---
title: 'PS5 vs. Xbox vs. Switch 2: Who Had the Best 2026 Exclusives? - Next-Gen Console Watch'
source: 'https://youtube.com/watch?v=29zHF41_54I'
video_id: '29zHF41_54I'
date: 2026-11-06
duration_sec: 1196
channel: 'IGN'
---

# PS5 vs. Xbox vs. Switch 2: Who Had the Best 2026 Exclusives? - Next-Gen Console Watch

> Source: [PS5 vs. Xbox vs. Switch 2: Who Had the Best 2026 Exclusives? - Next-Gen Console Watch](https://youtube.com/watch?v=29zHF41_54I)

## Summary

The video is a panel discussion from IGN's Next-Gen Console Watch, where hosts Damon Hatfield, Ryan McCaffrey, and Nick Limon analyze and compare the exclusive game lineups for PlayStation 5, Xbox, and Nintendo Switch 2 in 2026. They break down each platform's actual and console exclusives by review scores, share personal opinions, and discuss future exclusive prospects like The Elder Scrolls 6.

### Key Points

- **PS5 Exclusive Lineup Analysis** [00:36] — PS5 had three actual exclusives: God of War: Sorrow's (7/10), Wolverine (6/10), and Saros (6/10), averaging 6.33. Console exclusives (Nioh 3, Silent Hill Townfall, Phantom Blade Zero) averaged 8.75. Combined average: 7.7.
- **Xbox Exclusive Lineup Analysis** [01:18] — Xbox had zero actual exclusives. Console exclusives included Replaced (7/10), Subnautica 2 (7/10), Forza Horizon 6 (10/10), Gears of War E-Day (9/10), and Lightyear Frontier (7/10), averaging 8.0.
- **Nintendo Exclusive Lineup Analysis** [01:44] — Nintendo had many actual exclusives: Mario Tennis Fever (7/10), Pokémon Pokopia (9/10), Yoshi and the Mysterious Book (9/10), Splatoon Raiders (9/10), Orbitals (10/10), Ocarina of Time (9/10), and Nintendo Switch Sports Resort (7/10), averaging 8.1.
- **Forza Horizon 6 Praise** [02:24] — Ryan McCaffrey highlights Forza Horizon 6 as a standout, scoring a perfect 10/10 from reviewer Luke Reilly, who has given 10s to Forza Horizon 4, 5, and 6. The game finally takes the series to Japan.
- **Gears of War E-Day Review** [03:25] — Ryan McCaffrey calls Gears of War E-Day the best post-trilogy Gears game, praising its single-player campaign, combat evolutions, set pieces, and characters. He gave it a 9/10.
- **Sony's First-Party Decline** [05:34] — Nick Limon expresses disappointment with Sony's first-party output in 2026, calling it the weakest year for PlayStation exclusives. He notes that while Sony offers visually impressive games, Microsoft's offerings like Gears and Forza wowed him more.
- **Phantom Blade Zero as Standout** [07:09] — Nick Limon considers Phantom Blade Zero the game to beat this year, despite being third-party. It's a console exclusive for PS5 but also available on PC, making it accessible to a wider audience.
- **Nintendo's Strong Output** [07:51] — Nintendo had the largest output of exclusives, including the Ocarina of Time remake, Starfox 64 remake, Pokémon Pokopia, and Fire Emblem: Fortune's We (10/10). The hosts agree it's hard to criticize Nintendo's lineup.
- **Elder Scrolls 6 Exclusivity Debate** [13:11] — Ryan McCaffrey argues that The Elder Scrolls 6 (titled 'Sentinel') should be an Xbox console exclusive to drive console sales, given its massive anticipated popularity. He notes the game could be the second biggest of the decade after GTA 6.
- **Timed Exclusive Prediction** [16:57] — Nick Limon predicts The Elder Scrolls 6 will be a timed exclusive, launching on PlayStation later as a Game of the Year edition, similar to Skyrim's multi-platform success.

