---
title: 'I Got My Body Fat Tested Every Way- Which Is Most Accurate?'
source: 'https://youtube.com/watch?v=Y6xv3dACPss'
video_id: 'Y6xv3dACPss'
date: 2026-11-12
duration_sec: 1468
channel: 'Renaissance Periodization'
---

# I Got My Body Fat Tested Every Way- Which Is Most Accurate?

> Source: [I Got My Body Fat Tested Every Way- Which Is Most Accurate?](https://youtube.com/watch?v=Y6xv3dACPss)

## Summary

In this video, the creator undergoes a comprehensive body fat assessment using multiple methods, including BodPod, underwater weighing, skinfolds, BIA, and waist-to-hip ratio, to determine which is most accurate. The results vary wildly, from 3.2% to 32.8%, highlighting the strengths and limitations of each technique. The creator concludes that while no single test is perfect, combining several methods and understanding their biases provides the best estimate.

### Key Points

- **BodPod Principle** [00:42] — The BodPod measures body volume to calculate density, using the known densities of fat and lean mass to estimate body fat percentage. It's a two-compartment model.
- **BodPod Result** [01:37] — The BodPod gave a body fat estimate of 4.4%, which the creator considers optimistic but more accurate than a previous 12% reading.
- **Underwater Weighing Result** [03:24] — Underwater weighing, the gold standard, estimated body fat at 3.2-3.9%. The creator notes this is likely skewed low due to his extremely dense bones.
- **Skinfold Results** [05:24] — Skinfold measurements varied by site count: 3-site gave 4.13%, 9-site gave 5.9%, and 7-site gave 8.3%. The 7-site is considered most valid due to research support.
- **BIA Results** [06:52] — Bioelectrical impedance analysis (BIA) gave wildly inconsistent results: 20.5% on a handheld device and 32.8% on a standing scale, both deemed unreliable.
- **Waist-to-Hip Ratio** [08:13] — Waist-to-hip ratio gave a 10-14% estimate, but it's considered a rough tool, not a true body fat measurement, as it doesn't measure actual tissue.
- **True Body Fat Estimate** [16:59] — The creator estimates his actual body fat at 7-8%, based on the cluster of results from more reliable methods like skinfolds and DEXA.
- **Practical Advice** [17:27] — Waist circumference is excellent for tracking progress, BIA is unreliable for non-standard demographics, and skinfolds are best done by professionals for tracking changes.
- **BodPod and DEXA Recommendations** [19:36] — BodPod is accurate within 3% and a good choice; DEXA has a 1-3% error rate and should be used sparingly, not every few weeks.
- **Underwater Weighing Caveats** [21:41] — Underwater weighing is the gold standard but has a 1-2% error rate due to lung volume assumptions; blowing out all air is crucial for accuracy.

### Conclusion

The video demonstrates that body fat testing methods vary significantly in accuracy, with no single test being perfect. The best approach is to use multiple methods, understand their biases, and focus on tracking changes over time rather than absolute numbers.

