---
title: 'I Rank The Best A4/S4 Generations'
source: 'https://youtube.com/watch?v=-8BBKmnnuqg'
video_id: '-8BBKmnnuqg'
date: 2026-11-07
duration_sec: 89
channel: 'Doug DeMuro'
---

# I Rank The Best A4/S4 Generations

> Source: [I Rank The Best A4/S4 Generations](https://youtube.com/watch?v=-8BBKmnnuqg)

## Summary

This video features a discussion ranking the Audi A4/S4 generations, with participants debating the merits of each model from the B5 to the B9. The conversation highlights the B5's role in saving Audi, the B7's improved facelift, and the overall competence of newer generations.

### Key Points

- **B5 as the Best Audi** [00:03] — The B5 is considered the best Audi of all time because it 'saved Audi' and was well-engineered and tight.
- **B5 S4 Reliability Issues** [00:16] — The B5 S4 had notorious water pump failures, leading some shops to refuse working on them.
- **B5 A4 as a Compact Executive Car** [00:30] — The regular B5 A4, which made up 98% of sales, was an excellent compact executive car and is now affordable at around $4,000.
- **All A4 Generations Are Good** [00:42] — The B7, B5, B6, B8, and B9 are all considered good cars, with the B9 being particularly competent.
- **B8's Strengths** [00:55] — The B8 is praised for its rear sport differential and overall quality, making it a strong contender for the best A4.
- **Ranking the Generations** [01:09] — One participant ranks the generations as B5, B7, B6, B8, B9, noting that the B9 is last only because the others are so strong.
- **B7's RS4 and Facelift** [01:22] — The B7 is ranked second due to the RS4, which introduced a V8, and its facelift is considered one of the few that truly improved the original design.

### Conclusion

The discussion concludes that while the B5 holds historical significance and the B7 offers a great facelift, all A4 generations are competent, with the B8 also being a strong contender for the best.

## Transcript

&gt;&gt; Next would be B7, man, at the end of the day. &gt;&gt; B5 is the best looking. &gt;&gt; I'll get B5 second place over the B6. &gt;&gt; First off, B5 literally saved Audi. From that perspective alone, it's the best
Audi of all time. B5 was like a tight, well-done, well-engineered, perfectly &gt;&gt; a a stretch. &gt;&gt; You're thinking of S4s. I'm thinking of &gt;&gt; ever had a water pump go out on a B5 S4 There there's a there's a literal shop
in San Diego that has a rule that says we will work on any Audi except for the B5. &gt;&gt; Regular B5 at A4, which was 98% of sales, was an excellent compact executive car. To this day, I think
&gt;&gt; you know what? They're available for like 4 grand [laughter] in anyone's like 4 grand [laughter] in anyone's driveway. So B7, B5, B6, B8 &gt;&gt; B9. B9's a pretty good car, honestly. All of the A4 gens have been good.
rear sport diff. You could still get it &gt;&gt; From the perspective of all A4s, it's hard to say the B8 is not like the best. It was a really nice car. My list is probably B5, B7,
&gt;&gt; Yeah. &gt;&gt; B6, B8, B9. Which is hard to say B9 is last cuz they're so competent. B7 has to be second because the RS4. If not for &gt;&gt; No. &gt;&gt; It introduced the V8 and had the big fat
&gt;&gt; It looks good. Don't get me wrong, but the B7 is just It's one of the few facelifts that truly improved upon the original.
