---
title: 'Big Oil’s Plan Is Working Beautifully'
source: 'https://youtube.com/watch?v=GekGgq6HRuk'
video_id: 'GekGgq6HRuk'
date: 2026-11-11
duration_sec: 415
channel: 'Sabine Hossenfelder'
---

# Big Oil’s Plan Is Working Beautifully

> Source: [Big Oil’s Plan Is Working Beautifully](https://youtube.com/watch?v=GekGgq6HRuk)

## Summary

This video critically examines the rise of Carbon Capture and Storage (CCS) as a climate strategy promoted by oil companies and embraced by governments worldwide. It highlights the massive subsidies and investments, the gap between claimed and real-world efficiency, and the political dynamics behind CCS's growing acceptance.

### Key Points

- **What is CCS?** [00:26] — CCS involves capturing CO2 from power plants, compressing it, and burying it underground. It's been sold as a miracle solution, but it's especially beneficial for oil companies.
- **US Subsidies for Oil Extraction** [01:08] — The US government subsidizes carbon capture even when the CO2 is used to extract more oil, effectively subsidizing increased oil production.
- **Global Government Investment** [01:23] — The UK invested £21 billion, Norway $2 billion, Denmark $4 billion, Germany €5 billion, and Canada has heavy subsidies. The EU passed a law requiring oil and gas producers to build storage facilities by 2030.
- **Industry Response and New Facilities** [02:05] — ExxonMobil sued to remove the EU legislation, claiming they can't meet the requirements. Europe's largest CCS facility opened in the Netherlands, and the world's first industrial-scale cement plant CCS started in Germany.
- **Political Shift Towards CCS** [02:50] — Governments have shifted from listening to climate activists to OPEC's stance that climate agreements are about emissions reduction, not choosing energy sources.
- **Paper vs. Real-World Efficiency** [03:24] — On paper, CCS promises 90-95% efficiency. In reality, a Canadian coal plant averaged 63% in a good year, and an Australian plant just 35%.
- **The Energy Penalty** [04:20] — CCS consumes energy, reducing net plant output by 30-40%. Even at 90% capture, total greenhouse gas savings are only 70% per net energy because more fuel is burned.
- **IPCC Report Controversy** [04:55] — A Guardian investigation found at least a dozen lead authors of the IPCC report on CCS have links to oil and gas institutions, suggesting a biased outcome.
- **Conclusion: The Inevitable Path** [05:26] — The video concludes that CCS is an inevitable development due to the failure to price carbon and switch to nuclear fission. It's not great, but it's something.

### Conclusion

Carbon Capture and Storage is being embraced by governments worldwide, but real-world efficiency is far lower than claimed, and the energy penalty reduces net climate benefits. It's an inevitable compromise, driven by the failure to price carbon and transition to nuclear power.

