---
title: 'The Biggest Threat to Forever Is Us'
source: 'https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=S_UcD-Q_37U'
video_id: 'S_UcD-Q_37U'
date: 2026-10-29
duration_sec: 1124
channel: 'Bellular Warcraft'
---

# The Biggest Threat to Forever Is Us

> Source: [The Biggest Threat to Forever Is Us](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=S_UcD-Q_37U)

## Summary

The video discusses the economic and cultural challenges facing World of Warcraft: Forever, a new MMO server, focusing on how player behavior, bots, and monetization schemes could undermine the game's economy and community. It highlights specific examples like the devilsaur mafia, GDKP raids, and dungeon boosting, and questions whether the player base will embrace cooperative play or fall into exploitative patterns.

### Key Points

- **The Player's Dilemma** [00:03] — A scenario where a player reaches level 40 but cannot afford mount training due to spending gold on auction house gear and materials, illustrating how the in-game economy directly affects player experience.
- **Bots and the Economy** [01:10] — Bots have plagued Classic and Modern WoW, and Forever will likely be no different. The realm-less nature of Forever means bot-driven supply increases will lower prices, making gathering professions less rewarding for regular players.
- **The Devilsaur Mafia** [02:59] — In Classic, organized groups controlled devilsaur leather spawns in Un'Goro Crater, using auto-clickers and macros to monopolize supply, fix prices, and allegedly engage in real-money trading, effectively holding end-game gear hostage.
- **GDKP Raids and Their Consequences** [05:15] — GDKP (Gold Dragon Kill Points) raids allowed players to bid on loot with gold, leading to inflation, RMT, and a culture where gold became king. This system is banned in Forever, but the incentives behind it remain.
- **Reserved Items and Raid Leader Power** [08:11] — Raid leaders often reserve items for themselves or friends, sometimes selling them under the table. This soft power dynamic can become problematic when it becomes the norm, pushing players toward guilds with fair systems.
- **Blizzard's Cultural Nudges** [09:46] — Blizzard has made changes like no mob tagging and no summoning stones to encourage cooperation and social interaction, but these can have unintended consequences, as seen with the dungeon XP changes that accidentally boosted dungeon boosting.
- **The Big Question for Forever** [13:51] — Will new players push back against gold-first gameplay, or will the game be dominated by min-maxers selling services? The beta shows entrepreneurial behavior like selling quest shares, but also potential for exploitative practices like automated warlock summoning services.

### Conclusion

The video concludes that the biggest threat to Forever is not bots or specific exploits, but the player culture that has developed around WoW. It urges Blizzard to actively manage the game's culture to prevent it from becoming dominated by gold-driven, exploitative behavior, and encourages players to choose a more cooperative, less greedy approach.

