[00:03] these Tik Tok live auctions. >> These natural diamonds that were hyped up during the live. Look like tiny gray specks of dirt. hadn't been filled out correctly and they suspect that it's a counterfeit [00:17] >> This is what I was supposed to be getting a Nintendo Switch. >> If you get sent something else, guess what? Tik Tok shop will not help you. [00:31] about Tik Tok live auctions. You've probably scrolled past one. A host, a countdown, and a diamond bracelet or a designer bag going for a fraction of the price. People are bidding thousands of dollars on these. And now they're [00:46] posting what actually showed up. Fake perfume, broken bracelets, a watch seized at customs. Meanwhile, the biggest live auction app, WhatNot, just got valued at over $20 billion. So, are [01:00] these auctions a real deal or are people getting played? Let's find out. >> I got conned during a Tik Tok live diamond auction and now I have to call the company out because they won't let me get a refund. I bought three diamond [01:13] tennis bracelets, two natural and one lab from Silver Aura New York. The natural bracelets were overly hyped during the live because they were mainly natural diamonds came onto the scene, they were hyping them up saying, "Oh, [01:29] natural blah blah blah blah." Because obviously natural is better than lab. Guys, I'm running this beautiful 7 in natural diamonds. [01:41] for the jewelry that I buy. >> 9 to5 solid sterling silver. This is all natural diamonds, guys. Go. [music] >> Y'all got to forgive me. Y'all know how Edward's economics works. Some of y'all think that I spend all day on TikTok. [01:56] compile the content. I give my commentary. Okay. I was not aware that we have reached such peak levels of consumerism that we will sit and just [02:08] watch people show us stuff so that we can impulsively buy it on the spot with a swipe. Now, I know I'm a young buck, right? But I used to watch Shark Tank. I know about all about Lori. I know all about QVC. I used to stay up sometimes [02:21] too late, wake up, the TV's still on. I'm looking at these infomercials. I get it. People have been doing it. But why? Why do we just watch people try and sell commercial. We just watch long enough for our dopamine to spike so that we can [02:35] finally just make that impulsive purchase and then we just get satiated. We're satisfied because we spent money. [laughter] This is crazy. I can't believe I'm watching this. >> Natural diamonds. you're getting a free [02:47] tennis bracelet bas basically. >> So they tricked me. They got me. They made me think that I was getting the steal of the century by getting natural bracelets arrived, I realized that not [03:00] only all of the clasps were completely defective and either broken and sealed shut and unable to open or completely open and unable to seal shut because of bent things and this little push down thing not working. But the diamonds, [03:15] these natural diamonds that were hyped up during the live, look like tiny gray specks of dirt. Here's a photo of a close-up. You can't really see it on the video, which is exactly why I was convinced to buy it because they have [03:29] that beautiful light going and they're going like this. They don't show it being class because they're all broken. And so I thought, "Oh, wow. A beautiful bracelet." But no, when you look up close again, here's another photo. [03:43] >> After hearing all this, what did y'all expect? [laughter] I'm not trying to make light of it. Hopefully, she got her money back. But the person is on Tik Tok money back. But the person is on Tik Tok live showing jewelry. That's not real. I [03:55] don't care about that stuff, a lot of people do care about it. I don't care [laughter] What were y'all expecting? Be be honest. What were y'all expecting? Be be honest. These are all tiny gray specks of dirt. [04:09] And when I reached out to complain and ask for a refund, these people had the audacity to say that maybe I should have looked into lab because natural diamonds are going to always have a variety. I'm sorry. What? no jeweler in their right [04:23] mind would ever with good conscience sell pieces that are this messed up and then claim that they're actually better because they're natural only to lo and because they're natural only to lo and behold be pieces of crap. So, I hate [04:37] like I have no choice. And I want to warn people of the severe injustice going on because they are selling these bracelets every single day and they all look the same and all of the clasp are broken. I have three completely [04:54] broken. I have three completely defective and ugly bracelets