---
title: 'The YouTube Advice Keeping Small Channels Stuck'
source: 'https://youtube.com/watch?v=kIVXD5855SM'
video_id: 'kIVXD5855SM'
date: 2026-11-10
duration_sec: 1046
---

# The YouTube Advice Keeping Small Channels Stuck

> Source: [The YouTube Advice Keeping Small Channels Stuck](https://youtube.com/watch?v=kIVXD5855SM)

## Summary

This video challenges four long-standing pieces of YouTube advice that may be keeping small channels from growing. The host explains how YouTube's algorithm has evolved, shifting focus from niches and tags to audience satisfaction and relevance, and offers updated strategies for creators to adapt.

### Key Points

- **Old YouTube advice is outdated** [00:01] — Many small channels follow advice that was effective years ago but no longer works because YouTube's algorithm and viewer behavior have changed significantly.
- **Four old rules identified** [00:14] — The video will cover four outdated rules: pick a niche, tag your videos, watch time is all that matters, and post consistently or the algorithm forgets you.
- **Rule 1: Pick a niche** [00:28] — In YouTube's early days, recommendations were like a trending page and search dominated. Picking a niche helped viewers find you. But by 2018, over 70% of watch time came from recommendations, which became personalized based on viewer behavior.
- **Niche alone is not enough** [01:46] — The recommendation algorithm follows the person, not the niche. A fitness channel can attract different audiences with different videos (e.g., beginners, parents, advanced lifters). The advice now is to pick a niche and then a specific person within that niche.
- **Data shows niche+person works** [02:25] — Examples: 'The Real Reason You're Skinny Fat' from a 4,000-subscriber channel and 'Chair Tai Chi for Belly Fat Loss After 50' from a 6,000-subscriber channel each got over 300,000 views by targeting a specific person.
- **Define your promise** [03:09] — Picking a niche defines the category; picking a person defines your promise. The promise is what brings viewers back, e.g., a parent returns because the channel gets workouts done before the kids wake up.
- **Identify your audience** [03:35] — Ask 'Who is this for and what did this video do for them?' for your best-performing videos. If you don't have one, pick a person on purpose. Finish the sentence: 'This video is for [type of person] who wants [outcome].'
- **Most creators still focus on niche** [04:01] — Data shows 'how to pick a niche' is searched over 47,000 times a month, while 'how to find my target audience' gets under 9,000 searches. YouTube is telling creators to find an audience, but most are still asking about the category.
- **Rule 2: Tag your videos** [04:30] — Tags used to matter when search dominated, but YouTube now uses many signals, including the video itself, to understand content. Tags are considered spam if stuffed, and YouTube's help page says they only help with misspelled words.
- **YouTube exec: Tags don't matter** [05:23] — In an interview, YouTube's head of discovery said tags and categories don't have a meaningful difference to discovery in 2026. Tags are a low priority for YouTube.
- **Better way: relevance, engagement, quality** [06:31] — YouTube's search system uses three factors: relevance (title, description, video content matching search intent), engagement (whether searchers watch the video), and quality (trustworthiness, especially for health/news).
- **Keywords in description help** [07:11] — Using keywords in the description that match viewer intent is more effective than stuffing tags. Example: a video titled 'How to Replace Drywall on a Budget' matches a viewer searching exactly that.
- **Relevance beats subscriber count** [08:21] — The chair tai chi video appeared near the top of search results ahead of a 100,000-subscriber channel because its title and description were relevant to the viewer's search, even with no tags.
- **Use VidIQ MCP for keyword research** [09:28] — The host recommends using the VidIQ MCP with Claude or ChatGPT to find trending keywords in your niche and understand what viewers are searching for, then use those words in your title and description.
- **Rule 3: Watch time is all that matters** [10:08] — In 2012, YouTube shifted to valuing watch time, leading creators to inflate video length. But YouTube now measures satisfaction, not just watch time, because not all time is equally valued.
- **Satisfaction is key** [11:01] — YouTube introduced the concept of satisfaction, using surveys to rate videos. Four-to-five-star ratings count toward 'valued watch time.' YouTube predicts satisfaction for all viewers based on survey responses.
- **Example: Two videos, different satisfaction** [11:42] — A 10-minute video with open loops and engagement gets five stars, while one with preamble and fake tension gets one or two stars. YouTube aims to measure whether viewers are glad they spent time watching.
- **Make satisfaction the goal** [12:22] — Instead of focusing on watch time, focus on satisfaction. If you satisfy viewers, watch time will increase as a byproduct. Use retention graphs to understand what parts viewers enjoy, not as a verdict on your worth.
- **Rule 4: Post consistently or else** [13:28] — This belief is common but not officially pushed by YouTube. Consistency matters more to you and your audience than to the algorithm. Frequency gives more opportunities to reach the audience and helps the algorithm understand who your audience is.
- **Cadence depends on your content** [14:49] — News channels should post more frequently, but channels that help digest news have more grace. The rule is now to develop an expectation your audience can rely on, not to post out of fear of the algorithm.
- **Focus on audience, not algorithm** [15:59] — Replace the word 'algorithm' with 'audience.' YouTube's changes are all about creating an engaging, satisfying experience for viewers. If you focus on your audience, YouTube will work for you.
- **Teaser: Storytelling techniques** [17:08] — The host teases a future video about storytelling techniques from Christopher Nolan that can keep audiences watching.

