[00:00] Some time ago I had an exchange on Twitter with  Jake Mey, he's a registered dietitian and PhD   and he does research on ketogenic diets and he was  basically saying he's less worried about saturated   [00:13] fat in the background of a low carb diet and I've  heard people ask this question many times but it's   almost never an argument with any scientific  foundation and he was trying to construct an   [00:25] argument so it seemed interesting so we hopped  on a call to have an informal conversation about   this. This is pretty free-flowing, we didn't even  think we were going to publish it initially but   we keep getting this question over and over so I  thought, why not. So I hope this helps. This topic   [00:41] often comes up when I talk to either RD students  or nutrition students, I give lectures because   I do ketogenic diet research, right, that is part  of my work and it always comes up on positives and   [00:54] negatives of the ketogenic diet for the general  public and my starting point is always the   negative effects of saturated fats and I always  start with saying, look, the lay interpretation   [01:06] of a ketogenic diet, which I call your bacon,  beef and butter ketogenic diet, that is not good,   that is clearly defined as super high saturated  fat, in no context could we find any situation   where that high a level of saturated fat can be  construed as anywhere in like the healthy range,   [01:24] right, and I contrast that always with the  research-grade ketogenic diets, work that I do on   a small level but work that Kevin Hall and Chris  Gardner have done when they develop these really   [01:36] well formulated ketogenic diets that focus on  omega-3 fatty acids, omega-6, olive oils, right,   your avocados, your healthy fats, your poly, mono  and saturated fats, right, and so that's always   the starting point, the starting point is, hey,  when we do research-grade ketogenic diets, they   [01:52] look like this, they don't look like bacon, beef,  butter, right, so that's always the starting point   but beyond that, when you get into something like  the ketogenic diet it is really difficult and not   [02:04] even necessarily necessary to drop saturated fat  to the standard levels that we use on other diets,   right, our less than 7% of total calories or  less than 10%, wherever you lie in that range,   [02:17] right, that gets extraordinarily difficult to have  massive amounts of poly and monounsaturated fats   in the diet and in the context of ketogenic  diets when you just look at that population   [02:30] I think it's pretty clear that there's a different  physiology, there's a different metabolic milieu   as we call it, right, there's different things  going on in the body, different utilization of   fat metabolism, different turnover rates of fats,  and then beyond that, what's in the blood is,   [02:44] you don't see the higher levels of insulin and  sugar and all that, right, so it's a different   physiology, the ketogenic physiology. What  I generally try to portray is that all the   information and correlations we have on higher  saturated fat intakes and their relationships   [02:58] with LDL cholesterol and cardiovascular disease  and all that those are built in the context of a   carbohydrate-based diet, right, so we don't  actually have strong research on the levels   of relationships of saturated fat outside of  a carbohydrate-based diet context, right, we   [03:14] just don't have that large epidemiologic data to  be able to assess it, so when I say things like,   hey, the levels of saturated fat in the context of  a ketogenic diet are not likely to have the same   [03:27] risk outside of that, it's one, because we don't  have the research that shows it does, and in the   studies where we have individuals on ketogenic  diets we don't have, if you would look at, and I   [03:41] don't know if anyone's done this but just based  on the lack of studies that have been cancelled   for heart attacks and whatnot or cardiovascular  disease, right, you don't see just people getting   [03:54] heart disease when they have higher saturated fats  on these diets when it's the research-grade diets,   right, so you have this issue where all  the data is on a carbohydrate-based diet,   we don't have great reasons to necessarily  say, hey, these high saturated fat levels in   [04:09] the context of a ketogenic diet has the same  risk as outside of it, that's when I say,   look, there's likely a different physiology  and we probably need more research to show   [04:21] where that healthy amount of saturated fat is  on a ketogenic diet in terms of cardiovascular   disease health. Based on just my perception  of everything I don't view them the same,   like I don't view saturated fat on a carb diet  the same as saturated fat on a ketogenic diet,   [04:36] for those reasons, so that's like where all that  comes from, right, is the context of where the   data is at and came from versus the physiology  of being on a ketogenic diet and the difference   [04:49] in the role saturated fat could potentially play  in heart disease, LDL-cholesterol, all those sort   of items. I think there's a difference here  between acknowledging a level of uncertainty,   [05:01] which I completely agree with, and then going too  far and saying the risk factor doesn't count on my   diet, it's an oasis and you guys can go ahead  and expose yourselves. What I do think is a   reasonable argument and something that we should  bear in mind is the level of uncertainty for a   [05:18] risk factor that hasn't obviously been shown  in every possible dietary iteration, it has   never been shown in very low carb diets, in very  low fat diets, in vegan diets, in paleo diets.   [05:31] However I think it's important to bear in mind  that this uncertainty would extend to not just all   diets but all risk factors too: smoking, diabetes,  high blood pressure. We don't have outcomes based   [05:43] trials for every risk factor on every possible  diet, it's theoretically possible that one day   diet X, the Jenny Craig diet, will be shown to be  an exception for smoking, smoking will be fine in   [05:55] the background of that diet. Is that theoretically  possible? Yes. Am I going to stake my health or   recommend that in guidelines on the off chance?  No. Right? And so this is for me, that's kind of   [06:08] how I see it, for me all these diets, I see  them all with the same principle and I see   low carb diets and ketogenic diets with the same  lineup where, is it possible that one day they'll   [06:20] pressure? Sure, same as any other. Would I stake  my life on it or would I issue recommendations,   do I think that makes sense? No. That's really  interesting, so I've never heard someone kind   [06:37] of group the concept like that but I totally  understand it and that makes perfect sense and in   the context of like viewing probably what a lot of  people say on social media, man I agree 100% with,   yeah if someone just says, well does this apply  to diet X? Well like, yeah, it might not but   [06:55] just because we don't have data doesn't mean it  doesn't. I totally agree with how you said that,   the one area that I'll say why I specifically view  just saturated fat and just the ketogenic diet   [07:08] differently is because compared to all other diets  the ketogenic physiology is a unique physiology,   right, when we look at energy metabolism and the  utilization of fats and ketones, it is different,   [07:24] and every cell in the body´s energy utilization  is different and that is specifically relevant   to the utilization and turnover of saturated  fats, so conceptually I agree with you 100%,   [07:36] in my mind I view specifically the ketogenic  diet and the saturated fat item as different   from that broad concept in terms of, like, just  having uncertainty on a diet doesn't necessarily   [07:48] mean I would change recommendations for it, but  that's why I view just this one particular point,   saturated fat/keto different than the others,  is because, and you know, I'm a big fan of like,   [08:01] there's so much more in diets other than  just like fats and carbs and proteins, right,   there's phytochemicals, you know, zoochemicals,  all those sort of other items and so, like, yeah,   technically every diet is unique but only one  of them really has whole body physiology changes   [08:16] that we look at in terms of energy utilization at  the cellular or even mitochondrial level and that   is sort of the ketogenic diet approach, like,  even when you look at the really low-fat diets   [08:28] they're still utilizing carbohydrates and fats  similar to other standard higher carbohydrate   diets and this is anything in the range of,  like, I don't know, 20, 30% carbs and up,   which covers about everything except ketogenic  approaches, and so that's why I do view that   [08:44] one a little differently, but otherwise, to  your points, man, I couldn't agree more, like,   that would drive me nuts if everyone just said,  well, not on my diet because it hasn't been tested   [08:56] on my diet explicitly, man, yeah that stuff drives  me bonkers. Yeah so the metabolic differences,   I think we could list metabolic differences,  abundant metabolic effects of all kinds of diets,   [09:14] of course the effects on ketogenic diets will  be specific to keto, and then we can find all   kinds of effects of low fat diets in lipoprotein  metabolism for example. Oh yeah, sure. Right?   And we can find all kinds of effects of vegan  diets on the microbiome, and you know, you name   [09:28] it, we break the internet listing these things  so we could easily find mechanistic arguments   on any of these diets to argue that saturated fat  might have a different effect, or really any risk   [09:41] factor, we could, I usually say anybody with  five minutes on PubMed can find a mechanistic   argument for pretty much anything, we know this,  how easy that is to come up with some kind of,   [09:53] this molecule binds to that molecule, this  molecule phosphorylates that molecule therefore   this risk factor will have this effect in your...  