## Transcript

hardware. I'm Damon Hatfield, coming to you from home. I would love to be in studio with Nick Lemon. Unfortunately, my son is home sick today, so I am also Uh and calling in from home is Ryan McCaffrey.
And with The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time remake out now, that is the last big console exclusive of the year. Probably a good time to start taking stock of which platform had the strongest exclusive lineup in 2026. So,
let's break down each platform by the numbers, starting with PlayStation 5. I think PS5 had three games: God of War: Sorrow's, which got a seven; and Wolverine, which got a six. An average
Not good. Not a Not a good actual exclusive lineup this &gt;&gt; okay one. &gt;&gt; Some Well, some might say, "Okay." But their just console exclusive lineup was much stronger. They had Nioh 3, which
Silent Hill Townfall got an eight; and Phantom Blade Zero got a nine, which is an average of 8.75. Very high score. So, if you take the total average between exclusives, their average score was a 7.7 this year, which is good.
Turning your eyes to Xbox, actual exclusives, zero. Xbox has not had an actual exclusive in a very long time. But as for console exclusives, they had Replaced, which got a seven; Subnautica 2, which got a seven; Forza Horizon 6,
got a 10; 33 Immortals, which we didn't review; Gears of War E-Day, got a nine; and Lightyear Frontier, got a seven, with an average score of an eight. So, average great average great score for their Xbox's console exclusives. And
finally, Nintendo had a ton of actual exclusives. They had Mario Tennis Fever, which got a seven; Pokémon Pokopia, got a nine; Yoshi and the Mysterious Book, Splatoon Raiders, got a nine; Orbitals,
we've got a 10; Ocarina of Time got a nine, and then Nintendo Switch Sports Resort got a seven, with which leaves us with an average score of 8.1. So, basically, they all three platforms have fairly similar average
scores for the exclusives this year. So, with all that said, get the numbers out of the way. Ryan, how'd you feel about Xbox's lineup this year? &gt;&gt; Pretty good. I mean, it's it's you can
never argue against a 10, which was Forza Horizon 6 again for at least the third game in a row. I know we've had the same amazing reviewer, Luke Reilly, who is I would put him in terms of racing games, there's nobody
racing games. He just loves them, knows them, plays them all. Um yeah, I think Forza Horizon [snorts] 4, 5, and 6 got got 10 out of 10s from Luke, and I think got 10 out of 10s from Luke, and I think Forza Horizon 3 was a 9.5 memory serve.
So, anyway, Horizon 6, awesome. Finally taking the series to Japan, which is where people have wanted to see it go for a while. And uh it's still, as of this recording and up until January, it will be it will remain an Xbox console
exclusive because the the promised PS5 version isn't coming out until January And then certainly, I reviewed Gears of War E-Day myself. I'm a huge fan of that series going all the way back. And for me, I E-Day is the best of the
new the new the post-trilogy Gears. So, since since the Coalition took over for Epic, um I mean, granted there was Gears of War Judgment, which Epic didn't make. uh anyway, point being, I thought E-Day was
phenomenal. I very happily gave it a nine out of 10. Both single-player and multiplayer were tremendous, especially the campaign. Another great story, great combat, some great little little small evolutions to the combat, great set
pieces as always, great characters, and so yeah, you know, you mentioned a few but at the end of the day, yeah, I mean, it's your if your two major first party games in Gears of War and Forza Horizon get a
nine and a 10 respectively, that's a pretty good year. Xbox side. &gt;&gt; You and I both were looking forward to Replaced for years. It ended up being I mean, it we got a
but it wasn't the Did you give Inside a 10? &gt;&gt; I sure did. And that in fact gosh, that was 10 years ago cuz that was 2016. Time flies, my friend, but yeah, I'm I would say I I think I personally liked
Replaced a little bit more than our reviewer did. It's probably an eight for me, but but yeah, it's it definitely had maybe I would say I I felt my spidey sense was telling me like, oh, this one could be really