## Transcript

before your channel even existed. You're out here tagging videos with all your heart. You're picking a niche like you're picking a spouse, and still nothing. See, YouTube videos stay up forever. So, when one tips video does
of it, and the same advice gets passed around for years. Which means, right now, you could be doing everything right for YouTube that doesn't exist in. So, let's catch you up. Today, we're taking four old rules that small channels are
still playing by today. Now, I'm going to show you how each and those work now, towards something that actually counts. And I'll show you why each one of those old rule again. Starting with rule one, pick a niche, right? You could say, "I'm
boom, that part is handled. But, that's actually only half of the decision. And was the whole decision. In YouTube's early days, recommendations were basically one big trending page. And most views came from people searching or
them. So, just pick a niche. I mean, it made total sense. It's like, just pick a people searching for fitness could find you. And when they subscribed, they knew and it worked. But, as more and more people started to watch, one big
trending page wasn't going to cut it. So, YouTube needed a better way to figure out what each person actually wanted to watch. So, they went all in on recommendations. By 2018, YouTube said that more than 70% of watch time came
from what it recommends. And those recommendations got personal. YouTube people who watch the same stuff, and shows you what they like. Their own example is, if you watch tennis videos, and other tennis fans also like jazz,
even though you've never watched jazz videos before in your life. So, the recommendation follows the person. And that's why picking a niche by itself isn't quite enough anymore. Going back to the fitness channel example, you make
find it and like it. Then you make a vlog about maxing out your bench and going pro, and a few different people find that one. And then you make a yoga fitness video, so you're still in the
actually watching, right? There's somebody who's never worked out before a walk up the stairs without getting winded. Not that I would know anything about that, okay? But then you've got a parent who maybe has about 20 minutes in
up. And somewhere there's a lifter who's been stuck at the same bench press for months and is driving him crazy. Same niche, three completely different about which one you would click on and then which two you would just go right
our Viddler Q plugin for Cloud and I pulled a breakout videos from small pull way more views than other channels. Looking at the outliers you have here, The Real Reason You're Skinny Fat, a channel with about 4,000 subscribers and
also have the chair tai chi for belly fat loss after 50, about 6,000 subscribers, over 300,000 views. Each one of these is specifically talking to one person. So, the advice used to be pick a niche. Now, it's yes, pick a
niche and then pick a person inside that niche. Who is this person and what did on it? That second part is your promise. Picking a niche defines the category, but picking a person defines your promise. And that promise is what brings
again, that parent comes back to this fitness channel because it's the channel that gets the workout done before the kids get up. YouTube's own Renee Ritchie have to want to grow on YouTube, but a lot of people want to grow on YouTube.
video another video to love. So, the same people who loved that, they're not remember the feeling you gave them. And if that next video gives them the same they're going to click on it. And then the next video.
small channels have one or two videos that maybe did better than everything ask, "Who's this person for and what did this video potentially do for them?" And if you don't have one of those videos yet, just pick the person on purpose. A
two ago before you got to where you are right now in your life. And then before your next video, finish this sentence. This video is for who wants to This video is for this type of person who wants this type of outcome. And if you
of most creators because even our own data shows that most creators are still niche for YouTube gets searched over 47,000 times a month versus how do I find my target audience on YouTube gets under 9,000 searches. YouTube is telling
us to find an audience, but most of us are still asking about the category. the next question is how does that person actually find your videos? And I what I think is probably one of the oldest pieces of advice on the list and
that is tag your videos. We got to talk about tags. When I was coaching lot or some version of it and that is like what are the right tags for my for it to get seen? And I get it because back when most of the videos came from
search, the words that you typed on the upload page were a big part of how who searched. So you would fill up those tags like your channel depended on it. sentences. And for a while that made sense, but tags had a big problem.
anything whether it had something to do with the video or not. And a lot of people did. YouTube even calls stuffing extra tags into your description spam. than tags to figure out what your video is actually about including the actual
video itself. When you upload your video and you see processing, that is YouTube YouTube's help page on tags, it'll tell you. It says tags can help people with commonly misspelled words for what your video is about. Otherwise, they play a
Your title, your thumbnail, and description matter more. Rob Wilson actually asked top pre YouTube's head of discovery in an interview about this and &gt;&gt; And going back to something that we've spoken about ad nauseam at this point.
