---
title: 'My First Mistake as an Engineer'
source: 'https://youtube.com/watch?v=n05Yu3UAI_o'
video_id: 'n05Yu3UAI_o'
date: 2026-11-10
duration_sec: 469
channel: 'Practical Engineering'
---

# My First Mistake as an Engineer

> Source: [My First Mistake as an Engineer](https://youtube.com/watch?v=n05Yu3UAI_o)

## Summary

The video is a personal narrative by an engineer announcing his upcoming book, 'Disasters By Design,' and reading an excerpt from its preface. The excerpt recounts his first mistake as a young engineer—dropping a bailer down a monitoring well—and how this trivial error reshaped his understanding of engineering as a human endeavor. He then discusses the book's release details, including pre-order bonuses and formats.

### Key Points

- **Book Announcement** [00:00] — The author announces his new book, 'Disasters By Design,' coming out in March, which explores famous engineering failures and how building codes and practices evolved from them.
- **Personal Anecdote Begins** [00:31] — He reads from the preface, describing his first solo visit to a construction site as a young engineer, tasked with collecting a water sample from a monitoring well.
- **The Mistake** [01:45] — While lowering a bailer into the well, he accidentally uses the wrong rope spool, causing the bailer to fall into the well. He panics, fearing the cost of re-drilling and environmental penalties.
- **The Rescue** [02:29] — With help from a colleague, he uses fishing gear to retrieve the lost bailer, an event that becomes a site-wide story and a source of embarrassment.
- **Lesson Learned** [03:11] — The incident shatters his idealized view of engineering as infallible expertise, revealing it as a profession of well-intentioned, well-trained, but human people.
- **Failure as a Defining Force** [04:12] — He reflects that failure is not just a possibility but a defining force in engineering; every standing structure is a response to one that failed.
- **Collective Learning** [04:45] — He emphasizes that we learn from each other's mistakes, updating codes and regulations, and telling stories to prevent future errors.
- **Book Details and Pre-order** [05:13] — He shares early reviews, mentions the book's illustrations, and announces a pre-order exclusive poster of the Arecibo Radio Telescope for US customers.
- **Formats and Availability** [06:47] — He mentions signed copies available through Nowhere Books in San Antonio, an audiobook read by himself, and a UK edition with minor differences.

### Conclusion

The video serves as both a personal reflection on the human nature of engineering and a promotional announcement for the author's upcoming book, 'Disasters By Design.' It underscores that failure is a catalyst for learning and improvement, both individually and collectively.