## Transcript

cold, dark evening. The heating is on, all your chores are done, which means uninterrupted forever time. You've spent the last few weeks slowly exploring Azeroth's new additions, but today you're ready to go a little bit faster.
&gt;&gt; You're finally level 40, and at last the days of walking everywhere are over. So, you hearth home, take the flight to your starting area, and run up to the mount trainer like a child running downstairs on Christmas morning.
Only to find that the button is grayed out because you, my friend, are broke. You got no money. You bought too much auction house gear. Maybe you bought too many pots. And worse yet, all your cloth went into leveling first aid for the
legacy points instead of filling your own coffers. Oh, well. No big deal. A quick loop of herbing or mining should sort that problem out. An hour or so later, you pop back to the auction house to sell your stacks. And well, [&nbsp;__&nbsp;]
They're barely above vendor price. No mount skill for you just yet. Back to the grind. Now, you may be wondering, why did we just make up that fake scenario? Well, actually, there is a real reason. And that is because
economy being broken, and that could be economy being broken, and that could be a problem that you and me actually feel. for similar [music] here. Now, there's a ton of reasons for that, but one of the
major causes is, of course, bots. Even from the first days of the beta, legions of automated level one hunters were roaming around the world on a mission. That mission? Gathering spawn data and tuning up their routing scripts. You
see, Classic was plagued by these bots, modern is plagued by them, and there's really no good reason to believe that Forever won't be plagued by them, too. Worse yet, at least for the economy, the whole realm-less nature of Forever will
actually make the economic impact of all this stuff impossible to avoid. Every bot in Orgrimmar or will increase supply, and that will end up meaning low low prices. And maybe that sounds fantastic for crafters, but it does make
gathering almost useless for regular players. And different bots can always just go and craft for a profit, which will further drag down the value of low to mid-level crafting. Now, a world where no one has to do boring labor
sounds good enough, but wow is a game. In a way, the drudgery of gathering and the time spent crafting are actually part of the fantasy. They make the world feel real. And when it comes to forever, people are properly [music] afraid that
heavy botting and RMT is just something that Blizzard are not equipped to combat. And then because of that, all the economy-based gameplay is a little doomed before it even begins. And it's especially dark when you realize just
how much effort Blizzard have put into revamping professions [music] to make them far more fun and a good bit more useful. If bots ruin the value and you lose motivation to play with professions, then that would just suck.
But bots aren't even the only economic problem, because sometimes, well, human players can actually just be worse. culture, you probably don't know just how bad this can get. But you may
remember the devilsaur mafia, at least from classic where it became pretty servers and eventually the real classic, large groups of players used their abundance of time and classic knowledge to hold one resource hostage. Devilsaur
leather. That's because it was used to make pre-raid bis gear for a whole bunch of classes, and it came from one source, Un'Goro Crater devilsaurs. There were six spawn points, each on its own timer, in a dangerous late game zone. And that
meant that all it took was just a few parties to control the entire supply on any given server. But these were no mere mortals. Using auto clickers and spammed macros, they would grab the tag instantly whenever a devilsaur would
spawn. And with complete control over the leather, they could fix prices as much as they wanted and come out with an abundance of gold. Or allegedly, even a handsome real-life wage. Now, the word mafia might sound a little bit strong
for this, but it absolutely was organized like one. Depending on who you hear the story from, it was multiple guilds across both factions with PvP-ready squads on both sides on call to corpse camp [music]
anyone who wanted to compete. Not a great experience. Cross-faction collusion is in fact explicitly against the World of Warcraft terms of service, and well, there were more than a few whispers about the scale of real money
transactions involved. Of course, it did make for some excellent emergent gameplay. I mean, the whole idea that there was a devilsaur mafia [music] and was doing anti-terms of service things across servers, across factions, that's
cool. And I think it's almost proof that Classic is an amazing MMO. But of course, at the end of the day, they were holding end-game gear hostage in order to profit off of your other players and RMT buyers.
Forever's mega servers and world refreshes might make this kind of thing impossible, but I can almost guarantee you that someone is going to try. And I can guarantee you it's far from the only skulduggery they're going to try and
pull off as well. That's because there's another kind of toxic emergent gameplay that people come up with. And that is GDKP. Those are gold dragon kill points. And that might just sound like complete
actually is is a very controversial type of raid. raids were plagued by people bidding on items with in-game gold. [music] That
for loot or using the old participation-based DKP system, dragon kill points. The idea would be the more you actually turn up and contribute to kills and stuff within your raid, you get DKP points. And then,
the guild you're raiding with, you basically just spend those. It was a system people came up with back in the day to essentially ensure fairness in though, at the end of the raid, the total amount of gold is then split
