---
title: 'Neuroscience’s Case Against Free Will Is Falling Apart'
source: 'https://youtube.com/watch?v=15s0OWN4BSI'
video_id: '15s0OWN4BSI'
date: 2026-11-11
duration_sec: 435
channel: 'Sabine Hossenfelder'
---

# Neuroscience’s Case Against Free Will Is Falling Apart

> Source: [Neuroscience’s Case Against Free Will Is Falling Apart](https://youtube.com/watch?v=15s0OWN4BSI)

## Summary

This video challenges the long-held neuroscientific claim that free will is an illusion, based on Libet's experiments. The host presents three recent studies that question the interpretation of these results, offering a more nuanced view of decision-making.

### Key Points

- **The Classic Libet Experiment** [00:31] — Libet found brain activity predicting finger movement before conscious awareness, undermining free will; this has been reproduced many times.
- **Improved Experimental Method** [01:20] — A London team improved the method by having participants type random words and asking if they knew the next word; brain signals were stronger when decisions were made.
- **Study Conclusion: Intentions Are Real** [02:05] — They concluded that conscious intentions are not merely retrospective confabulations, challenging the standard interpretation.
- **Thomas James's Process Argument** [02:31] — Thomas James argues that decisions are processes, not sudden moments; early brain activity is part of the process, not an unconscious decision.
- **Decisions Take Time** [02:57] — The experiment showed that decisions take non-zero time, not that free will is an illusion.
- **Australian Team's Forgiveness Study** [04:14] — An Australian team found that people primed to disbelieve free will reported more self-forgiveness and forgiveness toward others, contradicting previous claims that free-will disbelief leads to immorality.
- **Responsibility Without Free Will** [04:42] — The host argues responsibility depends on preventability, not free will; Bob is responsible for eating a donut because a warning could prevent it, but not for sneezing.

