---
title: 'Mystery Photon Might Be First Evidence for Quantum Gravity'
source: 'https://youtube.com/watch?v=3rxQyfOfjuU'
video_id: '3rxQyfOfjuU'
date: 2026-11-11
duration_sec: 386
channel: 'Sabine Hossenfelder'
---

# Mystery Photon Might Be First Evidence for Quantum Gravity

> Source: [Mystery Photon Might Be First Evidence for Quantum Gravity](https://youtube.com/watch?v=3rxQyfOfjuU)

## Summary

The video discusses a recent claim that a single photon detected by the Carpet 3 experiment in Russia might be the first evidence for quantum gravity. This photon, with extremely high energy, originated from a gamma-ray burst billions of light-years away, defying expectations that it should have been absorbed on its journey. The presenter critically examines the findings, considering alternative explanations and the broader implications for physics.

### Key Points

- **First Evidence for Quantum Gravity?** [00:00] — A team of physicists report the detection of a single photon by the Carpet 3 experiment in Russia, suggesting it could be evidence for quantum gravity.
- **The Photon's Energy and Origin** [00:43] — The photon came from a gamma-ray burst in October 2022, the brightest ever recorded, with an energy of about 300 tera electron volts (TeV) — about 100 times more than what the Large Hadron Collider produces.
- **Why the Photon Shouldn't Have Arrived** [01:38] — The photon should not have reached Earth because space is filled with cosmic microwave background light, and at high energies, light interacts with light, making space opaque.
- **Improbability of Detection** [02:02] — The authors calculated the chance of the photon's survival at about 1 in 10 to the minus 96, while the chance of it being a false detection or unrelated is about 1 in 30,000.
- **Quantum Gravity Explanation** [03:08] — If space-time is made of quanta, it might behave like a medium, which could affect photon propagation — a modern form of the ether concept.
- **Paper's Rating and Skepticism** [04:02] — The presenter rates the paper 7/10 on the 'fascination meter', noting that while the observation is puzzling, theoretical models can be adjusted to explain anything, so skepticism is warranted.
- **Value of Single Events** [04:43] — The presenter advises paying attention to single events like this because they might be the first sign of new physics, but not to overstate their significance.

