---
title: 'AI Will End Philosophy, Physicist Claims'
source: 'https://youtube.com/watch?v=RmvQtxc9R3Q'
video_id: 'RmvQtxc9R3Q'
date: 2026-11-11
duration_sec: 421
channel: 'Sabine Hossenfelder'
---

# AI Will End Philosophy, Physicist Claims

> Source: [AI Will End Philosophy, Physicist Claims](https://youtube.com/watch?v=RmvQtxc9R3Q)

## Summary

This video critiques Louis Vervoort's book 'Problem Solving in Philosophy: How to Do Philosophy in the Age of Ultra-Intelligent AI,' which argues that philosophy should adopt the methods of theoretical physics and that AI can settle philosophical debates. The host, Sabine, disagrees with both the author and a responding philosopher, offering her own perspective on the limits of AI in philosophy.

### Key Points

- **Author's Background** [00:14] — Louis Vervoort has a PhD in physics and a second PhD in philosophy, lending credibility to his argument.
- **Core Argument** [00:38] — Vervoort argues philosophy should be done like natural science, using a 'maximally coherent theory' that explains the most cases and contradicts the least accepted knowledge.
- **AI Experiment** [01:46] — Vervoort asked ChatGPT (GPT-4) which notion of causality is best; it answered 'counterfactual causality,' which he agrees with, but Sabine notes this is circular reasoning.
- **Topics AI Will Settle** [02:17] — Vervoort believes AI will settle free will (which he thinks doesn't exist) and induction (which he calls a pseudoproblem).
- **Philosopher's Response** [02:46] — A philosopher's comment argues that if philosophy is about generating theories, AI can do it, but if it's about thinking through problems yourself, it cannot.
- **Sabine's Critique** [03:20] — Sabine argues that quantifying the 'best' explanation is itself a philosophical problem, and philosophy addresses questions science cannot answer.
- **Problem of Induction** [04:00] — Vervoort treats induction as an axiom, but Sabine argues the question of why it works is exactly a philosophical question.
- **Human Laziness** [05:13] — Sabine suggests philosophers will increasingly use AI due to laziness, potentially improving discourse quality.
- **Final Verdict** [05:30] — Sabine rates the book 6/10, acknowledging the method is worthwhile but not likely to make philosophy obsolete.

### Conclusion

Sabine concludes that while Vervoort's method of quantifying explanations has merit, it won't make philosophy redundant, and if AI does, philosophers will debate it for decades.