and they won't give me my money back. So, shame on you, Silver Ara New York. Let me get my money back. Do the right thing because this is actually ridiculous. [05:07] >> So, they're scamming people and it seems like that's the case because it's not just effective. It's three. All three of them are messed up. But I appreciate people increasing the consumer awareness. So, if there are companies [05:21] Call them out by name. But I hope that she got her money back. And I know some much did this stuff cost? How much does the stuff on Tik Tok live cost?" That's and looked it up. Says that most Tik Tok live diamond auctions sell for $100 to [05:38] live diamond auctions sell for $100 to $500 with bids opening as low as $1. And that's according to Rolling Stone. But according to Caleb, he's asking, "Why are people buying these things off Tik Tok lives?" So, [laughter] pass the vibe [05:51] but let's not live in the past. Maybe this is where things are going, you know? Maybe this is a sign like so many things are probably going to be bought trying to sell y'all stuff, you know? [laughter] [06:06] [laughter] Then we have KWJ that says, "Why would a natural diamond tennis bracelet be set in sterling silver? Red flag." And then we have Teresa Plantern that says they showed a completely different bracelet. [06:20] By the way, which that's a scam. You're showing one thing and then you're giving people the Come on, man. I spent $6,000 of my own money on Chinese live auctions and I purchased three luxury watches and partially got scammed. So, I'm going to [06:35] today, and I'm going to tell you about my experience with the other ones so you the three watches was a tutor Black Day 58 that I bought for $2,300 from them down below. My experience with them [06:50] see this video and change the way they do business. So, basically, this is what happened. 2 weeks ago, I bought this watch. I won it in an auction, [music] it was going to dispatch with the original box. And then later on, the [07:02] come with the box. In any case, [music] I don't know if they sent the box or not because I never got the watch. So, the watch arrived in the United States in my local facility a little over a week ago. And then immediately, I got a call from [07:15] seized by customs because the paperwork hadn't been filled out correctly and >> Wow. >> So, I reached out to Tik Tok shop and working on getting me a refund and if they don't, then I'm going to go through [07:28] MX. So, in any case, I'm going to get my money back, but this just left a would never ever buy a watch from them again. I waited two weeks. Um, pretty much wasted hours talking to FedEx and I'll never get this watch. So, [07:42] watch, especially one that's been used, there's so many watch dealers out there. There's so many ways to verify. He did everything right as far as how he contact with the right people who can help him get his money back. But, it's [07:56] risk it. I just don't trust Tik Tok. "Probably easier to just buy a watch from a jeweler." That's what I'm saying. Andre, this person says, "Your first topic is literally on FedEx and customs, [08:09] not them. Laugh out loud." Catalina Ray says, "Bought one and is in need of servicing cuz it was opened and they won't refund me my money." So, this is happening to a lot of people. >> Go, [08:26] you next. I waited cuz I wanted him to see. Okay, guys. I'm pissed. see. Okay, guys. I'm pissed. We need to talk about the invasion of fakes because I am tired of getting scammed [08:41] and I'm tired of watching people get scammed. So, let's talk about it. >> But has she ever not got scammed buying from Tik Tok shop, you know? And how are they even allowing this? Is there nobody monitoring? I recently um won these at [08:57] auction and I'm going to put the name of the seller up here. These and this one. The first one I opened was this one. And I know this is an expensive cologne and I was immediately suspicious [09:12] because do you guys see the glue right there? The quality of the box is totally cheap. This is so light. Here's [09:29] juice. This hardly holds. So, I requested a refund on all four. They denied and then I filed an appeal. [09:41] And I just so happened to catch them doing a live and this is what I recorded. Oh, >> see >> guys. I'll run a malikica for you next. >> I waited cuz I wanted him to see. [09:57] >> Fake. >> Now watch how he blocked me. >> and blocked. As you see, they blocked me. And I also [10:09] submitted that as evidence. And the moment I did, my um refunds started to get approved. >> Y'all, they scammed me. This is what I was supposed to be getting. A Nintendo