---
title: 'FINALLY: A Proof that Particles Take All Paths At Once?'
source: 'https://youtube.com/watch?v=A2ImadKWaHA'
video_id: 'A2ImadKWaHA'
date: 2026-11-11
duration_sec: 413
channel: 'Sabine Hossenfelder'
---

# FINALLY: A Proof that Particles Take All Paths At Once?

> Source: [FINALLY: A Proof that Particles Take All Paths At Once?](https://youtube.com/watch?v=A2ImadKWaHA)

## Summary

A Chinese physics team claims to have experimentally validated Richard Feynman's path integral interpretation, suggesting particles truly take all possible paths simultaneously. The video critically examines this claim, concluding that while the experiment confirms the math, it does not resolve the deeper interpretive questions of quantum mechanics.

### Key Points

- **Feynman's Path Integral** [00:00] — Quantum particles can take every possible path at the same time, an 80-year-old interpretation from Richard Feynman. A Chinese team claims to have experimentally proved this is physical reality.
- **Quantum vs. Classical Paths** [01:02] — In classical physics, a ball takes one deterministic path. In quantum physics, Feynman proposed summing amplitudes over all possible paths to get probabilities, known as the path integral.
- **Path Integral Equivalence** [01:28] — Feynman's path integral gives the same results as the Schrödinger equation, but offers a visual interpretation: particles can go all different paths at the same time.
- **Multiverse Claims** [02:04] — Some physicists, including Google in a press release, claim such experiments support the multiverse idea, citing David Deutsch's prediction. However, the paths are never observed directly.
- **The Experiment** [03:15] — The team used single photons traveling through a grid of measurement locations (17 along travel, 5 transverse). They measured amplitudes between two grid points, fitting Feynman's predictions.
- **Critical Analysis** [03:47] — The experiment validates the math but does not prove particles 'really' take all paths when unobserved. The authors misunderstood the task; it's about Bell's inequality and superdeterminism.
- **Conclusion** [05:28] — Feynman is still right, but the interpretation of quantum physics remains unresolved. John Bell's work is still relevant, and experiments like this won't settle the debate.

### Conclusion

The experiment confirms Feynman's path integral mathematically but fails to prove the physical reality of all-paths interpretation. The foundational questions of quantum mechanics remain open.