## Transcript

Big Oil has found a way to survive climate change&nbsp; legislation: Rather than stop using fossil fuels,&nbsp;&nbsp; pretend to make them harmless&nbsp; by capturing the carbon dioxide,&nbsp;&nbsp;
and burying it underground. The strategy is not&nbsp; new, but in the past months, it’s become clear&nbsp;&nbsp; just how amazingly successful it’s been. What&nbsp; does science say about it? Let’s have a look.
The technology that oil companies are pushing&nbsp; is called Carbon Capture and Storage. For this,&nbsp;&nbsp; you take the exhaust from a power station&nbsp; or industrial plant, separate out the&nbsp;&nbsp; carbon dioxide and compress it. Then you&nbsp; transport it through pipelines or on ships,&nbsp;&nbsp;
dump it into some underground reservoir, and hope&nbsp; that it stays there until someone else is CEO. Carbon Capture and Storage, CCS for short, has&nbsp; been sold as somewhat of a miracle solution&nbsp;&nbsp;
to climate change that’d allow us to&nbsp; keep using fossil fuel power plants.&nbsp;&nbsp; And in some sense it has been a miracle&nbsp; solution, at least for oil companies. Fun fact for our viewers in the United States:&nbsp; Your government supports carbon capture,&nbsp;&nbsp;
regardless of what happens with the&nbsp; carbon. Oil companies capture the carbon,&nbsp;&nbsp; inject it into the ground to extract more&nbsp; oil, and get subsidies for that. Yes,&nbsp;&nbsp; you heard that right. They get&nbsp; subsidies for extracting more oil.
But it’s not just the US government&nbsp; that likes carbon capture. The British government has invested a&nbsp; staggering 21 billion pounds into it.&nbsp;&nbsp; The Norwegian government has committed&nbsp; about 2 billion dollars, Denmark about 4,&nbsp;&nbsp;
and Germany as much as 5 billion Euros. Canada&nbsp; has heavy subsidies, India is working on it,&nbsp;&nbsp; and the Japanese just passed a&nbsp; law to support carbon capture.
The EU has gone so far to pass a law that requires&nbsp; oil and gas producers to build so many carbon&nbsp;&nbsp; storage facilities by 2030, that ExxonMobil,&nbsp; which has lobbied for carbon storage for years,&nbsp;&nbsp;
went to court to have the legislation removed&nbsp; because they say they just can’t do it. And it’s not just words. Europe’s largest carbon&nbsp; capture facility just opened in the Netherlands.&nbsp;&nbsp;
The gas will be liquefied and shipped to Norway&nbsp; where it’ll be stored in the seabed. Last year,&nbsp;&nbsp; the German company Heidelberg&nbsp; Materials opened the world's first&nbsp;&nbsp; industrial-scale carbon capture plant&nbsp; at a cement factory. Just last month,&nbsp;&nbsp;
Exxon started a carbon capture&nbsp; facility at a steel plant in Louisiana. Governments have been approving CCS projects left&nbsp; and right, and globally, investment in carbon&nbsp;&nbsp; capture was over five billion dollars last year,&nbsp; that’s more than fifteen times as much as in 2020.
I think what’s happened is that governments&nbsp; have stopped listening to climate activists&nbsp;&nbsp; who have claimed that carbon capture is bad&nbsp; and instead started listening to what OPEC,&nbsp;&nbsp; the organization of petroleum exporting countries,&nbsp; has been saying all along. Namely that the point&nbsp;&nbsp;
of climate change agreements is, quote, “emissions&nbsp; reduction; not choosing energy sources.” And they are right. So in some sense this&nbsp; is a good development because it means that&nbsp;&nbsp; governments are being more reasonable.&nbsp; The question is though, will it work?
On paper, it looks good. The&nbsp; British government, for example,&nbsp;&nbsp; says natural-gas power stations fitted&nbsp; with carbon capture can reduce emissions&nbsp;&nbsp; by 90% or more. The Canadian government&nbsp; likewise described a carbon capture project&nbsp;&nbsp;
at a gas power plant with 90% efficiency. And&nbsp; companies themselves claim 90- 95% efficiency. Reality, however, isn't quite as&nbsp; impressive. A test project at a coal&nbsp;&nbsp;
plant in Canada that’s been running since&nbsp; 2014 reached almost 90% efficiency during&nbsp;&nbsp; a three day test. But according to a review&nbsp; from 2022, it averaged just about 63% in a&nbsp;&nbsp;
good year. A plant in Australia averages&nbsp; something like 35% in real world tests. And this is only half the problem. The&nbsp; other half is that the carbon capture&nbsp;&nbsp; itself eats up energy which also comes from&nbsp; the gas, coal, or oil plant. This means that&nbsp;&nbsp;
the net output of the power plant drops, by&nbsp; some estimates by about 30 to 40%. And then&nbsp;&nbsp; if you look at what this means for the total&nbsp; greenhouse gas output per net energy produced,&nbsp;&nbsp; even a capture efficiency of 90% would only be a&nbsp; 70% saving because, effectively, you burnt more&nbsp;&nbsp;
gas to get the energy. For the same reason, it’s&nbsp; going to make steel and concrete more expensive. The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change&nbsp; is working on a report about this. A Guardian&nbsp;&nbsp; investigation that just came out found that&nbsp; at least a dozen lead authors of the report&nbsp;&nbsp;
have links to oil and gas institutions.&nbsp; I think it isn’t hard to guess what’s&nbsp;&nbsp; going to come out of this report, it'll&nbsp; acknowledge that the current facilities&nbsp;&nbsp; are expensive and don’t do much, but will&nbsp; claim that the technology can improve and&nbsp;&nbsp;
it’s a reasonable transition option. Climate&nbsp; activists will complain that big oil is bad. So what are we to make of this? I think&nbsp; that this is an inevitable development and&nbsp;&nbsp; a consequence of our persistent failure to (a)&nbsp; put a price on carbon to prevent market failures&nbsp;&nbsp;
and (b) switch to nuclear fission as fast&nbsp; as possible. It is therefore very likely&nbsp;&nbsp; that we will see more of Carbon Capture&nbsp; and Storage, not less. It’s not great,&nbsp;&nbsp; but at least it’s something. And if nothing&nbsp; else, it tells us that the easiest way to&nbsp;&nbsp;
predict human behavior is that we’ll keep&nbsp; on doing what we’ve already been doing. I love all the conveniences of a smartphone, but&nbsp; traveling with it used to be a headache until I&nbsp;&nbsp;
found out about the electronic SIM cards from&nbsp; today's sponsor, Saily. What they're good for?&nbsp;&nbsp; If you're traveling, you can avoid roaming fees&nbsp; just by switching to a local eSIM. That can save&nbsp;&nbsp;
you a ton of money. Something that I found it&nbsp; useful for, too, is to keep using an old phone&nbsp;&nbsp; which no longer has a SIM card. You can also use&nbsp; it to set a virtual location. How does it work?&nbsp;&nbsp;
It's super easy. Download the app, select a&nbsp; country and a plan, and don't forget to enter&nbsp;&nbsp; my code SABINE before checkout because that'll get&nbsp; you 15% off. Download the eSIM and switch it on,&nbsp;&nbsp;
and that's it. Yes, it's really that simple.&nbsp; Saily has 24/7 support, and if the eSIM doesn't&nbsp;&nbsp; work on your phone, a money-back guarantee. So,&nbsp; use my code SABINE for an exclusive 15% discount&nbsp;&nbsp;
on Saily data plans, and I wish you a good&nbsp; trip. Thanks for watching. See you tomorrow.
