---
title: 'The Secret Cheesesteak Only Philly Locals Actually Order'
source: 'https://youtube.com/watch?v=FeB2YaswT8w'
video_id: 'FeB2YaswT8w'
date: 2026-07-29
duration_sec: 502
---

# The Secret Cheesesteak Only Philly Locals Actually Order

> Source: [The Secret Cheesesteak Only Philly Locals Actually Order](https://youtube.com/watch?v=FeB2YaswT8w)

## Summary

In this video, the host reveals a hidden gem known to Philly locals: the chicken cheesesteak. He elevates the classic by using confit chicken thighs, buffalo sauce, and a custom blue cheese dressing, offering a major upgrade in texture and flavor.

### Key Points

- **The Hidden Chicken Cheesesteak** [00:02] — Locals keep chicken cheesesteak a secret; discovered from the RU Garbage Podcast. The host aims to upgrade it.
- **Confit Chicken Upgrade** [00:42] — Uses confit chicken thighs instead of dry breast. Seasoned with salt, cooked in olive oil with garlic at 225°F until fork tender (185-190°F).
- **Chicken Preparation Next Day** [02:03] — Firmed-up chicken from fridge allows clean dicing without shredding. Dice into small cubes for better texture.
- **Cheese Selection** [02:57] — Uses American and Cooper Sharp American cheese for color and flavor.
- **Sponsor: Good Chop** [03:11] — Promotes Good Chop for high-quality meats and seafood delivered frozen. Discount code: 50NACS for $50 off plus free shipping.
- **Buffalo Sauce and Blue Cheese Dressing** [04:48] — Uses leftover buffalo sauce. Blue cheese dressing made with mayo, sour cream, Worcestershire, vinegar, onion powder, garlic powder, Dijon, pepper, blue cheese, blended smooth.
- **Umami Seasoning** [05:35] — Mix salt, garlic powder, and MSG in pinch proportions to enhance flavor.
- **Assembling the Sandwich** [06:11] — Sear diced chicken in confit oil with umami seasoning, add buffalo sauce, then cover with cheese and chop to melt. Fill bread with more sauce and blue cheese.
- **Final Taste Test** [07:31] — Texture is perfect; recommends trying even if you prefer classic beef cheesesteak.

### Conclusion

The confit buffalo chicken cheesesteak offers a juicy, flavorful alternative to the classic, with techniques that elevate a simple sandwich into a gourmet experience.

