[00:02] proprietary and expensive software getting cloned lately thanks to the power of AI coding tools. Well, what better software to target than apps that better software to target than apps that cost two, three, or even $500 a month. [00:15] Last time, our graphic design pros looked at a scary Photoshop clone. But this time, we've got some of our product designers and fabricators reacting to vibecoded versions of Fusion and Solid Works. [00:27] What? >> Spacebar doesn't work. S doesn't work. Right click wheel doesn't work. >> This is a bad experience. >> Let's see if they can recreate this widget right after this segue to our [00:41] sponsor, >> Delta Hub. Delta Hub's Carpio 2.0 wrist rests glide smoothly across your desk and help reduce strain during long shifts or gaming sessions. And they come in an LTT colorway. Grab yours at the [00:54] link down below. Well, so far the controls are the same, so that's that's already drives me nuts about most other CAD programs is the default controls. I >> Okay. >> Uh you're an Autodesk Fusion expert [01:09] >> of sorts. Sure. >> How uh how familiar are you with it? >> Uh very familiar. I've been using it for about 8 years now. The interface is looking pretty similar actually. Like it's almost identical just looking back [01:22] >> Uh you do Fusion? I told him I do like 3D printing stuff these days. I'm making deck boxes for Magic the Gathering. >> And what's your favorite Magic the right now. >> Okay. Neither can I cuz I don't play. I [01:35] could have if you thought of a card, but now I will never will. So, in terms of design, it looks a lot The >> It looks cooler. >> Yeah. That's just an aesthetic thing, [01:47] probably change it here, but you know, >> you are a capital D designer. >> you are a capital D designer. >> Yes. With with a big D. Um, this is SolidCraft and despite the name, it actually looks and works a lot more [02:00] it actually looks and works a lot more like Fusion. It is not a part of the growing artcraft suite. Interestingly, the GitHub page for SolidCraft lists lead developer Burbrook and Anthropics Claude as the primary two contributors, [02:15] but there's 120 other developers who have also contributed. So hopefully that means we're dealing with something that resembles a useful product. >> UI looks pretty similar. Like they pretty much copied the the tabs and [02:27] stuff like that. Um except looks like some stuff is missing. >> What's missing? Oh, the icons or like >> just the utilities stuff here. Like >> Right. Or right. >> Oh, even here in the surface stuff as [02:41] counts. >> Yeah. I like but it looks like like most to use is here. So, uh >> that's interesting. Yeah, in the mesh empty spaces. >> Empty sections. Yeah, it doesn't look [02:55] >> does say assemble. Oh, it's just the icons that are missing. Is it >> Not available yet. >> Okay. See if you can recreate this. Um as it's a general vibe because this is [03:10] vibe coding. So, we're all about vibes. his first steps in the new software. See how it feels. It's like stepping into a house where someone has recreated your place and it's like, "Hold on, something's off. Something's a little [03:25] >> So far, I've just used a sketch, but uh Sketch feels exactly the same as every other software. >> Are you a Fusion expert? >> Can you do the Can you do this thing? Don't include that. [03:39] >> Okay. So, this has a grid pattern that you can kind of align things. One of the things that I end up using a fair bit is I can just drag something along a line and then go up. Oh, it does have it. So, it can only snap in one direction at a [03:52] time. That is actually something that would annoy me. So, it's either horizontal or it's aligned as an extension. So, if I went from here, it automatically does that cross line and snaps in both directions. [04:06] Yeah, >> it also even gives me the midpoint. >> so that's a slight difference. There's it's quality of life things that I would >> And I normally use when I'm doing design. [04:19] >> Oh, it's hallucinating. >> Is it is it not acting the way you would expect? >> Not entirely. So like here, let me just do a comparison here in Fusion just to [04:33] >> yeah, >> this shape stays the same, >> right? >> Whereas if I start doing that on this >> oh, >> it starts changing the shape of it. [04:48] Works before, too. >> So, I don't think this is necessarily like it's wrong. It's just this is not the viewport's actually smoother on this than it is in Fusion. [05:00] >> I saw this saw this lagging a little bit. Some people have been saying it it feels smoother. I think a chunk of that is because it's less featurerich. >> When you start adding more things on top, software