---
title: 'Uh, Rowling Why Does Slytherin Still Exist?'
source: 'https://youtube.com/watch?v=VeS1pITHufo'
video_id: 'VeS1pITHufo'
date: 2026-07-28
duration_sec: 2574
channel: 'Quinn Curio'
---

# Uh, Rowling Why Does Slytherin Still Exist?

> Source: [Uh, Rowling Why Does Slytherin Still Exist?](https://youtube.com/watch?v=VeS1pITHufo)

## Summary

This video critically examines J.K. Rowling's portrayal of Slytherin house in the Harry Potter series, arguing that it is canonically depicted as an 'evil house' with few morally grey or good characters. The creator, a self-identified Slytherin, explores the world-building flaws, the lack of redemption arcs, and the systemic issues that make Slytherin a breeding ground for blood racism, ultimately questioning why the house remains unchanged by the story's end.

### Key Points

- **Introduction to Slytherin's Problem** [0:12] — The video sets up the central question: did Rowling botch the handling of Slytherin, or is the story itself biased against the house? The creator, a Pottermore-certified Slytherin, will argue both sides.
- **Slytherin is Canonically Evil** [2:12] — Despite fan attempts to rehabilitate Slytherin's image, the canon presents the average Slytherin student as bullies, cheaters, and blood supremacists. There are almost no good or neutral Slytherin characters, and the few antagonists from other houses are exceptions that prove the rule.
- **Missed Opportunities for Good Slytherins** [6:26] — The video highlights two missed opportunities: making the Hogwarts champion in Goblet of Fire a Slytherin (which would have collapsed Harry's worldview) and having Slytherins join Dumbledore's Army in Order of the Phoenix (which would have shown their ambition and self-interest).
- **The Good Slytherins: A Short List** [8:49] — The creator lists the few Slytherins who are not evil: Merlin, Andromeda Tonks, and Horace Slughorn. However, even Slughorn is casually blood racist in the books, and the creator admits he was wrong to include him after re-checking his first appearance.
- **Death Eater Defectors: Regulus and Draco** [11:54] — Regulus Black's redemption is a flash in the pan, and Draco's reform is largely off-screen. Draco's actions are more about passive resistance and self-preservation than genuine moral change, and Rowling doesn't seem to like him enough to give him a proper redemption arc.
- **Snape: The Most Complex Slytherin** [14:38] — Snape is the most emotionally complex character, but his redemption arc is controversial. The video argues that his last-minute reveal as a spy is overshadowed by his tragic love for Lily, and his cruelty towards children makes his redemption feel inadequate to many fans.
- **World-Building Flaws: The Sorting System** [26:42] — The sorting hat judges values at age 11, which are usually just family values. The house system creates an 'us versus them' mentality, and Slytherin's traits (cunning, ambition) are framed negatively compared to other houses. The house's connection to blood racism is a hidden value that is never addressed.
- **Slytherin as a Breeding Ground for Bigotry** [34:50] — Slytherin's isolation in the dungeon, combined with its emphasis on pure-blood values, creates a 'magical blood racism factory.' Characters like Snape and Draco are radicalized by their environment, and the school does nothing to intervene.
- **The Battle of Hogwarts Missed Opportunity** [39:02] — Slytherin students not participating in the Battle of Hogwarts is a huge missed opportunity. Rowling later claimed in a podcast that they returned with reinforcements, but this is not in the books, and the creator finds it hard to believe.
- **Conclusion: Slytherin Needs Reform** [41:28] — The creator argues that Slytherin should be reformed or the sorting system reworked entirely. The house system promotes ideological fracturing, and without change, a new Voldemort could easily rise from Slytherin again.

