---
title: 'One Million Dollars for Telling the Truth. Who Might Win It?'
source: 'https://youtube.com/watch?v=Z0xPGVMtZK4'
video_id: 'Z0xPGVMtZK4'
date: 2026-11-11
duration_sec: 383
channel: 'Sabine Hossenfelder'
---

# One Million Dollars for Telling the Truth. Who Might Win It?

> Source: [One Million Dollars for Telling the Truth. Who Might Win It?](https://youtube.com/watch?v=Z0xPGVMtZK4)

## Summary

Billionaire investor Bill Ackman has launched the $1 million Carob Trust Prize for Academic Courage, aimed at rewarding scientists who pursue intellectually independent, non-conformist ideas that are later vindicated. The prize, led by Harvard economist Roland Fryer, is initially restricted to social sciences and US citizens or residents. The video discusses potential candidates and the broader implications of such an award.

### Key Points

- **Prize Announcement** [00:00] — Bill Ackman funds a $1 million award called the Carob Trust Prize for Academic Courage, with Roland Fryer leading the selection committee.
- **Prize Criteria** [00:32] — The prize rewards scientists who demonstrate intellectual independence, non-conformist ideas that had an impact and were vindicated, encouraging truth-telling despite inconvenience.
- **Eligibility Details** [00:45] — Up to 5 people can win per year, initially only for social sciences, with hopes to expand later. Candidates must be US citizens or residents and must be alive.
- **Purpose: Changing Career Calculus** [01:09] — Ackman and Fryer aim to change academia's 'career calculus' where publishing unpopular results can cost jobs, reputation, funding, or lead to lawsuits.
- **Potential Candidate: Hilary Cass** [01:24] — Hilary Cass investigated evidence for medical hormone treatments for transgender children, but she is not a US citizen and her work is more medical than social science.
- **Potential Candidate: Lisa Littman** [01:55] — Lisa Littman proposed 'rapid-onset gender dysphoria' in 2018, suggesting social contagion, but the question of vindication remains unresolved due to controversy.
- **Problem with the Award** [02:22] — Controversial topics may not be vindicated for decades, as few dare to touch them, revealing a structural issue with the prize.
- **Potential Candidates: Data Colada Bloggers** [02:39] — The three researchers behind Data Colada exposed statistical irregularities in social science papers, notably concerning Francesca Gino from Harvard Business School.
- **Francesca Gino Case** [02:56] — Harvard concluded research misconduct, revoked Gino's tenure, and fired her in 2025. However, Ackman believes she is innocent and has funded her legal defense.
- **Potential Candidate: Nathan Cofnas** [03:25] — Cofnas raised allegations about Cambridge professor Jason Arday and studies IQ and race, but he is a philosopher of biology, not a social scientist.
- **Potential Candidate: Economist Opposing Lockdowns** [03:57] — An economist and health-policy researcher publicly opposed Covid lockdowns and school closures, but vindication would require parallel universes.
- **Potential Candidate: Peter Arcidiacono** [04:09] — Arcidiacono did statistical work on racial preferences in Harvard admissions, fitting the criteria well, though impact is limited to American universities.
- **Comparison: John Maddox Prize** [04:36] — The UK's John Maddox Prize (since 2012) rewards standing up for science, is international and covers all fields, but only offers $5,000, making the new prize's money significant.
- **Final Reflection** [05:00] — It's depressing that scientists need a prize for sticking with the truth; vindication should be enough, but the money may drive impact.

### Conclusion

The Carob Trust Prize for Academic Courage is a timely initiative to reward intellectual bravery, though its success hinges on overcoming the challenge of vindicating controversial ideas. The video highlights several potential candidates while questioning the broader academic environment that makes such a prize necessary.