Video tags and video categories. Do they have any meaningful different meaningful difference to discovery in 2026? &gt;&gt; Um I would say uh not meaningfully. like a a band-aid that you don't want to rip off. Why don't we just get rid of
&gt;&gt; Yeah, I think &gt;&gt; it's it's been more of a like uh no one's just really prioritized it as opposed to like we about it and decided no, this is important to keep. So, it just uh hasn't
&gt;&gt; I I don't know about you, but it doesn't seem like tags from YouTube's perspective is a big priority. It feels like, "Oh, yeah, tags. I I forgot about &gt;&gt; And listen, I'm not going to lie. I know tags don't do anything.
But still, sometimes I can't help myself. I will load that thing up with as I can. But as long as I know, and as long as you know, long as you know, it doesn't really do anything, okay? But
What's the word? Superstition? Then you. But &gt;&gt; let me show you a better way. Remember those breakout fitness videos I pulled? Eight out of 10 of them had no tags,
zero. Now, that by itself doesn't prove that tags don't matter, but tags weren't actually lays out how your video actually gets found in search, and it comes down to three things: relevance, engagement, and quality. Relevance is
whether your title and description, and the video itself, matches what somebody bit confusing because for so many creators, tags and keywords kind of get down for you cuz it's going to be super helpful with how you prepare your video
for search. YouTube says the keywords in your description can help your video get you're matching what the viewer is looking for or just throwing together a word cloud of a YouTube title. So, let's say you made a video and you titled it
how to replace a drywall on a budget, and someone is looking for exactly that. How to replace a drywall on a budget. They see your video titled the same awesome. This is exactly what I need." Now, that's different than you taking a
video and tagging it and titling it how to replace drywall on a budget, drywall budget tips 2020, viral drywall tips, and just adding every word with drywall about. When you do your title and your description, and you're using keywords
our wonderful MCP, come on, somebody. You're using that to match the viewer intent, and this is where relevance comes in because you're looking to potential viewers are searching for so that you can create a video that matches
you're trying to match your viewers' expectation, not some expectation of YouTube that if you add enough words, YouTube will understand what your video that chair tai chi video? Someone searches up chair tai chi for seniors,
and there it is, near the top, from a channel with about 6,000 subscribers, sitting ahead of a channel with 100,000 subscribers. Now, when we look at it, we see that this video doesn't have any tags on it, but it is still showing up
in search. Why? Because the title and the description are relevant to the viewers' expectation and the viewers' search. Another thing that it probably does well is the second thing, and that is engagement. Do people who search the
video actually watch your video? YouTube literally says that it looks at the search. And third is quality, which is mostly whether you are a trustworthy source. This matters more so for like health or news. Are you a reliable
but the majority of us, depending on your channel, will probably really be about what this means for your content, right? You could tag a video begin a people who search begin a workout and they actually click on your video leave
signals to YouTube that your video really didn't answer what it was that you up is whether people who actually search your video stick around to watch. keywords, think about your viewers' actual intent so that you can create a
actually grab the VidIQ MCP, whether you're using Claude or ChatGPT, and you the trending keywords in my niche, and what does that tell me about what it is Remember, niche needs to lead to audience. Then, after you do that, you
information and turn it into a good title and description that resonates keywords and tags have kind of turned into now. They used to be labels that they're the closest thing to hearing your viewers say what it is that they're
their words in your title and then your description. So, now you have a relevant second part was engagement, keeping them watching. And that actually leads us to our third rule, and that is [music] watch time is all that matters. Back in
2012, YouTube made a big switch. Before that, the system mostly cared about weighing watch time, how long people actually stayed. Because if you were a good signal that you were enjoying yourself. And when creators got wind of
this, this became the primary advice, to keep them watching. And creators found something that should be 2 minutes into 12 minutes, making sure you stay to the before you actually get into the content. The thought was, you got to
YouTube has never stopped looking at watch time. Watch time is still super important. But YouTube did get better at figuring out that someone could watch satisfied. You can watch a whole video and still feel like you wasted your
time. YouTube said it themselves, &gt;&gt; Quite a few years now, we've uh learned that not all time spent with video is equally valued by our viewers. And so, uh while we do look at how long people watch videos, it's only one of the
understanding the value people are getting. We introduced this concept of satisfaction uh quite a few years ago, where we're trying to understand not just about the viewers' behavior and what they do, but how do they feel about
&gt;&gt; Because what YouTube really wants for you is to keep watching and to keep [music] and so on. So, they started measuring whether or not people were satisfaction. They sent out surveys asking people to rate what they just
