credibility and avoid inflating the economy.

## Transcript

there any uh news? Anything new happening? Nothing? No. Cool. In the blackma hold, there's a room filled with 30 blackma devotees. These creatures are non- elites that only auto attack, but can drop lots of loot. Uh-oh. This
dungeon, but by mounting through the first area and using the large fall as a clever aggro drop, groups can make this run efficient. Mages can even get to this area solo using locations where mobs cannot path to in order to reset
reset the run, and go for more gold. So, it's Zul Farac zombie farms, but on steroids. Instead of running into Zulock and clicking all the graves, you run into blackma hold and kill all of these. Loot them, reset, rinse, repeat, rinse,
repeat, rinse, repeat. Each of these mobs can drop 25 to 50 silver in raw currencies. Blizzard. No one No one thought about this. It's not elites, dropping half a gold a pop, as well as additional vendor items and greens.
Blizzard mobs also drop modes of unstable magic, which are valued at 13 mobs have been hot fixed and no longer drop any loot. Okay, good. So, it it it was a few hours. Some players have claimed to use this to make thousands of
gold. That's what you guys were telling me. Some people out there with four, five, 10,000 gold from this farm. 100 gold an hour. So they nerfed AoE farm to now people that did abuse it are trying to manipulate the auction house. So what
are they going to do? Does the casual gamer now get effed over? They should think should do something here. Removing the gold I think is a bare minimum. The gold, how do you handle that? I also know about a couple people from my guild
swimming in gold. You have like three modes here. It's remove the gold, remove the gold and temp ban them and remove the gold and perma ban. I think a perma ban is too far. I think remove the gold as a bare minimum. Roll back their
characters and zero their gold. Then hand them a one month ban. Let them miss raid opening week and unable to make any timesensitive and relevant content over vanishingly little choice. They can let these exploiters wreak havoc on their
core economy design pillar. Sacrifice any and all credibility on the matter. Inflate gold for all a mere two weeks into launch and add infinitum with every exploit discovered and abused. Or they can do the right thing. Stop handling
streamers and known content creators in clear breach of to us with a tread on eggshells same as everyone else. Whoa, that I was like on the same sentence. I don't know what this guy's
non-streamer alike. Okay, let's not pretend like the the post is literally saying, I also know a couple people from my guild swimming in gold. Streamers and non-streamers, let's be clear here. purchases from the auction
