[00:00] Have you ever thought about windows? Like really  considered the idea? If we hadn’t been exposed   to them our entire lives, it might seem like  kind of a bizarre concept. On the face of it,   [00:12] windows are about light. But it’s more esoteric  than that, especially now that we can make our   own light. We want to be inside, but not all  the way inside. So we put holes in the wall.   [00:25] It’s a heck of a trade-off: you get light and  a view of the outdoors, but it comes at a cost.   Not just the cost of the glass itself, but  also the structural changes they require   and their effects on ventilation, sound, cooling,  heating, safety, and security inside a building. [00:42] As simple as they seem, windows are a technology  of sorts. And like a lot of building science,   we’ve slowly been making progress, readjusting  those tradeoffs and giving us the benefits without   so many of the costs. I love to pick a relatively  innocuous part of the built environment and   [00:59] really take a close look. So, I’ve built a  few demonstrations in the garage to show you   how far the science of glazing has come. I’m  Grady, and this is Practical Engineering. [01:19] Glass is not a good substitute for  an exterior wall, in many respects.   If you take some wall away and replace it with a  window, you’re not trading like-for-like. For one,   you never accidentally throw a baseball through  a brick wall. But it’s especially true when   [01:35] it comes to heat. And this is a pretty big deal  because we collectively spend vast sums of money,   resources, effort, and energy on maintaining a  comfortable thermal climate inside our buildings.   [01:48] Almost all the time, in almost all the  places, the temperature outside of a   building is different from the temperature we  want it to be inside. But the laws of physics   (also all the time in all the places) are  constantly working to equalize those temperatures. [02:05] We usually categorize the flow of heat into three  separate modes. Conduction is heat moving through   solid objects, atoms or molecules that are  tightly packed, transmitting energy to their   neighbors directly by vibrating against each  other. Convection is heat transfer via the   [02:22] movement of a fluid like air or water. Radiation  is heat transfer through electromagnetic waves.   Since it is literally light, radiation doesn’t  need a medium. All three play a role in the walls   [02:34] of buildings. And of course, it works both ways:  sometimes it’s too hot outside and you want to   keep that heat out. Sometimes it’s too cold and  you want to keep the heat in. Any movement of   heat from inside to out or vice versa is a flow  of power, just like we measure with electricity.   [02:51] If you have 500 watts of heat flowing out of  your house, you essentially need a 500 watt   heater inside to make up for the loss and maintain  a steady temperature. And just like voltage is a   [03:03] difference in potential that drives electrical  current, heat flow is driven by a difference   in temperature. The bigger that difference, the  greater the flow of heat through a given wall. Continuing the electrical metaphor, insulation is  the generic term we use to describe materials that   [03:19] resist the transmission of heat from one side  to the other. It makes sense that we put it in   our walls. In the US, we use R-value as a measure  of this resistance. This is kind of a cursed unit   [03:32] of measurement, so I’m going to gloss over the  scientific definition. But, a typical exterior   wall assembly will usually have an R value  between 10 and 25, depending on climate and how   new the building is. A simple pane of glass has  an R value of about 1. Let me show that to you. [03:52] I built this box of foam insulation in my garage.  Inside, I have a 25 watt ceramic heat emitter.   I can close this up and wait for the temperature  inside to stabilize. When that happens,   [04:04] we can assume that the heat going into the  box is the same as the heat flowing out. difference between the interior and exterior  probes is about 43 degrees Fahrenheit,   [04:18] I think that’s around 24 celsius. This is R-5  foam, soif you do the math for a perfectly sealed   box with these dimensions that should be right  around 50 F, 28 C, um, so accounting for the   [04:34] imperfections in my setup, like this, uh, terrible  tape seal, that’s actually pretty close. Um, so   now I’m going to swap this lid out with a  pane of glass, and we’ll set this going again. the temperature inside the shop hasn’t really  changed, but the temperature inside the box   [04:53] has gone down a lot compared to the  foam lid. The difference is about 22 F,   which I think is around 13 C. So, just replacing  one side of the box with glass instead of foam,   [05:07] it takes a much smaller difference in temperature  to move that same 25 watts out of the box. I’m sure you see the issue here. If we want  windows in our buildings, it comes at a cost   [05:19] of thermal efficiency. For every square foot or  square meter of exterior wall that we swap with   single pane windows, heat will move through  that space roughly 10 to 25 times faster.   [05:32] So, we rarely use single-pane glazing  anymore. Almost all modern windows use two,   and sometimes even three panes of glass with  a sealed air gap between them. Sometimes   [05:44] this gap is filled with a heavy gas like argon or  krypton that has lower conduction and convection.   There are even vacuum insulated panels that have  no air inside, eliminating convection entirely.   [05:58] I happen to have a double-pane glass  unit, so we can try the experiment again. difference is right at 30 F, 17 C. Remember with  the foam lid it was about 43 degrees and with the   [06:18] single pane it was around 23 degrees. So this  is basically right in the middle. It’s not as   good as when there was no window, but it’s  a lot better than the single pane of glass.  This varies a lot with details of the  frame and coatings. But very generally,   [06:33] modern double-pane windows can double to quadruple  the insulative value of a single pane of glass,   This idea of a sealed air gap between panes  comes with one problem. If you’ve ever brought   [06:49] a bag of chips on an airplane, you know what I’m  talking about. If the glass manufacturer is at   a low elevation and the window’s going  to be installed somewhere much higher,   you end up with an overpressure situation between  the panes compared to the barometric pressure.   [07:04] That can cause them to bow out and even  fracture. In some cases, manufacturers   will actually dial in the pressure for  the altitude of the final destination.   Another option is to install a capillary tube  that equalizes the pressure inside and out.   [07:20] These are very narrow diameter and long  tubes meant to reduce the amount of moisture   that diffuses between the panes, which would  otherwise lead to condensation inside the unit. Insulating glass panels help reduce heat  conduction and convection, but that’s not   [07:36] the only way heat gets into and out of a building.  The whole point of a window is to let in light,   and we already learned that heat can move as  electromagnetic waves. Of course, if we block   [07:48] visible light through a window to avoid heat  transfer, that kind of defeats the purpose. But   radiation also happens at other wavelengths on the  electromagnetic spectrum. Specifically, for the   temperatures we deal with on a day-to-day basis,  most of the thermal radiation happens in infrared:   [08:06] wavelengths longer than visible light but shorter  than microwaves. Even within that range, there are   big differences in how the waves interact with  matter. That’s particularly true for windows. [08:18] Typical stuff at ambient temperatures  like a sun-baked driveway or human body,   emit thermal radiation mostly in the far-infrared  spectrum. This is the stuff you can see on a   normal infrared camera. And even though glass  is designed to let visible light through,   [08:34] it is almost completely opaque to longwave  infrared light. Try looking through a window   with an infrared camera and you just see  the window itself, not anything beyond. [08:46] It’s cool to think that if our eyes worked a bit  differently - if they were tuned to a slightly   different part of the electromagnetic spectrum  - a glass window would be entirely useless.   And it seems like it would be a  good thing for our thermal problem,   [09:00] preventing heat from transferring through.  Unfortunately it’s not that simple. Glass isn’t just opaque to far-IR; it’s also  highly emissive. That means it mostly absorbs   thermal radiation rather than reflecting it.  So, the radiation doesn’t come directly through,   [09:17] but it does warm the glass, which can then  just conduct through the pane and reradiate   it where you don’t want it to go, whether inside  or out. It’s basically radiation with extra steps. On the shorter wavelength part of the spectrum  we call near IR, it’s a little different.   [09:34] The main source of near IR radiation is the  sun, and like visible light, that radiation   can pass directly through most glass. This is  how greenhouses work. The shortwave radiation   [09:46] passes right through where it can warm the stuff  inside. But the stuff inside radiates longwave IR,   which can’t pass back out through the glass.  