---
title: 'Einstein’s Biggest Blunder Might Have Been Even Bigger!'
source: 'https://youtube.com/watch?v=Kln2KRqrZOk'
video_id: 'Kln2KRqrZOk'
date: 2026-11-11
duration_sec: 400
channel: 'Sabine Hossenfelder'
---

# Einstein’s Biggest Blunder Might Have Been Even Bigger!

> Source: [Einstein’s Biggest Blunder Might Have Been Even Bigger!](https://youtube.com/watch?v=Kln2KRqrZOk)

## Summary

The video discusses a new paper proposing that the universe's expansion is influenced by a quantum uncertainty principle, which could explain recent observations that dark energy is decreasing. The author reviews the paper's strengths and weaknesses, and places it in the broader context of cosmology and quantum gravity.

### Key Points

- **Universe's expansion is changing** [00:00] — Recent observations show the universe's expansion acceleration is decreasing, potentially leading to a future contraction.
- **Dark energy and the cosmological constant** [00:30] — Dark energy is the cause of accelerating expansion; the simplest form is a constant, the cosmological constant, introduced by Einstein in 1917.
- **Einstein's blunder and revival** [01:00] — Einstein called the cosmological constant his 'biggest blunder' after it became unnecessary; it was revived in the late 1990s with a positive sign.
- **Dark energy is decreasing** [01:29] — Observations from DESI and the Dark Energy Survey confirm dark energy is not constant but decreasing.
- **Quantum uncertainty for the universe** [02:29] — The paper proposes the universe has an uncertainty principle: you can't know both its size and the rate of change of its size.
- **Uncertainty affects acceleration** [02:57] — The observed acceleration is smaller by a contribution from the uncertainty, which depends on the universe's size.
- **Prediction and data limitations** [03:27] — The formalism predicts how expansion depends on time, but current data aren't good enough to confirm the exact form.
- **Skepticism from the field** [03:55] — Some astrophysicists, like Lawrence Krauss, are skeptical that dark energy changes over time.
- **Paper's shortcomings** [04:09] — The paper has two major shortcomings: a free constant (can't predict absolute size) and no derivation from quantum gravity.
- **Bullshit meter score** [04:25] — The author gives the paper a 4 out of 10 on the 'bullshit meter'—good idea but loose ends.
- **Need for quantum gravity connection** [04:42] — The author believes connecting cosmological observations to quantum gravity is what's missing in physics.

### Conclusion

The paper offers a neat but incomplete idea linking cosmic expansion to quantum uncertainty, with a free constant and no derivation from quantum gravity. While it's not conclusive, it highlights the kind of connection between observations and quantum gravity that could advance physics.