## Transcript

the world hasn't split into good people
and death eaters we've all got both
light
and dark inside of us are you sure about
that
ah the four hogwarts houses a
cornerstone of harry potter iconography
a lucrative engine that powers a lot of
the brand's merchandise
these symbols and colors are tattooed
onto my cerebral cortex forever
they are a smart simple piece of world
building functioning as a question a
jumping off point to inspire children to
imagine themselves attend in a wizard
school doing you know wizard things like
not receiving a well-rounded education
the hogwarts houses are
if memes are to be believed gryffindor
smart yellow and last but not least
evil despite my love for harry potter
i've always been more interested in the
characters and i adore the general
setting but i have a lot of issues with
the world building that stem from
problems in the books
some of it's kind of funny and mostly
harmless like rowling's really bad at
math and it creates a lot of
embarrassing mistakes
other times it's infuriating like the
house elves that love being slaves until
you beat them too much
and the biggest subplot involving
freeing them is more about how hermione
did activism wrong by ignoring the
people she was advocating for
you know you gotta listen to people when
you're advocating for them
so you know just accept that the
hogwarts kitchen is filled with sentient
creatures that keep insisting they love
being slaves
that video will be like therapy i get
paid for today we're diving into
something much more
gray elusive slithery we're talking
about the handling of slytherin house
did rolling botch it is hogwarts or the
story itself
biased against slytherin is it
unrealistic can you intelligently
explain why
all the bad guys seem to share a dorm as
children or is it just indicative of jk
rowling's inability to see
evil in the brave the intelligent and
the well-meaning and are fans drowning
in their head cannons
all of it argued by a slytherin oh yes
pottermore certified
i was a snake the whole time so if i
start arguing slytherin might need
big reforms or a big thanos snap well
it's nothing personal kid
i got skin in the game too not really
that's a lie
i got a comfy hot topic sweatshirt in
the game so let's start with an easy
question
is slytherin really the evil house
chapter one yes they really are the evil
house and not our dark academia fantasy
i know it sucks i hate it too
a lot of slytherins are morally
complicated people who fell off the path
of good but forget those melodramatic
attention hogs for a minute
just who's the average everyday
slytherin student
well some harry potter fans try
so hard to rehabilitate slytherin house
they will make memes and lengthy posts
about how slytherin traits could
hypothetically produce a good person
they paint this picture of an ambitious
cunning sarcastic friend who tells you
like it is but because of the fraternity
trait is delightfully biased in your
favor
and wants to undermine your enemies with
ceptifuge so that you can reign together
and sip black coffee in your dark
academia hallways and then run through
spiraling dark green hedge mazes
anyone who got into harry potter from
seeing these posts would be
disappointed by the books even if you've
never been exposed to filthy fandom
propaganda i think
most people on a gut level react to this
situation
with a healthy spoonful of skepticism
they go
no what even is this a den of evil
children
it must be more complicated than that
and if it
isn't it should be in any fandom
especially such an old one people get
bored and they just start playing with
the universe
as if it was a toy even with no new
material they can hype themselves up by
making their own fun
using their creativity so people
dedicate entire blogs to for example
pansy parkinson
except to them pansy is the idea of a
slytherin girl fueled mostly by the
premise that rich
ambitious girls with jet black bobs look
cool and you want to kiss them
fans find great pleasure in pulling
something complete out of tiny details
that differentiate them from each other
so a character like pansy is an original
character wearing the skin of a minor
character
this is how the fandom's concept of
slytherin evolves and is actually more
complex and morally grey than the canon
reality of slytherin the canon has very
few grey characters and almost no good
ones
and you can contrast that against the
fact that there are almost no
antagonists from other houses there are
technically three but really there's two
the average slytherin student harry
attended hogwarts with from gregory
goyal to theodore not in the movies is a
blurry blob of bullies cheaters and bad
attitudes
this is so true that when goyle's actor
josh herdman got his arm herded during
the third movie they just swapped him
out with another slytherin boy
when krabs actor jaime whalett got
arrested for growing marijuana the
movies were like okay well if you're
gonna blaze it then we're gonna blaze it
too and then blaze became the guy
standing opposite de goyle in malfoy's
