[0:00] the world hasn't split into good people [0:03] and death eaters we've all got both [0:05] light [0:06] and dark inside of us are you sure about [0:08] that [0:09] ah the four hogwarts houses a [0:11] cornerstone of harry potter iconography [0:13] a lucrative engine that powers a lot of [0:15] the brand's merchandise [0:17] these symbols and colors are tattooed [0:19] onto my cerebral cortex forever [0:21] they are a smart simple piece of world [0:23] building functioning as a question a [0:25] jumping off point to inspire children to [0:27] imagine themselves attend in a wizard [0:29] school doing you know wizard things like [0:31] not receiving a well-rounded education [0:33] the hogwarts houses are [0:35] if memes are to be believed gryffindor [0:38] smart yellow and last but not least [0:42] evil despite my love for harry potter [0:44] i've always been more interested in the [0:45] characters and i adore the general [0:47] setting but i have a lot of issues with [0:48] the world building that stem from [0:50] problems in the books [0:51] some of it's kind of funny and mostly [0:53] harmless like rowling's really bad at [0:55] math and it creates a lot of [0:57] embarrassing mistakes [0:58] other times it's infuriating like the [1:01] house elves that love being slaves until [1:03] you beat them too much [1:05] and the biggest subplot involving [1:06] freeing them is more about how hermione [1:08] did activism wrong by ignoring the [1:11] people she was advocating for [1:13] you know you gotta listen to people when [1:14] you're advocating for them [1:16] so you know just accept that the [1:17] hogwarts kitchen is filled with sentient [1:19] creatures that keep insisting they love [1:21] being slaves [1:23] that video will be like therapy i get [1:24] paid for today we're diving into [1:26] something much more [1:27] gray elusive slithery we're talking [1:30] about the handling of slytherin house [1:32] did rolling botch it is hogwarts or the [1:35] story itself [1:35] biased against slytherin is it [1:37] unrealistic can you intelligently [1:39] explain why [1:40] all the bad guys seem to share a dorm as [1:42] children or is it just indicative of jk [1:43] rowling's inability to see [1:45] evil in the brave the intelligent and [1:47] the well-meaning and are fans drowning [1:49] in their head cannons [1:51] all of it argued by a slytherin oh yes [1:53] pottermore certified [1:55] i was a snake the whole time so if i [1:57] start arguing slytherin might need [1:59] big reforms or a big thanos snap well [2:02] it's nothing personal kid [2:04] i got skin in the game too not really [2:06] that's a lie [2:07] i got a comfy hot topic sweatshirt in [2:09] the game so let's start with an easy [2:11] question [2:12] is slytherin really the evil house [2:15] chapter one yes they really are the evil [2:17] house and not our dark academia fantasy [2:19] i know it sucks i hate it too [2:22] a lot of slytherins are morally [2:23] complicated people who fell off the path [2:25] of good but forget those melodramatic [2:27] attention hogs for a minute [2:29] just who's the average everyday [2:31] slytherin student [2:33] well some harry potter fans try [2:36] so hard to rehabilitate slytherin house [2:38] they will make memes and lengthy posts [2:40] about how slytherin traits could [2:42] hypothetically produce a good person [2:44] they paint this picture of an ambitious [2:46] cunning sarcastic friend who tells you [2:48] like it is but because of the fraternity [2:50] trait is delightfully biased in your [2:52] favor [2:52] and wants to undermine your enemies with [2:54] ceptifuge so that you can reign together [2:56] and sip black coffee in your dark [2:58] academia hallways and then run through [3:00] spiraling dark green hedge mazes [3:02] anyone who got into harry potter from [3:04] seeing these posts would be [3:06] disappointed by the books even if you've [3:08] never been exposed to filthy fandom [3:10] propaganda i think [3:11] most people on a gut level react to this [3:14] situation [3:15] with a healthy spoonful of skepticism [3:18] they go [3:18] no what even is this a den of evil [3:21] children [3:22] it must be more complicated than that [3:24] and if it [3:25] isn't it should be in any fandom [3:28] especially such an old one people get [3:30] bored and they just start playing with [3:31] the universe [3:32] as if it was a toy even with no new [3:34] material they can hype themselves up by [3:36] making their own fun [3:37] using their creativity so people [3:39] dedicate entire blogs to for example [3:41] pansy parkinson [3:42] except to them pansy is the idea of a [3:44] slytherin girl fueled mostly by the [3:46] premise that rich [3:46] ambitious girls with jet black bobs look [3:49] cool and you want to kiss them [3:50] fans find great pleasure in pulling [3:52] something complete out of tiny details [3:54] that differentiate them from each other [3:56] so a character like pansy is an original [3:58] character wearing the skin of a minor [4:00] character [4:01] this is how the fandom's concept of [4:02] slytherin evolves and is actually more [4:04] complex and morally grey than the canon [4:06] reality of slytherin the canon has very [4:09] few grey characters and almost no good [4:11] ones [4:11] and you can contrast that against the [4:13] fact that there are almost no [4:14] antagonists from other houses there are [4:16] technically three but really there's two [4:19] the average slytherin student harry [4:21] attended hogwarts with from gregory [4:23] goyal to theodore not in the movies is a [4:25] blurry blob of bullies cheaters and bad [4:28] attitudes [4:29] this is so true that when goyle's actor [4:30] josh herdman got his arm herded during [4:32] the third movie they just swapped him [4:34] out with another slytherin boy [4:36] when krabs actor jaime whalett got [4:38] arrested for growing marijuana the [4:39] movies were like okay well if you're [4:41] gonna blaze it then we're gonna blaze it [4:42] too and then blaze became the guy [4:44] standing opposite de goyle in malfoy's [4:46] squad [4:47] in fact goyle got to take crab's place [4:49] in the fiery grave because it just [4:51] doesn't matter which one of them dies [4:53] the cliff notes is just draco got to see [4:55] his friend who didn't pull out of evil [4:57] at the last second perish [4:58] so just kill the spare i i mean the one [5:01] that got the most screen time [5:02] the bad guy cannon fodder basically i've [5:05] seen people try to argue well the books [5:06] are told from harry's perspective and [5:08] he's biased and that's true but harry is [5:10] not such an unreliable narrator as to [5:12] make up dialogue for other people [5:14] this argument falls flat for me when a [5:15] slytherin student opens up their mouth [5:17] and the only thing they have to say for [5:19] themselves