---
title: 'Physicists Can’t Explain This, And Now It’s a Problem'
source: 'https://youtube.com/watch?v=mh-e78kaQ8o'
video_id: 'mh-e78kaQ8o'
date: 2026-11-11
duration_sec: 390
channel: 'Sabine Hossenfelder'
---

# Physicists Can’t Explain This, And Now It’s a Problem

> Source: [Physicists Can’t Explain This, And Now It’s a Problem](https://youtube.com/watch?v=mh-e78kaQ8o)

## Summary

The video challenges the common misconception that quantum physics only applies to small objects, arguing that it should apply to everything, including galaxies. It highlights a new paper that shows the standard explanation for why galaxies lack quantum properties—decoherence—is insufficient, and that the problem is more complex than physicists thought.

### Key Points

- **Quantum Physics Misconception** [00:00] — Quantum physics is often thought to apply only to small things, but it actually applies to everything, including galaxies. The question is why galaxies don't exhibit quantum properties like being in two places at once.
- **Origin of Galaxies** [00:26] — Galaxies, stars, and planets started as tiny quantum fluctuations in the early universe, which were stretched to enormous sizes during cosmic expansion. Matter clumped under gravity, forming solar systems and galaxies, and quantum properties seemingly disappeared.
- **Decoherence Explanation** [01:19] — Physicists typically explain the loss of quantum properties through decoherence—the loss of coherence due to random interactions between particles, which shifts phases and makes quantum interference unobservable.
- **New Paper Contradicts** [02:04] — A new paper argues that decoherence doesn't fully explain the disappearance of quantum properties. When interactions between early universe fluctuations are considered, quantum interference doesn't always vanish and can even grow, contrary to standard lore.
- **Other Recent Papers** [02:29] — Several other papers in 2023 also challenge the standard story: a Japanese group found that fluctuations passing decoherence checks can still be entangled; another showed that ignoring quantum behavior contradicts observations; and another found that decoherence could disturb gravitational fields incompatibly with observations.
- **Testable Consequences** [03:17] — The renewed discussion could be testable—depending on how quantum properties disappeared, there might be traces in galaxy distribution or the cosmic microwave background.
- **Measurement Problem** [03:45] — The author criticizes the papers, stating that decoherence doesn't solve the measurement problem—it only removes interference, but still leaves galaxies in superpositions (e.g., 50% in one place, 50% in another), which isn't observed.
- **Cosmological Implications** [04:31] — The measurement problem is now returning in cosmology, and if wave-function collapse is a physical process, it might leave observable traces. This could force physicists to confront a century-old problem.