A rampant, rampant issue, yeah. And then how often   [10:05] that does not pan out is pretty much almost  always. The random mechanistic scenario. So   yeah I think the hypothesis, this risk factor  might play a different role in this diet,   [10:23] we could come up with a hypothesis for pretty  much any diet. Is it possible that it will be   in a ketogenic diet or a low carb diet? Sure, and  if it is and if they demonstrate that, great...   [10:37] Difference is we have clinical ketogenic diets  that don't have the saturated fat limits though,   right? Like, again, this specific item on this  specific diet is different in more evidence   than all those other ones, right, like it is a  different scenario, right, we do this clinically,   [10:53] they have it for epilepsy, they have it for other  different pulmonary realms, right, when they want   to get people off ventilators, right, they have  ketogenic formulas that specifically actually   have saturated fats in there, right, so there is  precedence towards this diet not following our   [11:08] standard guidelines, I know dietary guidelines  aren't for clinical situations but the standard   guidelines for saturated fat being a risk factor  are, again, in that context, so I do think, again,   [11:23] there's a difference, because we have a specific  diet that is clinically used that is outside of   that context and doesn't have those same criteria.  I'm not saying that I'd be positive that there   wouldn't be an association between saturated fat,  I do think there's definitely a limit where it is,   [11:39] but to me there's enough information that has  been around for decades to say that we have an   understanding that the utilization of this diet  in certain scenarios does not come along with   the risk that we're worried about in terms  of saturated fat in the context of the diet   [11:55] that we recommend from the dietary guidelines, so  again, it may just be a difference of opinion at   this point but again, just that item and just that  diet I think is a little different than the other   situations that we're talking about, although  generally I agree with you on all those points,   [12:10] I do view this specific nutrient on this specific  diet differently than the others. When you say   we have data in the clinical setting where the  saturated fat in the context of a keto diet is not   [12:23] associated with the risk, or if I phrase that,  if I misquoted you there feel free to correct   but what do you mean exactly? Somewhat right, so  like the development of the dietary guidelines   [12:35] and the saturated fat cut offs were developed in  the context of a carbohydrate-based diet, right,   when we develop clinical diets whether it's for  diabetes or otherwise they generally follow those   [12:47] guidelines appropriately, because they're  carbohydrate-based diets. our clinical grade   ketogenic diets do not follow those guidelines  and for that reason, not just myself but others   that have developed those clinical diets have  not associated those guidelines with what they   [13:04] do in developing those ketogenic diets, so this  is beyond just my personal information, right,   this is me trusting the process and development of  people that have developed these diets before me,   [13:16] right, and if they don't associate that potential  inherent risk as something that would prevent them   from developing diets with those saturated fats,  or even specifically putting saturated fats into   [13:28] those sort of formulas, makes me more confident to  say that yeah, there's likely something different   specifically in that diet that has gone into our  clinical use of it. You're saying that when these   [13:43] diets are designed for clinical purposes, that  people aren't worried about going over limits in   saturated fat that would worry us for other diets,  that's what you're saying when you say... Yeah not   [13:55] the limits that we set for the dietary guidelines.  Got it. Because otherwise we very much abide by   making sure diets are appropriate in terms of food  groups and utilization of all these other items   [14:07] that minimize risk, right, and minimize the risk  of developing disease for developing all sorts   of clinical diets, right, we follow those by a  standard. Yeah I think I understand. Saturated   [14:22] fat on the ketogenic diet is generally not one  of those that we put to that same stringent   criteria. I'm not saying, and again,, right this  goes back to the initial thing I talked about,,   like man I do not align with the bacon, beef and  butter, any level of saturated fat is totally   [14:38] fine and inert, I don't believe that at all, all I  would say is the limits that we put on minimizing   health risk on a carbohydrate-based diet for  saturated fats are likely not the same on a   [14:51] ketogenic-based diet, that's like the clearest way  I could put it, I'm not saying they're not there,   I'm just saying that threshold is likely  not the same based on all the information   we have available and the development of the  guidelines that were on a carbohydrate-based diet,   [15:08] just generally from a physiology perspective,  are not the same physiology, not the same   metabolic milieu as a ketogenic diet, so for  those