squad
in fact goyle got to take crab's place
in the fiery grave because it just
doesn't matter which one of them dies
the cliff notes is just draco got to see
his friend who didn't pull out of evil
at the last second perish
so just kill the spare i i mean the one
that got the most screen time
the bad guy cannon fodder basically i've
seen people try to argue well the books
are told from harry's perspective and
he's biased and that's true but harry is
not such an unreliable narrator as to
make up dialogue for other people
this argument falls flat for me when a
slytherin student opens up their mouth
and the only thing they have to say for
themselves is lol mudblood or lol blood
traitor
or and i love this example it baffles me
in the sixth book
blaise savini unlike draco malfoy gets
into the slug club and elbow-rubbing
dinner party club presumably because
professor slughorn the club runner has
no reason to suspect his family are
death eater aligned but
rowling can't help herself so blaze is a
dismissive jerk the entire night he does
a rude skepticism cough at slughorn
suggesting harry survived the night of
his parents death because he may be
extraordinary in some way and for some
mind-blowing reason he somehow manages
to info dump that his famously hot mom
has been married seven times and her
rich husbands keep dropping dead under
mysterious circumstances
how did he even do that how did he just
announce
that he's indifferent to the fact that
his mom is a serial killer
what could he have possibly said that
caused this
big of a misunderstanding in harry's
mind i don't even think it's a good joke
it's just like okay i get it they're all
bad
haha it's so funny there were
opportunities to introduce a good or
just
neutral minor slytherin student and it
just never happens
i'll give you a couple examples the
first one will be what i'll call a big
ask and the second one is like a little
ask
so and this is a popular like fandom
idea
hypothetically what if the hogwarts
champion in goblet of fire was a
slytherin
now this choice would be a shame since
it's taking away one of hufflepuff's few
times to shine
but people argue this would be the
perfect way to conclude the later half
of the series and i agree
if cedric diggory or a hypothetical
other hogwarts champion was a nice
slytherin boy who was killed in front of
harry just as he was starting to warm up
to him
that collapses harry's whole world view
of slytherin bad
gryffindor good after all the entire
conflict is just the kiddie pool version
of what's going on with the adults
right in the adult wizarding world it
doesn't matter if he's team
snake if to voldemort he's just another
blood traitor
then there are decisions that seem much
more about realism that require
very little effort nothing as big as an
important character being in slytherin
in the order of the phoenix dumbledore's
army didn't make use of
any slytherins this was one of the first
times harry got to hang out with people
outside of his house for an extended
project but
no slytherins joined in fact they seemed
to team up with dolores and filch
inexplicably everyone in the house tied
to
all magical families and ambition
doesn't care that their school which
they need to make themselves more
powerful
is turning into some type of muggle
school where they don't practice magic
in class
this is a very clear betrayal of what
their house stands for and just their
general cultural values
and doing something like this creating
secret classes in a hidden location that
seems
very slytherin i think this displays the
strange relationship harry potter as a
series has with the hogwarts houses
they take up so much time and oxygen and
shelf space
and yet while some significant
characters come from other houses
really it's only two houses that matter
but when you get a little bit closer
actually it's just one it makes
everything seem a bit more mechanical it
breaks the illusion that hogwarts is a
big place filled with unique students
well they're not all bad that would i i
know i've said this before and i think i
said it to emerson they are not
all bad and and well far from it as we
know
i would feel bad about avoiding talking
about specific slytherin characters who
do good things i don't want you to feel
like i'm skipping over them because it's
inconvenient
so let's talk about them a lot
a lot a lot let's start out with the
most upstanding snakes snakes can't
stand or are they always standing
just the good normal guys no morally
gray cutie pies
i have set the bar for unimpeachable
goodness at the truly unreasonable
standard of
was never a blood supremacist or death
eater gee willikers let's see who clears
it first up we got merlin a wizard who
thought wizard kind should be helping
muggle kind and he was in slytherin he
was probably in the first
class ever because he's as old as dirk
you know merlin
as a collectible in the harry potter
video games and not as an actual
character in the story
hey harry remember me wrong weasley
hello harry it's me hagrid the harry