is lol mudblood or lol blood [5:21] traitor [5:21] or and i love this example it baffles me [5:24] in the sixth book [5:25] blaise savini unlike draco malfoy gets [5:28] into the slug club and elbow-rubbing [5:30] dinner party club presumably because [5:32] professor slughorn the club runner has [5:34] no reason to suspect his family are [5:36] death eater aligned but [5:38] rowling can't help herself so blaze is a [5:41] dismissive jerk the entire night he does [5:43] a rude skepticism cough at slughorn [5:45] suggesting harry survived the night of [5:47] his parents death because he may be [5:49] extraordinary in some way and for some [5:51] mind-blowing reason he somehow manages [5:53] to info dump that his famously hot mom [5:56] has been married seven times and her [5:57] rich husbands keep dropping dead under [5:59] mysterious circumstances [6:01] how did he even do that how did he just [6:04] announce [6:04] that he's indifferent to the fact that [6:06] his mom is a serial killer [6:08] what could he have possibly said that [6:10] caused this [6:11] big of a misunderstanding in harry's [6:13] mind i don't even think it's a good joke [6:15] it's just like okay i get it they're all [6:17] bad [6:18] haha it's so funny there were [6:20] opportunities to introduce a good or [6:22] just [6:22] neutral minor slytherin student and it [6:25] just never happens [6:26] i'll give you a couple examples the [6:28] first one will be what i'll call a big [6:29] ask and the second one is like a little [6:32] ask [6:33] so and this is a popular like fandom [6:35] idea [6:36] hypothetically what if the hogwarts [6:38] champion in goblet of fire was a [6:40] slytherin [6:40] now this choice would be a shame since [6:42] it's taking away one of hufflepuff's few [6:44] times to shine [6:46] but people argue this would be the [6:47] perfect way to conclude the later half [6:49] of the series and i agree [6:50] if cedric diggory or a hypothetical [6:53] other hogwarts champion was a nice [6:55] slytherin boy who was killed in front of [6:57] harry just as he was starting to warm up [6:58] to him [6:59] that collapses harry's whole world view [7:02] of slytherin bad [7:03] gryffindor good after all the entire [7:05] conflict is just the kiddie pool version [7:07] of what's going on with the adults [7:09] right in the adult wizarding world it [7:12] doesn't matter if he's team [7:14] snake if to voldemort he's just another [7:16] blood traitor [7:17] then there are decisions that seem much [7:19] more about realism that require [7:21] very little effort nothing as big as an [7:23] important character being in slytherin [7:25] in the order of the phoenix dumbledore's [7:27] army didn't make use of [7:28] any slytherins this was one of the first [7:31] times harry got to hang out with people [7:32] outside of his house for an extended [7:35] project but [7:35] no slytherins joined in fact they seemed [7:38] to team up with dolores and filch [7:40] inexplicably everyone in the house tied [7:43] to [7:44] all magical families and ambition [7:45] doesn't care that their school which [7:47] they need to make themselves more [7:48] powerful [7:49] is turning into some type of muggle [7:50] school where they don't practice magic [7:52] in class [7:53] this is a very clear betrayal of what [7:55] their house stands for and just their [7:56] general cultural values [7:58] and doing something like this creating [8:00] secret classes in a hidden location that [8:02] seems [8:03] very slytherin i think this displays the [8:05] strange relationship harry potter as a [8:07] series has with the hogwarts houses [8:10] they take up so much time and oxygen and [8:12] shelf space [8:14] and yet while some significant [8:15] characters come from other houses [8:17] really it's only two houses that matter [8:19] but when you get a little bit closer [8:21] actually it's just one it makes [8:23] everything seem a bit more mechanical it [8:24] breaks the illusion that hogwarts is a [8:26] big place filled with unique students [8:29] well they're not all bad that would i i [8:33] know i've said this before and i think i [8:34] said it to emerson they are not [8:36] all bad and and well far from it as we [8:39] know [8:41] i would feel bad about avoiding talking [8:43] about specific slytherin characters who [8:45] do good things i don't want you to feel [8:47] like i'm skipping over them because it's [8:48] inconvenient [8:49] so let's talk about them a lot [8:53] a lot a lot let's start out with the [8:55] most upstanding snakes snakes can't [8:58] stand or are they always standing [9:00] just the good normal guys no morally [9:02] gray cutie pies [9:04] i have set the bar for unimpeachable [9:06] goodness at the truly unreasonable [9:08] standard of [9:09] was never a blood supremacist or death [9:11] eater gee willikers let's see who clears [9:13] it first up we got merlin a wizard who [9:15] thought wizard kind should be helping [9:17] muggle kind and he was in slytherin he [9:19] was probably in the first [9:21] class ever because he's as old as dirk [9:24] you know merlin [9:25] as a collectible in the harry potter [9:27] video games and not as an actual [9:28] character in the story [9:30] hey harry remember me wrong weasley [9:33] hello harry it's me hagrid the harry [9:36] potter wiki claims he is mentioned in [9:38] almost every book and movie but that's [9:40] because his name [9:41] is a wizard swear that's a great snake [9:43] right there it takes a pet like no [9:45] problem [9:46] right not afraid at all and then we have [9:49] andromeda [9:50] tonks she's nymphadora tonks's mother no [9:52] movie fans don't leave me [9:54] okay don't get scared stick with the [9:56] most popular guys all right [9:57] draco's mother has two sisters one is [10:00] bellatrix lestrange and the other is [10:02] andromeda who is disowned from marrying [10:04] a muggle-born wizard and she's cool [10:06] she's an example of how pure blood [10:08] families socially control each other to [10:10] keep their pureblood status [10:11] they commonly use disownment as a threat [10:14] finally horus slughorn is the closest [10:16] thing to a normal slytherin in the [10:18] entire series [10:19] he was introduced late he's a socialite [10:21] who loves throwing parties [10:23] he doesn't like conflict but he has a [10:25] good heart and he comes through for [10:26] harry [10:27] in the books he is casually blood racist [10:29] in a bigotry of low [10:31] expectations sort of way towards [10:33] muggleborns but this dialogue is cut [10:35] from the half-blood prince movie making [10:36] slughorn i think [10:38] the only never blood racist named [10:41] slytherin character [10:42] in the movie series wow it doesn't even [10:46] end there they expanded on slughorn's [10:48] relationship with lily [10:49] he expresses the shame he feels how