## Transcript

Quantum particles can take every possible&nbsp; path at the same time. This is an 80 years&nbsp;&nbsp; old interpretation of mathematics which&nbsp; comes from Richard Feynman. But now a team&nbsp;&nbsp; of physicists in China says they have shown&nbsp; that this is more than an interpretation.&nbsp;&nbsp;
They say they have experimentally proved that&nbsp; it is physical reality. So can we finally stop&nbsp;&nbsp; arguing about the interpretation of quantum&nbsp; physics? That’d be huge progress. I mean,&nbsp;&nbsp;
it’s only been 80 years. By physics standards,&nbsp; that’s basically express delivery. Let’s have a&nbsp;&nbsp; look. Stay around until the end for a special&nbsp; offer that will bring your coding skills to&nbsp;&nbsp; an entirely new level with boot.dev. In&nbsp; ordinary physics, if you throw a ball,&nbsp;&nbsp;
then the ball takes one particular path, depending&nbsp; on its initial place and velocity. That’s if you&nbsp;&nbsp; throw the ball. If I throw the ball, I’ll tear a&nbsp; body part I didn’t know exists and then the ball&nbsp;&nbsp; will get lost in the bushes. Still, physicists&nbsp; insist, it’s all strictly deterministic.
In quantum physics, this isn’t&nbsp; the case. Rather, Feynman said,&nbsp;&nbsp; what you do for a quantum particle is that&nbsp; you look at every possible path. Not just the&nbsp;&nbsp; straight connection from a start to an end&nbsp; point, but every connection. For each path&nbsp;&nbsp;
you calculate a quantity called the amplitude.&nbsp; You sum them all up and from that you get the&nbsp;&nbsp; probability of the particle to go to a particular&nbsp; place, but just where it goes is not determined.
It’s called a “path integral” and Feynman&nbsp; showed that it gives the same result as using&nbsp;&nbsp; the wave-function and the Schrödinger equation.&nbsp; But the neat thing about Feynman’s method is&nbsp;&nbsp;
that it gives you a visual interpretation of&nbsp; what is going on and also tells you exactly&nbsp;&nbsp; what is so strange about quantum physics: the&nbsp; particles can go all these different paths at&nbsp;&nbsp;
the same time. Or do they? This condenses eighty&nbsp; years of quantum foundations into three words. A lot of physicists think that yes that is&nbsp; really what the particles do, and not just this,&nbsp;&nbsp;
many of them even think it’s evidence&nbsp; that we live in a multiverse. For example,&nbsp;&nbsp; a press release from Google about their quantum&nbsp; computer claimed they’d done an experiment that,&nbsp;&nbsp; quote, gives “credence to the notion that quantum&nbsp; computation occurs in many parallel universes, in&nbsp;&nbsp;
line with the idea that we live in a multiverse,&nbsp; a prediction first made by David Deutsch.” The problem is that by construction of the path&nbsp; integral, you never observe the paths. You only&nbsp;&nbsp;
observe the particle at the final point. If&nbsp; you were to observe the particle in between,&nbsp;&nbsp; then you’d only ever observe one path. The authors&nbsp; of the new paper now say they have shown that,&nbsp;&nbsp; yes, the particles actually go all these&nbsp; paths. In their words, the paths are quote:&nbsp;&nbsp;
“more than mere mathematical artifacts” and&nbsp; “reflect a physical aspect of quantum reality”. Let me be clear, the question is not whether&nbsp; Feynman’s path integral is correct or not.&nbsp;&nbsp;
It makes probably the same predictions&nbsp; as Schrödinger’s formalism. It’s been&nbsp;&nbsp; tested a million times and we know&nbsp; it works. The question is whether&nbsp;&nbsp; we can experimentally settle what really happens.
So what did they actually do in their&nbsp; experiment? They used single photons,&nbsp;&nbsp; one at a time They let the photons travel from&nbsp; one place to another one and put in a grid of&nbsp;&nbsp; measurement locations in between basically, 17&nbsp; along the direction of travel and 5 transverse&nbsp;&nbsp;
to it. They take two of these grid points and&nbsp; measure what the amplitude of the photon does&nbsp;&nbsp; between them. And that, they find, fits exactly&nbsp; to Feynman’s prediction. So, New Scientist writes:&nbsp;&nbsp; “Richard Feynman’s 80-year-old quantum&nbsp; postulate has now been validated.”
Ok, but in this case the New Scientist&nbsp; article is more reasonable than the paper&nbsp;&nbsp; itself. Does it “validate” Feynman’s&nbsp; path integral. Yes, totally. It’s a&nbsp;&nbsp; beautiful direct confirmation that the maths&nbsp; really adds up the way he said. Then again,&nbsp;&nbsp;
no one doubted this in the first place. Does&nbsp; it prove that the particles “really” go all&nbsp;&nbsp; possible paths when no one looks? No, of&nbsp; course not. Because they didn’t find out&nbsp;&nbsp; what the particles do when you don’t measure&nbsp; them, they put in additional measurements just&nbsp;&nbsp;
to then find that the particles were on one&nbsp; particular path, which, again no one doubted. So, I am sorry, but I give this paper a 9 out&nbsp; of 10 on the bullshit meter. Nice experiment,&nbsp;&nbsp;
Why am I telling you about this&nbsp; anyway? It’s because this is a neat&nbsp;&nbsp; illustration of why the foundations of physics&nbsp; are stuck. The problem that these guys try&nbsp;&nbsp;
to answer is the exact problem that Albert&nbsp; Einstein tried to answer already and failed,&nbsp;&nbsp; and which John Bell then tried to answer.&nbsp; Namely: does a quantum particle “really” do&nbsp;&nbsp; all the things at the same time when we don’t&nbsp; look, or does it “really” only do one thing.
So not only did the authors of&nbsp; the paper misunderstand the task,&nbsp;&nbsp; they also didn’t realize that this is&nbsp; exactly what Bell’s inequality is about. Now as I’ve said many times, the conclusion&nbsp; from Bell only follows once you postulate&nbsp;&nbsp;
that superdeterminism is ruled out, which has&nbsp; never been ruled out, so actually the current&nbsp;&nbsp; situation is still inconclusive. But experiments&nbsp; like the one in the new paper won’t settle it.
In summary, Feynman is still right,&nbsp; we still don’t know how to interpret&nbsp;&nbsp; quantum physics, and John Bell is still dead. The last time I wrote code, it was Fortran this&nbsp;&nbsp;
is why I decided I need to urgently upgrade my&nbsp; coding skills. If you're in a similar situation,&nbsp;&nbsp; I have a recommendation for you. Boot.dev, who've&nbsp; been sponsoring this video. Boot.dev is focused&nbsp;&nbsp;
on back-end development. So, Python, SQL, Go, the&nbsp; kind of stuff that actually runs the world behind&nbsp;&nbsp; the scenes. And you don't just watch lessons, you&nbsp; build real projects, you write code directly in&nbsp;&nbsp; the browser, you solve challenges, and you level&nbsp; up like it's a slightly nerdy role-playing game.&nbsp;&nbsp;
They also have what they call the training&nbsp; grounds. That's basically infinite practice&nbsp;&nbsp; problem. I've been meaning for a while to set&nbsp; up a website for all my content, but I want&nbsp;&nbsp; to know what's going on with the data and what&nbsp; vulnerabilities to watch out for. And boot.dev has&nbsp;&nbsp;
been really eyeopening. You can create an account&nbsp; for free, read and watch all the content and try&nbsp;&nbsp; a demo of the interactive features. If you decide&nbsp; to go for the full experience, use my code SABINE&nbsp;&nbsp;
to get 25% off your first year. So go and check&nbsp; this out. Thanks for watching. See you tomorrow.