amongst the raiders. Now, in a way, this sounds good on paper, but in reality, it created perverse incentives for everyone involved. And it led to money becoming king. RMT was effectively a guaranteed way to get loot on your first run,
there was a lot of gold inflation. There was a lot of people doing RMT. That drove up the bids and led to fairly insane situations. It led to an overwhelming need for gold that drove players who weren't RMT'ing to, well,
either RMT themselves or to get some money to then join GTKP raids in order to, well, earn some gold so that eventually they could buy some gear in another GTKP raid. Effectively, what they were doing is
instead of playing the game for fun [music] or to help gear up their guildies. A side effect of splitting up and laundering botted or stolen gold base. And what that led to, just like in real life, was that laundered gold
becoming almost impossible to find and remove. Now, the good news is that GTKP is explicitly banned in Forever, and Blizzard actually promises to take the economy very, very seriously. They've already banned over 2,100 gold buying
accounts in Forever, again, Forever beta, with another 1,600 being banned for selling and botting. Basically, if you so much as touch illegal gold, they're going to crack down. No mercy, no remorse.
But, the problem isn't really the bots or that some people [music] might try GDKP or anything like that. It is the crazy ways that people will play World of Warcraft. Crazy ways that are all driven by very real incentives.
gold. [music] Players basically put the two together and develop GDKP as a way to guarantee that gold becomes gear or that gear becomes gold. GDKP may indeed be banned and I imagine
Blizzard will ruthlessly implement those bans, but the incentives still exist. People still want gear, they still want gold and because of that well, there's already a replacement for GDKP. Now, it's not as unhealthy for the
game economy, but it is just as annoying and it is reserved items. Because putting together a raid is a pain in the ass, raid leaders do end up finding themselves a lot of soft power. They often use that soft power to reserve
items or to put it more plainly, that sword is mine, I said so, I'm in charge and because I'm in charge, I can say so. Or maybe they soft reserve items for their friends. On paper, you may think that sort of thing is a little fair, but
it does become a bit of a problem when it ends up being the norm or even worse when the raid leader is selling the hard reserved item under the table. The world is not exactly fair and that does ring true for Azeroth as well. This
kind of thing happens, people widely hate it, but it is indeed everywhere. The solution is, of course, to join a guild, to make friends and to raid with, well, reasonable people using a fair system. That's a great personal
response, but it goes against the game's own natural incentives. That's because times have changed. Ninja looting used to make you a pariah. Seriously, general back in the day. But today, the game's entire raiding
culture is really about finding ways to get away with it. And in some ways Forever clearly knows that. And I say this because Blizzard have made changes that actually push us toward playing the game the way that they [music] want us
campsites, which are supposed to nudge the culture towards cooperation. Having say no mob tagging, which exists to nudge people towards grouping up with each other for quests. No summoning stones encourages people to spend more
time together and maybe maybe to talk whenever they're traveling. In people will do the right thing and that the culture side of things isn't going to be a problem. And unfortunately, we already have a big example of this.
Forever because basically they didn't want people just farming out dungeons or even worse paying for boosts. Basically, they said, "Play outside, do your quests." Now, the whole fiasco around this is still ongoing, but the important
part is not the mob XP. What's important is that Blizzard [music] buffed quest XP to make up for it. That's the dungeon quests. And that does mean that the first dungeon run you do is super valuable. But of course, that can make
about it, that means getting boosted by a single higher level player is way way better. Because what matters more is not the mob XP, it's the quests. And to be really good, this entire saga is just [music] a big lesson in unintended
consequences and player behavior and how [&nbsp;__&nbsp;] is just [music] hard to get right in an MMO. Because right now, if you bring a level 60 player into Dead Mines, you still get tons of XP. Now, you won't be getting any mob XP, of course, but
of tiny anyway. And you'll also get the loot. And all this means that Blizzard has accidentally made boosting, well, better. And they're kind of just hoping that you don't really notice that.
bit worse because just to sweeten the deal, they added in some items that the boosters might actually want. You see, in Dead Mines [music] at least, there's a ring that drops from our good old friend Mr.
Smite. It's a great ring for a level 17. This sounds bizarre, but at level 60, it's actually even better. That's because it pairs with the Band of the Better Half to give a flat 22 strength, and then another 50 with a proc.
cute little interaction, but it means that if you're lucky enough to get the Dead Mines ring, well, you get to wear that thing for quite a while. But then, instead will stick it in your bank because you may want to pull it out
later. Maybe you hunt down the second ring just [music] to make use of it. That's pretty cool. That's fun. But we know how people are. Sure, you could do Dead Mines a few more times at the appropriate level to hunt for the
