[00:03] watching YouTube right now there are plenty of video streaming sites out there a lot of them with some pretty major advantages over YouTube VI lets you watch a much higher quality and offers a much more curated [00:18] strict rules when it comes to copyrighted content Odyssey is decentralized and was made to try to recapture the 2000 era internet atmosphere that everyone is so install for nowadays with all these platforms [00:32] out there why do we stick with YouTube with this incredibly strict Community guidelines Creator hostile copyright policy and its aggressive reactions to ad blockers some might say that YouTube was just lucky they came out with the [00:46] first good video hosting site and they continue to be popular just because they always were popular it's where all the creators you follow up with their content but this neglects the real reason why YouTube has been and [00:59] continues to be as successful as it is the algorithm as controversial and disliked as a YouTube algorithm seemingly is it's also what separates YouTube from every other video platform it's what keeps you [01:13] the viewer coming back day after day for your fill of Niche slop it's what allows unknown creators that have no audience at all to release videos that can still get potentially hundreds of thousands or even millions of views it's a system [01:27] that rewards creativity and originality and it's really really good at knowing what you want to watch the Youtube algorithm in its current state would not be possible without Google very similarly what set Google [01:40] apart from every other search engine in the early 2000s was their page rank algorithm previous search engines would just show you the closest results to developed a system that could accurately measure the relevance and importance of [01:54] fastly improved search results from Google compared to every other search when Google bought YouTube in 2006 there wasn't an algorithm at all videos will blow up almost exclusively because of [02:07] word of mouth and all the videos on the front page were Clips handpicked by YouTube staff this led to 30% of videos getting 99% of the views with 2/3 of videos on the platform getting essentially no views to get an audience [02:21] around this time you just had to get really lucky in this era there was just the exact same set of videos in the same order for every user on the site but with that being said there was still some sort of algorithm the video sidebar [02:38] content related to the clip you were watching usually you would just find videos that had a similar title or the same tags as a current video and it's here in his humble beginnings where we'll find her first anomaly in the [02:51] YouTube algorithm on April 20th 2008 a user named morard would upload a video called Marina morard glor the video itself would show a red image of a man shaking with some Windows [03:05] image of a man shaking with some Windows Movie Maker effects and not much else at the end some bell sounds can be heard and the clip ends with a brief second image of the man for whatever reason this video blew up after being live for [03:18] 2 weeks it had garnered more than 60,000 views a pretty large amount for 2008 like everything else on YouTube at the time this video's success was likely due to work of mouth it had an accompany creepy pasta that told it the potential [03:33] harm this video could do to your sanity by the way if you want to know more man depicted in this video you can go check out this collaboration I did with something sinister where I talk about that stuff more in depth because of this [03:47] video's strangeness and his lack of any sort of relevant keywords in his tags or title YouTube had no idea how to categorize it so when it went to look for related Clips to put in the sidebar it mostly just put videos with the exact [04:00] same title since the clip had garnered a lot of views many people re-upload the video on their own channels or they just put up completely different videos with the same title hoping to get some attention from the sidebar in any event [04:14] seeing only a bunch of videos with this strangely specific title in the sidebar must have only enhanced whatever creepiness surrounded this video and it was quite the rabbit hole in 2008 and honestly it still is today as well if [04:28] you search Marina morard G scor right now on YouTube you'll still see almost exclusively videos with that exact same title whether the re-uploads of the original video copycat videos May in a similar style or just other unrelated [04:41] creepy Clips as time went on YouTube would continue to improve the algorithm in 2012 they switched from ranking videos purely based on views and clicks and began taking into account watch time as well leading to higher quality [04:54] recommendations and discouraging clickbait in 2016 the algorithm would start using networks which would infinitely increase the amount of data points it took into account and also made it infinitely harder to truly [05:06] understand it's grown into a behemoth that almost feels like this magical force that either works in your favor or it doesn't and it's what drives the it doesn't and it's what drives the entire modern experience of YouTube so [05:18] what happens when the algorithm malfunctions now you might be wondering what I mean by that you see the algorithm doesn't actually watch videos it only knows the data points that surround a video like the title [05:31] description tags and of course I can gather a lot of data by analyzing the viewers themselves that watch a video the algorithm will take all this data into account and try to group a video with other Clips it thinks are similar [05:44] but what happens when there's something off about the data it's working with like the video title is only made up of emojis how does it get categorized in can hallucinate and produce unpredictable results the YouTube algor [05:59] gorithm can also produce anomalies such as entire subsections of this site that shouldn't even exist Marina morgar glor was a pretty simple and innocent example from a much more primitive version of YouTube but for the remainder of this [06:13] video we're going to be looking at the much more complicated modern anomalies in the YouTube algorithm whenever you type anything into the YouTube search bar you'll be shown several autocomplete suggestions [06:25] usually based not just on the popularity of Any Given search term but also based on how the algorithm is categorized to you as a viewer if you enter an emoji or even just any non-letter character into the [06:37] search bar the suggestions always get pretty weird but there is one exception to this if you