---
title: 'It''s time we talk about James Gunn and the DCU'
source: 'https://youtube.com/watch?v=uLT8HeS7gS4'
video_id: 'uLT8HeS7gS4'
date: 2026-11-13
duration_sec: 1223
channel: 'ScreenCrush'
---

# It's time we talk about James Gunn and the DCU

> Source: [It's time we talk about James Gunn and the DCU](https://youtube.com/watch?v=uLT8HeS7gS4)

## Summary

The video discusses the recent firing of James Gunn and Peter Safran as heads of DC Studios, following a reported shift in strategy by new owners Sky Dance and the Ellison family. It explores the turbulent history of DC's leadership and the creative vs. corporate tensions that led to this change.

### Key Points

- **New ownership dismantling DCU** [00:29] — Sky Dance, backed by the Ellison family and Saudi investors, bought Warner Brothers and are dismantling the DCU, with plans to build towards Justice League.
- **Snyder era and its failures** [01:22] — Zack Snyder launched a cinematic universe with Man of Steel, but Batman v Superman drew cold feet, leading to a tonal pivot and eventual replacement by Geoff Johns and later Walter Hamada.
- **The Rock era and Black Adam** [03:02] — The Rock was given creative control for Black Adam, which didn't bomb but underperformed, leading to more instability in DC leadership.
- **Gunn's vision for DCU** [07:43] — Gunn's pitch was to focus on outcasts like Creature Commandos, and he wanted a creator-first approach, but also had a personal connection to the material.
- **Gunn's management issues** [08:37] — Gunn spread himself thin between studio head duties and writing/directing, leading to rumors of poor collaboration with other creatives and stalls in projects.
- **Performance of Gunn's projects** [10:35] — Superman made $600M (a modest hit), Lanterns was a hit with 19.3M viewers, but Peacemaker season 2 opening with a 'coke orgy' alienated families.
- **Replacement by Latcham** [13:14] — Sky Dance's new leadership replace Gunn with Jeremy Latcham, a former Marvel producer, aiming for a more family-friendly direction.
- **Possible futures for DCU** [14:50] — Options include keeping Gunn's plan, a full reboot, abandoning the shared universe, or even restoring the SnyderVerse.

