---
title: 'Kevin Warsh''s first Jackson Hole speech as Fed chairman [FULL]'
source: 'https://youtube.com/watch?v=sJ1q9daiOpI'
video_id: 'sJ1q9daiOpI'
date: 2026-11-19
duration_sec: 1825
channel: 'Yahoo Finance'
---

# Kevin Warsh's first Jackson Hole speech as Fed chairman [FULL]

> Source: [Kevin Warsh's first Jackson Hole speech as Fed chairman (FULL)](https://youtube.com/watch?v=sJ1q9daiOpI)

## Summary

In his first Jackson Hole speech as Fed Chairman, Kevin Warsh outlines his vision for monetary policy, emphasizing a shift away from heavy forward guidance and a focus on principles like the 2% inflation target. He also provides an economic assessment, highlighting AI-driven investment and persistent inflation.

### Key Points

- **Speech Overview** [01:53] — Warsh introduces the conference theme of innovation and outlines his speech topics: AI, forward guidance, principles, and economic assessment.
- **AI's Economic Impact** [04:37] — AI is a new variable and potential factor of production. Token sales for leading labs exceed $100 billion annually, up 500% from a year ago.
- **Limiting Forward Guidance** [08:15] — Forward guidance was essential during the crisis but has outstayed its welcome. In normal times, it should be limited to avoid ambiguity and overcommitment.
- **Hall of Mirrors Problem** [10:54] — The 'hall of mirrors' problem occurs when markets rely on Fed guidance and the Fed relies on market prices, leading to policy errors. The most serious harm falls on those without financial assets.
- **Seven Principles** [13:48] — Warsh outlines seven principles: 1) Interrogate reality, 2) Aggregate demand vs supply is imprecise, 3) 2% inflation target is firm, 4) Dual mandate is not either-or, 5) Short-term rates are the primary tool, 6) Money matters, 7) A quieter Fed is better.
- **Economic Strength** [19:09] — The economy appears strengthened. Business CapEx is rising at 9% (highest since 2021), with over half attributed to AI. S&P profits grew over 20% in the past year.
- **Labor and Inflation** [21:56] — Labor markets are stable with a 4.1% jobless rate, near full employment. However, inflation remains above target at 3.7% PCE, and the Fed's focus should be on prices.
- **Commitment to Discipline** [27:42] — Warsh concludes by committing to a discipline, not a decision, and emphasizes the Fed's responsibility to deliver price stability.

## Transcript

again. See so many familiar faces from academia, from my last tour of service, and from my first 100 days, which is just this weekend. weekend. And before I go further, I want to thank
Jeff Schmitt and his team for the incredible hospitality. your colleagues here at the Federal Reserve Bank of Kansas City. Uh our Jeff uh thanks uh to you and your team.
Now, he and the other planners here have some recreation options lined up for later today. I'd advise you to be very careful with your choices. As I learned years ago, you can take two
different kinds of hikes on the trails around Jackson. I can sum up my hikes with former Vice Chairman Don Kohn with two words. I survived. These steely marathon death marches
revealed the sign of Don that that I was not ready for. But there's another kind of hike. This one was with my former Chairman Ben Bernanke, another dear old colleague. With Ben, it was a much more leisurely
pace. An easy stroll along the wandering trails of the Rockefeller Preserve. So before setting out today, my recommendation is do a wellness check. Ask yourself, is this a Kohn day or a
Bernanke day? The best thing about this gathering is that it helps us all get out here to the mountains and clear our minds and think straight about our world and our time.
For me, it feels like the right place and the right audience for real engagement with the ideas that matter most. Innovation, as Kristen mentioned, is the conference theme.
understand that innovations in the conduct of Fed policy will help deliver price stability So, here's a quick overview of what I'll cover in my remarks this morning.
