---
title: 'I’m Sorry But Small Nuclear Reactors Are Basically Over'
source: 'https://youtube.com/watch?v=PF7wSiG9w8c'
video_id: 'PF7wSiG9w8c'
date: 2026-11-11
duration_sec: 349
channel: 'Sabine Hossenfelder'
---

# I’m Sorry But Small Nuclear Reactors Are Basically Over

> Source: [I’m Sorry But Small Nuclear Reactors Are Basically Over](https://youtube.com/watch?v=PF7wSiG9w8c)

## Summary

The video argues that small modular reactors (SMRs) are not the cost-effective solution they are touted to be, despite heavy government subsidies and enthusiasm. The creator points to bankruptcies, a critical cost analysis, and fundamental scaling disadvantages to conclude that SMRs are essentially over, with the 'golden era' being largely taxpayer-funded.

### Key Points

- **Initial optimism turns to skepticism** [00:00] — The creator initially believed SMRs would fix problems but now sees them as creating more problems than they solve, calling them 'basically dead'.
- **Nuclear power's appeal and SMR promise** [01:26] — Nuclear fission is carbon-free and ideal for baseload, but plants are expensive and slow to build. SMRs were supposed to solve this via factory mass-production and transport.
- **Government enthusiasm and subsidies** [02:08] — Trump celebrated 3 SMRs reaching criticality, the US invested $1B in X-energy, the UK pledged £2.6B, Russia is building more, and the EU announced a strategy. This is heavily subsidized.
- **Startup failures signal trouble** [03:17] — French Naarea, US Ultra Safe Nuclear, and UK Moltex Energy have filed for bankruptcy or are insolvent; NuScale dropped its original plan.
- **Cost analysis shows SMRs are not competitive** [04:00] — A Nature Communications paper found SMRs 'are not competitive in current U.S. electricity markets' and 'dedicated power production is uneconomic,' even with cost declines.
- **Scaling disadvantages** [04:42] — Smaller reactors require relatively more shielding, and stacking them duplicates efforts. Cost advantages come from larger scale, not smaller. Regulations also remain a hurdle.
- **Recommendation and hybrid future** [05:13] — The creator suggests focusing on large plants first, then making smaller ones economical. A hybrid approach with factory-produced parts but not full reactors may emerge.

### Conclusion

The 'golden era' of nuclear power may be arriving, but much of the investment is taxpayer-funded and SMRs have not proven their core economic advantage. The future likely lies in large plants or hybrid designs, not the small modular reactors currently being pushed.

