---
title: 'Complexity, citizen engagement in a Post-Social Media time | David Snowden | TEDxUniversityofNicosia'
source: 'https://youtube.com/watch?v=JkJDyPh9phc'
video_id: 'JkJDyPh9phc'
date: 2026-11-15
duration_sec: 1113
channel: 'TEDx Talks'
---

# Complexity, citizen engagement in a Post-Social Media time | David Snowden | TEDxUniversityofNicosia

> Source: [Complexity, citizen engagement in a Post-Social Media time | David Snowden | TEDxUniversityofNicosia](https://youtube.com/watch?v=JkJDyPh9phc)

## Summary

David Snowden's TEDx talk contrasts ordered and chaotic systems with complex adaptive systems, arguing that modern society's over-reliance on outcome-based measurement and rigid targets destroys intrinsic motivation and creativity. He advocates for a complexity-based approach to governance and citizen engagement, using boundary constraints, catalytic probes, and narrative-based data to manage emergence and foster beneficial change.

### Key Points

- **Ordered vs. Chaotic Systems** [00:14] — Human history contrasts ordered and chaotic systems, providing legal structure but also risking the imposition of unnecessary order that destroys creativity and freedom.
- **Engineering Focus on Society** [00:51] — Society has taken an engineering focus, compounding order with excessive outcome-based measurement (KPIs, number of papers), which destroys intrinsic motivation where it's most needed.
- **Complex Adaptive Systems** [01:50] — A more sophisticated view is the complex adaptive system, where everything is connected but many connections are unknown, requiring understanding of linkages rather than control.
- **Party Example: Three Approaches** [03:01] — Organizing a party illustrates three system types: chaotic (random behavior, high recovery cost), ordered (rigid learning objectives, project plans), and complex (boundary constraints, catalytic probes, managing emergence).
- **Managing Complexity** [06:52] — In complex systems, management is simpler: manage only boundary conditions, probes, and amplification strategy, treating ecosystems not as engineering problems.
- **Anecdotal Data and Voice** [07:09] — Understanding complex systems requires anecdotal data (school gate, street stories, beer after work) interpreted by the people themselves, not by AI or experts, and those in power need direct access to raw stories.
- **Citizen Engagement** [08:33] — Engagement tools (e.g., girls' rugby clubs) capture experiences, and people become ethnographers of their own condition within a quantitative framework, not qualitative.
- **Power of Interpretation** [10:27] — Power comes from the power to interpret your narrative, not from handing it over. Art precedes language in evolution; overemphasis on STEM without art hinders invention.
- **Slow Thinking and Reflection** [11:13] — Use popular language to encourage slow thinking and reflection, not immediate questionnaire responses. A triad of qualities yields better data, using games and visual forms (triangles) to capture knowledge beyond text (text is only 10% of what you know).
- **Micro Observations vs. Surveys** [12:38] — A project on health and safety used thousands of micro observations (rule compliance vs. job completion) revealing that surveys and focus groups give socially desirable answers, while micro observations show real patterns, including a crisis of giving up.
- **Change in Complexity** [14:16] — Instead of defining a desired future state (engineering), describe the present and nudge the system in the right direction, looking for the 'adjacent possible' and measuring vectors, not outcomes.
- **Fractal Engagement** [15:30] — Fractal engagement: each district creates its own map from the same source data, adapting to context, avoiding the 'tyranny of the average.' Small actions in the present create sustainable change.
- **Peace and Reconciliation** [16:10] — In conflict resolution, different groups see the same data differently; changing day-to-day narratives of the present is essential, as is trans-generational engagement (e.g., young people with grandparents).
- **Scaling Change** [17:56] — Interventions at local levels, with questions like 'What can I do to create more stories like this, fewer like that?' at ministerial, council, and community levels, achieve genuine sustainable change based on a scientific, not engineering, approach.

### Conclusion

Snowden concludes that to achieve genuine sustainable change, we must shift from an engineering mindset to a scientific one, managing complexity through boundary constraints, probes, and amplification, and empowering citizens to interpret their own narratives. The key is to start with small, local actions that create more beneficial stories and fewer harmful ones.