really really special. And then when it came out, it was excellent. It was very good, but yeah, not quite not quite in the certainly not in the Inside caliber of of of you know, indie games, but yeah,
still nevertheless excellent. In fact, you you bringing it up here, I didn't &gt;&gt; Yeah. Yeah, it's still Xbox console exclusive. check it out. Play it if I think it's 20 bucks, so go go have
&gt;&gt; Yeah, it's a cool game. So, Nick, one of the one of the main narratives of this entire console generation is that Sony's first party dried up. They you know, they they used to be
known as the the platform for AAA prestige single player couple every year during the PS4 generation. Not so during the PS5 actual exclusive lineup this year. God of War, Sons of Sparta, Sorrows and
Wolverine. But in terms of their console exclusive deals, they're making really smart deals for this, you know, Neo 3, Marvel Toko, and Silent Hill Town are all The only console you can play those on is PlayStation 5. So, what's
your sort of overall feeling about the PS5 exclusive lineup this year. &gt;&gt; I mean, for those of you who have, you know, for some reason know my track record of being a bit critical of Sony in this particular console generation, I
don't think 2026 is changing that tune particularly much. I've been pretty disappointed with the offerings from PlayStation I think I think this console generation in general, let alone this year. I think by far this is easily the
the weakest year for me personally from a first-party PlayStation exclusive. I love me some Housemarque, but Saros unfortunately didn't quite hit the same something more tricky. I want something more difficult, but that said, I do
think what PlayStation tends to offer stuff that looks flashy, something that consumers who can point to their TV and say, "Look how good this looks. This looks so pretty." That said though, looking at what Microsoft is offering on
the Xbox console with Xbox Series X and their PC strategy, I think Gears of War E-Day and a Forza Horizon are the games that just kind of wowed me and grabbed me a lot more. That said, taking a look at the kind of new strategy that Sony's
opting into, I think Phantom Blade Zero is the one to beat this year. Even though that is a third-party title, I do believe that that is a game that is going to draw the envy of both Nintendo and Xbox console owners alike. I think
the one thing that Sony does have going against it and this is just a a big win for S game in general, it's also available on PC. So, a lot of those Xbox players are also going to be able to enjoy this game on their PC. I am an
Xbox and PC player myself, so I get to play this game wherever I desire on on PC or PlayStation. &gt;&gt; And then there's Nintendo, which man, in terms they have they definitely have the the largest output of of exclusives
this year. A remake of one of the most beloved games of all time, The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time. A remake of Starfox. It was Starfox 64 that they &gt;&gt; That's correct. &gt;&gt; Then they had some surprises with I
think everyone was surprised with how good Pokémon Picopia was, and uh they had Fire Emblem: Fortune's We, which we gave a 10. Just so many uh good peppered throughout the year. What do we What do we say? Can we just
exclusive lineup? Right, Ryan, what do you think? really take much issue [laughter] with that. Uh Ocarina delivering as, you know, it was unfortunate that the surprise got got
leaked ahead of time, but that actually shipping this week and and getting great reviews. Uh by the way, our I want to shout out our our video team, our production team. We put a little Well, not we, not me. I had nothing to do with
it, but we IGN put a little extra level of production into that Zelda review. So, if you're interested in in Ocarina of Time, please go take a look at the IGN video review cuz it's It looks a little a little fancier, a little
special, more special than our typical video reviews do, but um yeah, I Ocarina video reviews do, but um yeah, I Ocarina for me, Damon, uh really I won't say saved Nintendo's year for me specifically, but I I I've been on this