reasons if I had to step back and say,   [15:20] like yeah, if I had to bet my life on something I  would say that if we had thousands and millions of   people's data on a ketogenic diet, that saturated  fat relationship between the risk of developing   [15:33] CVD or something is probably not the same level  as it would be on a carbohydrate based diet,   like that is my actual thought and opinion based  on what we have out there. Now, is it to the point   where every person that I put on a ketogenic diet  in terms of private practice that I do, right,   [15:49] we always talk about like, hey you need to go to  your physician, you need to talk about this, this   will likely be higher in saturated fat than your  other diet and you need to talk to them about,   are they okay with that and the potential risk  that comes to it in the context of the potential   [16:04] other benefits that you may see. Very few of my  personal clients or research directed individuals   have stayed longterm on a ketogenic diet, I would  put it at 1%, like 1% of people that I counsel end   up going that route so it's not like I'm even a  ketogenic proponent that's out here pushing the   [16:20] diet, but I can at least sit here and recognize  that there is in my mind enough evidence,   or lack of evidence to support the reasonable  thought that there's likely a difference in terms   [16:35] of saturated fat health risk on a carb diet versus  saturated fat health risk on a ketogenic diet,   yeah. I would like to hear more about what that  evidence is that you're referring to now in terms   [16:47] of... because I haven't seen any data informing  us on actual risk of saturated fat on low carb   versus high carb, except for something that I  can cite but it doesn't, it wouldn't apply to   [17:00] a ketogenic diet, it would apply to variations of  carb, maybe between the 30s and 50% of calories,   in that range, but it wouldn't be germane to keto.  So actually there is one randomized trial on this   [17:15] question, we didn't remember this during the  conversation but we chatted about it later, and   what they did in this trial was they put people  on a ketogenic diet, either high in saturated   fat or polyunsaturated fat, same calories  in both, same total fat, same total carbs,   [17:30] just different type of fat, and basically what  they saw was their LDL-cholesterol went up on the   saturated fat diet, not the polyunsaturated fat  keto diet, as expected, and the PUFA keto diet,   [17:42] the unsaturated fat keto diet raised ketone bodies  about twice as much as the saturated fat diet,   it was also better at raising insulin sensitivity  and lowering triglycerides and glucose, fasting   [17:56] glucose, and the downside that they saw with the  PUFA diet was it induced one of the side effects,   nausea, more often than the saturated fat  keto diet. They basically concluded that   "a polyunsaturated fat ketogenic diet may be  superior to a classical saturated fat ketogenic   [18:14] diet" although this was a pretty small trial,  guys, 20 people over 5 days so big grain of salt,   there are several other studies ongoing on this  question, we'll see what happens. Regarding this   [18:28] note of uncertainty, when we're talking about,  well, we don't know what the effect of this risk   factor is in this context of this diet, the effect  of saturated fat on a low carb diet on a keto diet   might be different, I think we have to bear in  mind the uncertainty goes both ways, saturated   [18:44] fat could be less detrimental, the effect could  be the same or it could be more detrimental,   when we have uncertainty we just don't know where  it goes, now... that's if you have uncertainty and   you don't understand the mechanism related to why  saturated fat has a health risk, right, so like,   [19:04] there is a difference and we do know that just  like fat turnover is dramatically different when   you're on a ketogenic diet, right, and that  in itself I think creates a situation where   [19:18] you have reasonable physiologic underpinning to  say, hey, like, this isn't just a random item   that is just related to health and we don't really  know why, we have those relationships, right,   [19:36] we're aware of that, we're aware of the role of  fat and ectopic lipid storage and these issues   of different membranes having more saturated  fat than others, and when you have the the   [19:50] ketogenic physiology and you understand how the  fat metabolism is different, I think that adds to   the direction of the uncertainty to the point  where, again, I would personally be confident   [20:04] in saying it's one direction versus the other.  I don't see how understanding those changes in   the fat physiology even tell us anything about the  effect of saturated fat on cardiovascular disease,   [20:16] much less what the direction might be, maybe  it helps if we get a bit more specific on that,   so from my view of the literature the main  candidate for mechanism of saturated fat affecting   [20:30] cardiovascular disease, not the only one, there's  some other data out there but the main thing seems   to be levels of LDL cholesterol as a mediator,  and specifically this effect on the LDL receptor,   so basically we're talking about Apob levels,  so based on what we know it's the level of   [20:45] Apob that would determine risk, not the intake of  saturated fat, so what is it about the physiology   that leads you to believe that this elevation in  Apob would not be a problem on a low carb diet?   [20:58] Different conversation though, right, so now we're  talking about risk of high cholesterol levels,   we're not talking about just diet and saturated  fat, so I think that changes the conversation,   right, which is fine, and I am not a LDL denier by  any means, I don't have evidence to believe that   [21:20] the LDL metabolism and risk related specifically  to LDL and cardiovascular disease is different   between carbohydrate based diet and ketogenic  diet, like I don't align with that at all, so   [21:33] yeah, I'm with you there, if we're going to change  the conversation to targeting cholesterol levels   and LDL, like, yeah, we're on the same page. Okay,  because this is how saturated fat is thought to   [21:45] mediate its cardiovascular impact. Certainly  in part, and that is our primary indicator,   but I think it would be naive to assume that  there's no other effects of saturated fat in   [21:57] terms of cardiovascular disease or other health  risks, to the point where it's in our guidelines   as saturated fat intake, right, so yeah, again,  man I'm a nutrition guy, right, I'm a dietitian,   like, that's my focus so I go with nutrition-based  questions, and certainly we have underlying   [22:13] physiology that defines sort of the rationale as  to why we have that, but those are two different,   two very different things to me, so like yeah, if  we want to talk specifically about LDL and risk,   [22:27] I don't think we have enough evidence to  largely say that they're different on carb   diets or keto diets, and I think that's a very  different question than asking the question of   saturated fat intake levels and whether or not  that has a disease risk associated with it,   [22:41] like, to me those are two very different  questions. That's interesting because to me   they are linked at the hip and to me saturated  fat intake is only an issue to the extent that   [22:55] it raises ApoB. There's a profound amount of  other mechanisms, so like, that's the rationale   to why we even have these positive health  benefits of poly and monounsaturated fats,   [23:07] but I would still sit here and say yeah, the diet  question is very different than the LDL question,   and I'm here where I see enough that I say, look,  the diet question to me is different, the LDL   [23:23] question to me is not different at at this time.  Interesting, so then if somebody raised their,   let's say somebody goes on a low carb diet with a  lot of saturated fat and their LDL/Apob goes up,   [23:36] in that case you're worried but if it doesn't go  up you're not worried about the saturated fat,   is that essentially...? You could kind of wear it  down to that but not not fully, right, like, I do   think it's important to also focus on getting mono  and polyunsaturated fats in, but in the context of   [23:55] ketogenic diet, it's not only difficult but in my  mind not necessary to drop saturated to such a low   level, and that's the rationale behind me saying  that, why I view those things separately, right,   [24:11] but yeah, like, I guess... But going back to my my  first point, like, that bacon/beef/butter, like,   just a high saturated fat, don't worry about it,  I don't agree with that, like, I think that is   a poor approach to take, or reducing it to just  saying, well, it didn't increase my LDL so it's   [24:28] okay, I also wouldn't say that, right, because  again, I think there are other effects of the fats   in the body that play a role in health and disease  risk, so... but yeah I would be less concerned if   [24:41] you didn't see an increase in LDL, just like  I would with changing any diet in anyone,   right? Like yeah, you don't want to see LDL go  up pretty much ever. And I don't think that's   [24:54] inherently unique on the keto diet, I see the  new research coming out, I'm not sold by it,   so... I'm trying to figure out if we actually  disagree on anything because... and this is,   by the way, this is my experience also with these  conversations, once you drill down to the details   [25:10] a lot of times there isn't that much disagreement  on the fundamentals, for example Ethan Weiss,   we were talking about saturated fat on a low carb  diet and all these questions and his take was   essentially this ApoB thing, if your ApoB is great  I'm less worried about it even if you're eating   [25:27] more fatty meats or whatever, and if your apob is  not good then I would want to do something about   that regardless pretty much of your saturated fat  intake, and I generally tend to agree with that,   [25:39] I think that has a lot of merit, so it sounds  like we're almost essentially on that same page,   but you had, maybe the only difference was you  had another level of concern there, you're