## Transcript

Quantum physics is a theory for the small things.&nbsp; You have probably heard this somewhere. Problem&nbsp;&nbsp; is: it’s not true. Quantum physics applies to&nbsp; everything including entire galaxies. So why do&nbsp;&nbsp;
galaxies not have quantum properties? Why are they&nbsp; stubbornly in one place rather than two places&nbsp;&nbsp; at once? Physicists are finally realizing that&nbsp; this is a pretty big problem. Let’s have a look.
Everything you see around you, galaxies,&nbsp; stars, planets, you, started out as tiny&nbsp;&nbsp; quantum fluctuations in the very early universe.&nbsp; At least that’s what our best theory of the early&nbsp;&nbsp; universe says. Then the universe expanded&nbsp; dramatically and these fluctuations were&nbsp;&nbsp;
stretched to enormous size. The matter began&nbsp; to clump under the pull of gravity and solar&nbsp;&nbsp; systems and galaxies slowly formed. And somehow,&nbsp; magically, the quantum properties disappeared.
OK. But if you know one thing about quantum&nbsp; physics, it’s probably that quantum effects&nbsp;&nbsp; persist until you make a measurement. And exactly&nbsp; who made a measurement on the entire universe to&nbsp;&nbsp;
make its quantum effects go away? Why do we&nbsp; see stars and galaxies boringly being in one&nbsp;&nbsp; and only one place and not, as quantum physics&nbsp; likes to tell us, in several places at the same&nbsp;&nbsp;
time? A new paper now says that the problem is&nbsp; more difficult to solve than physicists thought. You see, physicists normally say, decoherence&nbsp; does the job. Coherence is an alignment of the&nbsp;&nbsp;
phases of different parts of the wave-function.&nbsp; Decoherence is the loss of this coherence. It can&nbsp;&nbsp; happen if the quantum particles randomly bump&nbsp; into each other or other particles. Because&nbsp;&nbsp; that will shift the phases around. The issue&nbsp; is now that decoherence makes it impossible to&nbsp;&nbsp;
observe some quantum-typical effects like&nbsp; interference. And this, physicists say,&nbsp;&nbsp; is also what happened with these fluctuations&nbsp; from the early universe as they grew. They lost&nbsp;&nbsp; coherence and quantum effects disappeared. The authors of the new paper, however,&nbsp;&nbsp;
say that this doesn’t work. The fluctuations in&nbsp; the early universe interact with each other, and&nbsp;&nbsp; once you take these interactions into account, the&nbsp; quantum interference doesn’t always go away. In&nbsp;&nbsp;
some cases, it even keeps growing, as the authors&nbsp; write, quote, “contrary to standard lore.” It’s a&nbsp;&nbsp; little inconvenient if an effect becomes bigger&nbsp; after you've explained why it should disappear.&nbsp;
This isn’t the only paper that’s poked a hole in&nbsp; the standard story this year. In June, a group&nbsp;&nbsp; from Japan reported in Physical Review D that the&nbsp; usual way to check whether the fluctuations have&nbsp;&nbsp; lost their quantum properties doesn’t work.&nbsp; They found that fluctuations which pass this&nbsp;&nbsp;
check with flying colours can still be quantum&nbsp; entangled. Another group showed that you can’t&nbsp;&nbsp; just leave aside the quantum behaviour either,&nbsp; that just doesn’t agree with the observations. And yet another group said that&nbsp; actually the random interactions&nbsp;&nbsp;
required for the decoherence can disturb&nbsp; the gravitational field so much that this&nbsp;&nbsp; is also incompatible with observations.&nbsp; So decoherence can’t simply be assumed.&nbsp;&nbsp; At the very least one must check that it’s&nbsp; compatible with what we actually measure.&nbsp;
The brief summary is: It’s much more&nbsp; complicated than physicists thought.&nbsp;&nbsp; And this renewed discussion about just where the&nbsp; quantum properties of galaxies go has an upside:&nbsp;&nbsp;
it could be testable. Depending on how you think&nbsp; these properties disappeared, that might have left&nbsp;&nbsp; traces in how galaxies are distributed,&nbsp; or in the cosmic microwave background.&nbsp; That said, I give all these papers a 10&nbsp; out of 10 on the bullshit meter because&nbsp;&nbsp;
we already know that decoherence cannot solve the&nbsp; problem. Just because you destroy the coherence&nbsp;&nbsp; between some parts of the wave-function&nbsp; doesn’t mean that particles, or galaxies,&nbsp;&nbsp; are suddenly in one place at a time. All this does&nbsp; for you is to get rid of the quantum interference.&nbsp;&nbsp;
Decoherence then tells you that a galaxy is,&nbsp; say, 50% in one place and 50% in another place,&nbsp;&nbsp; which isn’t what we observe either. A galaxy&nbsp; is either there or not. It’s not 50% there.
This, of course, is nothing else than the&nbsp; good, old measurement problem of quantum&nbsp;&nbsp; physics. The interesting development here is&nbsp; that it is coming back to haunt physicists in&nbsp;&nbsp; a completely new regime: cosmology. And the&nbsp; consequences might be observable. Indeed,&nbsp;&nbsp;
already a few years ago, a group of&nbsp; physicists pointed out that if the&nbsp;&nbsp; wave-function collapse is a physical process,&nbsp; then that might leave observable traces.&nbsp; So the reason I am telling you about this&nbsp; is not because I think the papers are great,&nbsp;&nbsp;
but because it’s a very interesting development&nbsp; that could move the field forward by finally&nbsp;&nbsp; forcing physicists to confront a neglected problem&nbsp; that’s more than a century old. The problem has&nbsp;&nbsp;
now literally grown to the size of the universe.&nbsp; To paraphrase Einstein, do not worry about your&nbsp;&nbsp; difficulties in mathematics. I can assure you&nbsp; that physicists’ difficulties are still greater.
It might seem like an eternity since the invention&nbsp; of electricity, but looking at the history of our&nbsp;&nbsp; species, we've only just begun to understand the&nbsp; world. This is why I believe the best time to get&nbsp;&nbsp;
started to learn maths and science is now. And the&nbsp; best place to get started is with today's sponsor,&nbsp;&nbsp; Brilliant. Brilliant is an online learning&nbsp; platform with a large number of courses on&nbsp;&nbsp; mathematics, science, and coding. They just&nbsp; recently introduced a new digital tutor that&nbsp;&nbsp;
adapts to your personal level of knowledge.&nbsp; It was built by learning experts from places&nbsp;&nbsp; like MIT and Harvard, and it'll help you to&nbsp; learn by hands-on exercise. Just like this,&nbsp;&nbsp;
Brilliant made private math tutoring affordable&nbsp; for everyone. Brilliant is constantly improving&nbsp;&nbsp; their courses and they now have a large&nbsp; selection on everything from data analysis&nbsp;&nbsp; to logical reasoning and the technologies&nbsp; that shape today's life. And of course,&nbsp;&nbsp;
I have a special offer. You can get started&nbsp; with Brilliant for free. And if you use my&nbsp;&nbsp; link brilliant.org/Sabine or scan the QR code,&nbsp; you can save 20% on an annual subscription with&nbsp;&nbsp;
unlimited access and full tutoring support.&nbsp; Thanks for watching. See you tomorrow.