podcast uh for a a long time, this show for a while, and every year I keep thinking this is finally going to be the year for 3D Mario, and this year again wasn't that year, but Ocarina is tremendous, and I'm I'm really looking
&gt;&gt; Yeah. &gt;&gt; uh which So, it's not quite out yet. &gt;&gt; Oh, fun. &gt;&gt; at at the Nintendo store in San Francisco. It's And mercifully, it's it's actually 9:00 p.m. Pacific since
that's It's that's the That's when it actually drops in this time zone, but uh getting into this game. &gt;&gt; Yeah, I am, too. of exclusives, uh Nintendo Switch 2 keeps things going
then at some point they're going to have Dust Bloods, uh which is a actual FromSoftware. And then PS5 will have Until Dawn 2, and then God of War: February into May. Uh Ryan, Xbox will have Fable in
Yeah, not an exclusive. I know, so yeah, I just Do you have any sort of predictions for what Xbox might have uh next year that could be exclusive? &gt;&gt; Well, it's Clockwork Revolution for sure. That's the confirmed one. Uh,
although, you know, for all we know that What if it slips to 2028? Cuz games get delayed and that happens. Uh, but honestly, Fable is I'm so excited for that game. I Again, I
doesn't really matter to me if it's coming out on on multiple platforms. If anything, I'm glad more people will get to maybe get into it and and get and uh Playground [snorts] is a studio, you know, we just we just
ago with Forza Horizon 6. They have an insane track record of basically a 10 out of 10 developer in terms of what they make. Like, they don't make eights. They don't really make nines. They make 10s. If
they can do that with this revival of Fable, I'm a really major fan of Fable going all the way back. Uh, I reviewed the first two Fables for Official Xbox Magazine back in the day and and loved
them both, especially Fable 2. So, and everything I've seen of Fable so far and and thankfully, uh Playground has shown us more of the before. If Fable
is the home run that I so badly want it to be, that's going to just be That'll be Xbox's big game for next year, even though it happens to also be shipping day and date on PS5.
that one. So, Nick, Until Dawn 2, God of War Ragnarök for PS5, what do you think? Do you think uh Intergalactic: The Heretic Prophet could make it out next year? &gt;&gt; Uh, I I don't see a world where it
announcement. I get I think we get a date for it next year. I'm going to say that's going to be a fall announcement uh for hopefully a spring release, but I buying it just yet. I do think Naughty Dog is one of the few studios that does
think they can kind of just dictate because in my opinion, I think that they are currently the apart from Santa Monica Studio, the only belt that people will kind of drop whatever they're doing for whatever
their next release is. So, I would be hopeful for a 2027 release. I'd be a little more of a betting man to do early 2028. &gt;&gt; Well, it wouldn't be the first time that Naughty Dog dropped a potential banger
They did it with The Last of Us. &gt;&gt; Mhm. That's true. of having an entire console generation to really their dig their fingers in and and see how the thing works.
PlayStation needs to turn around this narrative that they you know, are no longer the powerhouse of big AAA prestige single-player games that they Looking ahead even further, we got confirmation this week that The Elder
Sentinel. And then Ryan, I think you put up an op-ed talking about that discussing whether or not Xbox would dare make that a console exclusive. What Can you share your thoughts here? &gt;&gt; There's a case to be made either way,
And what I the conclusion that I came to and it's certainly easy for me as as not the person having to make billion-dollar decisions at Microsoft, but I think you know, this is the ultimate
test of Asha Sharma's s- uh return to exclusivity to use her own words. Like refocusing on exclusives, bringing exclusives back. There's no bigger game. Like I I mean, I
would be happy to have a healthy debate about this with anybody, but assuming that The Elder Scrolls 6 ships this decade, which I think it probably will cuz maybe fall 28, maybe it ends up being 29.