## Transcript

another cinematic universe? Or does this change herald the beginning of a better change herald the beginning of a better DCU? And I got to wonder, are we about No, really. I think that might actually happen, and I'll explain why. Welcome
today I'm going to explain this entire controversy over the DCU, and together, let's decide if James Gun got or if the best days of the DCU are ahead. Now, we don't actually know what's going to happen yet. if Gun's entire DCU is
talk about how we got here. But there is reporting from the puck that the Ellison's and Sky Dance are now working to actively dismantle everything that other reporting that says that they're giving Latcham a new mandate to build
toward the Justice League as soon as possible. And guys, haven't we done this already? This is I mean, [laughter] we've been here before. This is exactly what Warner Brothers tried to do with Zack Snyder to try to get him to make
that ended up with a halfbaked Justice League. Now, not that everything Gun has all the problems later on and all the different options that they might choose. And this reporting might be way off base, but they're stopping yet
another cinematic universe just as it was really starting to get going. Wait, I was taking a nap. They killed another DC universe. Yeah, man. It gets confusing, but here's a very abbreviated timeline. Obviously, DC movies have been
Batman to carry the weight at the box office. But then after Marvel hit it big wanted to convert its new Superman film, Man of Steel, into the start of a cinematic universe. DC Comic Book and television writer Jeff Johns and Warner
as co-chairman of this endeavor. They oversaw this new franchise with Snider's vision and his style leading the creative. His next film, Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice, now had the onus of setting up a cinematic universe
all these characters on a laptop, Warner Brothers put on a big splashy show to kidding. They actually sent out a press release to shareholders detailing plans for a Ben Affleck directed Batman film. Zack Snyder led Justice League spin-off
Cyborg. But then the studio obviously got cold feet when Batman v Superman there was a tonal pivot with Aquaman and Shazam. And of course, we all know what had a personal tragedy and the studio used this as an excuse to let Jos Sweden
spew banter and CGI upper lips all over his work. John Berg and Jeff John underperformed. Then they were replaced by Walter Hermada. DC became so Zack Snder, giving him 80 million bucks to finish the Justice League, but just
for streaming. And behind the scenes, Warner Brothers was in turmoil. They Discovery did not yield the results they wanted. And in April 2022, David Zazlov was brought in to rehabilitate the studio. Now, actually, it's more
to flip the studio, to make it attractive to potential buyers, and then and the shareholders. Now, the most hilarious chapter of this story has to be when Warner Brothers, desperate for box office relevance, decided to give
creative control to The Rock. &gt;&gt; Because the hierarchy of power in [music] the DC universe is about to change. His film Black Adam set up a showdown between him and the Man of Steel. It was released on October 21st,
2022, 2 days after Hermada stepped down as president, reportedly because of how WB handled Batgirl. Black Adam didn't outright bomb, but it definitely Henry Caval announced to fans that he was back as the man of steel. Zazlov was
new leadership, their own Kevin Feige, to run DC films. Now, Feige was a seasoned producer who later became a fan figurehead. There was no one else like after Black Adam was released, James Gun and his producing partner Peter Saffron
took control for us. It was great news. We were so happy. And then things got weird. Now, one thing that I don't get a chance to talk about much on the channel It started with baseball when I was a kid. Then I got really into superhero
cards and movie spin-off cards and recently Pokémon cards. But the way I basketball, football, and Pokémon cards on Prize Pick. They're the sponsor of instantly in the app for cash or have them shipped straight to my front door.
Plus, Prize Picks packs give everyone the opportunity to pull high value cards worth millions of dollars in packs as low as one buck. Cards are priced at 100% fair market value based on recent sales data. Now, for our current prize
picks players, make sure you check your account for five bonus packs on them. It's another way to run your game when you rip packs on prize picks. Now, also type of pack between basketball, football, and Pokemon. Each type of pack
has a price point ranging from $1 to $2500. And each pack shows your percentage of pulling high value cards. Then you rip your pack to reveal what pool, you have a choice to sell it back instantly for real cash or ship it to
your home. Cash from your sale will immediately be added to your prize picks right now. I got a h 100 bucks in my account. So, I am going to do Pokemon Emerald. Minimum pool is $40. Maximum pool is $2,000 and the grail is 8
can't wait to see what it is. This is my favorite part. I get so excited about favorite part. I get so excited about the opening. Here we go. Rip to open.
which is valued at $155. I am going to sell this back right now. I'm not even going to debate on this. I'm gonna accept it. And live in front of you guys, I just made 55 bucks. It's that easy. Price pick packs are a great way
opening a new pack of cards. Next time, I'm going to pull for one of those grail cards. Now, new users can download the app today and use the code screen crush to get $25 instantly in packs after you rip your first $5 pack. That's code
screen crush to get $25 instantly in packs after you rip your first $5 pack. 18 years and older in eligible areas. Terms apply and collect responsibly. prize picks. Run your game. I just made 50 bucks. That's awesome. Now, back to
know James Gunn, the writer, director behind Guardians of the Galaxy and Marvel, director of great films like Slyther and Super, Suicide Squad. He's also a huge DC fan. And actually, when he made the Suicide Squad, he said that
continuation of the John Ostrander book from the8s. Now, that film was, I think, the best in the DC Extended Universe. It had a middling box office thanks to a same day release on HBO Go Max Go. But Warner Brothers liked it so much that
they gave him the keys to their entire kingdom. So Gun immediately went to work alienating fans by showing Henry Caval the door rather than continuing the DC extended universe or adding to the Batman franchise that Matt Reeves had