## Transcript

how artificial intelligence will&nbsp; make much of philosophy obsolete,&nbsp;&nbsp; soon. A philosopher thinks otherwise. And I&nbsp; think, well, they’re both wrong. Let me explain.
The new book comes from Louis Vervoort who&nbsp; started out with a PhD in physics but then&nbsp;&nbsp; did a second PhD in philosophy. So this is not&nbsp; your stereotypical ignorant physicist with a&nbsp;&nbsp;
YouTube channel, you have me for that. The book is titled “Problem Solving in&nbsp;&nbsp; Philosophy: How to Do Philosophy in the Age of&nbsp; Ultra-Intelligent AI.” To make a long story short,&nbsp;&nbsp;
the author argues that philosophy should&nbsp; be done like a natural science in general,&nbsp;&nbsp; and like theoretical physics in&nbsp; particular. As he writes in the book,&nbsp;&nbsp; quote: “philosophy is now mature enough&nbsp; to come to reasonably solid answers to key&nbsp;&nbsp;
problems” and “there is one overarching&nbsp; method to do so, in essence the same&nbsp;&nbsp; method as the natural sciences use to obtain&nbsp; answers, in particular theoretical physics.” He argues that philosophers should quantify how&nbsp; good an explanation is by using that explanation,&nbsp;&nbsp;
which gives the largest number of coherent&nbsp; answers to the well-posed problems. He calls&nbsp;&nbsp; this the maximally coherent theory. The best&nbsp; theory is the one that explains the most cases,&nbsp;&nbsp; makes sense of the most counterexamples, and&nbsp; contradicts the least other accepted knowledge.
And AI can do it, so his argument, because&nbsp; all it really comes down to is counting the&nbsp;&nbsp; questions answered and contradictions. He&nbsp; has even done an “experiment” in which he&nbsp;&nbsp; used AI to allegedly solve a thorny problem of&nbsp; philosophy, that is how to define causality.
The experiment works like this: ask ChatGPT&nbsp; --- at the time that was GPT 4 --- which&nbsp;&nbsp; notion of causality is the best. ChatGPT said&nbsp; “counterfactual causality” which Vervoort thinks&nbsp;&nbsp;
is correct because it’s the one he also likes&nbsp; best. Maybe doing philosophy like theoretical&nbsp;&nbsp; physics is not the flex he thinks it is. Other philosophy topics that Vervoort thinks&nbsp;&nbsp; AI will settle is free will, which&nbsp; clearly doesn’t exist, and induction&nbsp;&nbsp;
which he thinks is a pseudoproblem. Though I&nbsp; have to add that he also says that he does not&nbsp;&nbsp; think AI will solve all philosophy problems,&nbsp; in particular he says ‘big questions’ like the&nbsp;&nbsp;
meaning of life or the existence of god&nbsp; are still up for grabs, presumably until&nbsp;&nbsp; ChatGPT 7.8 max pro ultra agrees with him. The author published a paper with his main&nbsp;&nbsp; argument before the book, so we already have&nbsp; a comment from a philosopher titled “Can we&nbsp;&nbsp;
automate philosophy through AI? And should we&nbsp; want to?” The philosopher basically says that&nbsp;&nbsp; if you think philosophy is about generating&nbsp; theories and arguing for and against them,&nbsp;&nbsp; then, yes, an AI can in principle do it. If&nbsp; you, on the other hand, think philosophy is&nbsp;&nbsp;
about thinking through these problems yourself&nbsp; then an AI cannot do it for you. The remarkable&nbsp;&nbsp; thing about this argument is that he managed&nbsp; to blow it up to 15 pages which is basically&nbsp;&nbsp; my problem with all philosophy literature,&nbsp; loads of words to say the pathetically obvious.
That said, I don’t have much sympathy for&nbsp; the physicists’ argument in this case either.&nbsp;&nbsp; Because the question of how to quantify the “best”&nbsp; explanation for a philosophical theory is itself&nbsp;&nbsp;
a philosophical problem. And the entire idea that&nbsp; you can “sciencify” philosophy is nonsense because&nbsp;&nbsp; philosophy is exactly what we use to discuss&nbsp; the questions that science can NOT answer,&nbsp;&nbsp;
or not yet. There are of course questions that&nbsp; eventually move from philosophy to science,&nbsp;&nbsp; consciousness is just doing this and&nbsp; free will is likely going to come next. The problem with the author's argument&nbsp; is nicely illustrated in his take on the&nbsp;&nbsp;
problem of induction. That’s the question&nbsp; of why induction works, why do the laws&nbsp;&nbsp; of nature continue to work, why does the sun&nbsp; rise every morning, why do atoms remain stable,&nbsp;&nbsp;
why does sabine keep making stupid jokes. You&nbsp; might say, well, it’s because we have seen in&nbsp;&nbsp; the past that that’s the case. Yes, but that&nbsp; would be proving induction by induction which&nbsp;&nbsp; is a circular argument. Vervoort basically&nbsp; says it’s a meaningless question because&nbsp;&nbsp;
induction should be treated as an axiom and&nbsp; as such it doesn’t require a justification. But induction is an axiom in science. We need&nbsp; it for science to work. The question is why&nbsp;&nbsp;
does it work? That’s a question science can’t&nbsp; answer which is exactly why it’s a question&nbsp;&nbsp; for philosophers. If you say a non-scientific&nbsp; question isn’t a question then yeah, I guess&nbsp;&nbsp; you can close the philosophy departments, but even&nbsp; Claude could tell that this is a pseudo-argument.&nbsp;
That said, I think both of these&nbsp; gentlemen miss the obvious point,&nbsp;&nbsp; which is that humans are by default lazy. Most&nbsp; philosophy papers are already collections of&nbsp;&nbsp; useless words that no one reads, and of&nbsp; course increasingly more philosophers&nbsp;&nbsp;
will let AI do this job. Indeed I am sure&nbsp; this is already happening. And I hope that&nbsp;&nbsp; this will ultimately encourage philosophers&nbsp; to improve the quality of their discourse. I give the book a 6 out of 10 on the bullshit&nbsp; meter. Why is it so low after all I’ve said?&nbsp;&nbsp;
It’s because I think that the method that the&nbsp; author suggests, to quantify how “good” different&nbsp;&nbsp; explanations are, is worthwhile. I just don’t&nbsp; think it’s going to make philosophy redundant.&nbsp;&nbsp;
And if AI really does make philosophy obsolete,&nbsp; philosophers will spend the next fifty years&nbsp;&nbsp; debating whether that actually happened. If you have a trip coming up, I have a&nbsp;&nbsp; recommendation for how you can make&nbsp; this so much more convenient with the&nbsp;&nbsp;
electronic SIM card or eSIM from Saily.&nbsp; What's it good for? If you're traveling,&nbsp;&nbsp; you can avoid roaming fees just by switching to&nbsp; a local eSIM. That can save you a ton of money.&nbsp;&nbsp;
Something else that I found it useful for is to&nbsp; keep using an old phone which no longer has a&nbsp;&nbsp; SIM card. You can also use it to set a virtual&nbsp; location. How does it work? It's super easy.&nbsp;&nbsp;
Download the app, select a country under plan,&nbsp; and don't forget to enter my code SABINE before&nbsp;&nbsp; checkout because that'll get you 15% off. Download&nbsp; the eSIM and switch it on. And that's it. Yes,&nbsp;&nbsp;
it's really that simple. Saily has 24/7 support&nbsp; and if the eSIM doesn't work on your phone,&nbsp;&nbsp; a money back guarantee. So use my code&nbsp; SABINE for an exclusive 15% discount&nbsp;&nbsp;
on sale data plans and I wish you a good&nbsp; trip. Thanks for watching. See you tomorrow.