## Transcript

I have a new book coming out in March,&nbsp; Disasters By Design. It’s about famous&nbsp;&nbsp; engineering failures throughout history,&nbsp; how they happened, and how systems like&nbsp;&nbsp; building codes and engineering practice&nbsp; evolved as a result of those disasters,&nbsp;&nbsp;
because there have been a lot of good things&nbsp; come out of the moments we’re not so proud&nbsp;&nbsp; of. And I thought it was only fair to include&nbsp; a few of the errors I’ve made in my career as&nbsp;&nbsp; an engineer in the book. One of those stories&nbsp; is in the preface, and it also - I think at&nbsp;&nbsp;
least - makes a compelling case for the rest&nbsp; of the book, so I want to read part of it&nbsp;&nbsp; to you and then try to answer some of the&nbsp; questions I’ve been getting about the release. The first time I visited a construction site as&nbsp; a young engineer, I was by myself. I think my&nbsp;&nbsp;
boss arranged it that way on purpose. I pulled&nbsp; the company truck through the rutted entrance&nbsp;&nbsp; to the site and brought it to a bumpy stop,&nbsp; surveying the scene. The ensemble of yellow&nbsp;&nbsp; machines kicking up dust and spewing black&nbsp; smoke seemed to know exactly how to avoid&nbsp;&nbsp;
one another. The deep rumble of diesel engines&nbsp; and piercing backup alarms drowned out the soft&nbsp;&nbsp; public radio voices playing inside the cab. My job was simple. A new dam was being built,&nbsp;&nbsp;
and environmental permits required us to&nbsp; monitor groundwater for contamination. I&nbsp;&nbsp; needed to collect a water sample from a monitoring&nbsp; well for testing, a seemingly easy task for the&nbsp;&nbsp; new guy. I carefully steered the truck down a&nbsp; twisting path and eventually found the well,&nbsp;&nbsp;
a nondescript PVC pipe poking from the weeds.&nbsp; I stepped out wearing my new white hard hat&nbsp;&nbsp; and neon green vest, still creased from the&nbsp; packaging, shining like inexperience incarnate.&nbsp; A bailer is a simple tool. It’s just a length&nbsp; of pipe with a check valve at the bottom,&nbsp;&nbsp;
allowing water in but not out. I tied the a rope&nbsp; to the device and began unwinding the spool,&nbsp;&nbsp; allowing it to slowly descend the casing. It&nbsp; reached about halfway, and then, suddenly,&nbsp;&nbsp; it was gone. I watched in terror as the loose&nbsp; end of the rope whipped over and into the well,&nbsp;&nbsp;
and a couple of seconds later, I heard the splash.&nbsp; I hadn’t realized that the spool held two separate&nbsp;&nbsp; lengths of rope, one much shorter than the&nbsp; other. I had inadvertently chosen the wrong one.&nbsp;
Instantly, panic set in. I thought about the cost&nbsp; of re-drilling the well and the steep penalties&nbsp;&nbsp; of noncompliance with environmental rules.&nbsp; I didn’t know anyone on the site, so I began&nbsp;&nbsp; an awkward chain of introductions, looking for&nbsp; help. Passed from one puzzled face to another,&nbsp;&nbsp;
I eventually found a sympathetic colleague.&nbsp; We devised a makeshift rescue plan involving&nbsp;&nbsp; fishing gear purchased from a nearby store. I&nbsp; spent the next hour dropping various hooks and&nbsp;&nbsp; weights down the well, fishing for my lost&nbsp; bailer. By the time I finally pulled it up,&nbsp;&nbsp;
dripping triumphantly in the afternoon sun,&nbsp; everyone on the site had heard the tale.&nbsp; Naturally, I was embarrassed. But my feelings were&nbsp; more complicated than that. Up to that point, I’d&nbsp;&nbsp;
held an idealized image of engineering. I imagined&nbsp; a world filled with confident experts who deftly&nbsp;&nbsp; controlled complex systems, who effortlessly&nbsp; anticipated every detail with exacting precision.&nbsp;&nbsp;
The built environment appeared so intricate yet&nbsp; so steadfastly dependable. I had spent six years&nbsp;&nbsp; in college looking forward to the day when I would&nbsp; start my career and become one of those experts.&nbsp;&nbsp;
Fishing for my equipment that day afternoon&nbsp; shook some sense into me. It was a silly,&nbsp;&nbsp; inconsequential mistake, but my notions of&nbsp; infallible expertise had plunged into the&nbsp;&nbsp; well alongside that bailer. It was the first of&nbsp; many errors I would make throughout my career,&nbsp;&nbsp;
but it helped me see clearly what engineering&nbsp; truly is: a profession filled with people&nbsp;&nbsp; just like me, well-intentioned and&nbsp; well-trained, yet undeniably human.&nbsp; I kept that fishing gear on my desk for nearly&nbsp; a decade afterward as a reminder of my capacity&nbsp;&nbsp;