Switch. [10:25] getting. A Nintendo Switch. >> A Nintendo Switch for $65. Is this the first gen? Is it Gen 2? Like, guys, >> that's exactly what they told me I was getting. They were like, I'm Hold on. [10:39] $65. AND JUST LIKE THAT, EVERYONE, DID I OR DID I NOT TELL Y'ALL IT WAS COMING UP? DID I OR DID I NOT TELL YOU? >> Mind you, she said my name wrong. But regardless, it's Arie. Anyway, I got [10:53] scammed, >> but I never played them games. I was not back cuz I saw it wasn't shipping at all. Like, it was saying it wasn't shipping. So, I'm like, "Oh, yeah. They playing with me. Refund." I got my [11:05] refund back. refund issued. I never played. refund issued. I never played. But then I checked my uh my mailbox and something had came in. Hold on. And it was really small. So I'm like, what is [11:19] this? Then I read it said Tik Tok shop. So I'm like, wait, I know this not. So regardless, they scam me cuz look at So regardless, they scam me cuz look at this. This is what they sent. [11:40] Girl, what is this? >> They sent her the Soulja Boy Game Boy. Oh my goodness. They're shameless. The fact they even took the time out to send fact they even took the time out to send anything. Homeg girl recorded the live. [11:53] She recorded you saying that she won the Switch and then you sent her the Teimu Game Boy. I mean, you could have at least sent a Nintendo DS, you know, Game Boy, Game Boy Color, something retro. You gonna send her? Come on, man. [12:07] Let's see these comments. Cookie Mama says, "Anybody talking loud and screaming? I don't trust them." And that's a good little rule to live by. Lighty says, "How do y'all fall for these? Selling an item that sells for [12:21] these? Selling an item that sells for $30 plus dollar for more than half off. Be for real." Kebison says, "I was watching a perfume one and they kept resetting the countd down until the price was over $60." [laughter] [12:35] So, they will legitimately sell something, but they going to make sure people, they think of everything. You could never put anything past somebody who's willing to steal or scam you out of your money. So, let's be fair first. [12:49] Auctions aren't new and they aren't a scam by themselves. Small sellers reach buyers without a store. You can watch the item handled live and plenty of orders show up exactly as described. And as you saw, some of these buyers did get [13:03] their money back. But look at how these are built on whatnot. An auction can last 3 seconds to a minute. And when you win, there's no confirmation screen. One gambling researcher at East Carolina University said, "The less time you have [13:19] to think, the bigger the dopamine rush." That's not an accident. That's the product. Proverbs says that haste leads to poverty and that timer is built to rush you. And the product is big. What not raised $545 million in August at a [13:35] $20 billion valuation and it did $8 billion in live sales last year. The platform takes a cut of every sale. So the faster you swipe, the more it makes. Then there are the random sets. You pay for a shot at the iPhone on screen and [13:50] you get whatever comes out of the pool. Tik Tok only pulled iPhones, iPads, TVs, and diamonds out of those sets the day after a reporter asked about them. A law lecturer at Berkeley put it simply, "If there's a wager, chance, and a prize, it [14:05] doesn't matter how you dress it up. It's gambling. More than 30 whatnot customers are in arbitration making that exact argument about card breaks. There's been rejects it." And on November 6th, Tik Tok told US sellers again, no [14:21] lotteryies, no raffles, and no paying for a chance to win. So, if you're going to shop these, set a spending limit before you open the app, not after. Never pay for a random draw. Be sure to screen record the live because that's [14:35] what got one of these buyers her refund. And pay with a credit card so that you you. Have you ever bought something from a live auction? Go ahead and let me know in the comment section below. I know these are getting way more popular. [14:48] it's the next big thing. It's already big in China. Do y'all think it's coming here? Let me know your thoughts. >> I've spent an insane amount of money on >> I've spent an insane amount of money on these Tik Tok live auctions. No, really. [15:01] It's like gotten to the point where I'm afraid to go on my phone. I have so many packages on the way and I have no idea what's in them. I mean, like no clue what's in them. I mean, like no clue whatsoever. So, [15:15] family know that they're not getting a gift receipt this Christmas because everything I bought was from Tik Tok Live. I