## Transcript

because last time we did some dexes, the results were absolutely wacky. &gt;&gt; You're fat. &gt;&gt; What's a percent and a half in 12 weeks of dieting? &gt;&gt; Man, this is the first major DEXA flub
I've ever seen. So, we came here. It is in the state of Michigan. It is an lab, amazing people, and they were like, "Hey, get in here and just take every body comp test known to man except for the MRI." But we're working on that.
Let's get started and see how fat I am using every test ever [music] invented.
body has a certain density and we know roughly what the average density of lean mass is. That is your muscles, bones, all the fluids, everything else. And roughly what your density of fat mass is. [music] And we can get your density
the bodpod. And the bod pod just really measures one thing, how much volume you it's just a relationship of volume to mass. We'll have both. So, it's actually a very, very accurate representation of body composition and a two compartment
model. [music] We're going to get body fat percent off of this and we can infer body fat amount and lean mass amount. [music] It's a little claustrophobic in there, but uh I like it because every single BodPod is also a time machine and
teleportation device. Just bonus stuff that comes with the machine. &gt;&gt; All right, &gt;&gt; see what the numbers look like.
&gt;&gt; Where is it? &gt;&gt; A moment of truth. &gt;&gt; A moment of truth. 4.4. Wa. Um, that's generous. I wish. You know,
there's levels to this. That ain't me. That's a little optimistic, I think. Had a DEXA just a few days ago. Got me at 6%. I kind of believe more of that a little bit, you know. Although, this is cool. Amazing reference standard. I'm
really curious to see how this compares to underwater weighing instead of just pure assumption on the air cavity situation. You are allowed an ability to kind of breathe out as much as you candeed. And then it references that uh
&gt;&gt; Right. Correct. &gt;&gt; But I'm with you. it. That's low and I would say generous, but yeah, but um it [music] seems more accurate than a 12%. &gt;&gt; Yeah, definitely more accurate than
&gt;&gt; So, you're going to sit right on that platform. Um [clears throat] &gt;&gt; Yeah, it does move cuz that's what's weighing you ultimately.
&gt;&gt; Are you sure? &gt;&gt; Well, I'm so sorry. &gt;&gt; No, you're all right. I'm too fat for the machine. the machine. &gt;&gt; Insane.
[laughter] &gt;&gt; You're fat. You're fat. You're fat. &gt;&gt; You're fat. You're fat. You're fat. &gt;&gt; Shut up, man. [laughter] platform [music] and you're going to blow out all your air, like as much as
you physically can, and then duck under. And the biggest thing is staying still. come up and we'll see how the data &gt;&gt; Yeah. &gt;&gt; All right. We're ready when you are.
Get it all out. Get it all out. Get it all out. green line is measuring his his weight underwater. So, it's truly literally a
scale that's just communicating with the computer wirelessly. And you can see a that's a lot of movement. How I find body fat is by [music] highlighting over that flat area and it averages the three to five seconds that he was underwater
inside of his system. And it says his body fat percentage is 3.9. dog. &gt;&gt; Uh, do I need a cookie? &gt;&gt; All right, ready, Mike? We're going to do another one. Go
All right, you ready? &gt;&gt; All right, let's do it.
&gt;&gt; Hey, he's always laughing. I don't know what &gt;&gt; We got to start drug testing our work. I got 3.4 at 3.4 when I look at the full good. Pretty consistent. Well done. All's got a towel for you.
All's got a towel for you. &gt;&gt; I was just filming in case you eat hair. on your head. &gt;&gt; Hair on your head. It's a joke.
&gt;&gt; Yeah. [music] &gt;&gt; We're going to do skin folds now. &gt;&gt; Okay. I love it.
sites. As I mentioned, the nine sight formula is not near as validated as the them both to be most inclusive, but at [music] the same time most validated equation. And then I am going to do a couple trials per spot. One of the error
reasons with uh skin folds is it is [music] going to have naturally occurring variation between repetitions. So four I'm going to have you help me a little bit and find your iliac [music] crest.
site because that is all the sites um plugged into an equation with that. We got 5.9%. So slightly elevated from some of the other two more accurate measures. However, when we dropped it down to seven sight, I got 8.3%. [music]
What um can play a role in that is the two that it eliminates is bicep and &gt;&gt; Well, exactly. So that's where it could be a little inflated because [music] yeah, we're eliminating two sites and which sites will matter for people's
results. Same thing with three sight down to three sight. We got 4.13ish%. [music] That is actually closest to the other two methods. Definitely the site selection is going to play a role in that, but you got three different ones.
front of you. It's going to throw you a number. So, it'll think and then it [music] will give you your response. &gt;&gt; Yeah, baby. &gt;&gt; 20.5%. &gt;&gt; 20.5%.