## Transcript

A team of physicists say they may have found the&nbsp; first evidence for quantum gravity. No, really.&nbsp;&nbsp; And unusually for quantum gravity, the evidence&nbsp; doesn't come from the 17th dimension with a small&nbsp;&nbsp;
zoo of hypothetical particles. It's one photon.&nbsp; Yes, you heard that right. One single photon.&nbsp;&nbsp; Let's have a look. The photon was detected by&nbsp; the Carpet 3 experiment in Russia. It appears&nbsp;&nbsp;
to have come from a gamma-ray burst some billions&nbsp; of light-years away. It's remarkable just because&nbsp;&nbsp; no one had ever heard of this experiment&nbsp; previously. It's also remarkable because&nbsp;&nbsp; this was the brightest gamma-ray burst ever&nbsp; recorded. The event happened in October 2022&nbsp;&nbsp;
and several observatories detected photons from&nbsp; it with extremely high energies. But Carpet saw&nbsp;&nbsp; one that was in an entirely different league. This&nbsp; photon came in at about 300 tera electron volts.&nbsp;&nbsp;
This is about 100 times as much energy&nbsp; as the Large Hadron Collider produces.&nbsp;&nbsp; One photon casually outperforming several billion&nbsp; euros of European infrastructure. And according to&nbsp;&nbsp; the press release that came with the new paper,&nbsp; this photon means that effects attributable to&nbsp;&nbsp;
quantum gravity may emerge at high energies. This&nbsp; photon is very, very surprising. It's not just its&nbsp;&nbsp; existence per se. The gamma-ray burst might well&nbsp; have produced it. Astrophysicists believe that&nbsp;&nbsp;
gamma-ray bursts are sometimes caused when stars&nbsp; die. And that can create enormous energies. The&nbsp;&nbsp; issue is that the gamma-ray burst was billions of&nbsp; light-years away. And the photon should never have&nbsp;&nbsp;
made it to Earth because space isn't entirely&nbsp; empty. It's filled with the light of the cosmic&nbsp;&nbsp; microwave background. Even if you leave aside&nbsp; other particles. And at high enough energies,&nbsp;&nbsp;
light does interact with other light. This means&nbsp; that space isn't entirely transparent to photons&nbsp;&nbsp; at high energies. The photon might have been&nbsp; produced, okay, but it should never have arrived&nbsp;&nbsp;
on Earth. Yet, it did. The authors of the new&nbsp; paper went and calculated what the chance is that&nbsp;&nbsp; such a photon would have reached us. They say it's&nbsp; about 1 in 10 to the minus 96. In other words,&nbsp;&nbsp;
roughly comparable to the chance I'll ever get rid&nbsp; of the clover in our lawn. It's not just unlikely,&nbsp;&nbsp; it doesn't happen. Indeed, it's more likely&nbsp; that this by the photon appearing together&nbsp;&nbsp; with the other photons of the burst, it was just&nbsp; an unrelated photon from an event nearer to us,&nbsp;&nbsp;
or it was a false detection of something else&nbsp; that was wrongly identified as a photon. The&nbsp;&nbsp; authors put the chance of that at about 1 in&nbsp; a 30,000. I think this one photon is much more&nbsp;&nbsp;
remarkable than this one potential dark matter&nbsp; signal, which we talked about the other week.&nbsp;&nbsp; But, what could it be? It could be that this is&nbsp; the first sign that something isn't quite right&nbsp;&nbsp;
with Einstein's theory of relativity. Because,&nbsp; you see, when we calculate what happens with a&nbsp;&nbsp; photon at that high energy, the calculations rely&nbsp; on the relativity of velocity. We assume that&nbsp;&nbsp;
Einstein was right and that the laws of physics&nbsp; don't pick out one preferred state of constant&nbsp;&nbsp; motion. The thing is, though, that if space-time&nbsp; is made of quanta of space, of space-time atoms,&nbsp;&nbsp;
then it might behave like a sort of medium,&nbsp; and then this might not be correct. And yes,&nbsp;&nbsp; this is somewhat like a modern form of the&nbsp; ether. It's just here on Earth with photons of&nbsp;&nbsp; moderate energy and at short distances, we never&nbsp; notice. Go to high energies and large distances,&nbsp;&nbsp;
and weird things can happen. But, exactly what&nbsp; weird things? Well, that's the problem. Basically,&nbsp;&nbsp; mathematically, you can make pretty much anything&nbsp; happening, and physicists have totally tried it&nbsp;&nbsp;
all. You can make highly energetic photons move&nbsp; faster or slower or farther or not as far. This&nbsp;&nbsp; is why I give the paper a seven out of 10 on the&nbsp; [&nbsp;__&nbsp;] meter. I think the observation is fine and&nbsp;&nbsp;
it really is puzzling, but you can make up pretty&nbsp; much any math to have it prove anything you like,&nbsp;&nbsp; quantum gravity or otherwise. That said, this&nbsp; single photon after the single potential dark&nbsp;&nbsp;
matter detection raises a more general question.&nbsp; How much attention should we pay to such events&nbsp;&nbsp; in the first place? Historically, we've&nbsp; seen weird and dramatic single events&nbsp;&nbsp; like a potential candidate for a magnetic&nbsp; monopole or super high energy neutrino event,&nbsp;&nbsp;
and these never repeated. We still don't know&nbsp; what they are. Well, my perspective on this is&nbsp;&nbsp; that you never know whether it'll remain only one&nbsp; event. It makes sense to pay attention to this&nbsp;&nbsp;
because it might be the first sign of something&nbsp; bigger, not because it already is something big,&nbsp;&nbsp; and ultra high energetic gamma ray bursts are&nbsp; plausibly events that can reveal new physics,&nbsp;&nbsp;
which we not be able to see on Earth. But for&nbsp; now, quantum gravity consists of one photon,&nbsp;&nbsp; one paper, and several thousand physicists trying&nbsp; very hard not to look too excited. I strongly&nbsp;&nbsp;
believe that it's better to be prepared and avoid&nbsp; trouble than to fix trouble after it's happened.&nbsp;&nbsp; To me, being prepared means wearing sun lotion,&nbsp; having my teeth cleaned twice a year, and a
little tool in my car to break the windows just in&nbsp; case. Because I like to be prepared, I only travel&nbsp;&nbsp; with noise-canceling headphones, have a cake in&nbsp; the freezer in case I forget someone something,&nbsp;&nbsp;
and it's why I protect myself from online scams&nbsp; with NordVPN's next-gen antivirus. NordVPN is&nbsp;&nbsp; an app that you install on your phone or&nbsp; laptop. It provides a secure and private&nbsp;&nbsp;
connection for your internet browsing through&nbsp; one of their thousands of servers all over the&nbsp;&nbsp; world. And they now also offer an all-around&nbsp; virus protection of the next generation,&nbsp;&nbsp; not just against malware, but also trackers and&nbsp; scammers, and to stay prepared for whatever the&nbsp;&nbsp;
next castle be that AI brings upon us. NordVPN&nbsp; is an easy and effective way to protect yourself&nbsp;&nbsp; online. And of course, I have a special offer. All&nbsp; you have to do is use my link nordvpn.com/ sabine&nbsp;&nbsp;
or use the coupon code SABINE. So, go and check&nbsp; this out. Thanks for watching. See you tomorrow.
