---
title: 'Physics Nobel 2026: You Will Hate Me for Saying This'
source: 'https://youtube.com/watch?v=yILp9vsw1eI'
video_id: 'yILp9vsw1eI'
date: 2026-11-11
duration_sec: 450
channel: 'Sabine Hossenfelder'
---

# Physics Nobel 2026: You Will Hate Me for Saying This

> Source: [Physics Nobel 2026: You Will Hate Me for Saying This](https://youtube.com/watch?v=yILp9vsw1eI)

## Summary

The 2026 Nobel Prize in Physics was awarded to Francis Halzen for his work on the IceCube detector, which measures neutrinos from beyond our galaxy. This video explains what Halzen accomplished, why it matters, and offers a critical perspective on the award's relevance to humankind.

### Key Points

- **Nobel Prize Surprise** [00:00] — Francis Halzen won the 2026 Nobel Prize in Physics for measuring neutrinos from cosmic sources, a surprise to many as he wasn't on most people's radar.
- **Halzen's Background** [00:27] — Halzen is known for his textbook 'Quarks and Leptons' with Alan Martin, and the prize sits at the intersection of particle physics, cosmology, and astrophysics.
- **Neutrino Basics** [00:41] — Neutrinos are fundamental particles, electrically neutral, and 'ghostly' because they rarely interact with matter. They have tiny masses and move near the speed of light.
- **The Goal** [01:36] — The aim was to detect neutrinos from outside our galaxy to learn about the universe's composition and origins.
- **Early Attempts** [01:54] — John Learned's 1970s idea to use ocean-based detectors failed due to a water leak and short circuit in 1993, leading to funding cuts.
- **IceCube Detector** [02:26] — IceCube uses hot-water-drilled holes in Antarctic ice, with over 80 strings and 5000 detectors covering a cubic kilometer, costing $300 million, funded mainly by NSF.
- **Key Discovery** [03:13] — IceCube detected neutrinos from outside our galaxy, with the highest energy at 20 PeV, comparable to LHC energies in the center-of-mass frame.
- **Source Mystery** [03:41] — Some neutrinos come from active galactic nuclei, but the sources of most remain unknown.
- **Critical View** [04:13] — The speaker argues the Nobel Prize highlights the irrelevance of fundamental physics, questioning the benefit to humankind as per Alfred Nobel's will.
- **Random Selection** [04:41] — The speaker questions why other experiments like SDSS, James Webb, or Parkes weren't chosen, suggesting the committee rotates fields.
- **Alternative Candidates** [05:24] — Guth and Linde for inflation were popular candidates but might have been too controversial due to multiverse implications.
- **Final Verdict** [05:39] — Despite being a deserving scientist, the speaker feels the award demonstrates how little benefit physics brings to humankind.

### Conclusion

The video acknowledges Halzen's achievement but criticizes the Nobel committee's choice, arguing that fundamental physics has become increasingly irrelevant to practical human benefit.