&gt;&gt; When I say the BIA is kind of not a real test, &gt;&gt; there's a reason I say that. [laughter] &gt;&gt; Okay, go ahead and step on and see what it gives us. I got my numbers. You can step off.
&gt;&gt; 32.8%. Body fat. [laughter] &gt;&gt; We started real good. &gt;&gt; Wait, what' you say? High, high, and &gt;&gt; That's what his categories are. For weight, it says high. For BMI, it says
&gt;&gt; Yes. &gt;&gt; That's crazy. That's crazy. All right, we got one more. This last one's a relatively new one. take a picture of you. It's called Sprren. I love it.
&gt;&gt; And they claim also on their website to be just as valid as Bod Pod. wrong. &gt;&gt; I want you to Let's move back. I'm going to push this table backwards. Scott still wants us to go back further.
going to work. &gt;&gt; Side scan. Stand with your feet &gt;&gt; Still wants us to take steps back. &gt;&gt; Move back so that your upper body fits into the frame. &gt;&gt; Well, h that's really interesting. All
right, we'll scrap it. &gt;&gt; All right, guys. So, our next test is something that I insisted upon. It is just taking a tape measure and doing waist and hip and all that stuff. It's cool because they used to use this test
all the time before you had enough people formerly trained in anthropometry to do skinfold assessments. And for masses of people, this does beat the BMI as an inference for body fat, but not by much because two measurements just tells
They use this kind of stuff for mass insurance purposes. They use it for military purposes back in the day. And so I what I just want to tell you guys is do not assume this tells you your body fat percent, but we're going to get
charts and graphs for you so you can see how all the measures compare. And uh this is just for vibes. So thank you for doing it. Yeah. What' you say? 74. &gt;&gt; Oh, 79. That's That's [music] low. So, that's what they're giving you. Low
which is good. And you were the shape of a pair according to this chart. odd pair, &gt;&gt; but I'll take it. &gt;&gt; I wouldn't eat that pair. I I I would I was
recently. I took like 2 and 1/2 months to recmp after recovering from surgery and 3 and 1/2 months to get way leaner over this last half year. My look and my
over this last half year. My look and my strength changed like crazy. I got some Dexas at the end and there was controversy. controversy. I got two Dexas showing me at 14ish%
body fat and showed that I had lost like 20 lb but apparently only 1% fat, which means I lost like a bajillion pounds of muscle. Then we used another different
muscle. Then we used another different brand of DEXA, and that had me at 6% fat and 222 lb, which vibed way better than the 14% fat original estimate. But it left me thinking, what if that 6% was just as much of an exaggeration as the
14%. Like, what if I was actually about 10% fat after that fat loss phase and not the 6% that I had hoped? We doubted that the 14% was true because it clearly wasn't. But then why would we just accept the 6% as true? Nah, we're a
science-based. We don't do that sort of thing. I'm not going to go on just one DEXA scan, you know? Like, we literally showed the DEXA could be erroneous and massively so. And then I'm all like, well, one DEXA showed I'm 6% fat. So, I
wanted to get some other body fat measures in there that weren't just dexas to make sure I wasn't smoking the rosecoled copium pipe too hard. Scott the video guy in his infinite wisdom reached out to a colleague of
wisdom reached out to a colleague of mine Dr. James Sackett at Cornerstone Dr. Sacket leads the kinesiology program at Cornerstone University in Grand Rapids, Michigan. Him and the team there are super experts and they have a new
unbelievably welle equipped facility with like almost every body composition with like almost every body composition test. And honestly, short of an MRI, test. And honestly, short of an MRI, they had it all. For these tests, I was
217 lbs measured on the day. For the DEXA, I was 222. All body water, all in DEXA, I was 222. All body water, all in the mix. All right, so let's go in order literature, like which of these tests probably doesn't say much, all the way
to the most valid. First, my waist to hip ratio was 79. 34 inch waist, 43 inch hips. Girl, this is citing the Bergman at all 2011
relative fat mass calculations would give me a 10 to 14% body fat estimate, which is a trip. Maybe that 14% was right, or best case scenario, 10. Uh-oh.
Now, don't worry. It gets worse because on the standing scale of the BIA biological impedance analysis, I scored an earthshattering 32.8%
body fat. Okay, good news, better news. On the handheld BAA, I got 20.4% body fat. So, we started at 10% being optimistic, and now we're in the mid20s again on average, which is strange with
glute details and veins, but who am I to critique? I'm just the guinea pig here. Now, the skinfolds started to tell a different story. On the three sight different story. On the three sight skinfold, I had a 4.13%
body fat estimate. On the nine site, the most comprehensive, I had a 5.9% estimate. And on the seven site, which has the most data on it, so it's 8.3% estimate.
Here's the interesting part. On the BodPod, I had a 4.4% body fat estimate. On the DEXA, which is the next most valid, as you guys know, I had a 6% and
