---
title: 'Making French Pumpkin Soup from 1651'
source: 'https://youtube.com/watch?v=_QPswWNDyTU'
video_id: '_QPswWNDyTU'
date: 2026-11-06
duration_sec: 92
channel: 'Tasting History with Max Miller'
---

# Making French Pumpkin Soup from 1651

> Source: [Making French Pumpkin Soup from 1651](https://youtube.com/watch?v=_QPswWNDyTU)

## Summary

This video explores a 1651 French pumpkin soup recipe by François Pierre de La Varenne, a pioneer of French haute cuisine. It contrasts the medieval use of heavy spices and sugar with Varenne's focus on fresh vegetables and local herbs, letting the pumpkin's natural flavor shine. The video also explains the historical origins of the word 'soup' and the tradition of serving it in a hollowed-out pumpkin.

### Key Points

- **Medieval vs. Haute Cuisine** [00:02] — Medieval cooking relied heavily on sugar and spices as dominant flavors, but La Varenne's 1651 recipe shifted to fresh vegetables and local herbs, establishing sugar for sweet dishes and letting key ingredients shine.
- **Pumpkin as the Star** [00:29] — Unlike 'pumpkin spice' (mostly spice), this soup uses pepper and cloves stuck into an onion, so it actually tastes like pumpkin. The spices play a supporting role, elevating rather than competing with the main ingredient.
- **Serving in a Pumpkin** [00:42] — Historic recipes suggest serving the soup in a hollowed-out pumpkin, a presentation that adds to the autumnal elegance of the dish.
- **Origin of 'Soup'** [00:55] — The word 'soup' comes from 'sops' — pieces of bread placed at the bottom of a bowl to soak up broth. Varenne calls it 'potage,' meaning anything made in a pot.
- **Light and Autumnal** [01:09] — The final soup is light, elegant, and autumnal, with pumpkin as the main flavor and pepper, onion, and clove providing subtle enhancement.

### Conclusion

La Varenne's 1651 pumpkin soup represents a culinary turning point, prioritizing natural flavors over heavy spices. It's a simple, elegant dish that connects modern cooking to historical traditions.

## Transcript

helped move French cuisine from the and Renaissance into what we would call French haute cuisine today. Just like how pumpkin spice is mostly spice and barely any pumpkin, medieval and
all about using lots of sugar and spices. These were actually often the dominant flavors in the dish, but François Pierre de La Varenne, who wrote this recipe in 1651, wanted spices to play a supporting role and instead
focused on fresh vegetables and local herbs. He wanted the flavor of the key ingredient to really shine and he helped establish the idea that sugar belonged primarily in sweet dishes rather than being added to everything from meat to
vegetables. So, instead of pumpkin spice, this soup, which uses pepper and cloves stuck into an onion, actually tastes like pumpkin. Other historic soup should actually be served in a hollowed-out pumpkin, which is a
back. The recipe also says to serve it with sops. Those are pieces of bread put on the bottom to sop up the soup. And it's from this tradition of soaking sops in broth that we actually get the word soup. Sop, soup. Except Varenne calls it
potage or potage, which is just anything that's made in a pot. Now, while I do love pumpkin spice, there is something so light and autumnal and elegant about this soup. Just like Varenne intended, the pumpkin is the main flavor and the
pepper and onion and clove are just there to elevate rather than compete with the pumpkin. For the full video on this soup, head over to YouTube and this this soup, head over to YouTube and this recipe is at tastinghistory.com.