But um I I think it's the it's going to be the second biggest game of the decade besides behind GTA 6. Like it's it'll have been have been if it's 2028, it'll be 17 years between
build-up. &gt;&gt; anniversary, right? week, 11/11. So, 15 years already. It's going to be at least a couple more. Uh and this thing, I mean, it's it's going to be
enormous. So, if you're Microsoft and you want to get people, you want to return to console, get people back on your box, on the machine, uh you have an ace up your sleeve, and that
is the you own The Elder Scrolls. And so, back, keeping that game off of PlayStation platforms is the best way to do it. Now, she's still she's trying to reach, by by
she's still she's trying to reach, by by her own words, a billion players a day, and she has shareholders to answer to. Like, Sentinels going to cost a ton of money to make. It's a AAA development team
that's going to spend five-ish years making it, not to mention all the with a project like that. So, I don't you know, financially, can they justify
not having the PlayStation money come in on that game? I don't know, but the the bottom line for me is just based on what they've been saying about exclusives and about bringing getting things back to console,
you got to make Elder Scrolls 6 a console exclusive. And they have the they have the benefit of The Elder Scrolls audience has always been really, really strong on PC. I mean, it's it's that series started on PC. It came to
Xbox later with Morrowind and then Oblivion and then eventually came to PlayStation in 2007 with a port of Oblivion, but you're going to make a ton of money on it on PC,
how many platforms it's on, it's pretty unlikely that that game sells 65 million copies, which is how many copies Skyrim has sold. So, like that's just
that's a that's a pretty high bar under any circumstances, uh especially now all the hardware to play these games costs way, way, way more than it did back in the Skyrim days. So, anyway, all that is to say
exclusives, they've got to make The Elder Scrolls 6 Sentinel an Xbox console exclusive. But, we'll see if they do. I don't know. &gt;&gt; I I completely agree, Ryan. I think that this is certainly a test of uh Asha
Sharma's mission statement for Xbox, and I'd be very curious to see how this unfolds. If If I had to say, I I I think this is a timed exclusive. I think it launches on PlayStation 6 or PlayStation 5, whatever the timing works out, as a
game of the year edition later on, so that then Microsoft can double down and do a game of the year edition. Because Skyrim did sell 65 million copies over the course of multiple console generations, and I have a feeling
one. &gt;&gt; Yeah, there's definitely going to be a Series X version, even if the launch of it happens happens to line up with Helix. But, yeah, it's uh it's it's this one is
how Microsoft plays it. &gt;&gt; All getting back to present day exclusives, uh GTA 6 not an exclusive, but it's you know, it's only 2 weeks run-up to it, what exclusives will you be playing while you wait for GTA,
Ocarina of Time, Phantom Blade Zero, Gears of War E-Day, or maybe maybe none. Maybe you just you want to be put into cryogenic freeze until until it's You can jump right in. Uh you can vote at ign.com uh or on
Discord or on Spotify the day this episode goes live. We'll share the uh link to our Discord in the description, and we'll discuss the results next poll, we asked, "How would you pay for a console that costs more than $1,000?"
You know, would you just pay outright or use a payment plan or sell old games and consoles. But, 65% said they would not pay more than $1,000 for a console, and job, everybody. You chose &gt;&gt; Did we Did we make donate blood one of
the choices on that poll? &gt;&gt; Yeah. Donate Donate blood. &gt;&gt; I'm going to donate a lot of blood. All right, it is time for a brand new month of gaming. J- Jump into the Humble November Choice Bundle and score an
can grab Mafia: The Old Country, The Outer Worlds 2, Shinobi: Art of Cris Theater of Idols, Space Haven, Dysmantle, and Squeak Cross: Home Squeak Home. This month's charity is Covenant
young people experiencing homelessness by providing 24/7 safe shelter, food, medical and mental health care, and supportive services across the US, Canada, and Latin America. Head to humblebundle.com to start playing today.
And that's our show. Thank you to both Nick and Ryan. Thank you to Jobert and make this episode possible. My name is Damon. We'll be back next week with more on the latest gaming hardware news, and we'll see you then.
was produced by Damon Hatfield, Jobert Atienza, and Sam Clayborn. Damon is also Ryan McCaffrey, Nick Limon, Logan Plant, and other IGN commentators. Technical technical production by Marian Fransen and Amir Akib. Audio engineering is
editing is by Jobert Atienza, and graphic design is by Justin Vachon. production and part of the Geek Media Network.