## Transcript

think the cheesesteak conversation begins and ends with beef. But there's a shadow version of this sandwich, a hidden gem that locals keep to themselves. And I only discovered it from my favorite Philly degenerate over
at the RU Garbage Podcast. And that sandwich is the chicken cheesesteak. >> Chicken cheesesteak with mayo? >> Yeah, but yeah, chicken chicken >> To the rest of us, it doesn't exist. But today we become locals and we're taking
this hidden little delicacy and making major technical upgrades. We're moving past that dry chicken onto something better. This is the confit buffalo chicken cheesesteak. Now usually this is made with like a sliced or diced chicken
breast. But again, I'm an outsider, so I'm starting from first principles here. And I want a juicy chicken with good texture without any worry of overcooking improvement, we're upgrading the chicken. And this is some confit chicken
thighs that I cooked last night. It's literally the easiest thing you could ever do. And it's kind of important that you do this in advance, which I will explain later. So you want to take your thighs and season them with salt and
allow that chicken time in the fridge to dry out and absorb that salt and allow it to penetrate the chicken all the way through. Overnight is best, but at least for a few hours. Then we're just going to take them and place them into a pot
and submerge them with olive oil. I'm just going to add a few garlic cloves. I'm going to then bring it up to a very gentle simmer. You just want to see an occasional bubble breaching the surface. Too hot and you're just frying the
you're at the right temp, put a lid on and place it in a 225° oven and allow that chicken to cook until it's fork tender and almost ready to fall apart, but still holding together. I pull it around 185 to 190,
which yields the right tenderness and the right amount of texture. You really shouldn't feel much resistance when you poke it with a thermometer. Then allow to cool down a bit, remove it from the oil. Once it's fully cool, we can wrap
it up, place it in the fridge, and it's ready to be manipulated the next day. And this is what the chicken looks like the next day. That collagen and all that fat has firmed up. Now, if hot, would shred, but now that it's firm, we can
get really clean dices to maintain texture and juiciness and tenderness. So, we want to prep the chicken first. I'm just going to cut strips and then cut them into a dice. If you want to make it a finer dice,
got a nice smaller dice. You can really control the texture this way. You can feel they're soft and moist, so I don't have to worry about overcooking them. were hot, it would just sort of turn into shards rather than cubes. About
sandwich, in my opinion. Now, to cook it, we still have that reserve oil we little bit of that. All the chicken juice kind of fell to the bottom, so I can just pull that oil. For the cheese, I'm going with American and then some
Cooper Sharp American. More so cuz the color of the American is a little bit flavor of Cooper, though, can't be beat. Now, any single recipe like this one relies on your ability to source high-quality meats and proteins. Some
high-quality meats, while others, unfortunately, do not. But now you can get high-quality American-sourced meats and seafoods delivered straight to your front door, thanks to our sponsor today, Good Chop. Now, most grocery stores have
a limited selection of meats and seafoods with quality that can be hit or miss. Good Chop removes the guesswork by delivering vacuum-sealed cuts frozen at peak freshness, so your freezer stays stocked and you can cook when you want.
They allow you to customize your box from over 100 menu items, including USDA Choice and Prime steaks, 100% grass-fed beef, wild-caught seafood, organic chicken, and responsibly raised pork, and more. Sourced exclusively from
American farms and fisheries, supporting local family farms and independent ranchers in the US. Personally, I love a pork tenderloin, highly underrated and affordable cut that I like to keep on hand. And I got lots of chicken thighs,
and my favorite kind of salmon is sockeye salmon. Pop these in the freezer and I have them whenever I need. And the best part, since Good Chop feels so confident in the quality of the meats and seafoods that they source, they're
willing to back it up with a 100% money guarantee. That means you either love Good Chop or your money back. That's a policy I can stand behind. So, go to goodchop.com/youtube and use the code 50NACS
or click the link in the description to get $50 off plus free shipping on your first order. That's goodchop.com/youtube code 50NACS to get $50 off plus free shipping on your first order. Now, back to the recipe. Still got some buffalo
sauce left over from our wing episode, which if you have not seen, you should blue cheese dressing, which is going in the sandwich. In a bowl, about a half cup of mayo, and then a half cup of sour cream, or equal parts. For the liquids,
about a cap of Worcestershire sauce, about a cap of white vinegar, maybe two caps. Teaspoon of onion powder, teaspoon of garlic powder, a tablespoon of Dijon cracked black pepper, and then in with some of the blue cheese. I don't like
for this application, I kind of want it pipeable and smooth, so I'm going to throw it in a blender and puree it till it's nice and smooth.
going to cook with the buffalo. Now, we're just going to make sort of like an umami seasoning to go with it. So, in a bowl, I'm just going to do about a pinch about half the amount of salt. We're going to add about a teaspoon of garlic
powder, and then we're going to add about an equal amount of MSG. That's basically a seasoning you could use on anything. So round and amazing with that MSG. Gives certain things that salt doesn't give. Now, the new trend with
Amoroso roll, but it's becoming increasingly popular to serve it on a seeded roll, which in the northeast are plentiful. So, I've got like two types of this one more, so I'm going to go with this.
I'm going to cut the butt off and cut it open. Nice and soft and pliable and I and warm. You could sear it on the griddle, but I'm going to keep it like that. Once your pan or griddle is nice and hot around 375°
take a bit of that confit oil and coat the pan with it. Then, go ahead and add your chicken and season it with that umami seasoning and begin tossing and searing the chicken for a few minutes just to warm it up. Now, it's already
cooked, so all we're looking to do here is basically heat up the chicken and combine it with everything to form a homogeneous mass. Once that chicken is warmed up, hit it with some of that buffalo sauce, get it tossed up and
cooking in that sauce almost glazing the pieces of chicken. Then, we can go ahead and start to add in the cheese. And I like to just totally cover that chicken with the slices of cheese and then start chopping
it up and folding it to help melt that cheese and to almost glue everything together. Once all that cheese is melted, we can take out bread, hit the inside with some buffalo sauce and some blue cheese, and then we can start to
scoop our chicken in and fill up the bread. little bit more blue cheese and a little bit more buffalo sauce, and there you have the buffalo chicken cheesesteak. Something I am certainly going to try
again next time I'm in Philly. You got to taste the texture of the when it's overcooked or the wrong texture, and this is just right. You cheesesteak next to each other, I'll always go with the cheesesteak. But does
that mean having a chicken cheesesteak in your arsenal is not valuable? Not saying that either. This is a very amazing recipe. It's a very good switch try it. Recipe's going to be down in the description, along with a link to my
Patreon where all of my episodes are early and ad-free, as well as we run our cooking school over there. Two lessons a month, live stream, homework, I kick have today. I'll see you next time. Until then, take care of yourself and go
feed yourself. >> Brown money, brown money, yellow.