## Transcript

In the past years we have seen a most&nbsp; interesting discovery: The universe doesn’t&nbsp;&nbsp; expand as we thought it does. New observations&nbsp; have shown that the acceleration is decreasing,&nbsp;&nbsp;
which means that eventually the universe might&nbsp; actually begin to shrink in size. Today I have&nbsp;&nbsp; a remarkable paper, published in a top journal,&nbsp; by a physicist who says that this is because the&nbsp;&nbsp; universe itself has an uncertainty principle. And&nbsp; these recent observations are actually the first&nbsp;&nbsp;
evidence that gravity obeys quantum principles.&nbsp; Well that is interesting, let’s have a look. Dark energy is whatever makes the expansion&nbsp; of the universe speed up. The simplest type&nbsp;&nbsp; of dark energy is one that doesn’t change&nbsp; in time, this is also called a cosmological&nbsp;&nbsp;
constant. Einstein himself already&nbsp; introduced this in 1917. Ironically,&nbsp;&nbsp; he did it with the opposite sign to&nbsp; stop the universe from expanding.&nbsp;&nbsp; When it turned out later that the universe&nbsp; expands, the cosmological constant became&nbsp;&nbsp;
unnecessary and Einstein referred&nbsp; to this as his “biggest blunder.” Then, in the late 1990s, observations revealed&nbsp; that the universe doesn’t just expand,&nbsp;&nbsp; but that the expansion also accelerates.&nbsp; This brought back the cosmological constant;&nbsp;&nbsp;
this time with a positive sign.&nbsp; The biggest remaining controversy&nbsp;&nbsp; was whether Einstein actually ever&nbsp; referred to it as his biggest blunder. But observations have gotten better and&nbsp; in the past years it’s become clear that&nbsp;&nbsp;
dark energy is not actually constant.&nbsp; Rather, its value seems to be decreasing.&nbsp;&nbsp; This has been independently confirmed now&nbsp; by a number of different observations,&nbsp;&nbsp; such as DESI and the dark energy survey&nbsp; and analyses of structures in the universe.
The author of the new paper now says he knows why:&nbsp; it’s a consequence of the uncertainty principle in&nbsp;&nbsp; quantum physics, applied to the entire universe. The uncertainty principle in quantum mechanics&nbsp;&nbsp;
tells us that some pairs of quantities can’t both&nbsp; be measured to arbitrary precision. The best-known&nbsp;&nbsp; example is the position of a particle and its&nbsp; velocity. It’s not that you can’t measure both,&nbsp;&nbsp;
of course you can. But say you have made sure&nbsp; that the particle stays in one place, then,&nbsp;&nbsp; if you repeat the measurement of the velocity,&nbsp; the results will be all over the place. This is&nbsp;&nbsp; what it means that the uncertainty is large, it&nbsp; has a large spread in the measurement outcomes.
The author of the new paper now says that the&nbsp; uncertainty principle must also apply to the&nbsp;&nbsp; universe as a whole: you can’t simultaneously&nbsp; know how large the universe is and how fast its&nbsp;&nbsp;
size is changing. We have an uncertainty&nbsp; contributing to the changing size of the&nbsp;&nbsp; universe. And since the uncertainty depends&nbsp; on the size itself, it’s not a constant. Then he points out that the quantity that we&nbsp; extract from observations is the mean value&nbsp;&nbsp;
of the square of the expansion. Whereas what&nbsp; the maths gives us is actually the square of&nbsp;&nbsp; the mean value. The difference is exactly the&nbsp; variance, so, the uncertainty. He concludes&nbsp;&nbsp; that the acceleration that we actually&nbsp; observe is smaller by a contribution that&nbsp;&nbsp;
comes from the uncertainty, and that&nbsp; depends on the size of the universe. Okay, I know this was somewhat confusing, but&nbsp; the brief summary is that he says the quantum&nbsp;&nbsp; uncertainty of the universe fits to the most&nbsp; recent observations. And the idea also gives&nbsp;&nbsp;
rise to a prediction. That is because this&nbsp; formalism fixes just how the expansion of&nbsp;&nbsp; the universe depends on time. At the moment the&nbsp; data aren’t good enough to say decisively just&nbsp;&nbsp;
how the time-dependence looks like. But&nbsp; it might become possible in the future.&nbsp; Indeed, astrophysicists haven’t even yet&nbsp; agreed that dark energy is not constant.&nbsp;&nbsp; If you have been listening to my monthly science&nbsp; news podcast with Lawrence Krauss, you might have&nbsp;&nbsp;
noticed that he thinks the recent observations&nbsp; that dark energy changes in time won’t hold up. So what are we to make of this? Personally, I&nbsp; like this paper. It’s a neat, minimalistic and&nbsp;&nbsp;
straight-forward argument from basic physics,&nbsp; I like this stuff. That said, it has two major&nbsp;&nbsp; shortcomings. One is that he can’t actually&nbsp; predict the absolute size of the effect,&nbsp;&nbsp; so there’s a free constant. The constant&nbsp; is free. The predictive power costs extra.&nbsp;&nbsp;
The other issue is that he hasn’t derived this&nbsp; quantum uncertainty from any candidate approach&nbsp;&nbsp; to quantum gravity. These two points make the&nbsp; paper theoretically somewhat unsatisfactory,&nbsp;&nbsp; this is why I give it a 4 out of 10 on the&nbsp; bullshit meter. Good idea, some loose ends. &nbsp;
But leaving aside the specifics of this paper,&nbsp; I think it is something like this that we are&nbsp;&nbsp; missing in the foundations of physics. Some way to&nbsp; connect the increasingly puzzling observations and&nbsp;&nbsp;
tensions in cosmology to quantum gravity.&nbsp; That could really move the field forward.&nbsp; It would also be historically a neat closure.&nbsp; It would leave Einstein wrong about introducing&nbsp;&nbsp; the cosmological constant, then&nbsp; wrong about discarding it again,&nbsp;&nbsp;
then wrong again because it’s ignored quantum&nbsp; physics, and yet he was still somehow responsible&nbsp;&nbsp; for us understanding all of this. Next up we’ll&nbsp; study the quantum uncertainty of peer review.&nbsp;
I used to receive a lot of spam calls&nbsp; after my cell phone number leaked,&nbsp;&nbsp; probably from some online shops that I used&nbsp; to use. This is why I've signed up to Incogni&nbsp;&nbsp; who've been sponsoring this video and who've&nbsp; prevented this from happening again. You see,&nbsp;&nbsp;
the issue is that each time you open a website,&nbsp; it'll try to collect data about who you are and&nbsp;&nbsp; where you are and what other websites you've&nbsp; visited. Many firms then make money by selling&nbsp;&nbsp; your private information to data brokers.&nbsp; Most countries have laws against that and&nbsp;&nbsp;
you can ask for your data to be removed, but&nbsp; doing this takes up a lot of time. Incogni&nbsp;&nbsp; automates the process of getting you out of those&nbsp; databases. You sign up and they will request that&nbsp;&nbsp;
your personal details be removed. They'll keep&nbsp; on doing that and if you want send you regular&nbsp;&nbsp; updates. They now also have a custom removal&nbsp; feature where you can submit specific websites.&nbsp;&nbsp;
I've been using this a lot. Incogni has really&nbsp; solved the problem for me. If that sounds like&nbsp;&nbsp; something you could need to use my code SABINE&nbsp; or the custom link in the info because the first&nbsp;&nbsp;
100 people to use it will get 60% off. Stay&nbsp; safe. Thanks for watching. See you tomorrow.