## Transcript

A billionaire just launched a $1 million award&nbsp; that will change science, at least I hope so.&nbsp;&nbsp; Today I want to tell you what this is&nbsp; all about and who might be candidates&nbsp;&nbsp; for the first round of awards. Let’s have a look.
The money comes from billionaire investor&nbsp; Bill Ackman, and the selection committee&nbsp;&nbsp; will be led by Harvard economist Roland&nbsp; Fryer. They called it the “Carob Trust&nbsp;&nbsp; Prize for Academic Courage.” It will go&nbsp; to scientists who have persevered with&nbsp;&nbsp;
“Intellectual Independence,” “Non-Conformist&nbsp; Ideas” that had an impact and were vindicated.&nbsp;&nbsp; It’s basically an encouragement for people to&nbsp; stick to the truth even when it’s inconvenient.
The prize may be awarded to up to 5 people a year,&nbsp; though I am sorry to say that at least next year&nbsp;&nbsp; it is only for the social sciences, though they&nbsp; say they hope to extend it to other disciplines&nbsp;&nbsp;
afterwards. And if you look at the fine print,&nbsp; the candidate must be a citizen or resident of&nbsp;&nbsp; the United States. Oh, and they must be alive. So&nbsp; in case you died recently, you wouldn’t qualify,&nbsp;&nbsp;
but please leave a comment, so we can&nbsp; confirm there’s YouTube in afterlife. Fryer and Ackman say they’re hoping to change what&nbsp; they call the “career calculus”. In present-day&nbsp;&nbsp; academia it’s sad but true that publishing&nbsp; an unpopular result might cost you your job,&nbsp;&nbsp;
your reputation, and your funding. Worse, you&nbsp; might get sued and have legal costs. This is why I&nbsp;&nbsp; think this award is a timely idea and a good one. So who might win it? The first person who came to my mind is&nbsp; Hilary Cass, who investigated the evidence&nbsp;&nbsp;
for the benefits of medical hormone&nbsp; treatments for transgender children,&nbsp;&nbsp; or their absence. But she is not a US citizen and&nbsp; also, it’s probably more medicine than sociology. The next obvious candidate might be Lisa Littman.&nbsp;&nbsp;
In 2018, she published a paper proposing&nbsp; the term “rapid-onset gender dysphoria”&nbsp;&nbsp; when parents reported their children suddenly&nbsp; developed the idea they were trans, often in&nbsp;&nbsp;
groups of friends. Littman suggested&nbsp; that social contagion plays a role. The question here is, though, how much evidence&nbsp; there is that Littman has been “vindicated,”&nbsp;&nbsp; the problem being that no one really&nbsp; wants to touch the topic. This,&nbsp;&nbsp;
in my mind, also reveals a problem with the&nbsp; award. If a topic is controversial enough,&nbsp;&nbsp; few people will dare to “vindicate”&nbsp; it, potentially for decades. The next candidates who came to my mind are&nbsp; the three researchers behind the blog Data&nbsp;&nbsp;
Colada. They’ve specialized in taking&nbsp; apart published papers in the social&nbsp;&nbsp; sciences and have revealed many suspicious&nbsp; statistical irregularities. Most famously,&nbsp;&nbsp; they raised concerns about several papers by&nbsp; Francesca Gino from Harvard Business School.
Harvard investigated and concluded that&nbsp; research misconduct had occurred. Gino was&nbsp;&nbsp; put on leave and, in 2025, Harvard&nbsp; revoked her tenure and fired her. To me this seems like an excellent case&nbsp; for an academic courage prize. But there’s&nbsp;&nbsp;
a fantastic complication, which is that&nbsp; Ackman, who is funding this new prize,&nbsp;&nbsp; said he believes that Francesca Gino is&nbsp; innocent and has covered her legal expenses.
A name that I saw mentioned a lot in&nbsp; relation to the new prize is Nathan Cofnas,&nbsp;&nbsp; who recently attracted attention for raising&nbsp; allegations about Cambridge professor Jason Arday,&nbsp;&nbsp;
but who also studies the relation between IQ&nbsp; and race. Cofnas is American, so that part is&nbsp;&nbsp; fine. But technically he is a philosopher&nbsp; of biology, which isn’t a social science. an economist and health-policy researcher.&nbsp; He publicly opposed Covid lockdowns and&nbsp;&nbsp;
school closures. Definitely courageous,&nbsp; certainly necessary, but just exactly&nbsp;&nbsp; how would you even vindicate this without first&nbsp; inventing travel between parallel universes?
Then there is Peter Arcidiacono, an economist&nbsp; now at Johns Hopkins. He did statistical work&nbsp;&nbsp; on racial preferences in Harvard admissions&nbsp; that became relevant for university reforms.&nbsp;&nbsp;
I think he probably fits the criteria best,&nbsp; though I would say that the impact has been&nbsp;&nbsp; limited exactly because it’s rather narrowly about&nbsp; what’s going on at some American universities.
A prize with such ambitions isn’t entirely new.&nbsp; The UK has the John Maddox Prize for standing up&nbsp;&nbsp; for science, that’s been around since 2012. It&nbsp; is open internationally and covers all fields of&nbsp;&nbsp;
science. The prize, however, is only $5000&nbsp; dollars. And I think that in this case the&nbsp;&nbsp; money actually matters. This is why I believe&nbsp; the new prize will actually have an impact.
Though I have to admit it’s kind of&nbsp; depressing that you have to offer&nbsp;&nbsp; scientists a prize for sticking with the&nbsp; truth. Isn’t the vindication prize enough? Did you know that I recently changed my phone&nbsp; number? No, you didn't because I use Incogni&nbsp;&nbsp;
to keep my private data off the internet. Each&nbsp; time you open a website, it'll try to collect&nbsp;&nbsp; data about who you are and where you are and what&nbsp; other websites you visited. Many firms then make&nbsp;&nbsp; money by selling your private information to data&nbsp; brokers. Most countries have laws against that,&nbsp;&nbsp;
and you can ask for your data to be removed,&nbsp; but doing this takes up a lot of time. Incogni&nbsp;&nbsp; automates the process of getting you out of those&nbsp; databases. They now cover more than 420 brokers.&nbsp;&nbsp;
You sign up and they'll get you out of their&nbsp; databases. They'll keep on doing that and if you&nbsp;&nbsp; want, send you a monthly risk assessment report.&nbsp; They now also have a custom removal feature where&nbsp;&nbsp;
you can submit specific websites. I've used that&nbsp; a lot. Incogni is a simple way to make your life&nbsp;&nbsp; better. If that sounds like something you could&nbsp; need to use my link SABINE or the custom link in&nbsp;&nbsp;
the info because that'll get you 60% off. Stay&nbsp; safe. Thanks for watching. See you tomorrow.
