---
title: 'Human Thought Can Depend on Quantum Superpositions, Physicists Shows'
source: 'https://youtube.com/watch?v=ehba2U4oNJo'
video_id: 'ehba2U4oNJo'
date: 2026-11-11
duration_sec: 428
channel: 'Sabine Hossenfelder'
---

# Human Thought Can Depend on Quantum Superpositions, Physicists Shows

> Source: [Human Thought Can Depend on Quantum Superpositions, Physicists Shows](https://youtube.com/watch?v=ehba2U4oNJo)

## Summary

This video explores a new scientific paper proposing that fleeting quantum effects can influence neural activity in the human brain, even without long-lived quantum states. The physicist author argues that quantum superpositions, even if brief, can leave lasting correlations that affect thought processes, offering a more modest and testable alternative to previous quantum-brain theories.

### Key Points

- **The Big Question** [00:00] — The role of quantum physics in the human brain is a major open question, with implications for understanding decision-making and AI capabilities.
- **A New Modest Proposal** [00:28] — A new paper by a physicist in Istanbul argues that fleeting quantum effects can influence neural activity much longer than previously thought, using only standard physics.
- **The Trivial Yes Problem** [00:52] — The answer to whether quantum physics plays a role in the brain is trivially yes, as everything has quantum properties. The meaningful question is whether quantum-typical effects like superposition can affect thought.
- **Previous Quantum Brain Theories** [01:40] — Roger Penrose and Stuart Hameroff proposed quantum processes in microtubules, and Matthew Fisher suggested nuclear spins in molecules, but both are widely considered implausible by physicists.
- **The New Insight** [02:37] — The new proposal argues that a quantum state doesn't need to last long to have a lasting effect. Even a brief superposition can leave correlations that wouldn't exist otherwise, based on quantum thermodynamics.
- **Physical Traces** [03:59] — The author suggests quantum effects could occur in hydrogen bonds and microtubules, leaving an imprint on thoughts without requiring exotic new physics like gravitational collapse.
- **Testing the Proposal** [04:47] — The author proposes a concrete experimental test using neural tissue in the lab to see if quantum correlations leave an imprint on neurons.
- **Assessment** [05:14] — The video rates the paper 6 out of 10 on the 'bullshit meter', noting it requires less exotic physics than previous proposals, but it remains unclear if these effects matter for information processing in the brain.

### Conclusion

The video concludes that this new paper might be the point where quantum physics in the brain finally begins to make sense, offering a more reasonable and testable approach than previous theories.