he [10:52] feels responsible [10:53] for voldemort's creation just because he [10:55] gave tom information about horcruxes [10:58] this is a student asking him about some [11:00] pretty forbidden [11:01] sketchy information but watching this [11:04] scene i can't help but feel that [11:05] horus was taken advantage of despite the [11:08] fact that he's desperately trying to run [11:10] from his mistakes out of shame [11:12] and the fact that he can come off as [11:13] kind of a airy socialite [11:16] i think he's actually a very sweet man [11:18] so there he is the good slytherin [11:20] he's good slytherin he's a good boy look [11:22] at him [11:23] wow so guess what guys i was wrong [11:27] in slughorn's first appearance he does [11:29] the same thing he did in the books and i [11:31] forgot [11:31] while i stand by my overview of him no [11:34] he doesn't belong in this category [11:36] anymore [11:37] so that's it he was the best i had he [11:39] was the only one that was a real [11:41] character and i was wrong [11:42] even he couldn't survive the standard i [11:45] set it's just ridiculous and in case [11:47] you're curious [11:48] even dolores umbridge was in slytherin [11:51] i just moving on [11:54] some people however fell off the path of [11:56] good and wandered back onto it [11:58] what do the death eater defectors say [12:00] about the moral character of slytherin [12:02] house [12:03] regulus black the betrayer of voldemort [12:06] sacrificed his life to destroy a horcrux [12:08] a thing [12:09] voldemort put a slice of his soul into [12:11] to be immortal [12:12] regulus inexplicably knew the horcrux [12:14] existed and where to find it to precious [12:16] secrets of a very [12:18] violent and suspicious man but he [12:20] doesn't appear on screen so the only [12:22] canon picture i have of him to show you [12:24] is this picture of a picture [12:26] his presence in the story is kind of [12:27] tenuous especially in the movies [12:30] when you google image search's name [12:31] you'll be hit with a wall of models [12:33] people use to represent him [12:35] he is a flash in the pan plot point more [12:38] of a mood board than a man [12:40] regulus reflects this idea of a renegade [12:42] death eater betrayer distraught and [12:44] disillusioned trying to find a scrap of [12:46] redemption to undo some of the harm [12:48] they've caused to the world [12:50] but i think truthfully he more so [12:52] reflects the idea that [12:53] sad pale-faced pretty boys with dark [12:56] hair [12:56] look cool and you want to kiss them i'm [12:58] about to pull some points i made in my [13:00] draco video to make this one a [13:02] standalone but it's good you should [13:03] watch it [13:04] unlike some other characters more [13:05] praised for their redemption arcs [13:07] draco's actions in deathly hallows are [13:09] more about [13:09] small inactions moments where he [13:12] passively resists [13:13] and then he and his parents shrink into [13:16] the shadows because voldemort can no [13:17] longer ensure their safety or power and [13:20] the only thing the malfoys truly love [13:22] is each other there is no concrete [13:24] evidence that draco harbors a heart of [13:26] gold [13:27] there is only evidence that he is much [13:29] more sensitive than he appears [13:31] these aspects of himself that he's [13:32] likely ashamed of combined with harry's [13:35] gryffindor nature [13:36] and those key moments where he passively [13:38] resist voldemort are the reasons why he [13:40] survived the events of the story [13:42] unfortunately draco's reform is largely [13:45] off screen the biggest one is raising [13:48] his son scorpius to be [13:50] normal and not a blood supremacist a [13:52] fact that's not even clear in the book's [13:54] epilogue [13:55] it was just assumed and brought up on [13:57] pottermore [13:58] the wizarding world there is definitely [14:00] symbolism that this is not [14:02] draco's true self but it's not explored [14:04] in any detail [14:05] rowling doesn't seem to like draco much [14:08] less like him enough to weave a [14:09] redemption arc into the story for him [14:11] he and his fellow slytherin friends are [14:14] stand-ins for posh bullies she faced in [14:16] her childhood [14:17] narratively he's a foil or he's a mini [14:19] boss in the early installments of harry [14:22] potter to give harry something to worry [14:23] about and compete with [14:25] he also teaches us about wizard [14:27] supremacy culture [14:28] let me teach you about wizard crackers [14:31] and it's sort of that simple most of the [14:32] people on voldemort's side are kind of [14:34] underdeveloped even though it'd be more [14:36] interesting to many people if they [14:38] weren't [14:38] but there is one slytherin rolling seems [14:41] to like [14:41] quite a bit snipe snipe [14:45] severus snipe snipe snipe [14:49] severus snipe to promote deathly hallows [14:53] the bookstore borders before they were [14:55] all closed down had these promotional [14:57] bookmarks and stickers they gave out [14:59] that would say things like [15:00] trust snape and snape is very bad man [15:04] he's very bad draco was actually held in [15:06] higher regard by the fandom than snape [15:09] probably because he was a teenager when [15:10] all of that went down and he raised his [15:12] son to not have brain worms [15:14] snape is more complicated severus snape [15:17] is sometimes considered to be [15:19] the most emotionally complex character [15:21] in the series [15:22] and he is sometimes considered to be a [15:23] hot mess with an inadequate redemption [15:25] arc that breaks its own hand [15:27] patting itself on the back because how [15:29] much can you really redeem a character [15:30] who spends most of his screen time and [15:33] word count [15:33] bullying children as time marches on i'm [15:36] confronted with what i see [15:37] as a failing unrollings part to make the [15:40] audience see what she sees [15:42] i feel more and more alone in my genuine [15:44] like of snape as a character beyond [15:47] appreciating alan rickman's acting [15:49] it seems like every year since the last [15:50] movie came out snape has been rotting in [15:53] the public consciousness [15:54] snape will you accept us rose fine [15:57] but wear this always i've observed the [16:01] fandom do this slow [16:03] penguin waddle from what i consider to [16:04] be the canon reality of snape or even a [16:07] candy-coated version of that reality too [16:10] uh how do i put this delicately snape is [16:13] literally an [16:14] in-cell he's got a simp patronus a [16:16] simptronis [16:17] if you will it's all because he's [16:18] obsessed with lily he got friend zoned [16:20] by harry's mom [16:21] in wizard high school how is that a [16:23] redemption arc [16:24] okay listen with that kind of mindset [16:26] you can make any story sound stupid [16:28] snape is notably divorced from most [16:30] slytherin redemption squad conversations [16:32] even though he's the head of slytherin [16:33] house and is a very slytherin slytherin [16:36] but let's start here maybe this is a [16:37] flaw in the writing or something to keep [16:39] in mind when reading or writing a story [16:41] the last thing a character does before [16:43] they die is not necessarily what redeems [16:45] them but i think people feel [16:47] emotionally that that is the case in [16:49] their guts [16:50] the part of the flashback that shows the [16:52] beginning of snape becoming a spy is not [16:54] even technically presenting a reveal at [16:56] all [16:57] harry learns that snape was a spy in [16:59] what goblet of fire what about snape [17:01] severus snape of the council that's very [17:03] much aware of giving evidence on this [17:04] matter [17:05] several snape was indeed a death eater [17:07] and prior to lord voldemort's downfall [17:09] turned [17:10] spy for us at great personal risk [17:12] today's no more a death [17:18] therefore learning that snape truly was [17:20] always on harry's side [17:21] gets overshadowed by the more emotional [17:24] surprising personal tragedy of his [17:26] unrequited love for [17:28] lily evans potter snape's feelings for [17:30] lily are context into his behavior [17:32] elaborating on what we learned about him [17:34] in the order of the phoenix when it was [17:36] made known that harry's father and his [17:37] friends were bullies [17:39] harry's dad hexed people for fun and [17:41] they were obsessed with ganging up on [17:43] snape [17:43] if you think snape loving lily doesn't [17:44] redeem him you're not wrong but i'm not [17:46] sure if it was meant to [17:48] the redemption arc is he's been a spy [17:50] for nearly 17 years in a world where [17:51] people can read your mind if you're not [17:53] careful [17:53] part of being a spy was killing the only [17:56] person who knew him on a personal level [17:58] the only person that [17:59] actually saw him for what he was there [18:01] is clear development that happens [18:03] between 21 year old snape begging [18:05] dumbledore to hide the potters or at [18:06] least lily [18:07] and the 37ish year old snape horrified [18:10] that dumbledore has known the whole time [18:12] that harry was gonna have to die for the [18:13] war to end [18:14] quite frankly i find this information [18:15] delivered in a way that's confusing in [18:17] the movie especially for all of the [18:19] people that are probably just gonna see [18:20] the movie once or twice [18:22] i mean twice alan rickman although he [18:24] made snape so iconic is 20 years older [18:26] than the character he's playing [18:28] and since snape and dumbledore basically [18:30] look the same it almost looks like [18:32] they're wearing the same outfits [18:34] i don't think you feel the weight of how [18:35] much time has passed and how much snape [18:37] has changed [18:38] not from mean man too nice man but his [18:41] moral fiber [18:42] he's put in the work and i actually [18:44] think it's the epilogue that's the final [18:46] nail in the coffin for people that feel [18:48] salty about snape when harry named his [18:50] son albus severus potter people felt [18:52] snape was disproportionately rewarded [18:54] for his bad behavior if you're not [18:56] impressed with snape this is a story [18:58] where a character built around a [18:59] decade-spanning redemption arc did not [19:01] redeem himself because he couldn't stop [19:03] being awful to children and to rub salt [19:05] in the wound he is honored after his [19:06] death in favor of others which is a [19:08] recipe for resentment [19:10] if harry needed a middle name for his [19:11] son there are many characters in the [19:13] story that served as a paternal figure [19:15] to him [19:16] snape is not even breaking the top 5 and [19:18] there are other dead men on that list [19:20] for me personally i think it does imply [19:22] an interesting emotional maturity harry [19:24] has after the war [19:26] but here's something that honestly does [19:27] bother me i can look at snape and [19:28] because he's a fictional character i can [19:30] go [19:31] oh what a fascinating broken man yes i [19:33] loved the time i spent reading about [19:35] severus snape [19:36] but i don't think people treat people in [19:38] their life like that [19:40] children grow to see the complexity and [19:41] motivations of their authority figures [19:43] but they usually don't honor teachers [19:45] that bully them [19:46] i've heard of that behavior before but [19:48] that kind of attachment seems more [19:49] common [19:50] in trying to sort your feelings out [19:52] about an abusive or kind of lackluster [19:55] parent [19:56] so it always kind of felt to me like [19:57] rowling worked backwards from the [19:59] premise oh wouldn't it be cool if harry [20:01] named his son after that teacher that he [20:03] hated [20:04] and like that's true it would be wild if [20:06] you told someone after reading the first [20:08] few books that harry was gonna name his [20:10] son after snape [20:11] but i don't think he got where it needed [20:13] to be after snape dies and deathly [20:15] hallows harry doesn't have much internal [20:17] dialogue about how he's [20:19] processing the meaning of snape's death [20:21] to him [20:22] the descriptions are very matter-of-fact [20:24] about it and it's not like rowling's [20:26] incapable of writing emotionally deep [20:28] deaths [20:28] let me read something to you this is one [20:30] of my favorite passages in the whole [20:31] series [20:32] this is when harry goes to see [20:33] dumbledore's dead body and half blood [20:35] prince [20:36] then he gazed down at the wise old face [20:38] and tried to absorb [20:40] the enormous and incomprehensible truth [20:43] that never again would dumbledore speak [20:45] to him [20:46] never again could he help [20:49] i always really loved this i like how it [20:51] speaks to loss [20:52] and i like how the first thing harry has [20:54] to process is how death has robbed [20:56] dumbledore of his ability to speak to [20:58] him both you know [20:59] those moments where dumbledore says [21:00] silly whimsical things but also his [21:02] ability to protect and give wisdom [21:05] so going into deathly hallows you can [21:06] feel it you feel that safety net is just [21:09] gone the only person voldemort was [21:11] afraid of is dead [21:12] so it's this beautiful summarization of [21:15] harry's relationship to dumbledore [21:17] snape's death scene on the other hand [21:18] it's written well [21:20] but it's playing this effective [21:21] emotional sleight of hand where for a [21:24] long time i didn't question [21:25] where are harry's thoughts