You can call it an outline. You can call it a trail map. But, please just don't call it forward guidance. longer-term questions we're asking at the Fed about the latest general-purpose
technology AI and where it might take the economy. Then, I'll reflect a bit on the practice of forward guidance and the interaction between the central bank and financial markets.
principles that I believe should guide the conduct of monetary policy. And finally, I'll give you my assessment of what's happening in the economy. So first, I think we should try to
prepare a bit for future policy conjunctures. With the unchanging picture of the T-times as our backdrop, we are here to survey an economic landscape that is anything but static.
It wasn't so long ago, including in rooms like this, in the run-up to the crisis of 2008 and over the decade that followed, when economists and policy makers were speaking of secular stagnation,
speaking of a global savings glut. It was a widely held view that an excess of capital would sit on the sidelines for a very long, long time because there just wouldn't be enough compelling investment opportunities.
been invented. So, growth would be low and slow. Well, times sure have changed. We've come to a hinge point in history
to borrow a a phrase, a framing from my former mentor George Shultz. To cite the clearest example, progress in AI, technology, has been faster even than its
evangelists predicted just a couple of years ago. The potential for substantially higher growth is on the rise. Ever-expanding pools of capital pouring into AI-related infrastructure of all
A kind of super Moore's law seems to be playing out. Scaling laws, too, are changing both the Scaling laws, too, are changing both the method and speed of innovation.
create large language models at the heart of AI. Users buy tokens to gain access to these models. Reports put annualized token sales for the two leading labs alone at more than
a hundred billion dollars. An increase of 500% from just 12 months ago. We at the Fed, we watch all this attentively. We recognize that AI is a new variable,
We recognize that AI is a new variable, potentially a new factor of production, economy and for the conduct of monetary policy. It opens up some major lines of inquiry. Will the application of AI cause a
productivity across the economy? If so, when? Will token usage be complementary or competitive to labor? Will the next generation of AI models
too? Or will the models themselves help Or will the models themselves help devise a capital-light solution? Among the other yet unknowns is the resulting market structure.
Who gets to make the money? It's not obvious when the where the returns on capital will land or on what time scale. Early on, how much of the surplus goes to owners of scarce assets, the AI labs
or chip makers or energy producers or cloud providers? Over time, how much of that value accrues to businesses and consumers? And importantly, what are the implications for workers and for the
employment side of the Fed's mandate? Likewise, we don't yet know the equilibrium price of the tokens that give access to these models. Might there be a heterogeneity of tokens, such that growing sums will be
paid for the access to the best models, those at the frontier? Will token prices for older models fall to the level of their marginal cost? Well, we'll be think thinking through these matters with the help of a task
force on productivity and jobs. My early check-ins with the leaders of that task force and the rest have been very encouraging. recommendations will come later and have no bearing
on decisions we make in the current policy conjunction. But I believe that for future policy challenges, this intellectual investment today will leave us much better prepared for
tomorrow. Next, let me say a word about forward guidance and its substitutes. As our task forces go about their work, as you might know, I'm not waiting to
introduce innovations at the Fed to help make us fit for purpose. To highlight one example, I've set out to change the form and function guidance. You might know about my long-time
discomfort with early pronouncements of future policy decisions. I much prefer another path and now we'll make the case for it. Transparency in communications about future policy decisions is not an end
unto itself. Communications must be in service to the Fed's paramount responsibility. And what is that? It's getting policy right. Forward guidance as a regular practice
was adopted by my colleagues and me during the global financial crisis. It was essential at the time. And we introduced it with much fanfare. But as with other legacies of crises past,
I believe the practice has outstayed its welcome. In normal times, the role of forward guidance should be limited and circumscribed. Otherwise, it risks creating ambiguity
in the name of clarity. Oversharing policy deliberations Oversharing policy deliberations and over committing to future decisions can lead markets, businesses, and households astray.
And I believe when policymakers make quasi commitments on interest rates throughout the cycle, we inhibit our own freedom to make the we inhibit our own freedom to make the right calls when it's time to decide.
the relationship right between the central bank and financial markets. The markets the excuse me, the Fed needs clear market signals as unfiltered as possible.