can get heavier to use. [05:13] >> So there's a widget >> that Wow, that was so quick. Can you >> Put my name on it. Okay. Not supported yet. The ball doesn't fit past the end of the edge. The operation failed. Not supported yet. [05:27] in that case. >> At least I will say it gave an error >> Oh, that makes sense to you. >> It does make sense to me. >> Which is surprising. >> Wow. Thanks, Chat. GPT. I think I kind [05:41] of made the doohickey. Seems like you did. Seems a little bit. license? >> I don't pay for a license right now. So >> No, nothing to give up. >> Well, Fusion 360, the personal license [05:53] >> Well, Fusion 360, the personal license is free. So this as an alternative, hard time is what you're saying >> or wasted AI's time. They've wasted >> Yeah. Yeah. Probably. >> I mean the reason I have a fusion [06:06] license as home is for the manufacturing capabilities. So no I mean it's a great doing is design work in my >> this is I got to say this is a much different experience with from the Photoshop one. I was like this is [06:20] >> you guys are coming in here being like this is pretty good. Uh, I've actually over to Linux and Fusion isn't on Linux. So, for us Linux boys, this is this is fantastic. >> A AI is accelerating the uh the the [06:34] >> Yeah, I think so. >> Heck yeah. Heck yeah about AI. Don't include that. Editor, don't include me saying heck yeah about the AI thing. Let's see how our next piece of vibecoded software holds up. [06:48] >> So, how how how often do you use Solid Works? I mean lately not that much. I >> somehow. >> Um but you know when we were doing the >> Okay. >> At least I'm not the power user I used [07:02] make. >> What the freak keyboard is this? >> No. But no. Where's the keys? >> You have to guess. That's part of It's >> No. It's like >> there is no letters on the keys. Well, [07:16] who the freak reads the keys over there? Hold on. If I have to notice where my keys are, that's just a terrible design. As a product designer, that is >> No, it's okay. We'll get We'll get back on track here. [07:30] >> Rant over. As I'm trying to find the S key, and I just see a name. Okay. All right. Let's see. Let's see. We have We have sketch. We have surfaces. We have evaluate. Can we change the tabs? Nope. We cannot add tabs. Okay. Um cuz over [07:43] something like sheet metal or you want to do something like mesh modeling which I don't do or mold tool. >> This is purometric which looks and works a lot like solid works. It's only about a month old and it's currently closed [07:58] source but according to Reddit posts from developer Maleficent release 61 it's a mix of Rust and JavaScript. They also noted that they've been developing software for more than 20 years and that Claude Opus 5.5 was used for this [08:13] project. >> So far between the last software and this software, this one looks more different to Solid Works than the Solid Craft looked to Fusion. This one the spots aren't all the same. [08:26] >> It hasn't attempted to be an exact clone the way that the other one did. >> Yeah. Also, I don't really like how they do their planes. They're kind of like a little bit. >> Yeah, they kind of blend together. Oh, [08:40] these planes are atrocious. It just and it's not labeled until you hover over it. Okay. Fit and finish. Not as >> What's the equivalent of that of that uh scene with the planes? Oh, okay. [08:55] >> Yeah, this doesn't blind me. And I can see all of the planes immediately. >> this one blinded me cuz it just it overlaid all of them. It just made it >> Yeah. Yeah. >> Okay. [09:07] >> Let's start with sketch. Okay. Can we select? Okay. No, it it snaps. >> It's a little bit snappier. Okay. S key doesn't work. I I am pressing the S key. >> Are you sure that's the S key? >> Yes, I think so. Cuz it's on the side. [09:20] It's on the >> in Solid Works. S is for shortcut. It snaps up this like quick thing where you can also type in commands like measure instead of like dynamically mention it. But okay, let's see if the right click [09:34] right click in Solid Works, you can bring up a wheel. Okay, that can allow might use very often, like dimensioning, >> like a weapon wheel. >> Yeah. So, like if if I want to quickly dimension um and I if the camera's too [09:47] up and then all of a sudden you're dimensioning. Like holding right click doesn't do anything. Pressing S on this doesn't do anything. So, spacebar doesn't work. S doesn't work. Right click wheel doesn't work. Um, so that's [10:02] now? >> Strange. It has the same issue as Solid direction and when it gets to a different one, it doesn't. >> But I wonder if you can go past and trim. [10:15] So yes, you can. So that works. >> Let's