## Transcript

The 2026 Nobel Prize in Physics was awarded&nbsp; to Francis Halzen for measuring neutrinos&nbsp;&nbsp; from out there in the cosmos, billions of&nbsp; light years away. Halzen is the first to&nbsp;&nbsp;
win a Nobel Prize in physics alone for&nbsp; 32 years. I didn’t have him on my radar&nbsp;&nbsp; and few others did. So this is a big&nbsp; surprise. Just exactly what did he do,&nbsp;&nbsp; why does it matter, and what have we&nbsp; learned from it? Let’s have a look.
Francis Halzen will be a familiar&nbsp; name for many students because he&nbsp;&nbsp; wrote a famous textbook with Alan&nbsp; Martin about Quarks and Leptons,&nbsp;&nbsp; basically mandatory literature if you want&nbsp; to work on particle physics. This Nobel Prize&nbsp;&nbsp;
sits at the intersection of particle&nbsp; physics, cosmology, and astrophysics. Neutrinos are one of the fundamental particles&nbsp; of nature. There are three different neutrinos,&nbsp;&nbsp; the electron-neutrino, the muon-neutrino, and&nbsp; the tau-neutrino. They are electrically neutral&nbsp;&nbsp;
and often described as “ghostly” because they&nbsp; pass through atomic matter mostly undisturbed.&nbsp;&nbsp; It is very very rare that they bump into&nbsp; anything. Neutrinos are also special in that&nbsp;&nbsp;
their masses are very very small, so they move&nbsp; almost, but not exactly at the speed of light. Neutrinos are produced in nuclear reactions a&nbsp; lot, so nuclear power plants and also nuclear&nbsp;&nbsp;
bomb explosions emit a lot of neutrinos. The sun&nbsp; also showers us with large amounts of neutrinos.&nbsp;&nbsp; But neutrinos should also reach us from elsewhere&nbsp; in the universe and they are yet another way&nbsp;&nbsp;
to look at what is happening out there, and to&nbsp; learn how our universe is made up, how it works,&nbsp;&nbsp; and how it came into being. This, in a nutshell,&nbsp; is what this year’s Nobel Prize is about. In the 1970s, John Learned in Hawaii had the&nbsp; idea to look for neutrinos from the universe,&nbsp;&nbsp;
not from our planet, not from our sun, but&nbsp; from other stars or other galaxies, billions&nbsp;&nbsp; of light years away. But since neutrinos pass&nbsp; through matter mostly without leaving a trace,&nbsp;&nbsp; one needs a giant detector to see the&nbsp; occasional trace that they do leave.
His idea was to hang long strings&nbsp; of detectors down into the ocean&nbsp;&nbsp; and anchor them into the sea floor. But&nbsp; the project took decades to get going,&nbsp;&nbsp; and then, in 1993, the first string of&nbsp; detectors had a water leak and died from&nbsp;&nbsp;
a short circuit within hours. After that&nbsp; the US government scrapped the funding. The IceCube detector is basically the same idea,&nbsp; just in ice. They are drilling holes into the ice&nbsp;&nbsp;
on the South Pole, about 2 and a half kilometres&nbsp; deep. The holes are being drilled with hot water,&nbsp;&nbsp; then they lower strings, each with about 60&nbsp; sensors into it, and let the water freeze.&nbsp;&nbsp; They have more than 80 of these detector strings&nbsp; now, with together more than 5000 detectors that&nbsp;&nbsp;
cover about one cubic square kilometre.&nbsp; It’s the largest detector ever built. It was mostly paid by the US-American&nbsp; National Science Foundation (NSF) with&nbsp;&nbsp; contributions from some European countries,&nbsp; and it cost an estimated $300 million. Halzen,&nbsp;&nbsp;
who was awarded the Nobel Prize, has been the&nbsp; principal investigator since the beginning. And, yes, they did see neutrinos from&nbsp; outside our galaxy. Some of them have&nbsp;&nbsp;
amazingly high energy. The highest one they&nbsp; detected had about 20 Peta Electron volt,&nbsp;&nbsp; Peta is 10^15. So on the face of it,&nbsp; the energy seems to be more than 1000&nbsp;&nbsp; times higher than the energy of the Large&nbsp; Hadron Collider. Though if you convert&nbsp;&nbsp;
this into the centre of mass system&nbsp; the energies are kind of comparable. Where do the neutrinos come from? That's a&nbsp; very good question. Some of them clearly come&nbsp;&nbsp; from active galactic nuclei. But for most of&nbsp; the neutrinos, astrophysicists currently just&nbsp;&nbsp;
don’t know where they come from. What have we&nbsp; learned from it? Well, we have learned that&nbsp;&nbsp; these neutrinos exist. Which no one doubted.&nbsp; What is it good for? Nothing, really. I mean,&nbsp;&nbsp; it does teach us something about neutrino sources&nbsp; outside our galaxy. But that’s pretty much it.
Now look, this is a great detector and Halzen is&nbsp; very deserving regardless, but to me this Nobel&nbsp;&nbsp; Prize just documents how irrelevant the&nbsp; foundations of physics have become. Okay,&nbsp;&nbsp;
so we’ve built a big detector to measure even&nbsp; more neutrinos than we measured before. But by&nbsp;&nbsp; Alfred Nobel’s will, the prize is to be&nbsp; awarded to those who have “conferred the&nbsp;&nbsp; greatest benefit to humankind” in the preceding&nbsp; year. And what is the benefit of this exactly?
It also seems rather random. I mean, why not&nbsp; give a Nobel Prize to the leaders of SDSS for&nbsp;&nbsp; confirming baryon acoustic oscillations.&nbsp; Or to some people related to the James&nbsp;&nbsp; Webb telescope for observing the first&nbsp; galaxies. Or to Parkes for discovering&nbsp;&nbsp;
fast radio bursts that we still don’t&nbsp; know what they are. These are all great&nbsp;&nbsp; experiments and I don’t see how we have&nbsp; learned more from IceCube then from them. The bottom line is that in this case I can't quite&nbsp; follow the reasoning of the Nobel Prize committee.&nbsp;&nbsp;
It is well known that they like to rotate through&nbsp; different areas of physics, and we haven’t had a&nbsp;&nbsp; Nobel Prize in astrophysics/cosmology since&nbsp; 2020. The candidates that many people had on&nbsp;&nbsp;
their list were Guth and Linde for inflation.&nbsp; But maybe this was too controversial for the&nbsp;&nbsp; Royal Swedish Academy as it could have been&nbsp; misconstrued as endorsing the multiverse. Again, it’s a wonderful experiment&nbsp; and the winner is doubtlessly a&nbsp;&nbsp;
highly accomplished scientist&nbsp; who totally deserves the award,&nbsp;&nbsp; but to me it sadly demonstrates just how&nbsp; little benefit physics now brings to humankind. But humankind can now sleep soundly&nbsp; knowing that very energetic neutrinos are,&nbsp;&nbsp;
I read a lot of news to keep you well informed. And the most useful and time-saving way&nbsp; I found to do this is with Ground News,&nbsp;&nbsp; who've been sponsoring this video. Ground News&nbsp; is a news platform that collects news from all&nbsp;&nbsp;
over the world. It really saves me a lot of&nbsp; time because I don't have to sort through a&nbsp;&nbsp; dozen headlines on the same story. I can just get&nbsp; a quick summary of all the coverage. And Ground&nbsp;&nbsp; News also gives you a lot of extra information&nbsp; at one glance. Take for example this recent story&nbsp;&nbsp;
about the AI agents that tried to hack a Canadian&nbsp; government website. Ground News gives you a brief&nbsp;&nbsp; summary here. This really saves me so much time.&nbsp; They also have this interesting bias comparison.&nbsp;&nbsp;
This tells you that left-leaning outlets see&nbsp; a pattern of misbehaving AI agents whereas&nbsp;&nbsp; right-leaning ones stress that well actually&nbsp; nothing happened. Ground News also gives you&nbsp;&nbsp; a fact check for each news item. tells you who&nbsp; owns the media outlets and shows you where the&nbsp;&nbsp;
news has appeared. I found this to be super&nbsp; useful for checking whether stories being&nbsp;&nbsp; blown out of proportion, ignored or distorted.&nbsp; And of course, I have a special offer for you.&nbsp;&nbsp; That's a 40% discount on the Vantage plan, which&nbsp; gives you access to all their features. All you&nbsp;&nbsp;
need to do is use my link ground.news/sabine&nbsp; or use the QR code so they'll know I sent you.