watch time on the four to five stars actually counts toward what they call valued [music] watch time. And since most people actually never get a survey, YouTube uses the answers that it does get to predict how everyone else would
rate said video. Picture two people who both watch a 10-minute video on your channel. One is engaging, it has open loops, it keeps them interested and and watching. It answers one question and brings up another until they eventually
make it to the end. The second video has a lot of preamble, fake tension that the to add in there just to keep them watching, and they watch to the end in hopes that there will be a point and it pays off, but it never does. That's the
of them will get a five-star and the other one will get a one or maybe two. YouTube is trying to measure. So, keep them watching has evolved into make them that counts is the kind that people are actually glad that they spent. And it
can almost feel kind of backwards because essentially you have to stop just making watch time the goal and you have to make satisfaction the goal. And if you satisfy them as a byproduct of that, your watch time will increase. So,
and you look at your retention graph, your mindset when you approach it is a "Okay, did I hit this magical number?" You're looking at that retention graph to better understand how people are interacting with your video. What parts
starting to trail off and leave? And what parts are they really enjoying? mean you have to give everything away in the first 10 seconds. Some videos are story, you have a reveal, you have a before and after. But, the question is
is that build-up for your audience or is that build-up for your retention graph? video like your viewer. Ask yourself, "Does this feel like it is going there a reason for me to keep watching?" Pay attention to your audience and learn
what you can from every upload. Don't treat every upload like it is a verdict [music] of whether or not you are a good creator. It's actually an opportunity satisfies your audience. Which leads us to our next bit of old advice, which to
be fair, I can't really say that YouTube ever really push this as something that will grow your channel, but it was a strong belief that many creators [music] had and actually still have and that is post consistently, never miss an upload.
if you can or the algorithm is going to forget about you. And and I do get where works differently. On some of them, especially the feeds that show the newest post first, posting more literally keeps you in front of your
gone. And I think a lot of that thinking has actually followed creators over to scary. If you miss an upload and then the algorithm will stop pushing you I've had plenty of creators ask me if moving their upload from Monday to
another will break something. And honestly, a A of that pressure sometimes because nobody wants to be the one to mess something up. And YouTube has said that consistency does matter, but it matters more to you and your audience
But here's the thing, frequency isn't nothing. The more that you post is the more opportunities that you have to get in front of your audience, to understand that you give the algorithm to understand who your audience actually is
the right audience. So, frequency in that sense does matter. But everything creators is find a cadence that you can reliably show up for your audience even
fair, if you're a news channel and you're breaking news for the sake of your audience [music] and not the algorithm, you should be posting more because news changes so much. But that depends on what you do
for your audience. If you break news for your audience, then yeah, you need to show up the moment the news is breaking. But if you help your audience digest or understand the news, you might have a bit more grace and time because your
breaking news, they're coming to understand the news that they already relationship that you and your content have with your audience. So, the rule post consistently or else really now is develop an expectation that your
and stick [music] to it. And again, that doesn't mean that oh my gosh, if I don't post, my audience is going to hate me. No, maybe part of that expectation is your audience knows, "Hey, he takes a break every December or around
are developing a relationship and a connection with your audience. All you as you can. So, ask yourself, "What kind of relationship should my viewer have with my content and how often do they actually need me?" Then pick a pace
where every upload still passes the three rules that we talked about so far, expect. And again, every upload is a chance to learn something new. It is not All right, so those are the rules that too many small channels have been living
and dying by, and it's actually might have been keeping them small. And really what I want you to see is the pattern. So many creators are so focused and so worried about, "Oh my goodness, does does YouTube get mad at this? Does
YouTube want this? Do the Do the algorithm want this?" But YouTube is focused [music] on your audience. And so, if you are focused on your audience instead of trying to work for YouTube, you can actually get YouTube to work for
you if you focus on creating a satisfying and engaging experience for your audience. So, we we say it all the time. Say it again. Replace the word algorithm. I know algorithm is like a hot button hot topic word. Replace the
word algorithm with audience. Because any changes that YouTube makes to the algorithm are all about how to create an engaging satisfying experience for the keep your audience watching, storytelling is a fantastic way to do
favorite, storyteller of all time is Christopher Nolan. Come on, somebody. some of the storytelling techniques that Christopher Nolan uses to keep us watching his movies that you can use to keep your audience watching. So, [music]
keep your audience watching. So, [music] I would watch that next.
