---
title: 'We Used To Think The Sun Was Cold'
source: 'https://youtube.com/watch?v=gNVj-FIxoe4'
video_id: 'gNVj-FIxoe4'
date: 2026-10-28
duration_sec: 180
channel: 'Vsauce'
---

# We Used To Think The Sun Was Cold

> Source: [We Used To Think The Sun Was Cold](https://youtube.com/watch?v=gNVj-FIxoe4)

## Summary

This video explores the surprising historical belief that the sun is cold, a theory championed by Aristotle and others. It details how Leonardo da Vinci used a simple experiment to disprove this, establishing the sun's heat as intrinsic to its rays. The video also touches on Leonardo's philosophical reflections on life and death, tying his scientific genius to his broader worldview.

### Key Points

- **Da Vinci's Proof** [00:01] — Leonardo da Vinci proved the sun is hot, contrary to the long-standing belief that it was cold.
- **The Ancient Mystery** [00:29] — Ancients asked why the sun doesn't run out of fuel and why it isn't the color of fire, leading them to conclude it was cold.
- **Aristotle's Ether Theory** [00:42] — Aristotle proposed the sun was made of ether, a substance less dense than fire, and that its heat came from friction against the fire sphere and air sphere.
- **The Mirror Experiment** [01:36] — Leonardo used a concave mirror to show that sunlight concentrates heat, indicating heat is intrinsic to the sun's rays.
- **Color of Heat** [02:01] — Leonardo argued that molten bronze at its hottest matches the sun's color, countering the claim that fire's color is the only indicator of heat.
- **Philosophical Reflection** [02:29] — Leonardo described humans as 'vehicles and conduits of food, tombs of animals, hostiles of death, coverings that consume, deriving life by the death of others.'

## Transcript

did is not one of his paintings, inventions, or anatomical studies. Oh, no. It's the work he did to prove that the sun is hot. That might seem [music] unnecessary, right? But as it turns out, it's actually not that obvious. I just
of Leonardo's thoughts on art and life, a book full of things he wrote while he box, and some of the things in here are long time ago, people were very mystified by the sun. What the heck was
it doing up there? Is it burning? If so, what is its fuel source? And why does it not run out of fuel? Also, if the sun is so hot, why is it not the color of fire? Smarty [music] pants. This is not a joke. These questions were seriously
asked by some of the greatest minds in human history up to Leonardo's time. And from those questions, they concluded that the sun must be cold. One of those minds was Aristotle's. Now, his theory was that the terrestrial world is made
got fire, air, water, and earth. In order of increasing density, the densest &gt;&gt; layer of earth, water. Then comes air. And above all that air, there must be a sphere of unignited elemental fire. [music] Perfect problem. What's outer
out of? The sun, the stars. [music] His answer to that was that they were made of something that must be less dense than fire since they're so high up. And [music] Now, this ether could be cold, but you
know what's not cold? Friction. There you go. The sun is up there. It's made of ether. It's cold, but it rubs against the fire sphere and the air sphere and produces frictional heat that we then feel coming from its direction. Boom.
Problem solved. That idea was very clever. And in Leonardo's world, it was of the sun. But Leonardo noticed something strange. If you take a concave mirror and you focus the sun's light to
a point, you will concentrate light on that point, but also heat. [snorts] And so Leonardo reasoned, "Heat must be an intrinsic property of the rays that come from the sun and the sun itself, not the result of the sun rubbing on the
atmosphere." Also, he said this, "They say that the sun is not hot because it's not the color of fire." But the answer to this is that when molten bronze is hottest, it resembles the color of the sun. And when it is less hot, it has the
color of fire. Now, I love this. I mean, this is huge stuff. This is science. You could time travel back to the 1400s and walk around saying stuff like this. Uh, the sun is hot. And people would be like, "Whoa, genius alert." I got to
leave you with this. So, Leonardo was also obsessed [music] with the fact that Okay? That in order to live, I have to consume stuff that used to be alive, whether it be plant or animal. Listen to this. Men and animals are in reality
vehicles and conduits of food, tombs of animals, hostiles of death, coverings that consume, deriving [music] life by the death of others.
Doesn't that just make you want to go paint the Mona Lisa?