see if it will Where did the line >> It's beautiful. >> What? So, as opposed to the solid craft when you have a like line that's not fully it would it would let me extrude [10:32] >> Okay, >> this one is not letting me do that. If I >> this one is not letting me do that. If I edit the sketch, it's definitely not as uh refined as Solid Craft. On the other one, it kind of just worked as expected. [10:46] one, it kind of just worked as expected. >> Here, there's more differences of stuff. >> But it's not snapping. Oh, I can't snap. That's annoying. >> Oh, escape not clearing the tool you're on. Wait, it did. What? [10:59] >> You have to you have to click it five times. >> pop up. >> It is wildly inconsistent >> It's in a browser. It has to send everything to the cloud. [11:14] >> that's not a good excuse. Okay. So, one thing that it does not have compared to Solid Works. Here I've got got two circles and a box. >> In Solid Works, I could choose which part of these I want to manipulate. So, [11:28] either to cut away or do this. Unless I'm missing the feature, I don't see where I can select that. So, like right now, it's cutting that part. I can show So I can choose if I want to do that line like that circle [11:43] >> or if I want to choose this part >> or choose like each individual thing. >> Right. So that will now cut just that post here. There's no option for that. [11:55] So the only thing for me to be able to do that I'd actually have to edit this do that I'd actually have to edit this sketch and delete that line and this intuitive. >> Yeah. Yeah. the the spottiness of the [12:11] >> Mhm. >> Man, this thing is inconsistent as heck. every now and then it's just not going to do what you want. I'll just say right off the bat, absolutely not uh losing not transitioning licenses. This is um a [12:28] rough time. >> I think it's fair to say this at this point. >> It is not great. >> Okay. Well, are you ready to give up your Solid Works license? [12:40] >> Per per but it's called parametric. It's fun. >> Yeah, >> we use Solid Works every day. So, Works cuz work pays for it. Um, you [12:54] >> so I ain't giving that up a fan. >> Kyle is officially crashing out. >> Uh, >> now there are even more CAD software clones out there. Some notable ones are CAD Craft from the Art Craft Suite, [13:06] which is just a few weeks old at the time of recording, but appears to be making quick progress. There's also Open CAD Studio, which is about 6 months old. And like pretty much else we've seen so far, the recipe seems to be one part [13:20] experienced developer, one part Claude, and a light sprinkling of help from like-minded folks on GitHub. We didn't have our guys try those ones out in this video because they're more familiar with Solid Works and Fusion. According to our [13:34] reactors, these clones don't seem like they're ready to take over the world just yet. But the developers of these apps beg to differ and they are making some bold predictions. The developer of Parametric made this prediction on [13:47] Reddit. Give it one to two years and software developers will have the same job opportunities as blacksmiths. The whole industry is completely cooked. Time will tell whether that prediction is right, and it remains to be seen how [14:00] Autodesk, Adobe, and other software giants respond to these threats. But seeing how fast these tools are progressing, the next few years at the very least are going to be very interesting, almost as interesting as [14:13] our sponsor, Delta Hub. Whether you're gaming or working, sitting at your computer desk for a long period of time can leave you aching in all sorts of ways. A Delta Hub Carpio 2.0 know can be used every day to help support your [14:26] wrists while you're working. But what if you aren't just punching numbers into competitive first-person shooters or action RPGs? Well, Delta Hub's Carpio G2.0 comes with a wrist strap so you never lose track of your wrist rest even [14:40] during faster paced gameplay. It also sports a perforated design to help have that signature glide feeling that Carpio is known for. And if you have larger hands, they also come in a larger size. But no matter which model or size [14:53] you go with, they're going to be small, lightweight, and easy to pack around for with friends. Learn more about both versions and find the right Delta Hub Carpio for you using the link in the [15:06] video description. If you like this video, then you might be an AI. You have to tell me if you are. It's the rules. You also have to go check out the video we did on the vibecoded Photoshop and then check how much progress that has [15:19] been made on that app since we did the video. It's kind of