From market internals, from the level and change in asset prices across sectors, the prices and trading volumes of Treasury securities, the foreign exchange value of the
dollar, the cost and availability of credit, the cost and availability of credit, a broad set of commodity prices. These and other indicators should inform the Fed's near-term outlook
on economic activity and inflation throughout the business cycle. They should also reveal the state of broader financial conditions and the risks and uncertainties of the financial cycle.
At the same time, market participants them themselves should be tracking real information about the real economy. They should draw their own conclusions, form their own expectations
on things like output, employment, and inflation. And they too should stay sharply attuned to risks. In my view, the Fed should be humble and never naive.
The Fed plays an essential role in the economy and markets. Our tools are powerful. We determine the path of short-term interest rates, and market participants will always try
to anticipate what we will do next. But, we should not indulge a regime in which market participants are looking primarily to the Fed for their next
trade. The economic literature has long described the distorting effects what it called the hall of mirrors problem. If markets rely materially on the Fed's
guidance, and the Fed relies on market prices, we're more likely to be blinded to new developments, more likely to be caught unprepared, and more likely to commit errors in
policy making. Now, perversely, market participants are unlikely to bear the biggest costs of the hall of mirrors problem. The most serious harm is likely to befall those without any
financial assets. If the Fed gets inflation wrong, and judges the economy wrong, who gets the worst of it? Not the financial high-flyers. Hard-working Americans are the ones left
to deal with inflation that's too high or jobs that suddenly appear less secure. So, if forward guidance is ill-suited to normal times, how about the new Fed chief commits at a
meeting just like this to some explicit reaction function? rate path if say the data were to come in hot or cold. Well, I wish our understanding of the
economy were so precise as to provide a mechanical, tried and true answer. That some simple function, like a Taylor That some simple function, like a Taylor rule, could be rigorously relied upon.
that far. At least not yet. And other factors most relevant to the proper conduct of monetary policy, they change over time. Providing a forecast to illustrate the
Fed's reaction function works better in theory than in practice. Better in the lab than in the field. I am not alone in noticing that forward
guidance in 2021, to cite just one example, might well have slowed the policy response to high inflation. In my term as chairman, my colleagues and I will endeavor to construct more
reliable models, more robust rules, and we'll do this knowing that accuracy in forecasting is still just an aspiration. With so much changing so fast in our
geopolitics, global supply chains, technology, it's wise to be modest about what we can and cannot [clears throat] know as we sit here today. In the same spirit, we should receive
the full range of ideas on matters that may inform the Fed's monetary policy discussions. If the aim is optimal decision-making, and it should be, we should not crowd out views on the
economy. How then to chart a better path to policy? In the balance of my remarks, I will share with you some key principles that guide my thinking on the
appropriate conduct of monetary policy. And then I'll offer my promised assessment of the economy. So, let's turn first to principles. work, yesterday's news has a way of getting
mistaken for what's happening right now. The challenge is to know the difference. In other words, we must interrogate reality. Make sure we're not setting forward-looking policy
forward-looking policy based on stale or inaccurate data. Nor should we rely on isolated data points. Trends matter most. The Fed's a decision-making agency.
We make choices amid uncertainty. And the data upon which we draw must be relevant, contemporaneous, accurate, and as actionable as possible.
Second principle. The Fed's actions are intended to ensure that the aggregate demand side of the economy supply. However, all we observe directly is
activity. We never see, and can only infer, what's really happening on the supply side. Hence, evaluating the current and expected balance between aggregate
supply and aggregate demand is imprecise. Third principle. There should be no misunderstanding. The Fed's price stability objective of 2% as measured by the PCE price index is
2% as measured by the PCE price index is a firm fixed target. Let me be equally clear about another aspect of this objective. aspect of this objective. Price stability is not self-executing.
Nor does inflation necessarily mean reverting. It's the Fed's job to deliver stable prices. No excuses. Fourth principle.
