---
title: 'Climate Sceptics Call It a Scandal. They Have a Point.'
source: 'https://youtube.com/watch?v=15PV7qn8Phg'
video_id: '15PV7qn8Phg'
date: 2026-11-11
duration_sec: 434
channel: 'Sabine Hossenfelder'
---

# Climate Sceptics Call It a Scandal. They Have a Point.

> Source: [Climate Sceptics Call It a Scandal. They Have a Point.](https://youtube.com/watch?v=15PV7qn8Phg)

## Summary

The video examines the controversy surrounding a July report by the US National Academies of Sciences (NAS) on extreme event attribution, which climate sceptics have labeled a scandal. The creator argues that while the report is not outright wrong, it avoids addressing fundamental mathematical flaws in the methodology and is compromised by the political advocacy of its authors.

### Key Points

- **Sceptics' accusations** [00:00] — Climate sceptics, including David Zaruk and Roger Pielke, have called the NAS report on extreme event attribution a 'scandal' and 'Climate Science’s Fatal Mistake,' with some comparing it to 'climategate.'
- **Purpose of event attribution** [00:47] — Event attribution aims to quantify how much climate change made a specific disaster (e.g., flood) more likely, potentially enabling lawsuits against fossil fuel companies or governments.
- **Scientists' legal ambitions** [01:13] — Many scientists involved in event attribution openly pursue legal action. Myles Allen's 2003 paper is titled 'Liability for Climate Change,' and Friederike Otto has discussed using attribution as a litigation tool.
- **Conflicts of interest** [01:55] — The NAS report was authored by 14 scientists, several with ties to the World Weather Attribution group, and funded partly by the Bezos Earth Fund, which also supports that group.
- **Methodological flaws** [02:56] — The creator identifies key problems: assuming global warming is the main cause, poor model performance for extremes, and the dependence of probability on event definition, which can lead to 'zero to zero' comparisons.
- **Creator's verdict** [04:38] — The creator agrees with sceptics that the NAS 'f*cked up' by not clearly calling out the mathematical issues, instead giving a platform to scientists with a political cause, which erodes public trust in science.

### Conclusion

The video concludes that the NAS report missed an opportunity to address fundamental flaws in event attribution, instead appearing to support a political agenda, which damages public trust in science.