saying   [25:53] that even if apob does not go up you would still  consider the saturated fat level because there   might be additional mechanisms and so maybe you'd  worry about those on a high carb diet even if apoB   [26:06] does not go up but you would worry less on a low  carb diet, is that? I would say I would just have,   I would just probably likely have a different low  cut off, right, like if I really had to say, like   if we had the same amount of data on a high carb  and a low carb diet and I had to guess where the   [26:21] data would sit in terms of risk my guess is that  our cut off that we have for saturated fat levels   that don't increase risk on a high carb diet is  likely going to be lower than the saturated fat   [26:33] level on a ketogenic diet, right, like that would  be what I view if I had to predict if we had all   the perfect studies what it would look like, so  yeah, it's not that I wouldn't worry about it,   [26:45] I think there's a lot of other benefits to making  sure you have other healthy fats in your diet,   like I am... I know it's become kind of poor  taste to say, like, this complimentary and   [26:57] integrative health route, but I always use  that as food in the context of medicine,   right, or food as medicine has been a term that I  have really enjoyed because it doesn't mean "don't   [27:09] take medicine", it's like using foods to improve  our pharmacologic approaches, right, and that's   how I view food and I view the nutrients and food  not just as macronutrients but as polyunsaturated,   [27:22] monounsaturated, saturated fats, right, they  have different effects, phytochemicals and   zoochemicals, they have different effects and  they all have their own different and unique   impact on the body, even getting into herbals and  botanicals, right, they have different effects,   [27:36] the magnitudes and relevance of those effects  are all different but to like blanket and take   away that they have some sort of effect, I just  can't do, right, and so that's why, yeah, I just,   I'm always going to believe because of what's out  there that yeah, these different components of   [27:52] food are going to impact the body in some way and  it's always going to be a concern of mine that I   just don't want to jack up saturated fat, just  because I don't see health parameter X doesn't   mean there's not other items in the benefit of  poly/ monounsaturated foods or even just having   [28:07] a diversity in the foods of your diet to have a  potential health benefit. Yeah I don't disagree   with that either. Can you explain a little bit  when you say that maybe the mechanistic side of   [28:19] things leads you to believe that the same level  of saturated fat might be less detrimental on a   low carb diet, can you explain what mechanisms  you're talking about and why do they tilt you   in that direction. The general point is, in my  mind it comes down to nutrient metabolism and   [28:38] especially the utilization of ketones and fats as  fuel instead of carbohydrates and fats as fuel,   right, we know that has an effect down to the  mitochondrial level, right, I do mitochondrial   [28:50] respiration research and we see differences  when we put different nutrients, right, at the   mitochondrial level, we see this in muscle tissue,  we've seen it in airway smooth muscle cells, like,   you kind of see it across the board so to me that  creates a different physiology and that metabolic   [29:06] milieu I talk about, like, that's also different  from a healthy person to someone with diabetes,   right, the metabolic milieu on diabetes is  excessively high blood sugar and higher levels   of inflammatory markers in the blood, right,  and that creates a different physiology that   [29:20] we know is different than a healthy metabolism,  so that's kind of the difference I'm speaking   of in terms of where I see the difference is,  it goes down in my mind to the cellular level   to be mitochondrial related but the precise  dynamics of what's changing and why and where   [29:43] I think is still an area of discovery, right,  like I don't think we have everything exactly   pinpointed but we do know it's different and  to me that's enough to say, hey, we see enough   differences on this different physiology and  there's enough even at the whole body level,   [29:59] I don't know if you do the endocalorimetry work  too much in in the hospital setting but like,   you see differences at the whole body level in  terms of nutrient utilization and those different   RQ levels means different body systems are working  differently. I focus on the pulmonary system, so   [30:14] you just have a different effect of the generation  of CO2 when you're utilizing energy and that has   a different effect on the pulmonary system,  so you could see how that could whittle down   [30:28] to different tissues and an impact at that level  and that's how I kind of view it but I couldn't   sit here and tell you like, yeah man I absolutely  have everything whittled down, 100% figured out,   right, because that's like, that in my mind is  kind of the next frontier, is really