potter wiki claims he is mentioned in
almost every book and movie but that's
because his name
is a wizard swear that's a great snake
right there it takes a pet like no
problem
right not afraid at all and then we have
andromeda
tonks she's nymphadora tonks's mother no
movie fans don't leave me
okay don't get scared stick with the
most popular guys all right
draco's mother has two sisters one is
bellatrix lestrange and the other is
andromeda who is disowned from marrying
a muggle-born wizard and she's cool
she's an example of how pure blood
families socially control each other to
keep their pureblood status
they commonly use disownment as a threat
finally horus slughorn is the closest
thing to a normal slytherin in the
entire series
he was introduced late he's a socialite
who loves throwing parties
he doesn't like conflict but he has a
good heart and he comes through for
harry
in the books he is casually blood racist
in a bigotry of low
expectations sort of way towards
muggleborns but this dialogue is cut
from the half-blood prince movie making
slughorn i think
the only never blood racist named
slytherin character
in the movie series wow it doesn't even
end there they expanded on slughorn's
relationship with lily
he expresses the shame he feels how he
feels responsible
for voldemort's creation just because he
gave tom information about horcruxes
this is a student asking him about some
pretty forbidden
sketchy information but watching this
scene i can't help but feel that
horus was taken advantage of despite the
fact that he's desperately trying to run
from his mistakes out of shame
and the fact that he can come off as
kind of a airy socialite
i think he's actually a very sweet man
so there he is the good slytherin
he's good slytherin he's a good boy look
at him
wow so guess what guys i was wrong
in slughorn's first appearance he does
the same thing he did in the books and i
forgot
while i stand by my overview of him no
he doesn't belong in this category
anymore
so that's it he was the best i had he
was the only one that was a real
character and i was wrong
even he couldn't survive the standard i
set it's just ridiculous and in case
you're curious
even dolores umbridge was in slytherin
i just moving on
some people however fell off the path of
good and wandered back onto it
what do the death eater defectors say
about the moral character of slytherin
house
regulus black the betrayer of voldemort
sacrificed his life to destroy a horcrux
a thing
voldemort put a slice of his soul into
to be immortal
regulus inexplicably knew the horcrux
existed and where to find it to precious
secrets of a very
violent and suspicious man but he
doesn't appear on screen so the only
canon picture i have of him to show you
is this picture of a picture
his presence in the story is kind of
tenuous especially in the movies
when you google image search's name
you'll be hit with a wall of models
people use to represent him
he is a flash in the pan plot point more
of a mood board than a man
regulus reflects this idea of a renegade
death eater betrayer distraught and
disillusioned trying to find a scrap of
redemption to undo some of the harm
they've caused to the world
but i think truthfully he more so
reflects the idea that
sad pale-faced pretty boys with dark
hair
look cool and you want to kiss them i'm
about to pull some points i made in my
draco video to make this one a
standalone but it's good you should
watch it
unlike some other characters more
praised for their redemption arcs
draco's actions in deathly hallows are
more about
small inactions moments where he
passively resists
and then he and his parents shrink into
the shadows because voldemort can no
longer ensure their safety or power and
the only thing the malfoys truly love
is each other there is no concrete
evidence that draco harbors a heart of
gold
there is only evidence that he is much
more sensitive than he appears
these aspects of himself that he's
likely ashamed of combined with harry's
gryffindor nature
and those key moments where he passively
resist voldemort are the reasons why he
survived the events of the story
unfortunately draco's reform is largely
off screen the biggest one is raising
his son scorpius to be
normal and not a blood supremacist a
fact that's not even clear in the book's
epilogue
it was just assumed and brought up on
pottermore
the wizarding world there is definitely
symbolism that this is not
draco's true self but it's not explored
in any detail
rowling doesn't seem to like draco much
less like him enough to weave a
redemption arc into the story for him
he and his fellow slytherin friends are
stand-ins for posh bullies she faced in
her childhood
narratively he's a foil or he's a mini
boss in the early installments of harry
potter to give harry something to worry
about and compete with
he also teaches us about wizard
supremacy culture
let me teach you about wizard crackers
and it's sort of that simple most of the
people on voldemort's side are kind of
underdeveloped even though it'd be more
interesting to many people if they