type in a period you'll see nothing no suggestions at all why is [06:50] this if you actually do search for just a period and nothing else the results aren't that weird in fact all the results seem to contain the word Dot replacing the period character with that [07:04] results this wasn't always the case though up until a couple years ago YouTube would instead replace a period character with the phrase full stop punctuation which is a very specific group of keywords and just like Marina [07:20] morard glesgorv searching for a period a couple years ago on YouTube would only result in videos with the title full stop punctuation videos have been taken down and haven't been archived anywhere but according to [07:35] some people on Reddit despite the mostly innocent looking thumbnails many of these clips supposedly depicted violent scenes that probably broke YouTube's terms of service I can't verify whether or not that's true and I'll admit it [07:49] does sound a lot like a schoolyard rumor but after this glitch was discovered scary videos with the title fullstop punctuation to take advantage of this creating an unnatural YouTube Niche [08:02] but should have never existed in the first place let's take a look at some of these [Music] [08:24] fullstop punctuation but that's also the name of the channel and the only words there's not a whole lot to entangle about the video itself which is pretty short and doesn't really have much going on the mumbled audio at the beginning is [08:37] just a slowed down snippet of the song Strange Fruit by Nina Simone which you the leaves by Kanye West which sampled it the forest scene at the beginning is too generic to be able to recognize and I also couldn't find a source for the [08:51] Jeff the killer esque face at the end although I won't lie it kind of looks a little like your movie sucks this channel has two other uploads which are just the same video with the same title but different thumbnails one of them [09:03] disturbingly enough showing two kids in a bathtub along with a snake I feel like this must break some YouTube guidelines along with just generally being immoral in this context so I'm blocking it out here while this video isn't exactly very [09:17] interesting there are some genuinely horrifying videos with this glitchy title like this one [Music] [09:35] [Music] [Applause] entered your email address somewhere you probably shouldn't have and then started getting a lot of spam well chances are it was probably collected by a data [09:50] broker data Brokers collect personal information on mass and then sell it to sort of entities that might be interested in buying large amounts of personal data you can only imagine just what the various things they might want [10:02] to do with it it might start with Spam but it can escalate to fishing attacks where Bad actors try to deceive you to gain much more sensitive data or even identity theft as bad as all this is though I'm not worried about it anymore [10:14] because I've trusted delete me to deal with these data Brokers for me delete me targeted by and then they'll contact all of them on your behalf to get your submit all the info you want searched [10:27] and you'll get a detailed privacy report after only 7 days it's not just a regularly follow up to make sure your data hasn't found his way back into the hands of data Brokers get 20% off of delimi plan when you go to join deli.com [10:42] feral and use promo code Ferell at checkout that's join Del me.com feral and code farell thanks to delme for sponsoring this video this video is insane I think it might be one of the creepiest Clips I've [10:55] seen in a long time the big eyes the unsettling large mouth teeth and tongue the music with the synthetic vocals it all works to such a good effect and historic recording of the song Daisy [11:10] Bell from 1961 that features the first ever computer generated vocals pretty cool the video itself though is a little harder to track down I found a few other uploads in different context and also a readd a thread from 2020 searching for [11:24] its origin there wasn't a definitive answer in this thread but they did find the ear known upload of the clip which was originally also posted on Reddit to the void meme subreddit in July 2020 the user that made this post has [11:37] been suspended so he unfortunately can't contact them but they did post a comment in the thread explaining that the video was supposedly made by heavily editing a Snapchat recording with that old filter that would make your mouth and I big [11:49] they didn't say though if they made the video themselves or not but we could probably assume that they did but getting back to full stop punctuation the channel That posted this creepy video is called first name last name and [12:01] just like the last Channel they also have several other uploads all with the same title and while their first video we watched was pretty interesting the rest of these videos are all just lowquality post and you know what [12:14] most full stop punctuation videos on YouTube are exactly like this low Effort garbage made to sneakily grab some views from a glitch in the YouTube algorithm theory that the bug here was YouTube allowing illegal content I person think [12:29] the anomaly is the unnatural promotion of lowquality videos probably bypassing some of the usual factors like watch time clickthrough rate or ranking against other videos while we can't know for certain what the bug Was Here [12:41] YouTube would kind of prove that there was indeed something wrong by not only removing autocomplete when only a period is typed into the search bar but if you search fullstop punctuation a day you'll only get results for the word dot to [12:54] find these videos I had to purposefully misspell the word punctuation and let YouTube autoc Correct in the search results page which I guess bypassed this strange fix they implemented while YouTube may have fixed this glitch every [13:07] other anomaly we're going to talk about in this video remains untouched after controversy blew up people began looking for other broken keywords in the YouTube algorithm and a lot were found over the years the first of which being this Arab [13:21] phrase which roughly translates to a woman claiming to be mared days of my life searching this on YouTube again brings up only videos with titles that match this phrase almost identically for whatever reason the shipost factor in [13:35] these videos seems to be much higher than the full stop punctuation videos thing you might find on any random shipost video subred but that being said this Niche like this one this video was uploaded in 2021 and [13:52] has only 150 views which I guess would qualify