## Transcript

Does free will exist? Some people&nbsp; care about this question. For decades,&nbsp;&nbsp; neuroscientists have argued that we make decisions&nbsp; before we become consciously aware of it,&nbsp;&nbsp; so free will is an illusion. And at the same time,&nbsp; sociologists have argued that it's nevertheless&nbsp;&nbsp;
a useful illusion because it makes us better&nbsp; people. Well, today I have three recent studies,&nbsp;&nbsp; each interesting in its own way, that totally&nbsp; change this discussion. Let's have a look. In an&nbsp;&nbsp;
a now famous experiment from 1983, the neurologist&nbsp; Benjamin Libet found that people's brain activity&nbsp;&nbsp; shows they'll move a finger before they knew&nbsp; themselves that they will move. This finding&nbsp;&nbsp;
has been independently reproduced many times&nbsp; since. Bad news for free will, but excellent&nbsp;&nbsp; news for anyone whose finger has done something&nbsp; regrettable on the internet. The first paper that&nbsp;&nbsp; I have today sheds doubt not on the experimental&nbsp; results themselves, but on their interpretation.&nbsp;&nbsp;
You see, the problem with Libet's experiment is&nbsp; that people were asked to report when they became&nbsp;&nbsp; consciously aware of something. "But, please&nbsp; tell us exactly when your consciousness happened"&nbsp;&nbsp; is perhaps not neuroscience's finest measuring&nbsp; instrument. A team from London has now improved&nbsp;&nbsp;
the method. They recruited 51 people to type&nbsp; random words in certain categories like animals&nbsp;&nbsp; while their brain activity was measured. Between&nbsp; the words, they were told to briefly pause. In&nbsp;&nbsp;
that pause, the researchers randomly interrupted&nbsp; them to ask if they already knew what the next&nbsp;&nbsp; word would be. The brain measurement showed&nbsp; that if the participants had already made up&nbsp;&nbsp; their mind, then the brain signal that indicated&nbsp; their coming action was stronger. They conclude&nbsp;&nbsp;
that it's not true that we make decisions first&nbsp; and then become consciously aware of them and&nbsp;&nbsp; invent that it was our decision. As they write,&nbsp; "These results are difficult to reconcile with the&nbsp;&nbsp;
view that experiences of conscious intention are&nbsp; merely a retrospective confabulation." The second&nbsp;&nbsp; new paper that I have today supports this finding&nbsp; with a general argument. It comes from cognitive&nbsp;&nbsp;
neuroscientist Thomas James, who questions the&nbsp; assumptions behind the usual interpretation.&nbsp;&nbsp; Neuroscientists usually describe behavior&nbsp; as a sequence: perception, decision, action.&nbsp;&nbsp;
James says, "This isn't what happens. There's&nbsp; no sudden decision moment. Rather, what we call&nbsp;&nbsp; a decision is the process in which sensory input&nbsp; and motor processes develop to result in an action&nbsp;&nbsp;
or not." In this interpretation, the early brain&nbsp; activity that Libet and others observed was not an&nbsp;&nbsp; unconscious decision. It was merely an early part&nbsp; of the process that produced the action and the&nbsp;&nbsp;
experience of having made a decision. Basically,&nbsp; he says the experiment that supposedly killed free&nbsp;&nbsp; will merely showed that decisions take non-zero&nbsp; time. By the way, a simple way to support this&nbsp;&nbsp;
channel is to buy a t-shirt or a mug in our store.&nbsp; And the third paper I have today comes from an&nbsp;&nbsp; Australian team which re-examines the claim that&nbsp; people who are primed to question their free will&nbsp;&nbsp;
are more likely to support morally questionable&nbsp; actions, such as cheating on tasks. There's been a&nbsp;&nbsp; whole number of studies which seem to support this&nbsp; claim. They usually work by giving people some&nbsp;&nbsp;
passages to read that say basically, "Your actions&nbsp; are predetermined by whatever input your brain&nbsp;&nbsp; receives." And then asking the people basically&nbsp; whether people are to blame for their actions.&nbsp;&nbsp;
Unsurprisingly, usually these studies find that&nbsp; at least temporarily people say, "No." more often.&nbsp;&nbsp; Hence, free will disbelievers are immoral.&nbsp; Well, the new study now looked at the question&nbsp;&nbsp; differently. Rather than asking people prompted&nbsp; to disbelieve free will about moral failings,&nbsp;&nbsp;
they asked them to recall either a time they'd&nbsp; hurt someone or a time someone had hurt them.&nbsp;&nbsp; Those who then read arguments that free will is an&nbsp; illusion later reported more self-forgiveness and&nbsp;&nbsp;
more forgiveness towards others. Honestly, I think&nbsp; all these psychology studies are [&nbsp;__&nbsp;] one way or&nbsp;&nbsp; another. The problem is that the way they prompt&nbsp; people to disbelieve in free will really prompts&nbsp;&nbsp;
them to believe that people are not responsible&nbsp; for their actions. This makes zero sense though,&nbsp;&nbsp; because look, whether your brain gives you&nbsp; free will or not, it's still you, your brain,&nbsp;&nbsp; that results in an action or not. The question&nbsp; of who or what's responsible comes down to the&nbsp;&nbsp;
question of what measure could have prevented the&nbsp; result. If Bob sneezes, could he have prevented&nbsp;&nbsp; this by telling him not to sneeze? Probably not.&nbsp; If Bob eats Eva's donut, could you have prevented&nbsp;&nbsp;
this by warning him you'll find out and make him&nbsp; clean the toilet? More likely. Hence, you make&nbsp;&nbsp; Bob responsible for theft, but not responsible for&nbsp; sneezing. Nothing about this requires mentioning&nbsp;&nbsp; free will. So much about the psychology papers. I&nbsp; give the two neurology papers each an 8 out of&nbsp;&nbsp;
10 on the [&nbsp;__&nbsp;] meter. This is because despite&nbsp; all the educated sounding talk, the entire field&nbsp;&nbsp; still suffers from a definition problem. What is&nbsp; it that you're even looking for when you speak of&nbsp;&nbsp;
a conscious decision? The reason I'm telling you&nbsp; about this nevertheless is that this is a research&nbsp;&nbsp; area where I expect a lot to happen in the next&nbsp; decade, partly because of a better understanding&nbsp;&nbsp; of the human brain, but also because artificial&nbsp; intelligence will serve as a test case for what&nbsp;&nbsp;
it means to think, make decisions, and be aware&nbsp; of something. 40 years of philosophical panic&nbsp;&nbsp; and in the end the discovery was latency.&nbsp; If you want to stay safe on the internet,&nbsp;&nbsp;
I can really recommend NordVPN, which I've been&nbsp; using for many years. It's a high quality product&nbsp;&nbsp; that acts as a data filter between you and the&nbsp; bigger internet. It only lets in and out what you&nbsp;&nbsp;
want. NordVPN is an app that you install on your&nbsp; phone or laptop. It provides a secure and private&nbsp;&nbsp; connection for your internet browsing through one&nbsp; of their thousands of servers all over the world.&nbsp;&nbsp;
NordVPN also regularly updates its service. They&nbsp; now offer an all around virus protection of the&nbsp;&nbsp; next generation, not just against malware, but&nbsp; also trackers and scammers and whatever the next&nbsp;&nbsp;
cause will be that AI brings upon us. NordVPN also&nbsp; has a post quantum encryption and one of the great&nbsp;&nbsp; benefits of using NordVPN is that it's super handy&nbsp; to access websites in other countries that are&nbsp;&nbsp;
blocked for visitors from elsewhere. All you need&nbsp; to do is use a server in the respective country&nbsp;&nbsp; and Nord has thousands of those. NordVPN is an&nbsp; easy and effective way to maintain your privacy&nbsp;&nbsp;
online and of course I have a special offer. All&nbsp; you have to do is use my link nordvpn.com/sabine&nbsp;&nbsp; or use the coupon code SABINE. So go and check&nbsp; this out. Thanks for watching. See you tomorrow.