in this scene [21:28] he has no thoughts snape dead head empty [21:30] so this is the ultimate slytherin this [21:33] is the slytherin rowling will fight you [21:34] about on twitter before she'd [21:36] fight you about trans people this is the [21:39] slytherin who makes the greatest [21:41] sacrifice for the forces of good in the [21:42] story and his resume of good deeds is [21:45] not impressing everyone [21:46] and it's because rowling can't help [21:50] herself [21:50] it wasn't enough for him to just be a [21:52] strict intimidating teacher [21:54] he has to be cruel he has to turn a [21:57] blind eye [21:58] to slytherin bullying he has to mock [22:00] hermione's teeth when they're elongated [22:02] by a curse [22:03] he has to threaten to kill neville's pet [22:05] if he doesn't get a potion right so it [22:07] doesn't matter if snape saves harry's [22:08] life multiple times because any adult [22:10] would have done that [22:12] i mean i guess it goes back to [22:13] fundamental lessons right if you [22:15] intend a character to be sympathetic or [22:18] intend to redeem them [22:19] you have to throw in some save the cat [22:21] moments [22:22] you have to be mindful of the [22:24] character's perception [22:25] there's a careful balancing act [22:27] happening here snape sometimes has [22:29] moments where he's scary and getting in [22:31] the way of harry doing stuff but [22:33] upon re-reads he has a genuine reason to [22:35] think harry's up to something [22:37] congratulations your performance in the [22:38] black lake was inspiring [22:41] gillyweed am i correct gillyweed may be [22:43] innocuous but [22:44] boomslang skin lacewing flies [22:49] you and your little friends are brewing [22:51] polyjuice potion and believe me [22:53] i'm going to find out why that's moody [22:55] but then who's [22:58] holly juice potion now we know who's [23:00] been seeding from your store service [23:03] or harry's actually breaking rules and [23:06] of course snape's going gonna give him a [23:07] hard time he's [23:08] a teacher i would have loved to see [23:09] harry reflect more on [23:11] looking guilty or how his relationship [23:13] with his teacher is falling apart [23:14] because of misunderstandings [23:16] i think the reason snape rots every year [23:18] for a lot of people [23:20] is as you grow up you're able to put [23:22] yourself in snape's perspective more [23:24] because you're an adult now [23:25] so you have more of an appreciation for [23:28] how immature he is and how little his [23:30] fixation on harry is justified by the [23:33] narrative [23:33] i want you to imagine that when you [23:36] re-read [23:36] you could see that snape started out [23:39] curious [23:40] about what kind of person this kid was [23:42] he's intimidating and cold but he's not [23:44] really doing anything [23:45] evil besides giving out a lot of [23:47] homework and any adult could recognize [23:50] it's actually harry being judgmental [23:52] because he's thin [23:53] greasy haired all clad in black he's [23:56] described as looking like a giant bat [23:58] imagine if snape had logical reasons to [24:02] think harry was an [24:03] egomaniac who behind the scenes was [24:05] bullying children [24:07] and then he wrote him off and zeroed in [24:10] on him [24:10] then on top of that harry keeps getting [24:12] in trouble the next book he steals that [24:14] car [24:14] and exposes the wizarding world etc etc [24:18] if the inciting incident to this [24:19] toxicity made sense [24:21] harry would have his first encounter [24:22] with being hated by an adult for reasons [24:25] within his control [24:27] instead of what happens in the story [24:29] which is i don't know snape just kind of [24:31] ignores [24:31] all evidence that harry is not pampered [24:34] and the writing almost appeals to this [24:35] persecution complex [24:37] where harry is jesus on the cross and [24:40] snape is heckling him and we're supposed [24:42] to just throw up our hands and go [24:44] well he's traumatized by harry's father [24:46] snape picks on harry the first day for [24:49] not paying attention when in reality [24:50] he's writing everything snape says down [24:53] if snape just peers at his notebook [24:54] he'll see it this is a common mistake [24:57] children make when taking notes [24:58] then he asks a child raised by muggles [25:01] questions about magical ingredients he [25:03] can't possibly know to embarrass him [25:05] this isn't just about being mean this [25:07] character is not supposed to be [25:09] stupid his intelligence is a central [25:12] trait he's not supposed to be [25:14] the dursleys but at school this wasn't [25:16] handled properly [25:17] and at the end of the day the way the [25:19] narrative tries to make him an honorary [25:21] gryffindor because he's [25:23] brave does come off as really weird [25:26] like most people will just say oh my god [25:28] who the hell cares [25:30] and slytherin fans are just gonna be [25:32] like why he's one of the only slytherin [25:34] characters that fits slytherin [25:37] very stan slytherin stands the most [25:39] slytherin slytherin of them all [25:41] and guess what kids being sorted into [25:43] slytherin is directly responsible for [25:45] ruining his life [25:48] slytherin house clearly overwhelmingly [25:50] lacks nuance as almost all the unmoral [25:52] characters come from there [25:53] the few instances of hogwarts attending [25:56] non-slytherin evil [25:57] is a sniveling coward who is the [25:59] antithesis of a gryffindor and [26:01] exemplifies the slytherin trait of [26:03] self-preservation [26:04] and one singular ravenclaw who might [26:07] have ravenclaw motivations it's not [26:09] really explained [26:10] snape comes off like a very obvious [26:11] servant of voldemort in the first book [26:13] so it seems professor quirrell mostly [26:15] existed for the twist [26:17] it's kind of funny that this complexity [26:19] never shows up in the book again [26:21] rowling refuses at every moment big and [26:23] small to just [26:24] allow slytherin students to be normal [26:27] for like five seconds [26:28] the most morally ambiguous slytherin [26:30] characters have redemption arcs that [26:32] much of the fandom is unsatisfied with [26:34] you can make a solid argument that [26:35] they're not even meant to be completely [26:37] redeemed [26:38] just you know humanized and observed as [26:40] complex actors in their story [26:42] good slytherins are almost non-existent [26:44] until you get to the cursed child stage [26:46] play [26:47] they are largely hypothetical fandom [26:49] creations that tells me this isn't just [26:51] a place [26:52] anyone can end up [26:55] chapter 2 no slytherin makes sense world [26:58] building wise even if they are [26:59] one-dimensional and it feels like a [27:01] missed opportunity [27:02] once in a while lc young fans make [27:04] strange arguments where they point out a [27:06] way in which fictional world is [27:08] disturbing [27:09] and then they act like that's a mistake [27:11] just as characters can be flawed and [27:12] have contradictory [27:14] illogical or dark sides fictional [27:16] settings and communities can also be [27:18] flawed and have multiple sides to them [27:20] it's just a little harder to show this [27:22] because locations can't usually talk [27:24] directly to us [27:25] they are characterized by other things [27:27] like sights smells and the people that [27:29] inhabit that space [27:30] and hogwarts is despite how many [27:32] children dream of going there [27:34] kind of an alarming place by sorting [27:37] students into houses hogwarts assigned [27:39] stereotypes to all of its students on [27:41] the first night but slytherin is the [27:43] only house whose stereotypes are not [27:45] holy wholesome traits and honestly [27:48] sometimes it seems like the things that [27:49] make slytherin look sketchy are [27:51] superficial and would exist even if the [27:53] house had no connection to dark wizards [27:55] the most obvious thing is the house's [27:57] connection to a very stigmatized animal [27:59] the serpent but the values the house [28:01] centers itself around are also phrased [28:03] oddly [28:04] take the trait cunning ravenclaw words [28:06] like smart or shrewd have similar [28:08] meanings to cunning [28:09] but far more positive connotations [28:11] likewise what's the difference between [28:13] hufflepuff loyalty [28:14] and slytherin fraternity the word [28:16] fraternity makes me think of fraternity [28:18] houses so it makes me think of hierarchy [28:20] hazing and stuffy social circles with no [28:22] real intimacy [28:23] the word loyalty is warm and snuggly it [28:26] makes me think of a labrador [28:27] even though everyone knows you can be [28:29] loyal to a bad person [28:30] this makes something as simple as the [28:32] in-group loyalty between slytherin seem [28:34] dangerous and creepy even though it [28:36] exists in every house [28:38] rowling laughs in interviews about how [28:40] she's got that gryffindor showboating in [28:41] a store but what's the difference [28:42] between gryffindor showboatiness and [28:44] slytherin pridefulness [28:46] it's basically the color scheme all this [28:48] is a little stigmatizing and upon [28:50] observation it seems like slytherin [28:52] students are the ones [28:53] most likely to be sticky with each other [28:55] and have you ever noticed how a lot of [28:57] characters don't fit their house [28:58] the most famous one is why is hermione [29:00] not in ravenclaw something so obvious [29:02] it's asked by the characters in the [29:04] story but there are other examples [29:05] fred and george weasley are cunning [29:07] pranksters who are ambitious about [29:09] inventing new pranks and opening up a [29:11] prank shop fred and george are the only [29:13] people we see during the story actively [29:15] working on new ways to use magic [29:17] they're using it for toys and pranks but [29:19] that's still what they're doing [29:21] that sounds very ravenclaw or a shoe-in [29:24] for slytherin if snakes had shoes [29:26] oh and consider the crab and the goyle [29:29] if you will [29:29] they're in slytherin but their only [29:31] personality trait is that they're dumb [29:33] and strong [29:34] this idea that they're cunning is [29:36] hysterical [29:37] but let me tell you what they really are [29:39] they are unofficial [29:40] unpaid bodyguards of draco malfoy [29:43] imagine if you will [29:44] the bravery the nerve it takes every day [29:47] just to keep draco's teeth in his mouth [29:50] it's big gryffindor energy is what i'm [29:52] trying to say [29:53] quite frankly it's not only the dream of [29:55] every skinny coward to have two huge [29:56] dudes back you up but [29:58] also it's just like a herculean task but [30:00] uh why does it work out this way [30:02] well personality is actually quite [30:05] plastic especially when you're a kid and [30:07] people [30:08] are more versatile than we often give [30:10] them credit for even within a narrative [30:12] most harry potter characters who have [30:14] fleshed out personalities have [30:15] more than one house you could [30:17] hypothetically sort them into [30:18] because the house traits are kind of [30:20] vague and situational and they blend [30:22] together [30:22] they could apply to anyone at different [30:25] times in their life [30:26] so why are the sneaky children in the [30:29] dungeon [30:30] well uh the magic hat judges your [30:32] personality and it sees your inner [30:34] nature you can't just pick [30:36] whatever answer you want except that's [30:39] exactly how it works that's [30:40] literally what harry did harry comforts [30:43] his son albus in the epilogue by [30:45] reminding him that if it means so much [30:46] to you you can just tell the hat [30:48] not slytherin dude don't give me the [30:50] house with the mandatory spooky lighting [30:52] i want to be able to read in my common [30:54] room [30:55] the sorting hat does not place you for [30:56] what you are it places you for your [30:58] values your values at age 11 that are [31:00] probably just your family's values [31:02] unless you're a [31:03] serious black sheep so let's set the [31:06] stage for a new problem [31:08] although there are no rules saying that [31:09] people from different houses can't be [31:11] friends with each other they are [31:12] separated most of the day [31:14] in a sort of faux geographical divide [31:16] they have different living spaces where [31:18] they have their own common rooms and [31:19] dorms [31:20] although they don't have strictly [31:21] assigned seats at the great hall most [31:23] students sit with their house [31:25] this is prime socialization time for [31:27] students because what's left [31:29] seeing each other in the hallways or [31:31] talking to people in class [31:32] if you're allowed oh and days off but by [31:35] the time one of those comes around [31:37] you'll probably just want to spend it [31:39] with [31:39] your friends and this us versus them [31:42] it's encouraged the classroom is turned [31:44] into a game with a housepoint system [31:47] harry knows who belongs to what house on [31:50] site without knowing names [31:51] so that leads fans to speculate that [31:53] there must be some difference [31:54] in their uniforms and the movies make [31:57] these differences more pronounced [31:58] it's considered so weird to root for [32:00] someone else's quidditch team that the [32:02] only person who does it is luna lovegood [32:04] whose perhaps most distinctive [32:06] personality trait is that she's weird [32:08] she's a weirdo have you ever seen