## Transcript

Transcriber: Mollie Wilson-Milesi Reviewer: Peter van de Ven For all of our history as a species, we've contrasted two types of system:
ordered systems and chaotic systems. It gives us legal structure. it means we can rely on the fact
as they counted them in, As I get older, I find that sort of process of increasing importance.
On the negative side, the fear of chaos is being used to impose order unnecessarily and destroy creativity and to destroy freedom.
we've taken an engineering focus on society, and we've actually compounded order with excessive outcome-based measurement.
If you actually look at the whole history of the last 40 or 50 years, Everything has to have a defined outcome and it has to be a number, whether it's KPIs, number of published papers or whatever else.
says that when human beings are pursuing explicit targets, it destroys intrinsic motivation. And where do we most need intrinsic motivation?
And where do we impose the worst targets? So we need to start to think differently about this, in which we contrast one highly structured system
into something more sophisticated. It's a complex adaptive system. but by its connectivity.
In a complex system, everything is connected with everything else, but many of the connections cannot be known. a reference to cosmology and dark matter.
but we don't know what the constraint is. We see connections making things novel or different in different ways.
Humanity is a complex adaptive system. is critical. It's about understanding the connections, about changing the linkages.
to define the difference between the three types of system - ordered systems, complex systems and chaotic systems - to manage a day to day problem.
So imagine, if you can, that tomorrow you have to organize a party Everybody can imagine that, yeah? And you're making the mistake of holding it in your own house.
You learn not to do this, as you actually have more than one child, right? The advantage of community centres is they have fire hoses. Fire hoses are very useful for cleaning up after a party,
and they're occasionally necessary for crowd control during the party itself. So let's imagine how we would organize a party, If we assume that the system is chaotic,
Their behaviour is random. and go on a personal experience of self-discovery. but it was socially constructed in the first place,
I have a friend in California who did try this once. The recovery cost was too high. The ordered-systems approach, on the other hand,
and all good business consultancy outfits. Under this, it's of critical importance to agree learning objectives to the party The learning objectives should be aligned
with the mission statement for education in the society to which you belong and should be clearly articulated and printed off on motivational posters and water dropping into ponds,
and placed around the walls of the room where you're going to hold the party. As the children come into the party, they should be given Disney playing cards with the party value statement clearly printed on the back.
You will, of course, have produced a project plan for the party. against which you can measure progress against ideal party outcome, and the senior adult will start the party with a motivational DVD -
which isn't aligned with the learning objectives - to demonstrate their personal commitment to the party objectives to the achievement of the milestone targets.
Following the highly successful completion of the party, update your best practice database on party management If at this stage, for any remote reason, the children aren't happy,
who will train them to be really very, very happy, and God help them if they're not the next time they come to a party. The complex-systems approach, on the other hand, is much simpler.
known as a boundary constraint in complexity theory, and say, "Cross that and you die." And one of the things you learn pretty fast as an adult
because rigid boundaries have a habit of breaking catastrophically We then introduce catalytic probes - any type of thing which will actually trigger a pattern of play,
If it's beneficial, we give it more resources. If it's not beneficial, well, that's where we deploy the fire hoses. What we manage is the emergence of beneficial coherence
and we manage the only three things the boundary conditions, the probes and the amplification strategy.
Management and governance is much simpler and you stop trying to treat an ecosystem as if it was an engineering problem So the work I've been doing with my research group and elsewhere
but you have to understand what's going on. by understanding the small particular parts For humans, those are the anecdotal data
of the school gate, the street story, the beer after work. It's the day-to-day anecdotes of people's existence. And we need to understand them through the voice of the people who tell them,
not through an AI machine interpreting the text or an expert making them fit their cultural expectations. People's own voice has to be subject to their own interpretation.
And then we need to allow those in power at any level of society to have direct access to the raw stories of the people they govern, which allow them to hide from reality
behind the guise of policy reports and everything else. In order do that, we have to engage people. They've had enough of focus groups.
Focus groups are biased by the facilitator within 15 minutes. We've never, ever lived, by the way, in a fact-based society. It's just we used to trust experts and now we're trying demagogues for a change.
we actually hand over a lot of our cognitive processes to structures; So in order to do that, we have to engage people. we found that girls' rugby clubs are the main agent of change
So we give them tools by which they can capture their experiences Then they go into old people's homes