So, windows are kind of a two-way half-door for   far infrared (since they absorb and reradiate  it in both directions) and a one-way door for   [10:03] near infrared, but we can do better than that,  mostly through low-emissivity or low-e coatings. These coatings essentially convert a pane of  glass into a mirror for IR. And you can see   [10:15] the difference really well with an IR camera. You  still get some reflections with an uncoated pane,   but the difference is obvious when you  put a coated pane next to an uncoated one.   But this gets a little tricky, especially when it  comes to near IR. If you live in a cold climate   [10:32] and your main use of energy is heating, you’re  happy to invite as much sunlight as you can get   inside. You don’t want to reflect the near IR. The  opposite is true in warm climates. Fortunately,   [10:44] manufacturers can tune the coatings according to  the climate. You can reflect shortwave radiation   if you’re worried most about cooling, or you  can let it in to gather more heat inside.   [10:56] Window manufacturers also sometimes vary which  face is coated. In warmer climates, you can coat   the inside of the outer pane, called “surface  2,” reflecting the IR before it crosses the gap   [11:08] to keep it from warming the air between the panes.  In cooler climates, you can put it on “surface 3”   to reflect the long-waveshort-wave IR back into  your house without it having to cross the air gap.  Making windows more thermally efficient isn’t the  only use for glass coatings. If you’re like me,   [11:25] there’s a good chance you have the Merlin app  installed on your phone. I think it’s a bit of   an inevitability that once you reach a certain  age, you start getting interested in birds.   Unfortunately, one of the largest human-caused  sources of bird mortality is actually windows.   [11:42] At certain angles, windows work essentially  like mirrors, reflecting the trees and sky,   and birds (bless their hearts)  can’t always tell the difference.   It can happen the other way too. Sometimes  a bird will see something inside a building   [11:55] or all the way through two windows that they want  to fly toward, not recognizing that there’s solid   glass in the way. For you and me, walking into a  glass pane like a sliding door is embarrassing,   but for a bird flying at much higher speeds  with tiny, hollow bones, it is often fatal. [12:11] McCormick Place Convention Center on the lakeshore  in Chicago may be the most famous case study.   In an average year, monitors would find around  1,000 dead birds around the building from   collisions with the windows. In October 2023,  nearly 1,000 birds died in a single night.   [12:28] The owner finally decided to address the problem  head on, installing a pattern of dots on all the   glass surrounding the building. The solution  cut the number of bird strikes by 95 percent. [12:40] Awareness about bird safe glass is continuing  to grow, and so are the number of solutions.   Many glass manufacturers have bird-safe  products that work in a similar way.   The goal is to break the illusion of glass being  a mirror or imperceptible as a solid surface,   [12:56] so most of the fixes involve patterns or designs  on the glass. I think it looks pretty cool,   actually. And because many bird species  can see into the ultraviolet spectrum,   you can even get dots and patterns that  are practically invisible to humans,   [13:10] but still perceptible to birds to keep them  from crashing into windows. Some cities   are already including requirements for bird  safe glass into codes, particularly in major   migration corridors and for buildings that  use large, uninterrupted facades of glass. [13:27] This is a really common design for tall buildings  and skyscrapers. Ever since I was a kid,   I have always been impressed with this kind of  facade. From the outside, it looks like a sleek,   continuous column of glass. And it’s pretty  interesting how it’s actually done. These   [13:42] are called walls, specifically curtain walls. But  they’re also not walls in the traditional sense,   at least when it comes to bearing loads. We  typically think of a building’s exterior walls   as the primary load path - the way forces from the  building are transferred to the foundation. With   [13:59] curtain walls, that’s not true, and that name kind  of gives it away. In buildings with curtain walls,   the load bearing happens through interior  columns. The exterior walls just hang there.   Not that this needs another analogy, but it’s  pretty much like the building is wearing a coat. [14:15] This has a lot of advantages. A curtain wall  is relatively lightweight, reducing structural   loads on a building. It’s also thin, maximizing  space in a building where it comes at a premium.   