whittling   [30:43] into these organelles and nutrient utilization  but that's because that's just my realm so that's   what I like to talk about. Okay, all of those  differences between diets and nutrient utilization   [30:56] but I'm still not clear on why you think those  differences suggest that the risk of saturated   fat would be lower on low carb diets as opposed to  higher or the same. I think that is the rationale   [31:13] for an underlying mechanism because the nutrients  are being utilized differently, right, you have   saturated fats that are just more likely to be  utilized as energy on the ketogenic diet which is   different from when you're on a carbohydrate based  diet so you have different utilization of energy,   [31:30] at any given time you're utilizing more fats,  those are more likely to be used as energy and   we know when they're used as energy that  is different than ectopic lipid storage,   if the saturated fat is just sitting there, you  can have these saturated fat moieties that just   [31:45] create inflammatory issues or metabolites that  cause other downstream issues so yeah, in my mind   that's where it lays, if we're talking again about  the cellular level, you have those fat molecules   [32:03] that have negative impacts inside the cell,  everything from DAGs and ceramides and all these   things, these lipid species. Now, I don't know if  we have a 100% direction to say, yeah, saturated   [32:16] fat intake is directly impacting the level of  those, there's other things going on but that's   how I would view it, when you have that difference  in energy metabolism there's a different flow of   nutrients through things and that's why I would  view all the way down to the cellular physiology   [32:30] we know it's different and so that in my mind  supports the clinical findings that we see where   you don't see things like, again, we don't see  just a massive amount of heart attacks with all   [32:43] the information on ketogenic diet studies that  we have out there, studies aren't being stopped   high rate because their saturated fat int intake  is 15% instead of 10%, you know what I mean,   [32:59] so like that's how I view that more as a potential  underlying explanation for why we don't see those   differences but yeah, it's not something that I  think is perfectly clear but I think it's enough   [33:13] to say the physiology is different, like, there's  a rationale to believe why that risk would be   different. Yeah so now in this explanation I heard  something that I´m starting to understand why   [33:26] you go in that direction, it sounds like you're  saying because more of the fat, and specifically   the saturated fat, is going to get metabolized  for energy in someone on a low carb diet, that   maybe because it's not sitting around that's why  you're leaning towards it being less detrimental,   [33:42] is that...? Yeah yeah and I mean, that's when  I would go back and say the lipid turnover,   that's sort of the term that you would use for  that, yes the lipid turnover is different. Right,   [33:54] that would, sure, I understand what you're saying  now, that would still, we still have to include   into the equation saturated fats that are produced  endogenously, basically it would be net effect in   the end, right, and then because also more is  coming in, even if you're spending more, what's   [34:10] the balance, in the end it would be... Oh yeah you  bring all sorts of questions about energy balance,   overfeeding, underfeeding. You can get crazy.  And this is why in the end we want to look at   outcomes, because mechanisms can go in every  direction under the Sun, but I understand what   [34:25] you're saying, because the fat is being oxidized  more for energy, then maybe it's sticking around   a lot less and maybe that... Yeah and I mean, look  at the parallel with medium chain triglycerides,   [34:42] so these are the shorter chain fats, and so, the  reason that we don't see the same risk associated   with the shorter chain fats is they essentially  get shotgunned to the liver and immediately used   as energy, they don't go through the same long  chain fatty acid metabolism transport as your   [34:59] longer chain saturated fat molecules, and because  of that, even when you do fat substitution studies   where you're manipulating the percentage of  saturated fats versus MCTs and otherwise,   you don't see the same negative cardiovascular  disease risk biomarkers, if it's LDL or otherwise,   [35:18] when you have the medium chain triglyceride  feedings versus just longer chain saturated fats   and so that kind of feeds into a parallel of the  rationale, like, those medium chain triglycerides   [35:30] that are getting utilized don't have that same  risk and that's how I would, I guess, in a very   blanket overarching way, say how I would view  saturated fats on a keto diet versus a other...   