luna [32:11] without her radish earrings [32:13] that's weird most of the time in the [32:14] books when two people from a different [32:16] house are interacting with each other in [32:18] a positive way it has something to do [32:20] with dating [32:20] so the main thing getting you to [32:22] interact with people from other houses [32:24] is looking up from your quill and being [32:26] like all right you know what [32:28] if i had known all the hot people were [32:29] gonna be in ravenclaw i would have [32:31] showed up to the castle with a different [32:33] mindset [32:34] i'm just letting that be known it's a [32:36] very slytherin thing to say isn't it [32:38] goddammit [32:39] now when i put all this together it [32:40] might sound like i'm saying oh poor [32:42] snake babies the school is biased [32:44] against them [32:46] nope i don't think so slytherin is [32:48] definitely gridlocked in conflict with [32:50] gryffindor but it's reciprocal [32:52] the only example of bias i can think of [32:54] is dumbledore in the first installment [32:55] dumping a ton of points on gryffindor [32:57] last minute which causes slytherin to [32:59] lose the house cup [33:00] and while harry and his friends [33:02] definitely earned those points [33:04] from the outside it looks random as all [33:06] hell and don't get me wrong this [33:08] is hilarious i mean unfair but [33:11] slytherin had won the house cup six [33:13] years in a row and even once they begin [33:16] losing they're usually in second place [33:18] so teachers definitely award slytherin [33:20] students points for good behavior [33:22] if you're using house points as proof of [33:24] bias it's actually hufflepuff or [33:26] ravenclaw who are having a hard time [33:29] you know i'll remind you all this [33:31] hogwarts nonsense [33:32] has serious consequences in the adult [33:34] magical world because [33:36] it means all the little bigots get to [33:38] fester together in the dungeon where the [33:39] password on the entrance to the common [33:41] room in harry second year was literally [33:43] pure blood they're not socialized with [33:45] many muggleborns or people who don't [33:47] share their beliefs and they are the [33:48] group of students who [33:49] desperately need that we know zero [33:53] zero blood racist non-slytherins whom [33:56] attended hogwarts [33:57] it never comes up as a motivator for [33:59] pettigrew quarrel but there's [34:01] grindelwald [34:02] but he doesn't even go here i also think [34:04] it's notable pettigrew the evil [34:06] gryffindor's primary trait is that he's [34:08] a cowardly rat [34:09] he's not the brave gryffindor he's [34:11] supposed to be all this tells me [34:13] one evil in harry potter has a very [34:15] specific look and attitude to assist the [34:18] story's themes it's parasitic [34:20] it cowers in the face of death [34:22] voldemort's a pretty one-dimensional [34:24] hello i'm evil bad guy [34:25] so it actually helps harry potter as a [34:27] story that evil has this [34:29] very specific aesthetic and mindset it [34:31] makes it feel like it's [34:32] everywhere that it infects things it [34:35] sort of helps voldemort brute force his [34:37] way into iconicness [34:39] but as a result where evil comes from in [34:41] this series is [34:42] way too specific and can be easily [34:45] simplified into not [34:46] loving people enough and fearing death [34:49] too much [34:50] harry rarely deals with death anxiety [34:52] the times he does are memorable but [34:54] harry potter is more about grief and how [34:56] it's entwined with love [34:58] two either slytherins are all [35:00] brainwashing each other once they're in [35:01] the dungeon or having the belief that [35:03] non-magical people or muggle-born people [35:06] are lesser [35:07] is a secret factored in value that's [35:09] heavily weighted compared to other [35:11] traits [35:12] and it will get you shoved face-first [35:14] into salazar's steamy bowl of bigotry [35:16] soup [35:16] every time when people get defensive [35:19] about fans boiling down slytherin into a [35:21] house of bullies [35:22] i think they forget something very [35:24] important it's not just about these [35:26] traits [35:26] there is a hidden value on this list [35:29] draco was [35:30] raised to have these biases he showed up [35:33] to the school with them and what the [35:34] school did was reinforce them by letting [35:36] him live in a bubble [35:37] with the young severus snape it's [35:39] similar but a little different [35:41] snape had a physically abusive muggle [35:43] father half blood prince [35:45] is a little nickname that works on [35:47] multiple levels prince is his mother's [35:49] maiden name and she was a witch [35:51] it's a way for his teenage self to [35:52] reject his magic hating muggle father's [35:55] family name [35:56] as a child he befriended harry's mother [35:58] lily and he would tell her about how [35:59] they were special because they had magic [36:01] and that they would go to hogwarts this [36:03] wonderful magical place [36:05] unfortunately for snape he was separated [36:07] from his friend by the sorting hat [36:08] growing up he was harassed and attacked [36:10] often by james potter and his friends [36:13] this was ruthless bullying that on one [36:15] occasion crossed the line into very [36:17] public sexual harassment and this was [36:19] toned down in the movie [36:20] book snape was not the loner he looks to [36:22] be in the movie's quick flashbacks [36:24] he retreated into the arms of his fellow [36:26] slytherins [36:28] lily was infuriated by snape's ability [36:30] to hang out with voldemort supporters [36:31] and snape was furious that lily would [36:33] hang out with his [36:34] bullies this leads up to snape calling [36:36] lily a mudblood and ruining their [36:38] friendship forever now if you were [36:39] unaware of what slytherin house was like [36:42] you might say [36:43] where the hell did that come from when [36:44] he started school he was only biased [36:46] against muggles [36:47] how did his bigotry expand well it came [36:50] from his friends it came from [36:52] slytherin's influence over him [36:54] dumbledore has this line you know i [36:57] sometimes think [36:58] we sort too soon we'll get to it don't [37:01] worry [37:01] there's an interesting metaphor in here [37:03] somewhere that slytherin house is a den [37:05] of snakes that fills [37:06] children with its venom made funnier by [37:09] the fact that their dorm is the hogwarts [37:11] dungeon [37:12] also known as a prison and while the [37:14] prison may seem comfortable and [37:15] aesthetic [37:16] it's very much a magical blood racism [37:18] factory [37:19] and their upbringing puts them there [37:21] people who take harry potter house [37:23] personality quizzes don't [37:24] factor magical