They’re also unitized: you get very  large pieces assembled in a factory   [14:31] so they go up quickly on a construction site.  And, of course, you get a lot of light into   the building when the entire exterior wall is a  window. But how do you hold the glass in place? The process of installing glass, called glazing,  is not like installing most other materials.   [14:48] You can’t use traditional fasteners  like nails or screws. Glass is brittle,   and the sharp point forces would induce too much  stress. If you look at the windows of your house,   the glass panes are usually sandwiched inside  a frame with softer material that both seals   [15:04] against the glass to keep out the weather  and spreads out the holding forces across   a larger area along the edges of the glass.  That’s sometimes called captured glazing.   It’s done on large buildings with expansive  glass facades too, but it’s not the only way. [15:21] When you really want the outside of a  building to look like only glass with   no mullions or framing elements  protruding beyond the panes,   you can use structural silicone glazing,  where the sealant does some or all the work   [15:35] to hold the glass in place. In 4-sided  structural glazing, the glass panels are   adhesively bonded on all four edges. You have  nothing on the exterior except smooth glass. [15:47] If you’re used to the silicone sealants sold at  the hardware store, this might seem absolutely   crazy to you. I definitely wouldn’t trust a  tube of bathroom caulk to hold thousands of   pounds of glass hundreds of feet in the air  above sidewalks and roads full of people.   [16:03] To be fair, these systems do usually have  some kind of mechanical clips or toggles that   surreptitiously prevent panes from coming  entirely loose if the sealant fails, but also,   [16:15] structural silicone is very different from caulk. Just to demonstrate this, I have a glass  block. First I’m going to attach this to   a metal plate using typical silicone  caulk you might use in the bathroom. [16:28] probably a bit ambitious. but it held 45 lbs for just about a minute  before it dropped. And part of that’s cause,   [16:41] even after 2 weeks of curing, you can  see, only the caulk around the edges   actually cured. This stuff is just not  designed for heavy weights like this. This stuff comes from a few manufacturers  in a variety of strengths, curing systems,   [16:59] and material compatibilities. After I let  this cure for a week, which is when the   manufacturer says it reaches 50 percent of  its strength, I tried my little demo again. It’s holding 45 pounds just fine. [17:14] So I added this small  metal anvil just for good measure,   Just a silly little experiment like this can  give you a lot more confidence that those big   insulated glass units on tall buildings aren’t  going anywhere. But the engineering of windows   [17:31] doesn’t stop at holding them in place. We also  have to think about what happens if they break. The most typical glass we think about with picture  frames and windows is actually annealed glass. The   [17:43] manufacturing process is pretty impressive. The  molten material is allowed to spread out and float   atop a bed of molten tin, making it extremely flat  and very consistent in thickness. Then the glass   [17:57] is allowed to cool slowly, which relieves internal  stresses. That makes it possible to cut along   clean lines and even drill holes in the material.  But it also means that when annealed glass breaks,   [18:09] it usually fractures into large, razor-sharp  shards that can be extremely dangerous.   I think most people have enough experience with  the issue that there’s hardly a need at all to   [18:21] say that broken glass is a serious hazard. And  in many cases, it’s a simply unacceptable hazard:   a slip in the shower that breaks the  door, a toddler on a glass tabletop,   even pushing too hard on a glass door. There are  plenty of documented cases where a simple accident   [18:39] became fatal simply because of how annealed glass  becomes jagged and razor-sharp when it fractures. One of the main solutions to the problem is  tempering the glass. If you heat glass and   [18:51] cool it down quickly, often using a high-pressure  blast of air, you can get the outside to cool a   little quicker than the inside of the glass. The  outside faces shrink. Then when the inside cools,   [19:03] it shrinks as well, pulling the outside  faces of the glass into compression.   If you use a polarizing filter, sometimes you  can even see the stresses in tempered glass.   This is a tricky process because if the cooling  happens unevenly, the glass will crack or break.   [19:21] I’ve discovered this myself by accidentally  setting a glass dish on the stove burner.   