[00:00] An experiment to see what might be the first  ever evidence for a dark matter particle. It's   a single data point, so we can't conclude much  from it. But if there was a real discovery,   then this is how it did start. So I think we  should take this seriously and look at what   [00:15] we know and what it could mean. The data, or  maybe I should more accurately say the datum   comes from the LUX ZEPLIN experiment. That's  a very sensitive detector in South Dakota in   [00:27] an old gold mine about 1.5 kilometers  underground. And in some sense, they still dig for   gold, the gold of the Nobel Prize. Because let's  be clear, if we finally pin down what dark matter   is made of, that would win a Nobel Prize for sure.  It would end half a century of stagnation in the   [00:44] foundations of physics. This experiment uses about  10 tons of liquid xenon at - 99° C. that's very   closely monitored for anything that bumps into  the atoms. It's so deep underground to avoid   [00:57] cosmic rays and it's heavily shielded to avoid  contamination from radioactive decays and so on.   The idea is that dark matter just goes through  all the rocking shields and on occasion leaves   [01:09] a trace in the xenon. Now this one data point  here is outside of the normal background that   they expect. If it's really dark matter particle,  they calculate it would be a quite heavy one with   a mass of at least 400 GeV. That's more than three  times as heavy as the Higgs boson. And it explain   [01:26] why the Large Hadron Collider hasn't found it.  The energy simply wasn't high enough. Indeed,   the LUX ZEPLIN Corporation itself missed the  event in an earlier data analysis because the   energy is so high they didn't look for it.  The statistical significance is between 2.6   [01:42] and 3.4 and four σ depending on how you do the  analysis. So that's vaguely between 1 in 200   and 1 in a 1000 chance to be a statistical  fluke. That's mediocre for particle physics,   [01:54] but in cosmology it would be breaking news. And I  have to admit it does look like an unusual event.   There are standard physics events which can look  like this, but they're contrived. For example,   [02:07] you can have a radioactive decay that produces a  gamma ray. The gamma ray happens to hit two nuclei   whose signals overlap, but the second signal so  close to the wall of the detector that it looks   [02:19] like both came from the same nucleus. Possible  but unlikely. Or an electron can be spontaneously   absorbed by a nucleus which then spits it back  out. The energy will kind of fit the observation   [02:32] but the distribution possible but very unlikely.  So it's difficult to explain. And there are indeed   some new particles which have previously been  proposed that are compatible with this detection.   [02:45] There is for example a pseudo-Dirac Higgsino. That's a  type of super symmetric particle or electroeak   multiplets. But particle physicists have  invented so many particles at this point it   [02:57] would be surprising if there was not at least one  that fits. I give this a 7 out of 10 on the [ __ ]   meter. It's fine for what the data collection  and analysis and interpretation is concerned. It   [03:10] does indeed look like an odd event and it could  indeed be a dark matter particle and it's in a   range where that wouldn’t be ruled out by other  data already. I don't see any obvious red flags.   [03:24] My major problem is one that these analyses don't  account for. It's that I think once you compare   the plausibility of some unlikely standard physics  explanation like these specific radioactive decay   [03:36] signatures to the plausibility of the dark matter  models that's the question what's your prior   shouldn't we take into account that physicists  have made all these wrong predictions in the past   [03:48] none of which came true you see the LUX ZEPLIN  experiment is an upgrade of an earlier experiment   that's run since 2012 this is a common story with  dark meta searchers. They look for a particle,   [04:02] they don't find it. They say they need a more  sensitive detector. They upgrade it. They don't   find it. They say they need a more sensitive  detector and so on. The experimentalists justify   their experiments by saying the theorists have  theories for it. And the theorists justify their   [04:20] theories with saying there's experiments that  could test them. The experiments never confirm   the theories, but no one dares to question this  insanity because hey, you never know what they   might find, right? Of course, I'm not the only one  who's noticed this. The astrophysicist Stacy McGaugh   [04:38] has commented recently, "These experiments have  run their course. They've succeeded in failing.   At what point do we admit that and stop throwing  good money after bad?" Okay, but just because   [04:51] Sabine thinks something's going systematically  wrong doesn't mean this isn't dark matter. So,   the brief summary is obviously we need more data,  but yes, this could be the breakthrough we've all   [05:05] been hoping for, and I grant you permission to  be excited. It's just that to settle the case,   we need a bigger detector. I find it fascinating  how much research goes into everyday objects like   [05:19] the razors from today's sponsor, Henson. This  might come as somewhat of a surprise to you,   but Henson's team have a background in aerospace  engineering. They've built parts for the ISS and   [05:33] the ExoMars rover. They use the same precision  to design their Razor. They figured out at exactly   which angle the blades need to be positioned so  as to cut off hairs perfectly and not cut your   [05:45] skin. The pieces that hold the blades are not  plastic but cut out from metal to a precision   of a hundredth of a millimeter. I prefer my husband  cleanly shaven and without cuts and Henson's is by   [05:58] far the best razor I've seen at work. Also works  for women. And of course I have a special offer.   If you buy a Henson razor through my link or use  my code, you'll get 100 blades for free along with   [06:12] it. You've never shaved that scientifically.  Thanks for watching. See you tomorrow.