I have a really bad problem and I [15:29] >> and it's unfortunate because I kind of look at it like an addiction. Like I it. I think that they have shopping addictions. I think that they are in some cases gullible. But I think that the impulse is just too strong for them [15:42] to resist. They can't resist. And this is a perfect business for people who want to be scamming because they have the people, the shopping fiends just lined up ready to just swipe, swipe, swipe and just get junk. It's crazy. [15:54] >> No, I do. I'm not in denial. I just I don't know how to stop. I tried to stop. Okay. If anybody has been going through the same thing and has any advice for the same thing and has any advice for me, please, I need help. I don't have [16:09] the funds to keep up this lifestyle that I've created for myself. >> I have advice. I think she'll take it. Delete the app. Delete it. Hey, I'm here all day. Okay. [laughter] Invoice. Send it to you. You could swipe [16:22] money. I'll take it. Just delete the app. That simple. But it's not that simple. People get a lot of pleasure from doing these things. Got to delete the app. It says that half of Tik Tok users spent at least $100 [16:38] on influencer-driven impulse buys last year. A quarter of those people regret their decisions. And that was done by an Adobe survey. But these comments are pretty funny. Sarah Sora says, "We need to start a support group because I also [16:52] need help." [laughter] Angela says, "I got scammed by one of them. Maybe I'm missing out on something." But hey, you can't miss nothing you never tried, as my mom would say. Stop going on these weird auctions asking these people if [17:04] weird auctions asking these people if the pro products are real, authentic. What is a scammer supposed to say? Yes, I'm a scammer. Yes, these are fake products. Hey, by my They're not going to tell you. They tell you the products [17:16] are fake. Stop asking them if the if the website if if [laughter] if if they're too clo and dagger to even show their faces like this with these nameless faces in these nameless bottles. Why would you [17:30] >> I think that it's important to get them to admit that what they're selling is real so that when it arrives fake, you can at least file a dispute, get your money back. Because if they try to pull [17:42] the whole bait and switch, make something look like a dupe, but it's actually got like a different brand name and they never claim that it was real, be able to get away with it. >> Purchase from them. It looks It Does it [17:56] look like a scam? I know you see it. I know you see, but I see. But I'm trying to slap y'all away cuz some of y'all keep doing it. And I I want to I want to I want to I want to save you. [18:09] get your money back. >> The reason I haven't really posted on Tik Tok since February is honestly a little embarrassing. I accidentally got sucked into Tik Tok shop auctions, specifically luxury handbag auctions. [18:23] In December, my husband and I went on this trip to Las Vegas. It was the first real trip we've been on in like 5 years since we've been building our own business. All of our time, energy, [18:36] money. years. I wasn't buying pretty much anything, let alone luxury items. And I was carrying around this vintage Coach purse that I found at a thrift about handbags at all. Then we took this Vegas trip and I saw this Louis Vuitton [18:49] bag that I absolutely loved, but I couldn't justify spending thousands of dollars on it. So, I came home and Tik Tok did what Tik Tok does and it found my weakness. First, I discovered pre-loved luxury handbags, which I had [19:03] never thought about before. Then I discovered Tik Tok luxury auctions. I wish I was joking, but one minute I was just looking for deals at Aldi and strangers bid on Louis Vuitton bags like it's the Super Bowl. And at first it [19:16] felt harmless. I found some good deals. I won a couple auctions and I learned a lot. I felt like I discovered this little secret club on TikTok that then one auction turned into another and another and before I knew it, I was [19:30] spending way more time or money than I had planned to. Spent the last few months watching, bidding, winning, losing, coming completely engulfed and fascinated by the world of pre-love luxury handbags and luxury handbags in [19:42] general. And honestly, I've got some stories. the good, the bad, the ugly, purchases I love, purchases I regret, deals that were definitely deals, and back and I want to talk about all of it. I want to talk about how these auctions [19:56] worked, what I've learned, what I've bought, what I would not buy