But if you do it right, tempering glass makes  it much stronger than typical annealed glass.   Since the outer faces are in compression,  cracks are less able to propagate. [19:37] But even if it does break,  tempered glass has a big advantage.   Instead of the large shards, you tiny, relatively  harmless pieces. These can still have sharp edges,   but just being so much smaller means they’re much  less able to injure someone. They have a lot less   [19:54] mass when they fall, and the edges are shorter, so  it’s more like angry gravel and less like deadly   knives and spears. That’s why tempered glass is  often called safety glass, and lots of building   [20:06] codes require it in situations where broken  glass can pose a safety hazard like glass doors,   large windows close to the ground, and in  bathrooms and showers. Most vehicles also   [20:18] use tempered glass on the side windows to  reduce the risk of injury during a crash. One disadvantage of tempered glass is  that it can’t be modified after the fact.   All that built-up stress in the material  makes sure it shatters into tiny pieces,   [20:33] but it also prevents you from  cutting or drilling holes.   Tempering has to be the final step. The other  disadvantage also comes from its main advantage.   Because tempered glass breaks in a relatively  safe way, it doesn’t offer much security. And   [20:50] really it’s true for annealed glass too. Windows  aren’t just a thermal weak point in buildings;   they are also a security weak point. Why  would a criminal struggle to break through   a reinforced door if they can just quickly smash  a window? That’s where laminated glass comes in. [21:08] You can glue individual panes of glass together  where they still retain almost perfect optical   clarity. But even better than that, you can  sandwich a tough plastic interlayer between those   panes of glass, creating a composite material.  And it behaves a lot differently when it breaks.   [21:25] Now you don’t have shards separating  at all. Even completely cracked apart,   the glass stays adhered to the plastic  instead of flying apart. And more importantly,   this is still a barrier even after it breaks.  I’m not getting my hand through there.   [21:40] Laminated glass is ideal for overhead  applications, where a break could otherwise rain   down shards on people below. And it’s perfect for  commercial buildings, especially on ground floors,   [21:52] to make it more challenging for someone to  break in through a window or glass door.   Laminated glass is also standard on vehicle  windshields to offer more protection from a   road hazard that could otherwise break through  the glass and injure the driver or passengers. [22:06] What’s kind of crazy is that I’m just scratching  the surface of modern window technology, not to   mention the glass itself, which can get a lot more  complicated for applications like phone screens.   [22:18] But these are all innovations that are kind  of hiding in plain sight, and to me at least,   they make the view through a  window just a little bit sweeter. A lot of people ask me what I do with all these  demonstrations after I finish shooting a video.   [22:34] The answer is that a lot of the parts get reused  in the future. That steel plate with the tapped   hole I used to demo structural silicone was  originally used in my video about guyed antenna   [22:46] towers. I am always mocking up demonstrations like  this, and it’s rare that I can just pick something   off the shelf. Most of my builds have custom,  one-off parts to make them work, even simple   stuff like this. That’s why I rely on my friends  at Send Cut Send, the sponsor of today’s video.  [23:03] You can watch a lot of my videos and see this  process in action. Send Cut Send can fabricate   practically anything I can dream up in CAD  that uses sheet materials like steel, aluminum,   or acrylic. They have a huge catalog of materials,  and it’s not just laser cutting. They can bend,   [23:19] countersink, tap, and even insert hardware.  They’ve also started offering CNC machining.   which makes rapid prototyping a dream,  especially with the instant quotes. [23:34] It’s hard to convey how much of a superpower it  is to have a service like this to go from idea to   model to part so quickly. And you don’t even need  to know CAD, because they have a bunch of useful   [23:46] and customizable templates. I can’t recommend Send  Cut Send enough. They are an essential part of my   workflow in the shop. If you have projects that  could use some fabrication help, the link below   is going to give you a discount on your first  order. I really appreciate their support, and   [24:02] I hope you give them a try. Thank you for  watching, and let me know what you think.