created. Gun wanted a clean slate. Somewhat somewhat clean slate. See, he worked on. They would remain canon, but this would be a mostly new universe with a different big three. And I was excited about this. I hated those Snyder movies.
In fact, remember this tweet showing the heroes in the Kingdom Come comic book around a table making plans. It just seemed like Gun got it. This would be a cinematic universe run by creators and run by the fans. In fact, in their
announcement video early the next year, he laid out their plans for a 10-year saga called Gods and Monsters. There would be new takes on marquee heroes Green Lantern, but also obscure characters like Creature Commandos,
Amanda Waller, Swamp Thing, The Authority, Booster Gold, and a Wonder Woman prequel series about the Amazon. And more importantly, Gun said that they were not going to force projects to stick to a specific timeline. They would
ready. It seemed like this was a direct response to the slap dash nature of the MCU, where movies increasingly have felt like that they're made on the fly. So, what actually happened and where we go from here. See, Gunn has always had a
outcasts of society. I mean, after all, Rocket Raccoon is what drew him toward making the Guardians movies. [music] So, he led off this cinematic universe with Outcast, Creature Commandos. But, it was
universe, a universe which I guess technically began with the Suicide Squad and it spin-off Peacemaker. But, see, Gun is a filmmaker who always wears his heart on his sleeve. To him, every project has to be personal. In fact,
Chris Smith was partially based on his late father. &gt;&gt; You're big and you're dumb and you're stupid, but when I'm around you, I know that's my dad. &gt;&gt; That is incredibly powerful to hear, and
it's rare in Hollywood to find a creative who is this personally attached to big IP like the DC franchise. So, Gun is an amazing writer, director, but he studio head. For instance, he made this weird choice from the start. In addition
studio, which is a full-time job where he's reading scripts and hiring people all these different projects and listening to pitches, in addition to all that, he was also writing and directing Superman, Creature Commandos, and
Peacemaker. By his own admission, this spread him thin like butter over too to get into rumors. These are things that I have heard that were reported, but I can't confirm. James Gun was rumored to not be the best at working
with other creatives. Most of his announced projects stalled because the I've heard rumors that Andy Machete didn't appreciate Gun publicly saying ready. Clayface was intended to be in the Reeves Batman universe before Gun
made it cannon to the DCU. I also wonder if the reason Matt Reeves Batman script on it. I don't know that for sure, but it definitely seems to fit a pattern. But I think the best example of Gun maybe not being the best collaborator is
post where he stepped down, he shouted project in the DCU except Supergirl. Now, this movie is based on one of the greatest DC comics of all time. It has a celebrated writer and director. It
should have been a slam dunk. And yet, it felt like a carbon copy of a James tone or style that Craig Gillespie has established in previous movies. It had crude humor and an overreiance on needle drops that are way totally different
from the Supergirl Woman of Tomorrow source material. So, I'm just going to lay down my opinion here. James Gun is a great writer director and really not great at running a studio, which is fine. These are two very different skill
sets. I think producers and executives have a job that on the surface seems nitty-gritty, managing creatives and their egos is very difficult. Like if universe, I would have played it safe and led off with films about Superman,
Batman, Wonder Woman, and all the other big names. But instead, Gun approaches everything on a personal level and he focused on the weirdos and the outcast. Even his Superman film honed in on why Superman is a weirdo and an outcast.
working from his heart. They're not great business decisions, but I love James Gunn. Well, let's look at the track record. Superman came out in an movies were starting to trend downward. It made $600 million at the box office,
which is a modest hit given its budget. It laid a good foundation for what was massive theatrical flop that did get strong viewership on streaming. Now, announced slate, but Mike Flanigan
and they went forward. It was lowbudget, but it wasn't like a huge hit. Lanterns actually was a huge hit with 19.3 million viewers per episode on HBO, but it also alienated some DC fans who criticized it as being a surf Dracula.
give them to us until the last episode. I mean, I loved lanterns, but that's just me. But I think the most telly thing about Gun's DCU and ultimately the reason that indicates why he's fired was Peacemaker season 2. I love Peacemaker
story. I love everything about it. But Gun did tout this as a direct follow-up to Superman, and the show leads off with a Coke orgy. Lanterns is also an R-rated
Singer's review for Supergirl, he pointed out that this is based on a that he would want to take his young daughter to see. See, Gun's own creative sensibilities made this a very, very difficult cinematic universe to market
because it alienated huge swaths of the population who normally migrate to superhero films, children. And I think that's the ultimate reason why Warner Brothers and Skyance want to change direction. So recently, Sky Dance bought
Warner Brothers for $111 billion. They way overpaid. But they were backed by the fortune of the Ellison family and Saudi investors. After months of legal cleaned house a few weeks ago. They fired Warner Brothers heads Mike Duca
saffron. And both sides said that they had productive meetings. Ellison even one month ago, the duo were placed on Studios. So that meant [music] that instead of reporting to new studio heads
Goldberg and Greenstein, Gun would report to Ellison, just like he used to report to David Zazlov. But then just a few days ago, Gun and Saffron announced doesn't take effect till December 1st, and Gun is still going to finish his
work on Man of Tomorrow and producing The Batman 2 and I think Creature Commando season 2, but they no longer have direct access to the Ellison's just middle management. And what's a little bit shady about this is that Sky Dance
immediately announced their replacement, Jeremy Latcham, which means that they months, probably secretly going through the interview process behind Gun's back. Now, Gun is a really gracious guy, and in his Instagram post, he gave the
relieved of the corporate aspects of his job. But now, what does this mean for this franchise? Where do we go after this? The new head of DC Studios is Kevin Feigi's former right-hand man, Jeremy Latcham. He produced several