again, whether buying luxury this way is smart or if it's just Now that I've calmed down, let me go ahead and explain how Tik Tok auctions have quickly become a [20:09] scammer's paradise. If you get sent an item that was not the item in the video says on the invoice, if you get sent something else, guess what? Tik Tok shop will not help you. If you with evidence, guess what? Tik Tok shop will not help [20:24] you. If you have very clear it says that you got this specific item and you get you got this specific item and you get sent something different, you're bad. Tik Tok shop will not help you. So what's the point of even [20:37] shopping on there if they don't protect the customers? You know, these marketplaces don't exist unless there are some type of consumer protections. If you don't facilitate an environment that is conducive for commerce, then [20:50] people will not participate in that at all. There will be no transactions. There's no safety. So on Tik Tok, they're letting scammers run rampant supporting the people who get scammed on their platform. Am I getting that right? [21:05] >> Someone can go on a Tik Tok auction and sell you anything in the world and you can get nothing at all and Tik Tok shop will not help you. Tik Tok customer service is full of bots, nobody that you can actually talk to. And then when it [21:18] actual person has to address the return request that the seller denied, that person in customer service is just going to say, "Oh, I'm resubmitting your your uh I'm changing your dispute and [21:30] resubmitting the return request back to the seller because oh, you selected the wrong category." And Tik Tok Shop will not help you. If you are a fan of just completely throwing away your money, shop Tik Tok auctions. If not, go [21:44] somewhere like Poshmark or somewhere that has customer service and it isn't just bots. Because here's the thing, even though those auctions are also binding, if you it's still backed, if you get something and it is not matching [21:58] there's a hole or a stain or it's damaged in some type of way, guess what? You'll get your money back. >> They got to have some type of assurance policy, some type of insurance. Like, I don't know. This is crazy. I've never [22:11] been more happy to be a minimalist, you know, to just not want [laughter] [gasps] man consuming will get you cooked. Here is my hot take. Tik Tok is ruining your budget. Let me just say these [22:27] influencers, people who just literally just Tik Tok shop all of these videos, they are ruining finances for people. It is just become so easy to just spend spend spend spend spend spend spend. People spend so much and so easy and it [22:41] is become so toxic and this influencer culture of, "Oh my god, look at this new ever. You need it." And then it's like, "Oh my god, I do need that. That is the You don't need it. You already have 10 other sprays. Why do you need this [22:55] spray? And it's always like, "You have to get this. You need this. You need this new MacBook Pro." No, you don't. You already have one and it's perfectly fine. And it is just I am so tired of it. I'm so tired of that. You need this. [23:10] without this. My life is fine without it. I don't I don't need you influencing overconumption is getting so freaking crazy. It has gotten so freaking crazy. [23:23] all this crap. You don't need it. You literally don't need it. And I'm tired TikTok. Get this. Get this. No. Your budget says no. So don't get it. So, as you can see, the scam isn't always a fake item. Sometimes it's the [23:39] format. A timer that doesn't give you time to think, a random draw dressed up like a sale, and a refund that only works if you fight for it. Some buyers come out fine. A lot of them pay triple for a $10 bottle of perfume. The [23:52] platforms [music] are finally tightening the rules, but until they do, the safest bid is the one you decided on before the countdown started. guys haven't already, go ahead and subscribe at edwards economics.com because that's where I get [24:04] biblical perspective that I don't always get the chance to get into here. Be sure to like this video [music] and then share it with that one friend who always has a package from Tik Tok live sitting on their porch. Before you go, I have [24:17] one last question. What's the most you've ever spent on something because there was a timer that was about to run out? Don't be shy. Let us know in the you guys for watching today's video. Well, I pray that the Lord blesses you, [24:29] face towards you, that he turns his countenance towards you, gives you countenance towards you, gives you favor, and he gives you peace.