for blunders. And ever since, I’ve been&nbsp; trying to reconcile two competing ideas:&nbsp;&nbsp; we live in a remarkably safe and comfortable&nbsp; era, rarely needing to question the reliability&nbsp;&nbsp; of the infrastructure around us, yet this&nbsp; complex stability depends entirely on the&nbsp;&nbsp;
work of ordinary, imperfect people. That moment, and many others like it,&nbsp;&nbsp; taught me something I hadn’t learned in school.&nbsp; Failure isn’t just a possibility in engineering&nbsp;&nbsp; but a defining force. Every structure standing&nbsp; today is, in part, a response to one that didn’t.&nbsp;
There is a large group of amused construction&nbsp; workers and a small office of engineers who,&nbsp;&nbsp; after witnessing or hearing about my mishap&nbsp; with the bailer, will never use a spool of&nbsp;&nbsp; rope without first checking if it holds a&nbsp; continuous length. It’s a trivial example,&nbsp;&nbsp;
but it illustrates a deep truth: we&nbsp; learn from each other’s mistakes.&nbsp;&nbsp; One person’s error quietly becomes someone else’s&nbsp; precaution. Over time, those individual choices&nbsp;&nbsp; add up to something larger. We observe&nbsp; faults and misjudgments, big and small,&nbsp;&nbsp;
and weave them into our collective consciousness.&nbsp; We update codes, write new regulations,&nbsp;&nbsp; and establish procedures that help us catch errors&nbsp; before they escalate. And we tell the stories.
It goes on, but I’ll let you read the rest when&nbsp; you pick up your copy. I’m so excited about this book.&nbsp;&nbsp; In some ways it’s kind of the culmination&nbsp; of how my philosophy about engineering&nbsp;&nbsp; has evolved throughout my career both as an&nbsp; engineer and as someone who talks about the&nbsp;&nbsp;
profession online. It already has a lot of great&nbsp; reviews from early readers like Adam Savage,&nbsp;&nbsp; Latif Nasser of Radiolab, Fred Mills from the&nbsp; B1M, and more. It’s got a ton of beautiful&nbsp;&nbsp;
illustrations, and, actually, speaking of&nbsp; that, I have something special for you. Anyone in the US who pre-orders a copy,&nbsp; whether you already have or you do it&nbsp;&nbsp; before the release in March, can get this&nbsp; poster of the Arecibo Radio Telescope, which&nbsp;&nbsp;
famously collapsed in 2020. The investigation&nbsp; into what went wrong was super interesting;&nbsp;&nbsp; I have a whole chapter on it in the book. The&nbsp; poster is super nice, 11x17 inches, printed in&nbsp;&nbsp; uncoated cover cardstock. And they’re completely&nbsp; exclusive to the pre-order; we won’t make any more&nbsp;&nbsp;
once the book comes out. If you pre-order from&nbsp; any retailer in the US, you’re eligible while&nbsp;&nbsp; supplies last. Just click the link down below,&nbsp; enter your order number, and submit the form. Of course, the book comes out after Christmas,&nbsp; but (and this might be a controversial take)&nbsp;&nbsp;
I think a pre-ordered gift is even better&nbsp; than a regular gift. It splits the joy of&nbsp;&nbsp; receiving into two distinct moments, plus&nbsp; you get to give the gift of anticipation! you know that we will have them in the US. I’ve&nbsp; partnered with one of my favorite bookstores,&nbsp;&nbsp;
Nowhere Books in San Antonio. If&nbsp; you want to pre-order a signed copy,&nbsp;&nbsp; you have to get it through them. There’s a link&nbsp; down below to pre-order now, and of course,&nbsp;&nbsp; the poster offer applies to those as well,&nbsp; and it even applies to the audiobook version.
Yes, there is going to be an audiobook&nbsp; that comes out on the same day. And yes,&nbsp;&nbsp; I will be the one reading it. In fact I’m heading&nbsp; to the studio next week to start recording it,&nbsp;&nbsp; so say a prayer for my vocal chords. There&nbsp; is also a UK version of the book. I love the&nbsp;&nbsp;
cover for it. It shouldn’t be very different&nbsp; from the US version at all except for some&nbsp;&nbsp; word spellings and units. Book distribution&nbsp; is complicated, but my understanding is that,&nbsp;&nbsp; just about anywhere in the world, you should be&nbsp; able to get at least one of these editions from&nbsp;&nbsp;
your favorite bookseller. And if you do, I want to&nbsp; say thank you. And I really do mean that. You’re&nbsp;&nbsp; in this book. Your support and feedback means so&nbsp; much to me, and I’m so grateful to have such a&nbsp;&nbsp;
fantastic group of people watching these videos&nbsp; and making projects like this book possible.