## Transcript

When I first heard of small nuclear reactors, I&nbsp; thought they're really going to fix a problem.&nbsp;&nbsp; But in the past years, it's become increasingly&nbsp; clear that they're creating more problems&nbsp;&nbsp;
than they solve. At this point, small&nbsp; modular reactors are basically dead.&nbsp;&nbsp; It's just that investors haven't yet all noticed. I have a secret and the time has come to tell you&nbsp; about it. I'm a regular reader of IEEE Spectrum&nbsp;&nbsp;
magazine and I'm happy to say they've been&nbsp; sponsoring this video. IEEE is the Institute&nbsp;&nbsp; of Electrical and Electronics Engineers,&nbsp; and Spectrum is their flagship magazine.&nbsp;&nbsp; It's not your average popular science magazine.&nbsp; This is really in-depth coverage by experts and&nbsp;&nbsp;
it's a must-read if you want to stay up to date&nbsp; on robotics, electric vehicles, AI or microchips&nbsp;&nbsp; just to name a few examples. And you know what?&nbsp; If you look at what other YouTubers make videos&nbsp;&nbsp;
about, I'm pretty sure that a lot of them are&nbsp; reading the same magazine. As you can see,&nbsp;&nbsp; I prefer reading them in print. I just&nbsp; feel like I can think better that way.&nbsp;&nbsp; I'm not so secretly convinced that engineers&nbsp; are really running the world. And if you want to&nbsp;&nbsp;
know what the future will bring, then you should&nbsp; definitely get a subscription to it e Spectrum.&nbsp;&nbsp; All you need to do is use my link in the&nbsp; description. And now back to the science news.
Nuclear fission power doesn’t create&nbsp; carbon dioxide. This makes it the&nbsp;&nbsp; best currently available technology to&nbsp; replace the baseload in electric grids.&nbsp;&nbsp; Unfortunately, nuclear power plants&nbsp; have historically been more expensive&nbsp;&nbsp;
and took somewhat longer to build&nbsp; than modern gas power plants. were supposed to solve this problem. They&nbsp; should be small enough so that they can&nbsp;&nbsp; be mass-produced in a factory and then&nbsp; transported to the desired location. It’d&nbsp;&nbsp;
be a great solution not just for communities&nbsp; but also for large factories or data centres. Superficially, it looks great and especially the&nbsp; current president of the United States, Donald&nbsp;&nbsp;
Trump, has pushed for their rapid deployment.&nbsp; Just in June, the “Trump Administration celebrated&nbsp;&nbsp; achieving President Trump's ambitious goal” of&nbsp; having 3 small nuclear reactors reach criticality&nbsp;&nbsp;
and announced that “The Golden Era of American&nbsp; Nuclear Energy Has Arrived”. The US government&nbsp;&nbsp; just put another billion dollars into the&nbsp; startup X-energy that is also backed by Amazon. Enthusiasm over small nuclear reactors isn’t just&nbsp; to be found in the United States. The British&nbsp;&nbsp;
government announced a few months ago that they’re&nbsp; putting two point six billion pounds to its SMR&nbsp;&nbsp; programme. The Russians have two operating ones&nbsp; and just started preparing the site for another&nbsp;&nbsp;
one in Uzbekistan. A Finnish company wants to&nbsp; build the first AI data centre powered by SMRs&nbsp;&nbsp; in Idaho. And the EU has announced yet another&nbsp; strategy, structured around nine key actions,&nbsp;&nbsp;
whose central pillar is an alliance. You get&nbsp; the picture, small modular reactors are sexy. The problem is… all of this is very&nbsp; heavily subsidized by governments.&nbsp;&nbsp; And when you look at the companies that&nbsp; weren’t part of the financial windfall,&nbsp;&nbsp;
it’s not going great. The French SMR startup&nbsp; Naarea filed bankruptcy in January. The US&nbsp;&nbsp; company Ultra Safe Nuclear Corporation filed for&nbsp; bankruptcy a few months earlier, and NuScale has&nbsp;&nbsp;
dropped its original plan. The UK company Moltex&nbsp; Energy is insolvent and close to bankruptcy. Now you may say, okay, but startups fail all the&nbsp; time, the fittest will survive. I agree but it&nbsp;&nbsp;
drives home the point that small modular reactors&nbsp; haven’t yet proved their supposed main advantage,&nbsp;&nbsp; which is that they’re supposedly cheaper. A group&nbsp; of nuclear engineers just published a paper in&nbsp;&nbsp; Nature communication in which they analysed&nbsp; the expected costs of small modular reactors.&nbsp;&nbsp;
Even taking into account that the costs are&nbsp; expected to fall if the technology matures,&nbsp;&nbsp; they still find that, quote “SMRs&nbsp; are not competitive in current U.S.&nbsp;&nbsp; electricity markets” and “dedicated&nbsp; power production is uneconomic.”
And the French government has actually cut&nbsp; back on their small modular reactor program,&nbsp;&nbsp; while a committee of the senate has warned that&nbsp; as things currently go we might see “a series&nbsp;&nbsp;
of bankruptcies among nuclear startups”&nbsp; unless there’s more governmental backup. The problem is that while it’s reasonable&nbsp; to expect that small nuclear reactors,&nbsp;&nbsp; once a technology is established,&nbsp; could be rolled out faster,&nbsp;&nbsp;
it isn’t all that clear they’d also be&nbsp; cheaper, per energy produced. The issue is&nbsp;&nbsp; that the smaller the actual nuclear reactor,&nbsp; the more shielding you need relative to its&nbsp;&nbsp; size. And if you stack several of them you’ll&nbsp; basically be duplicating efforts. For most&nbsp;&nbsp;
products you get a cost advantage when you&nbsp; make them bigger, not smaller. Add to this&nbsp;&nbsp; that much of the delay with building nuclear&nbsp; power usually isn’t the actual construction,&nbsp;&nbsp; it comes from safety and environmental regulations&nbsp; that small modular reactors will not circumvent.
My takeaway from all this is basically,&nbsp; if you want to make nuclear power cheaper,&nbsp;&nbsp; start with large power plants, and then&nbsp; try to make the economics work out for the&nbsp;&nbsp; smaller ones. In practice what we might&nbsp; be seeing though is a sort of hybrid,&nbsp;&nbsp;
in which the reactors are small and parts of it&nbsp; are factory produced, but not the full thing. In summary, the golden era for nuclear&nbsp; power may have arrived, alright,&nbsp;&nbsp;
but a lot of this gold is coming from your taxes.