weren't
but there is one slytherin rolling seems
to like
quite a bit snipe snipe
severus snipe snipe snipe
severus snipe to promote deathly hallows
the bookstore borders before they were
all closed down had these promotional
bookmarks and stickers they gave out
that would say things like
trust snape and snape is very bad man
he's very bad draco was actually held in
higher regard by the fandom than snape
probably because he was a teenager when
all of that went down and he raised his
son to not have brain worms
snape is more complicated severus snape
is sometimes considered to be
the most emotionally complex character
in the series
and he is sometimes considered to be a
hot mess with an inadequate redemption
arc that breaks its own hand
patting itself on the back because how
much can you really redeem a character
who spends most of his screen time and
word count
bullying children as time marches on i'm
confronted with what i see
as a failing unrollings part to make the
audience see what she sees
i feel more and more alone in my genuine
like of snape as a character beyond
appreciating alan rickman's acting
it seems like every year since the last
movie came out snape has been rotting in
the public consciousness
snape will you accept us rose fine
but wear this always i've observed the
fandom do this slow
penguin waddle from what i consider to
be the canon reality of snape or even a
candy-coated version of that reality too
uh how do i put this delicately snape is
literally an
in-cell he's got a simp patronus a
simptronis
if you will it's all because he's
obsessed with lily he got friend zoned
by harry's mom
in wizard high school how is that a
redemption arc
okay listen with that kind of mindset
you can make any story sound stupid
snape is notably divorced from most
slytherin redemption squad conversations
even though he's the head of slytherin
house and is a very slytherin slytherin
but let's start here maybe this is a
flaw in the writing or something to keep
in mind when reading or writing a story
the last thing a character does before
they die is not necessarily what redeems
them but i think people feel
emotionally that that is the case in
their guts
the part of the flashback that shows the
beginning of snape becoming a spy is not
even technically presenting a reveal at
all
harry learns that snape was a spy in
what goblet of fire what about snape
severus snape of the council that's very
much aware of giving evidence on this
matter
several snape was indeed a death eater
and prior to lord voldemort's downfall
turned
spy for us at great personal risk
today's no more a death
therefore learning that snape truly was
always on harry's side
gets overshadowed by the more emotional
surprising personal tragedy of his
unrequited love for
lily evans potter snape's feelings for
lily are context into his behavior
elaborating on what we learned about him
in the order of the phoenix when it was
made known that harry's father and his
friends were bullies
harry's dad hexed people for fun and
they were obsessed with ganging up on
snape
if you think snape loving lily doesn't
redeem him you're not wrong but i'm not
sure if it was meant to
the redemption arc is he's been a spy
for nearly 17 years in a world where
people can read your mind if you're not
careful
part of being a spy was killing the only
person who knew him on a personal level
the only person that
actually saw him for what he was there
is clear development that happens
between 21 year old snape begging
dumbledore to hide the potters or at
least lily
and the 37ish year old snape horrified
that dumbledore has known the whole time
that harry was gonna have to die for the
war to end
quite frankly i find this information
delivered in a way that's confusing in
the movie especially for all of the
people that are probably just gonna see
the movie once or twice
i mean twice alan rickman although he
made snape so iconic is 20 years older
than the character he's playing
and since snape and dumbledore basically
look the same it almost looks like
they're wearing the same outfits
i don't think you feel the weight of how
much time has passed and how much snape
has changed
not from mean man too nice man but his
moral fiber
he's put in the work and i actually
think it's the epilogue that's the final
nail in the coffin for people that feel
salty about snape when harry named his
son albus severus potter people felt
snape was disproportionately rewarded
for his bad behavior if you're not
impressed with snape this is a story
where a character built around a
decade-spanning redemption arc did not
redeem himself because he couldn't stop
being awful to children and to rub salt
in the wound he is honored after his
death in favor of others which is a
recipe for resentment
if harry needed a middle name for his
son there are many characters in the
story that served as a paternal figure
to him
snape is not even breaking the top 5 and
there are other dead men on that list
for me personally i think it does imply
an interesting emotional maturity harry