## Transcript

Climate sceptics have been raising the alarm&nbsp; about a scientific scandal. David Zaruk,&nbsp;&nbsp; a retired professor for science communication,&nbsp; has called it “Climate Science’s Fatal Mistake.”&nbsp;&nbsp;
Roger Pielke, a political scientist and former&nbsp; professor, called it a “scandal” that “is just&nbsp;&nbsp; the tip of the iceberg.” Various commentators have&nbsp; called it “an organized crime,” “a felony,” “coup&nbsp;&nbsp; d'état,” and atmospheric scientist Judith Curry&nbsp; called it “Worse than climategate” and next week&nbsp;&nbsp;
they’ll call for NATO to intervene. So today we’re&nbsp; going to have a look at what this is all about. This stink has been raised after the US&nbsp; American National Academies of Sciences,&nbsp;&nbsp; NAS for short, released a report about extreme&nbsp; event attribution in July. That’s the idea that&nbsp;&nbsp;
one can quantify how much more likely climate&nbsp; change made a disastrous event like a flood,&nbsp;&nbsp; sue fossil fuel companies or governments&nbsp; for their failure to stop climate change.
The issue the sceptics have is only superficially&nbsp; about the report itself. Mostly their issue is&nbsp;&nbsp; that many scientists involved in this event&nbsp; attribution are openly striving to pursue&nbsp;&nbsp;
legal action. This isn’t much of a secret. Myles&nbsp; Allen, who came up with the very idea of event&nbsp;&nbsp; attribution in 2003, literally has it in the&nbsp; title of his paper which reads “Liability for&nbsp;&nbsp;
Climate Change.” Friederike Otto, who, I believe,&nbsp; was a postdoc of Allen, later went to join the&nbsp;&nbsp; World Weather Attribution Centre, has openly said&nbsp; in an interview with E&amp;E that, quote “she talks&nbsp;&nbsp;
‘a lot with lawyers’ about how attribution&nbsp; science could be used as a litigation tool.” And if you look at the report from the&nbsp; National Academy, it’s been authored by&nbsp;&nbsp; a select group of 14 scientists. Several of&nbsp; them have known ties to the World Weather&nbsp;&nbsp;
Attribution staff or legislation effort.&nbsp; The report received funding, among others,&nbsp;&nbsp; from the Bezos Earth Fund, which also supports&nbsp; the World Weather Attribution business. This is why Zaruk calls it the “Climate&nbsp; Attribution Cabal,” Pielke writes “it would&nbsp;&nbsp;
be fair to ask whether the NAS Attribution&nbsp; committee is about science advice at all,&nbsp;&nbsp; or instead, a not-so-subtle form of&nbsp; institutionalized stealth advocacy&nbsp;&nbsp; in support of climate litigation,” and Steven&nbsp; Koonin writes that the NAS “spins an illusion&nbsp;&nbsp;
of elite scientific consensus.” Tim Gallaudet, a&nbsp; retired admiral and oceanographer who served in&nbsp;&nbsp; the Trump administration, says “The new report&nbsp; strays even further from objectivity” than a&nbsp;&nbsp;
previous report that he didn’t like either.&nbsp; And twenty-five Republican state attorneys&nbsp;&nbsp; general have demanded an investigation&nbsp; of the NAS for their lack of objectivity. I had a look at the report, and I&nbsp; understand why these people are unhappy.&nbsp;&nbsp;
It’s not that the report is outright wrong.&nbsp; It’s that it’s a masterpiece of avoidance. The extreme event attribution business basically&nbsp; works like this. You take a specific extreme&nbsp;&nbsp;
weather event, quantify it in some way, and take&nbsp; a bunch of climate models. You run the models&nbsp;&nbsp; once with and once without global warming&nbsp; and compare the probabilities, basically.&nbsp;&nbsp;
This gives you an idea of how much climate&nbsp; change has contributed to the event. Maybe. The first problem is that you have to assume&nbsp; that the main difference comes from global&nbsp;&nbsp; warming. You can read this in a paper from&nbsp; Otto and collaborators, where they say “It&nbsp;&nbsp;
is assumed that the main changes in the&nbsp; distribution are due to global warming.” But often there are many other factors&nbsp; that contribute, sometimes significantly.&nbsp;&nbsp; For example, wildfire risk also depends&nbsp; on changes in land use or controlled burns&nbsp;&nbsp;
and so on. Another issue is that many&nbsp; of the existing climate models aren’t&nbsp;&nbsp; particularly good at predicting&nbsp; extreme events in the first place. My main beef is though that the probability you&nbsp; get will depend on how you define the event.&nbsp;&nbsp;
The more details you add about the event,&nbsp;&nbsp; the less likely it will become until&nbsp; eventually you are comparing zero to zero. There is pretty good evidence that climate&nbsp; change does impact trends of certain extreme&nbsp;&nbsp;
events. But making definite statements&nbsp; about the counterfactual probability of&nbsp;&nbsp; a particular event not occurring is, in my&nbsp; opinion, ill-defined mathematical nonsense.&nbsp;&nbsp; There is no amount of equations that will&nbsp; make this fundamental problem go away. It’s&nbsp;&nbsp;
not that I think climate change doesn’t&nbsp; happen or that I think it’s not man-made&nbsp;&nbsp; or that we shouldn’t worry about it. I think&nbsp; this event attribution business is bad maths. And where the 2016 NAS report clearly said that&nbsp; “the answers obtained are no longer directly&nbsp;&nbsp;
about the actual event” the new report vaguely&nbsp; says “Observations are typically insufficient&nbsp;&nbsp; to validate model-based estimates of event&nbsp; probabilities” and somewhere in their academic&nbsp;&nbsp; word salad they acknowledge that probabilities can&nbsp; differ wildly depending on how you calculate them.
In summary, I am sorry, but I agree that the NAS&nbsp; f*cked up. They had a chance to clearly call out&nbsp;&nbsp; how mathematically questionable this procedure is&nbsp; and they didn’t. Instead, they gave a platform to&nbsp;&nbsp;
a bunch of people with a political cause. This&nbsp; is the exact reason why people lose trust in&nbsp;&nbsp; scientists. Perhaps the National Academy should&nbsp; investigate how much this report contributed&nbsp;&nbsp; to the loss of public trust in science. Though I&nbsp; suspect they’d have difficulty defining the event.
I read a lot of news to keep you well informed&nbsp; and the most useful and time-saving way I found&nbsp;&nbsp; to do this is with Ground News, who've been&nbsp; sponsoring this video. Ground News is a news&nbsp;&nbsp;
platform that collects news from all over the&nbsp; world. It really saves me a lot of time because&nbsp;&nbsp; I don't have to sort through a dozen headlines on&nbsp; the same story. I can just get a quick summary of&nbsp;&nbsp;
all the coverage. And Ground News also gives&nbsp; you a lot of extra information at one glance.&nbsp;&nbsp; Take for example this recent story about&nbsp; scientists leaving the United States due&nbsp;&nbsp; to lack of funding. This received very little&nbsp; coverage on the political right. And Ground News&nbsp;&nbsp;
also has this bias comparison that tells you that&nbsp; the left-leaning coverage focuses on fears about&nbsp;&nbsp; future funding and academic freedom. Whereas the&nbsp; right leaning coverage emphasizes scale. Ground&nbsp;&nbsp;
News also gives you a factuality check on each&nbsp; news item which in this case is overall high.&nbsp;&nbsp; You can also see who owns the media outlets and&nbsp; where the news has appeared. I found this to be&nbsp;&nbsp; super useful for checking whether stories being&nbsp; blown out of proportion, ignored or distorted.&nbsp;&nbsp;
And of course, I have a special offer for you.&nbsp; That's a 40% discount on the Vantage plan,&nbsp;&nbsp; which gives you access to all their features. All&nbsp; you need to do is use my link ground.news/sabine&nbsp;&nbsp;
or use the QR code so they'll know I sent&nbsp; you. Thanks for watching. See you tomorrow.