because they've become engaged. because teachers need to teach kids about community engagement, about statistics.
their children can go into their communities so they become ethnographers to their own condition This is a huge programme
Wales is a small country. to be ethnographers to their own condition, but within a quantitative framework, not a qualitative framework.
I've seen many attempts at digital storytelling, but nobody thinks about how to scale it, and nobody allows people the power to tell you what their story means,
That kind of like leads us on to using people as ethnographers to their own condition. where we got young girls trying to understand the abuse
but making them the ethnographers, In order to get there, as I say, we have to empower people. And power comes from the power to interpret your narrative,
not from the power to actually hand your narrative over to somebody else. So there are several key elements on this. If you don't know it, art comes before language in human evolution.
The ability to abstract allows for scientific invention. the overemphasis on STEM education at the moment around the world because without art there is no invention.
So if we move up a level of abstraction, we avoid gaming. because we need to use the popular language to have people thinking slow, not thinking fast.
We need reflection, not the immediate response you get on questionnaires. another small country, to keep the stories of their own journey through the health system
so they become a subject in their journey for health, It doesn't challenge the role of the health professional, not the dominant partner, but a co-partner.
and balancing it on a triad between three qualities, you get better data.
typically five to six triangles together with other geometric shapes. It is more like a game, but it's quant backed up by qual, oral form or pictorial form.
We're not restricting it to text for data analytics, because what you can write down is at best 10 percent of what you know. If you focus on information, you radically reduce human knowledge.
Then, of course, we have to find a way to enact what comes out of that. Then we come on to a whole new theory of change.
This is an example from a project working on health and safety. or the health sector. the vertical dimension here is rule compliance;
the horizontal dimension is job completion. This comes from thousands of micro observations, recorded and interpreted by patients or by health professionals.
This is not based on surveys; it's a continuous mass capture. You either follow the rules, or you get the job done. All of the questionnaires, all of the focus groups,
because people know that's the right answer, The day-to-day micro observations tell you something completely different. On the right, it looks better because you've got a pattern at the top
and getting the job done. But that turns out to be a crisis. it's not the day-to-day operations.
to provide empathetic care to patients, but increasingly - bottom left - more people are just giving up a pattern we're seeing in universities.
A traditional change mechanism, and this is the engineering culture, would define a desired future state and try and close the gap.
In complexity, what matters is we describe the present, to nudge the system in the right direction. and nudge economics
because to be quite honest, that's more yanking than it is nudging. and it tries to tug them towards it. and see when it's ready to change.
I look for what in complexity is called an "adjacent possible," near to where I am, but going in the right direction - I don't measure outcomes, I measure vectors:
I click on the material and I say, What can I do tomorrow to create more stories like these and fewer stories like that? at any educational level.
to create more stories like this and fewer stories like that? If this is a hospital administrator, they ask the questions of themselves.
Because basically, as we go underneath that, at a government level, every district has their own map from the same source data,
in a direction appropriate to their context rather than being subject to the tyranny of the average approach, We need to start doing small things in the present
because that just leads to perpetual disappointment. This is from work on peace and reconciliation,
where we've taken ideas as to how we can resolve a conflict, for them to interpret it, how different groups in society represent or see the same data.
see the world in such a different way because you'll just increase conflict. The only thing they're both agreed on is that the red guys are really stupid.
How can we create more stories like this, fewer stories like that? How can we change the day-to-day narratives of the present If you don't change the way that people describe the past and the present,
So that is called fractal engagement, It goes beyond that. In the South Wales valleys at the moment, as we gather this data in,
Instead of young people coming together and having a great event we're saying to young people, we'll train you how to use the software,
but you have to bring somebody from your grandparents' generation with you so you work together as a trans-generation player, they won't tell to their children,
And if you start to create interventions at your local level which work, who can make your ideas happen. What can I as a minister do to create more like this, fewer like that?
At a council level, What can I do to create more like this, fewer like that? What can we do to create more like this, fewer like that in our community? to achieve genuine sustainable change in society,
and based on a scientific approach, not an engineering approach, rather than trying to maintain a machine. for countries, for engagement worldwide.
(Applause)