The Fed also bears responsibility for maximum employment. Achieving both sides of our mandate over the medium term is not an either-or proposition. I do not believe the Fed's dual mandate
works at cross-purposes. After all, high inflation itself After all, high inflation itself is very harmful to economic prosperity. Fifth principle. Short-term interest rates are the
predominant tool to achieve the dual mandate. Unconventional policies to spur economic activity may suit genuine crises, of which we all have much experience, but they should otherwise be used
sparingly if at all. Sixth. Money matters. I know it's not fashionable these days, but my view is that money has something important to do with monetary policy.
We should pay attention to money created by the central bank and money that comes from the banking and financial system. It's true that financial innovations, the subject of this conference, and other factors alter the mechanics
that link the monetary base, the velocity of money, and the broader economy. But that is scarcely a reason to ignore the ultimate effects of money on financial conditions and prices.
Finally, a quieter Fed, communications, is better able to meet its objectives.
And we can be held accountable for delivering on our remit, delivering on our remit, the only true test of our credibility. To borrow a line from General Chuck Yeager, at the moment of truth, there
Yeager, at the moment of truth, there are either reasons or results. So, having heard a little bit about AI and general-purpose technologies, having conjuncture, a little bit on principles, let's turn
Given those principles, how do I read the economy? window? It's a little ironic there are no windows in this room, but but there are big ones at the Federal
Reserve. And we've been using those in my first 100 days, and I expect we're going to continue to use those in the period right ahead of us. Now, you may have read in the July
Now, you may have read in the July minutes the unanimous view of the FOMC. Labor markets were stable, output solid, but inflation remained too high. A good majority of my colleagues and I
thought the wiser course was to await new information in the intermeeting period, especially given possible developments in supply chains, investment flows, and geopolitics,
before deciding whether a change in interest rate policy was advisable. And we expressed our joint readiness to act as circumstances Excuse me, require. For my part today, as we sit here,
I'm impressed by the overall performance of the economy, which appears to have strengthened. One indicator of strength stress, how well it holds up under shocks.
both Main Street and Wall Street have been remarkably resilient. Several other observations. Business CapEx is rising rapidly.
The four-quarter change in investment in equipment and intangibles has been around 9%. It's highest growth rate since 2021. And more than half of the CapEx growth can likely be ascribed to the build-out
related to AI. What about profits? For the firms in the S&amp;P, profits have grown more than 20% over the past year Profit margins are quite elevated relative to history.
Overall equity market volatility quite low. We're staying keenly focused on market internals, watching performance across sectors. Expectations for both growth and CapEx
high. I continue to watch the change in the growth rates, the second derivative. The follow-on effects on asset prices, business confidence, consumer incomes and spending are
equally important to gauge. Credit spreads on corporate bonds and leveraged loans are near the low end of their historical averages. And issue volumes this year quite strong.
the banking business, in the July so-called SLOOS survey, banks tell us that standards for C&amp;I loans on the easier end of their historical ranges.
That helps explain their growth that we've seen this year on these loans. In my view, credit and loan markets are showing few signs of policy restraint. Now, certain sectors, like housing and agriculture, are showing strains.
But, on balance, I would be hard-pressed to describe broad financial conditions as restrictive. Real consumer spending has been healthy despite these shocks, increasing more than 2% over the past
If you combine consumption with the brisk investment we talked about earlier, private domestic financial purchases These purchases have increased at a pace of nearly 3% or so so far this year.
That's a measure that typically correlates more signal than GDP. The trend here, too, positive. So, on the employment side of the Fed's dual mandate, our country is doing well.
Labor markets are quite stable. The jobless rate at 4.1% remains low by historical standards and hasn't changed much in a couple of years. Unemployment claims, on a four-week
an empirically robust real-time indicator, are near their lowest level in decades. In my view, the relatively low turnover in today's labor market is partly a result of the significant rematching
happened uh after the post in the post-pandemic But, when labor supply is barely growing, monthly job gains are naturally
going to run low. There always area of concerns in the labor market. For example, among recent graduates. In general, though, people who want to work, by and large, are holding or
finding jobs. They may well be concerned about future labor disruptions, but as of now, I believe the labor markets are broadly I believe the labor markets are broadly consistent with full employment.