it for my unwatch horror series we can see two different skinny and dirty figures moving in a very stiff and unusual way seemingly not being affected by gravity the source for this one was [14:06] pretty easy to track down this is a special effects test for the 2012 horror movie Mama there's another related Arabic search term that has its own weird nich associated with it this one translates to a woman claiming to be the [14:19] Virgin Mary is married to Christ the content here is more of the same teenage brain rot and not really worth watching I'm not too sure what the deal is with they're both relating to women claiming to be mother Mary I also don't know why [14:33] searching these doesn't bring up any actual Arab content some of these videos do contain Arabic but I'm fairly certain these are still Clips made by westerners trying to produce surreal memes this really is just another broken corner of [14:46] have been fairly tame the next one we're going to look at is a little darker to get to the following section of YouTube you need to type in this nonsensical string of characters into the search bar doing so will bring up again only videos [15:02] that match this phrase almost identically the trick with this niche in particular is that these videos are for the most part all clickbait the thumbnails all look very creepy and eye-catching but upon clicking the video [15:15] you'll end up seeing something completely unrelated usually some brain Rod ship post videos made for children now don't get me wrong there are some pretty creepy videos as well like whatever this is supposed to be but the [15:28] the problem here is not so much the videos themselves it's the thumbnails While most of them are just creepy images some take it a step further and use screenshots from actual gore videos and I don't just mean [15:41] screenshots taken before the violence happens this video for example has a thumbnail that shows a real extremely mutilated body taken right from bestcore.com this sort of thing just shouldn't be on YouTube and as a [15:54] YouTuber it's a little frustrating that I can get demonetized for even just having a word in a thumbnail while these videos get away with using actual Gore photos and not even getting an age restriction there are a few other weird [16:06] niches created by YouTube algorithm glitches but all these mostly follow the formats set up by the three we've already looked at except for one that's completely different which will also be our final topic for this [16:18] our final topic for this video on May 18th 2019 a user on forch following post okay so I type TR PF random keys on [16:30] the keyboard on the YouTube search because I was bored then I pressed back and I got these very weird suggestions from YouTube where the hell do they come recording of the autocomplete [16:44] suggestions they got after typing in Tri GF which appears to be similar to fullstop punctuation the op goes on to say that they tried some other words but nothing gave the same strange results as Tri GF except for an alternate spelling [16:58] of the same nonsense word trfg which supposedly resulted in weirder searching this on YouTube apparently results in six different uploads of the same 6-second video well the version linked on the 4chan post has [17:14] been taken down one of the other uploads is still live this video is a clip from the movie Elf with a text reading you did it congratulations the Opie ends a post with a different and even Stranger video [17:28] they found bar the same title this clip is just audio and visual static and nothing else for 30 seconds these videos on their own are strange but not really any more unusual than the other stuff we've looked at today and people in the [17:41] Paranormal thread would uncover more strange things about these accounts like the fact that they were all seemingly posting random social media gifts with nonsense titles the next day the 4chan threads op would write essentially the [17:54] exact same post but this time to the conspiracy subreddit and with a lot more information this time in this post they claim to have come across a lot of messed up stuff by searching TR GF on YouTube but people quickly noticed that [18:08] they themselves could not replicate these results going back to the forchan thread there are some weird videos that people came across here like this video that appears to show a body in a bathtub and which has some coordinance in its [18:20] and which has some coordinance in its description but wait this video is description but wait this video is unlisted how exactly was this discovered just kind of posted here randomly without any kind of explanation as to [18:33] how it was found in fact all of the creepy stuff in this thread just kind of appear there without any explanation as to how it was connected to anything else to understand what's going on here we need to understand what the goal of an [18:47] ARG is an alternate reality game is essentially trying to replicate a story or a mystery in reality so that they appear no different than a real internet Vlogs tried to make their ARG appear like a real Vlog channel that had [19:02] something wrong with it Allan tutorial tried to make their Channel seem like an actual tutorial channel that had something wrong with it Tri GF attempted to make a fake anomaly in the YouTube algorithm but what's interesting here is [19:16] that this ARG may have been what originally sparked interest in algorithm anomalies in the first place I can't find an earlier example of someone pointing out the strange things you see when you search for an emoji or a period [19:28] on YouTube and I wouldn't be surprised if all the rumors of gore videos and the other illegal content you can find by searching these terms all stem from this ARG by the way if you want to learn more about this ARG I recommend watching [19:40] night faar's recent video about the topic I think these anomalies in the YouTube algorithm always seem a little scarier than they actually are while it weird videos with nonsense titles the [19:52] is group and promote content in an unnatural way and that content is generally just low effort slop posted with the sole intention of cashing in on the malfunction I've yet to see a single original piece of content with any kind [20:06] of value in any of these niches it's all just the same few creepy videos copy and pasted endlessly all right guys I hope you enjoyed the video and I hope you have a good night thanks for watching and thanks again to Deli for sponsoring [20:19] this video to get your data removed from the internet check out Del me via the the internet check out Del me via the link in the description and get 20% off