## Transcript

What is the role of quantum physics in the human&nbsp; brain? We don’t have a good answer to this. It’s&nbsp;&nbsp; a big question because if it turned out that&nbsp; the human brain actually used quantum physics,&nbsp;&nbsp;
like the feeling that a decision we&nbsp; make turns a possibility into reality.&nbsp;&nbsp; It would also give us a new perspective on what&nbsp; artificial intelligence can and can’t achieve.
Most of what gets published on quantum physics&nbsp; on the brain is nonsense. But today I have&nbsp;&nbsp; a new paper that is both more modest and more&nbsp; interesting than anything I’ve previously seen on&nbsp;&nbsp;
the topic. A physicist argues, quite convincingly,&nbsp; that fleeting quantum effects can influence neural&nbsp;&nbsp; activity much longer than we thought, just&nbsp; by standard physics. Let’s have a look.
The major problem with the question of whether&nbsp; quantum physics plays a role in the human brain is&nbsp;&nbsp; not that we can’t answer it. The problem is that&nbsp; the answer is trivially yes. Because everything&nbsp;&nbsp; has quantum properties if you look closely enough.&nbsp; Without quantum effects, atoms wouldn’t exist,&nbsp;&nbsp;
so of course quantum physics plays a role&nbsp; in the human brain! By the same standard,&nbsp;&nbsp; quantum physics also plays an essential&nbsp; role in cheese. I await the conferences. The more meaningful question is therefore whether&nbsp; quantum-typical effects like being in two states&nbsp;&nbsp;
at the same time can affect thought. Can you&nbsp; literally have two thoughts at the same time?&nbsp;&nbsp; And can the power of your will turn&nbsp; one of those thoughts into a decision?
The most famous attempt to connect quantum&nbsp; physics to human thought comes from Roger Penrose&nbsp;&nbsp; and Stuart Hameroff. They proposed that these&nbsp; quantum processes happen inside microtubules,&nbsp;&nbsp;
that are tiny structures in neurons, and that the&nbsp; collapse of their wavefunction produces moments&nbsp;&nbsp; of consciousness. Their proposal connects&nbsp; this collapse to the structure of spacetime&nbsp;&nbsp;
and every physicist I’ve ever talked&nbsp; to about this thinks it’s nonsense. The physicist Matthew Fisher has proposed that&nbsp; nuclear spins in certain molecules could have&nbsp;&nbsp; long-lived quantum states which could eventually&nbsp; influence the release of neurotransmitters and&nbsp;&nbsp;
the firing of neurons. I don’t know anyone&nbsp; who believes this either. There are also a&nbsp;&nbsp; lot of theories about quantum in the brain from&nbsp; non-physicists which I don’t even want to mention The new proposal now comes&nbsp; from a physicist in Istanbul,&nbsp;&nbsp;
and he makes a very interesting point.&nbsp; He says that a quantum state doesn’t have&nbsp;&nbsp; to keep its quantum properties for&nbsp; very long to have a lasting effect. We usually assume that if we have some&nbsp; quantum superposition in the brain,&nbsp;&nbsp;
one of, say, two neurons firing at once or,&nbsp; more ambitiously, two thoughts at once. Then&nbsp;&nbsp; this superposition will at some point collapse&nbsp; and leave only one state. One neuron that fires,&nbsp;&nbsp;
one thought, one moment in which your memory&nbsp; of why you went into the kitchen evaporates. The author of the paper now says,&nbsp; actually, this might not be the case.&nbsp;&nbsp; Because if the superposition existed&nbsp; at some point, even if only briefly,&nbsp;&nbsp;
then what happens at a later time might be&nbsp; different than if the superposition never existed. He takes this insight from a research&nbsp; area called quantum thermodynamics,&nbsp;&nbsp; so he does have a theoretical and mathematical&nbsp; backing. With that, he shows that if you start&nbsp;&nbsp;
with a particular type of superposition, an&nbsp; entangled state, then you are later left with&nbsp;&nbsp; correlations that would not be there had it&nbsp; not been for the quantum effects. The quantum&nbsp;&nbsp; effects leave a physical trace that affects&nbsp; what happens next. As he writes, “functional&nbsp;&nbsp;
relevance need not require the long-time&nbsp; preservation of fragile quantum coherence.” He points to several places where this could&nbsp; happen. One is hydrogen bonds, where protons&nbsp;&nbsp;
can become delocalised between different&nbsp; positions. But he also looks at microtubules&nbsp;&nbsp; and these phosphate groups that I mentioned&nbsp; earlier. And in both cases he says, yes,&nbsp;&nbsp;
actually these might leave an imprint on thoughts.&nbsp; And you don’t need any gravitationally induced&nbsp;&nbsp; collapse or other fancy new physics for it.&nbsp; Which to be honest is slightly disappointing.&nbsp;&nbsp;
Consciousness was much more glamorous when&nbsp; it required the structure of spacetime. The author has no experimental evidence that&nbsp; this actually happens. But he has a concrete&nbsp;&nbsp;
proposal for how to test this, with neural&nbsp; tissue in the laboratory. Basically he says,&nbsp;&nbsp; just look at whether quantum correlations leave an&nbsp; imprint in the neurons later on. If he is right,&nbsp;&nbsp;
this could indeed mean that the human brain relies&nbsp; on quantum effects that a conventional computer&nbsp;&nbsp; does not readily reproduce. This, needless&nbsp; to say, would be a very big finding.
What are we to make of this? I give this a 6 out&nbsp; of 10 on the bullshit meter. Compared with earlier&nbsp;&nbsp; quantum-brain proposals, this one requires much&nbsp; less exotic physics. The core idea seems perfectly&nbsp;&nbsp;
reasonable to me: a tiny quantum effect can leave&nbsp; a big fingerprint in the brain. But it remains&nbsp;&nbsp; unclear whether those fingerprints actually&nbsp; matter in the human brain to process information.
That isn’t a question I would pose to a&nbsp; physicist though, so I don’t want to blame&nbsp;&nbsp; the author too much. I have a good feeling about&nbsp; this paper, I think this might be the point when&nbsp;&nbsp; quantum physics in the brain finally began&nbsp; making sense. If this turns out to be right,&nbsp;&nbsp;
I look forward to blaming quantum mechanics&nbsp; for every bad decision I have ever made. I find it fascinating how much research goes into&nbsp; everyday objects like the razors from today's&nbsp;&nbsp;
sponsor, Henson. This might come as somewhat&nbsp; of a surprise to you, but Henson's team have&nbsp;&nbsp; a background in aero space engineering. They've&nbsp; built parts for the ISS and the ExoMars rover.&nbsp;&nbsp;
They use the same precision to design their&nbsp; razor. They figured out at exactly which angle&nbsp;&nbsp; the blades need to be positioned so as to cut off&nbsp; hairs perfectly and not cut your skin. The pieces&nbsp;&nbsp;
that hold the blades are not plastic, but cut&nbsp; out from metal to a precision of a hundredth of&nbsp;&nbsp; a millimeter. I prefer my husband cleanly shaven&nbsp; out without cuts, and Henson's is by far the best&nbsp;&nbsp;
razor I've seen at work. Also works for women.&nbsp; And of course, I have a special offer. If you buy&nbsp;&nbsp; a Henson razor through my link or use my code,&nbsp; you'll get 100 blades for free along with it.&nbsp;&nbsp;
You've never shaved that scientifically.&nbsp; Thanks for watching. See you tomorrow.