But, on the price stability side of our mandate, the numbers are more The Fed's preferred measure of inflation, the one I talked about earlier, the 12-month change in the PC price index, stands at 3.7%.
price index, stands at 3.7%. The 6-month change, a little above four. The comparable measures from the CPI index are also elevated. As are core measures both of PC and CPI inflation. None of these measures are perfect.
But, they all tell a similar story. Inflation is running above our 2% target. So, the Fed's predominant focus So, the Fed's predominant focus right now should be on prices.
So, what's our job? The job for policy makers is to capture underlying trend inflation. Easier said than done. We want to gauge whether underlying inflation is rising, falling,
or seems to be stuck in place. We also want to understand not just the We also want to understand not just the direction of travel, but the speed. Each of these broad inflation measures have fallen significantly from their
highs of a few years ago. But, progress over the last couple of years has been more modest. And while this summer's PC and CPI readings were better than expected, they do not tell me that underlying trends
have meaningfully improved. The data also show moderate wage growth. But, in my view, when tracking underlying inflation, wage growth has not proven a reliable indicator of future inflation for a very long time.
inflation, I want to tell you about a couple things I've always looked to. I find it instructive to disaggregate I find it instructive to disaggregate the 199 individual components of the PC
price measure. Over the last 12 months, 50 port 54% of goods and services in this basket showed price increases above 3%. This is well below the post-pandemic highs of about 77%.
32 in a couple of the decades that preceded the pandemic. Looking over just the last 6 months, the conclusion is similar. 49% of goods and services in the PC
49% of goods and services in the PC basket showed price increases above 3%. Again, this is well below the post-pandemic highs, but still elevated, quite elevated. The recent rise in overall commodity
The recent rise in overall commodity prices also bears watching. What we need to judge is whether the trends we see indicate upside inflation risks. Now, it matters, too, whether the
inflation readings of the past 5 years have seeped into expectations. The good news is that measures of inflation expectations in the medium term by and large look stable.
And inflation compensation measures from the swaps market send a strong and similar message. Especially in light of recent it's a credit to the Fed as an institution,
traditions, that market prices show confidence that we will deliver price stability. And I can assure you they're right. The thing about market measures of
history, I know some economic historians in the is they all tend to look really strong and durable until they don't. easily.
anchored. But they must be closely minded. And it's the Fed's job to make sure that inflation expectations do not get unanchored. Now, there is one signal nobody can
miss. Responsibility for 65 months of sustained elevated inflation sits squarely with the central bank. And that's where it belongs. So, here is my standard.
We must be confident that underlying inflation is moving to our objective clearly and at sufficient speed. Otherwise, we have work to do.
That's our job. That's our mandate, and that's our charge to keep. So, I've covered quite a bit of ground in the last 25 minutes or so. in the last 25 minutes or so. Let me see if I can conclude this way.
I stand here today committed to a discipline, not a decision. My Fed colleagues and I are hardly the first to hold these positions in a time of great consequence.
We are determined to redeem the time by doing our very best work. For those of us those of you that know us, you'll know the following is true.
We take our responsibility seriously, with humility, and with resolve. We know so much depends on the choices we make. Sound monetary policy helps households and businesses to prosper.
When carried out effectively, it broadens and deepens the momentum of our economy and helps to secure America's leadership in the world. And I know that our country needs us to
think carefully and act wisely, perhaps now more than ever. It's a tremendous honor to serve once again at the Federal Reserve. encouragement, good counsel, and the
100 days from my colleagues. I'm also honored and grateful for the views that I've gotten, solicited and unsolicited, from so many of you in this room.
For that and for your kind attention this morning, I say thank you. Let's get on with the rest of the program. &gt;&gt; [applause]