Homecoming, and Guardians 1, where he worked alongside James Gunn. Latcham is also apparently more aligned with the politics of the Ellison family. He's said that he wanted to see more family-friendly superhero films.
that. &gt;&gt; So, basically, fewer coke orgies in the direction will Latcham take? Well, unlike Gun, he is not a writer or director. he can set the overall direction like say things like oh we
want a Justice League movie by 2031 and then hire people from there. Gun attempted a creator first approach where the studio took pitches from writers and directors. Marvel long developed a system where they had in-house scripts
already written and then directors like Gun or Taoiti could pick what they wanted to do. Now, the MCU later evolved into very fixed plans for films and TV and then they would find the directors to realize the vision of the studio
vision of the director. Gun and Saffron had a 10-year plan. They were setting up book Salvation, where villains were their own society. So, now what happens to those plans? So, as of now, of all
that James Gunn announced, four of those projects are cancelled and three are stuck in production limbo and likely can means that Latcham has a lot of options the options. Number one, Jeremy Latcham keeps the plan that Gun and Saffron
established. Man of Tomorrow is still happening. Gun also announced that he for After Man of Tomorrow. And there are rumors that Wonder Woman's already been cast and they were about to announce the casting of Batman. So, this tells me
the Justice League film with the big seven rounding out the cast. Now, maybe James Gun accelerated that casting because he knew his contract was up and he wanted to show results to the Ellison
plan. So, Latcham could just pick up definitely think that Latcham will cut James Gun's pet projects about the Outcast like Creature Commando and Swamp Think. I think Latchin will prioritize
with the Matt Reeves Batman universe since part two is going to end up taking six years to make. Now, if this happens and they want to keep James Gun around, leadership after being his own boss for a few years. Or maybe he'll want to see
this thing through and he'll relish in the role of just being a creator and not personally would like to see Gun become like the Russo brothers of the DCU, entrusted with the creative on the main projects while other directors and
writers get to build out the universe on the edges. So that's option one where we ship in a slightly different direction. Option number two, it might be the most likely one. Clean slate. Everyone is gone. New cinematic universe incoming.
Let me ask you guys, does anybody really want to see that happen? I feel like the DC EU is basically rebooted with a style change once and then again with the Flash movie and then done away with when James Gun came on. It's a lot for fans
after James Gunn took over, he criticized the previous creatives by anything and no one was minding the mint. And this made all those remaining DC movies DOA. Aquaman 2, Shazam 2, Flash, Blue Beetle, all flops because
fans knew they didn't matter anymore. This would be the fate of Man of going to reboot again. So, if they are going to announce that, I expect it to happen in August. Option number three, no more cinematic universe. Marvel
they proved why it doesn't work. The multitude of Marvel projects that have much for the surface dwellers to keep up with, and interest in superhero movies faded. That's one of the reasons Superman underperformed. So, what if DC
says, "Look, let's just make movies that are hits that people want to watch." That actually falls in line with David Ellison's kind of films. He likes these big ass blockbusters where blows up and then the poor people make him rich.
That would also be a far cry from the soulful personal work that James Gunn is would be an afterthought. Like even reportedly cancelling the series because
quote, "It didn't capture the zeitgeist. It gave us our biggest views on a million viewers an episode, but whatever. Zeitgeist my ass. you didn't like the show. Option number four, and this I don't think is totally out of
hand. They restore the Snyiderverse. So, hear me out. I think that Snyider's and the Ellison's. There's also still legions of fans who are pissed that Snyder didn't get to finish his Justice League story. And there were even wild
rumors that the Ellison Saudi investors wanted to see this Snyder restore. their new universe by releasing a Justice League movie. The Snyder cut can actually be released in theaters. Henry Caval also told Variety, "Never say
Superman." Ben Affleck was pretty checked out of the role, but maybe he would also return to be Batman in order to redeem Snider's vision. Even Galadotak got screwed over by the change as Patty Jenkins plan for Wonder Woman 3
I don't know about you guys, but I'm really tired of all the back and forth pick a direction and go with it. I do think that James Gun got in over his head and he tried to force his creative outlook on other creators. And at the
end of the day, these projects cost a lot of money, and it was his job to make money for the studio. Brave the Bold should have been the highest priority to could have had focus on the smaller, weirder heroes to build off of from
is this a good thing? You got to let me know in the comments. But I do think running the show is not the right role for him. And as much as I love all the superhero stuff he's made, I also would like to see James Gun go make some weird
again. I'm going to make some weird superhero cinema, though. For instance, I don't think we'll ever get offbeat Commandos while the Ellison are running the show. Look, the gunfiring is a
decision that I understand. Looking at the figures in black and white, it's hard to argue this is a pure financial decision, but still, this sucks. Ultimately, I think this shows us how when it comes to big IP, none of us ever
characters. The end of the day, they are just figures in a balance sheet. They are products that corporations sell to us. But for a few brief years, Gun something more. They could be something personal. They are myths that can be
resonate on a deeper level and speak to the very core of what drives the human heart. That is the ultimate potential of taking DC's characters and putting them on screen. They speak to something universal and pure about the human race.
Jensen Ackles plays Batman. &gt;&gt; I'm Batman. Let us know what you think the comments or on our free to join Discord server. And if it's your first bell for alerts for Screen Crush. I'm Ryan.
Ryan. [music]