the gold standard in the research literature has been and is underwater weighing in which I scored a 3.2% body fat estimate. Oh my god. So, what
does this mean? Let's interpret every single one of these results. The average waist to hip ratio in position was oh 12% body fat. The thing is this is such a rough test that it's more or less noise, but it's not crazy crazy far off
from what my body fat probably is. The big problem with tests like this is that no actual tissue was measured. like my hips and thus my butt could have been super lean or almost all fat and it would have given the same exact result.
Think about that. How could that be super valid? Genetics for wider or slimmer waist are almost entirely missing from this determination. So, it probably doesn't mean much. The standing scale BIA had me at 32.8%
fat. Now, guys, I can self-deprecate till I'm blue in the face, but this is till I'm blue in the face, but this is just comedy. I mean, look, I'm not 3% fat. I think we can all agree to that. And maybe I'm not even 6% fat in real
life. But anything much over 15% with grainy hamstrings and quad veins is kind grainy hamstrings and quad veins is kind of a bit absurd. The handheld BIA had me at 20.4% and it's almost as absurd as the scale. By the way, the scale and for
sure the handheld have a different button you press to choose athlete mode versus regular mode. Anything with a button in which you have modes are highly unlikely to give you actual outputs because it's all makebelieve.
Humans don't come in two modes. There's no such thing as athlete and regular person. It's all a gradation. Skinfolds three sight had me just over 4% fat. I'm almost certainly not that lean. 4% of shredded face striations
freaky. I might get there someday, but I'm sure not there today. I'm sure not there today. nines sight at 5.9% as possible and the most comprehensive which means it measured more parts of my body which
gives us a very good assessment. So very reasonable. The seven site has the most research support for it's the most valid had me at 8.3. Now it didn't include my calves which for me are super lean but otherwise seemed very very realistic.
otherwise seemed very very realistic. The Bodpot had me at 4.4%. I'm probably not this low in real life, but because my bones, according to every dex I've ever taken, and the older I get, seemingly the more dense they get,
are incredibly dense, like five standard deviations above the average. Because my deviations above the average. Because my bone density is so high, my overall body density is way higher. Because the bodpod and the underwater weighing
system of determining body composition rely heavily, actually exclusively on density, heavier than average bones can make someone like me look substantially leaner. And that's probably why my bod pod had me at lean as it did because I'm
not actually 4%, but I got heavy, heavy bones, which makes me seem leaner than I actually am. The DEXA 6% it seems optimistic but within the realm of reasonable underwater weighing at 3.2% almost certainly not this low in real
life and it's the same situation as the BodPod because my bones are like off the charts dense. This will skew to lower percents for me than is a thing in reality. Now for the Cudigra, what do I think my actual in real life ground
truth body fat was at the time of these tests? I'd throw some money at about 7 tests? I'd throw some money at about 7 to 8%. Very reasonable. Sure. not 14%, definitely not 32.8%, but in my most optimistic fever dream,
not 3.2% like the underwater weighing says. I have some insights for you about how to interpret your own various results from these tests should you ever get them. Here's my spiel for you guys. Take
[sighs] First, waist to hip ratios are not body fat estimates, but measuring your waist every 3 weeks or so during a fat loss plan is an amazing way to track fat loss progress. And choosing a top-end
measurement for your muscle gain plan can make it so that you don't get too bulky. If you're at your leanest at 34 in in your waist and you tell yourself, "My bulk ends at 38 in." You can't get delusional and be up to 42 in and be
like, "Oh god, I got too fat." you as soon as you hit 38 inches for two weeks then you cap it, you go to maintenance, and then you do a fat loss phase. Again, really good way to use the uh this system of measurement because all you
need is a waist circumference tape measure for this test is incredibly simple and easy for you to do at home. As a real indicator of body fat, it is almost completely useless. As a relative indicator of body fat for a single
person is an incredibly powerful, cheap, and effective tool. Next, the BIA works and effective tool. Next, the BIA works pretty well for a 65 kg 20-year-old male undergrad on who most of the validation work for these machines is done. But if
you're remotely more not in that demographic, if you're older or female or jacked or lean, the test is fundamentally kind of a random number generator, and I just wouldn't put any stock into it at all.