ring, but with reduced mob XP, it may not feel worth your time. So, how about you just come back later? Because if you want the ring at 60, then just come back at 60 when you can solo the boss in absolutely no time. Far faster, far
easier, and while you're there, maybe you can let some lowbies tag along to finish up their quests and pick up the loot that you don't want. Hey, nice and efficient. Everyone gets exactly what they want in way less time. And if
you're particularly enterprising, maybe you can ask for tips. GTKP is of course not banned, but dungeon boosting is 100% okay by the book. And of course, I mean, it probably should be, right? Players
having economic activity in a way that they organize between each other, I mean, that's peak MMO stuff. But where the worry comes in in an MMO, is that kind of thing can take off, and then it can lead to a culture of level 60s
making money by hanging around dungeons and offering a few quick clears for quests. On the lowbie end, it would mean the temptation to pay up because, hey, you pay up and then you skip having to find a group or, you know,
&gt;&gt; having to figure out how to actually run the dungeon. So, in other words, via a few funky changes to a few incentives, Blizzard accidentally revived dungeon boosting right at the same time that they tried to kill dungeon
boosting. Such is the nature of MMOs. They're Now, the real reason why I brought this up with the dungeon boosting [music] is it illustrates one of Forever's biggest questions.
The culture that WoW has built up over the years and how that will be in this new MMO. Will the influx of new players push back against the gold first gameplay that became so prevalent during classic, or
will the game be ruled by people trying to min-max every single copper that they can get by selling services? [music] Because right now in WoW, unless Blizzard explicitly clamps down on those things, well, they have just ended up
tell what the norms of Forever are going to be, Forever's beta does actually stand out. It It does stand out [music] in a unique way compared to so many Because people are almost playing it like it is a [music] real game where
their progress won't be reset. And that means we can take a look at what's means we can take a look at what's actually happening. there were people selling everything that they could. In Orgrimmar, people
were actually selling quest shares. Yes, quest shares. You see, there's a Ragefire Chasm quest that needs to be picked up from the Undercity. So, naturally, it's a pretty good idea to just hand over a few silver and save
yourself [music] the run time. I mean, hey, people are indeed a little entrepreneurial. And if you look at it in one way, it is perfect emergent MMO that being real with you, I do kind of love. You have other things [music]
like, say, people selling mage food or mage teleports back in the day. The majority of that's cool, flavorful, and makes WoW feel like a secondary world with its own little, well, goods sector and services sector.
Now, some people can take it a bit far. I haven't seen any myself first hand here, but I have heard whispers, let's just say, of someone setting up automated warlock summoning parties with bots. Basically, you pay a price and a
bot group will summon you wherever the hell you want to go. I mean, imagine it, right? You just have a network of warlocks just in parties across the whole of Azeroth, and for one low low fee, ah,
If that kicked off, it would be quite bad because the friction in the world is part of the intended experience. So, well, paying gold to skip [music] it is, of course, skipping out on the game itself. And one particularly bad example
class quest. The weapon reward was found a way to monetize it. What happened is hunters began to camp the limited spawns for the quest items. They would use traps, pets, [music] and just
the fact that they're a ranged class. And if you wanted to finish your quest without a massive struggle, well, you'd have to pay up for an invite to were doing. They were just sitting there taking [music] all the mob tags.
Screw you, normal player trying to do your quest. Now, a bit of griefing like that is normal, especially in a PvP server, but this relentless nickel and diming of players does feel a little bit different. It feels far less like
players offering legitimate service it feels a lot more like, say, stealing someone's shoes to sell them back rather than, say, making them a new pair. Now, Blizzard fixed this by upping the spawn rate in this case, but it's kind of
crazy that people will literally hold quests hostage for gold. So, I think all this boils down to a fairly basic question. Do you join streamers and [music] dedicated players in fast-paced
optimization culture where every single service imaginable is well, created via griefing or just sold and where loot is hard reserved or maybe paid for under the table. Or do you decide to play it a little bit
more like we did [music] when we were young, innocent and perhaps just a little bit less greedy. I know what my answer is, but we live in the real world and sometimes the majority culture decides what we end up doing just a
little bit more than we ourselves do. And the simple reason why this is important is it can actually damage the game. The prevalence of GDKP game. The prevalence of GDKP ruined classic for so many people. It's
good that Blizzard are disallowing it here, but what's really important is that they don't let the game culture completely escape them because if they completely escape them because if they close their eyes just for 6 months,
they could open them again to find a lot of pretty degenerate [&nbsp;__&nbsp;] going on that average person [music] who just wants to enjoy their MMO. though and that is to play the damn thing when it comes out, so we will have
thing when it comes out, so we will have to see.