blood racism into the [37:26] equation because why [37:28] would they and then these real people [37:30] are given a house and they [37:32] identify with it and buy key chains and [37:34] sweaters [37:35] the official quiz is like you like the [37:36] moon you like white [37:38] cats and vampires wow you're a slytherin [37:42] a muggle slytherin cue confused [37:45] salazar noises i have seen harry potter [37:47] fans pick what familiar they'd bring [37:49] what wand they would have [37:51] they typically don't imagine how blood [37:53] racist they'd be you know not everyone [37:55] can be home stuck [37:56] the hogwarts houses are presented to us [37:58] as four valid choices but they're not in [38:00] their current form [38:01] we are presented with a pretty plausible [38:04] system of indoctrination [38:05] chilling out at hogwarts in plain sight [38:07] sanctified in tradition but the [38:09] characters don't do anything about it [38:11] story didn't show them becoming more [38:13] than what they first appeared and rising [38:15] to the occasion [38:16] which was the thing i think they set up [38:17] most for in the fifth year the sorting [38:19] hat sings out oh know the perils read [38:22] the signs [38:23] the warning history shows from our [38:26] hogwarts is in danger [38:28] from external deadly foes and we must [38:31] unite inside her [38:32] or will crumble from within i have told [38:35] you [38:35] i have warned you let the sorting now [38:38] begin [38:38] well no apparently hogwarts didn't have [38:40] to unite they didn't mention anyone [38:42] remastering slytherin house or the [38:44] hogwarts houses [38:45] and they didn't remove slytherin as a [38:47] house no don't they not slap my [38:49] sweatshirt i think it's the lack of [38:50] action that bothers me it's bothered me [38:52] since i was a kid it feels so unfinished [38:55] and it's surprising because it's such an [38:57] obvious loose end it's secondary to [38:58] voldemort of course but it's the true [39:00] birthplace of voldemort as a concept [39:02] and i've held off on telling you [39:04] possibly the biggest missed opportunity [39:06] slytherin students not participating in [39:08] the battle of hogwarts like the other [39:10] students [39:10] if properly built up this would be a [39:12] cool moment especially when you consider [39:14] how much scarier it would be for many of [39:16] them as they'd be going up against their [39:17] own family in battle [39:19] it would give a sense that yeah maybe [39:20] harry is biased and slytherin house [39:22] isn't just draco and his loudest dumbest [39:25] cruelest [39:25] friends and here's a laugh and a half [39:27] there was a reddit post from four years [39:29] ago of a confused fan asking why in [39:31] random locations online [39:33] people talk as if slytherin returned to [39:35] the battle of hogwarts's reinforcements [39:37] it all seems to go back to one source [39:39] episode 131 of a podcast named [39:42] pottercast [39:43] where rowling was a guest star wow and [39:45] how much [39:46] is it that being sorted into slytherin [39:48] is you know sorted into [39:49] good guys and bad guys here well they're [39:52] not [39:52] all bad that would i i know i've said [39:55] this before [39:56] and i think i said it to emerson they [39:57] are not all bad and and [40:00] well far from it as we know at the end [40:02] they may have [40:03] they may have a slightly more highly [40:05] developed sense of self-preservation [40:07] than other people a part of the final [40:10] battle that made me smile [40:12] was slughorn galloping back with [40:14] slytherins yes but they'd gone off to [40:15] get reinforcements first you know what [40:17] i'm saying so [40:18] that yes they came back they came back [40:20] to fight [40:21] so i mean i'm but i'm sure many people [40:23] would say well that's common sense isn't [40:25] it [40:25] isn't that smart to get out get more [40:27] people and come back with them [40:28] i have no idea what she's talking about [40:30] i can't find it [40:32] i feel like that would be a significant [40:34] moment for harry if he realized there [40:36] were slytherins who would fight [40:38] did she wreck conor's story in a podcast [40:41] i can't fathom forgetting something like [40:43] that [40:43] i sometimes think we sought too soon [40:46] by sorting the children you're [40:48] hypothetically judging them for their [40:49] values [40:50] but there's something about this [40:51] sentence i hate especially when you [40:53] consider how it goes unresolved there [40:55] shouldn't be a wrong place to put a [40:57] child [40:57] some aspects of snape's backstory [40:59] demonstrate the cruelty of the system [41:01] and how it became a breeding ground for [41:03] magical blood racism [41:04] and dumbledore has dialogue expressing [41:06] that he's beginning to see the problem [41:08] but [41:08] no one fixes it and i don't believe it [41:12] i don't believe slytherin is actually [41:14] reformed i don't believe the root of the [41:16] problem has been sufficiently addressed [41:19] they put a picture of slughorn in the [41:20] common room because of his bravery at [41:22] the battle which implies an ideological [41:25] shift but it's literally just hanging up [41:27] a picture [41:28] if i were headmaster i would get rid of [41:30] slytherin or rework the sorting system [41:32] completely at the very least make sure [41:34] students get resorted every year [41:36] the existence of houses on their own [41:38] isn't necessarily harmful to children [41:40] and house that central tenant is [41:42] ambition likewise [41:43] is perfectly fine to me but the hogwarts [41:46] houses as they stand [41:47] stupidly help promote the ideological [41:49] fracturing of the adult wizarding world [41:51] i can't help but feel like a new [41:52] voldemort is going to sprout up from [41:54] slytherin like a dandelion and the [41:56] wizarding world is once again [41:58] not going to be prepared for it for me [41:59] it makes the deaths that occurred during [42:01] the war [42:02] and the victory at the battle of [42:03] hogwarts feel a little pointless [42:05] and not in the a circle of violence way [42:08] or in a tragic pulling on your [42:10] heartstrings way but in a sort of [42:12] did i leave the stove on kind of way [42:16] oh i hate to do it to you but [42:18] statistically it works [42:20] if you're amused by the thought of [42:21] fueling my slytherin ambitions then like [42:24] this video [42:24] and leave a comment to boost the [42:26] algorithmic ranking [42:28] youtube informs me that many of the [42:29] people who watch my videos aren't [42:31] subscribed so please do that please [42:33] subscribe and ring the bell and if [42:34] you're die hard enough about what i do [42:36] here you can support me on patreon [42:42] well see you later