Skinfolds are awesome and valid and precise if administered by a professional. Ideally, somebody certified in anthropometry, which is a administered by a not professional, you're kind of just gambling and it's
not reality. It's also best for skinfold not to actually estimate what your body fat is, but to track changes. If every three your skinfold, you can see how your progression is both in gaining fat on a
muscle gain phase to make sure you don't gain too much and in losing fat in a fat loss phase to see how you compare to the last time you did it. The Bod Pod is usually great and will get you within about 3% of your actual percent fat in
most cases. So in this case, my Bod Pod was about 4%. I think I'm actually 7 to 8%. That makes total sense. If you have a Bodpot around, feel free to use it at the end of every fat loss phase. And the great thing about the Bodpot is this.
wet and cold. You don't have to shoot X-rays literally at your face like you the way. But hey, one less X-ray and $100 is uh some good savings for you. BodPod is amazing, very precise, very accurate. It has its error rate, but
absolutely give you a reasonable estimate of your body fat. The DEXA is great, but the algorithms are classified firmware, and sometimes the algorithms are wrong, as we have seen in our huge DEXA controversy. Bad firmware update
can screw the whole thing. So, using a DEXA is totally fine. It's totally awesome if you want, but remember, the DEXA still has a 1 to 3% error rate on average. Sometimes it can be higher than that. So using Adexa at the end of every
fat loss phase is great, but don't squit too hard at the results and don't use it every 3 weeks because you're just measuring noise at that point. Use it for percent fat, by the way, and not too much lean body mass calculation to infer
muscularity because that LBM number depends on hydration like crazy. If you're similarly fed and hydrated and glycogen loaded with every scan, that helps a ton with muscle mass tracking. Because if you have different variables,
and once you were super dry and super depleted, you're going to look like you're losing or gaining 5 or 10 pounds of muscle and it's really just body water. If you use rep strength calculations, if you use the RPertrophy
progress and your rep strength is that you've maintained your muscle through a fat loss phase, you're good to for muscle mass because body water is such a huge confounder. With the fat
percent, that tends to be valid and very precise either way. The underwater weighing system of measurement is literally the scientific gold standard. literally the scientific gold standard. So, if you have one, absolutely use it.
Unfortunately, you probably don't have one because these systems are tough to around it, including the room that it's stored in and all that stuff. And even underwater weighing is going to have a 1 to 2% error rate on lung volume
assumptions. If you have very, very frail bones or very, very thick bones, of your air out underneath the water, or if you hold a bunch of air in, it's going to change the results big time. By the way, if you ever get underwater
weighing, the more air you can blow out of your lungs, the heavier you appear on the underwater scale and the leaner the machine is going to think you are. But not just leaner, more accurate. So, if you are
underneath the water and you have a lot of air in your lungs yet cuz you're too much of it as possible and wait just one or two seconds, you're going to look motivation for blowing out as much air as possible. Is it weird to blow out all
of your air underwater? Yeah. Hell yeah. It's weird. But the more you can do, the better. However, again, all of these have their error rates. So, don't go Otherwise, I would tell people I'm 4%
fat, be delusional, be made to feel like a clown, and that would in fact be the case. All right. Lastly, my future plans. If my health holds up, from March to July, I'll be dieting to try to get to that next level of lean, which
to that next level of lean, which scientists describe as Tristan Lee, and maybe getting some more measurements to see how lean I can get. Major major shout out to Cornerstone University, Dr. Sackett and his amazing
teams. Dr. James Sacket, PhD, and his amazing amazing team. Dr. James Sacket, PhD, and his amazing team hooked us up like crazy. If you're going to be an undergrad and you want an amazing exercise science undergrad program with
one of the best body composition labs in the whole world, and trust me, I've seen a lot. I'd highly recommend considering pursuing your education at Cornerstone pursuing your education at Cornerstone University in Grand Rapids, Michigan.
Guys, the professors here at Cornerstone University have an unbelievable setup. They're phenomenal people, utmost professionals. humongous thank you to you guys for letting us get in here and get all all over your equipment and uh
yeah, we learned some stuff. It turns out that some of the body fat tests come wacky results, but the real good way to do body fat analysis is to take a bunch cluster together. You have a few odd tests out, those are probably not the
and you try to just cope with living your life as someone with really high body fat like me. See you guys in the next video. [music]