but again, the difference I don't think is huge,  I'm not talking about have 60% saturated fat in   [35:46] your diet versus 10%, I mean I would view the  difference probably in the range of one to two,   like 10 to 20 to 30% is probably the range where  I would see the ketogenic diet potentially sitting   [36:01] in terms of, if, again, we had all the perfect  data and all the risk factors and all that,   where would the ketogenic diet sit, I don't think  it's consuming 60% of your diet in saturated fats   by any means, I just can't believe that the cut  off is going to be the same as a carbohydrate   [36:19] based diet, that's all. Well it'd be interesting  to see. With the MCT oils if I remember correctly,   yeah, they don't have the same risk association  and they also don't raise lipid levels and if I   [36:32] remember correctly they don't have the effect on  LDL receptor either. I don't know, I don't know   about the LDL receptor, that is not an area  that I dive into much. Yeah I think from my   [36:46] recollection they don't activate the same pathways  that lead to the LDL receptor internalization,   the same transcription factors and everything, so  that's my recollection, that's why it's thought to   [36:59] not be a risk factor for cardiovascular disease,  which is similar really to the unsaturated fats,   same thing, they tend to actually increase  expression of LDL receptor. Yeah. No I think   [37:18] it's an interesting conversation, I think it's  good to acknowledge the uncertainty there. Now,   when you said level 20 or 30% of saturated fat, I  don't know if that would be possible for somebody   [37:33] to be on that high level and not see a pretty  stark elevation of apoB. Yeah maybe not, I don't   know, that was just throwing numbers out there to  where..., I don't think the difference is going   [37:45] to be 60% versus 10%, I would see it somewhere as  probably in that lower range versus... maybe 15,   in my mind it's just, if I had to say more or  less I'd be like, more, but I don't think it's   [37:59] crazy high, again, I am not a proponent of  bacon, beef and butter keto, like, I do not,   I am not... I think you've made that very clear  for the fifth time now. So would it be fair to,   [38:14] if I were to summarize your position to see if I  understand, and feel free to change the wording,   would it be fair to say that you are less worried  about saturated fat levels on a very low carb diet   [38:26] like a keto diet independently of elevations of  apoB? Yeah I would say that's a solid summary.   Okay so as as long as it doesn't raise apoB  significantly, you're less worried? Yeah yeah,   [38:41] I mean dude, I don't want to see LDL/ ApoB  go up in any situation, like, I think that   is just inherently a negative thing. Interesting,  yeah, I think we found like a little niche where   [38:56] the question mark is now much smaller than it  seemed in the beginning, which is generally how   these conversations go. Yeah I think having  the uncertainty in mind is good, in my mind,   just to summarize, my position is that when we  don't have outcome data it's prudent to assume   [39:12] that a risk factor applies, and I'm consistent  for this for all risk factors and all diets,   so you know, we don't have outcome data for  smoking or high blood pressure, and I know you   [39:24] have a view that it's different for saturated  fat because of fat metabolism differences,   but I think we could probably, if we had taken the  time to come up with a mechanistic model ad hoc   [39:36] for blood pressure on a low-fat diet or some  of these things on a vegan diet for example,   we could probably come up with arguments that  wouldn't be too different from the fats on a   low carb diet scenario, so my point is just, it's  prudent to assume that a risk factor that has been   [39:52] validated in multiple populations, in multiple  contexts, will apply until proven innocent. Yeah   and I for 99% of situations I couldn't align  more with that concept, like, I'm dead on, like   [40:06] it drives me crazy when people try to make small  difference, like, well, they haven't, there's no   RCT in this population... all right, well, come  on. As long as it's consistent to all the areas   where we don't have RCTs and it's not specifically  "my diet is the Oasis". And I agree with the risk   [40:24] factor applying across the board for all these  different areas unless explicitly shown otherwise,   I largely agree with that as well. So at the end  of the day it seemed like we largely agreed, his   [40:36] position is basically that he's less worried about  saturated fat in the background of a low carb   diet as long as LDL-cholesterol and LDL particle  number and apoB and these metrics don't increase,   [40:51] and that's not very different from my position,  if those metrics don't go up I'm much less worried   about saturated fat intake on any diet. So if  there's a difference in our views it's not a large   one. Let me know if you want to see more videos  of these conversations or if we should stop with   [41:08] these and just stick to the normal regular videos  going over studies. Here's a lot more on saturated   fat going over a ton of studies, and here's my  conversation with Dr Ethan Weiss on low carb diets   and how to put them together in a healthy way.  Check them out, I'll see you in there, take care