has after the war
but here's something that honestly does
bother me i can look at snape and
because he's a fictional character i can
go
oh what a fascinating broken man yes i
loved the time i spent reading about
severus snape
but i don't think people treat people in
their life like that
children grow to see the complexity and
motivations of their authority figures
but they usually don't honor teachers
that bully them
i've heard of that behavior before but
that kind of attachment seems more
common
in trying to sort your feelings out
about an abusive or kind of lackluster
parent
so it always kind of felt to me like
rowling worked backwards from the
premise oh wouldn't it be cool if harry
named his son after that teacher that he
hated
and like that's true it would be wild if
you told someone after reading the first
few books that harry was gonna name his
son after snape
but i don't think he got where it needed
to be after snape dies and deathly
hallows harry doesn't have much internal
dialogue about how he's
processing the meaning of snape's death
to him
the descriptions are very matter-of-fact
about it and it's not like rowling's
incapable of writing emotionally deep
deaths
let me read something to you this is one
of my favorite passages in the whole
series
this is when harry goes to see
dumbledore's dead body and half blood
prince
then he gazed down at the wise old face
and tried to absorb
the enormous and incomprehensible truth
that never again would dumbledore speak
to him
never again could he help
i always really loved this i like how it
speaks to loss
and i like how the first thing harry has
to process is how death has robbed
dumbledore of his ability to speak to
him both you know
those moments where dumbledore says
silly whimsical things but also his
ability to protect and give wisdom
so going into deathly hallows you can
feel it you feel that safety net is just
gone the only person voldemort was
afraid of is dead
so it's this beautiful summarization of
harry's relationship to dumbledore
snape's death scene on the other hand
it's written well
but it's playing this effective
emotional sleight of hand where for a
long time i didn't question
where are harry's thoughts in this scene
he has no thoughts snape dead head empty
so this is the ultimate slytherin this
is the slytherin rowling will fight you
about on twitter before she'd
fight you about trans people this is the
slytherin who makes the greatest
sacrifice for the forces of good in the
story and his resume of good deeds is
not impressing everyone
and it's because rowling can't help
herself
it wasn't enough for him to just be a
strict intimidating teacher
he has to be cruel he has to turn a
blind eye
to slytherin bullying he has to mock
hermione's teeth when they're elongated
by a curse
he has to threaten to kill neville's pet
if he doesn't get a potion right so it
doesn't matter if snape saves harry's
life multiple times because any adult
would have done that
i mean i guess it goes back to
fundamental lessons right if you
intend a character to be sympathetic or
intend to redeem them
you have to throw in some save the cat
moments
you have to be mindful of the
character's perception
there's a careful balancing act
happening here snape sometimes has
moments where he's scary and getting in
the way of harry doing stuff but
upon re-reads he has a genuine reason to
think harry's up to something
congratulations your performance in the
black lake was inspiring
gillyweed am i correct gillyweed may be
innocuous but
boomslang skin lacewing flies
you and your little friends are brewing
polyjuice potion and believe me
i'm going to find out why that's moody
but then who's
holly juice potion now we know who's
been seeding from your store service
or harry's actually breaking rules and
of course snape's going gonna give him a
hard time he's
a teacher i would have loved to see
harry reflect more on
looking guilty or how his relationship
with his teacher is falling apart
because of misunderstandings
i think the reason snape rots every year
for a lot of people
is as you grow up you're able to put
yourself in snape's perspective more
because you're an adult now
so you have more of an appreciation for
how immature he is and how little his
fixation on harry is justified by the
narrative
i want you to imagine that when you
re-read
you could see that snape started out
curious
about what kind of person this kid was
he's intimidating and cold but he's not
really doing anything
evil besides giving out a lot of
homework and any adult could recognize
it's actually harry being judgmental
because he's thin
greasy haired all clad in black he's
described as looking like a giant bat
imagine if snape had logical reasons to
think harry was an
egomaniac who behind the scenes was
bullying children
and then he wrote him off and zeroed in
on him
then on top of that harry keeps getting
in trouble the next book he steals that
car
and exposes the wizarding world etc etc
if the inciting incident to this
toxicity made sense
harry would have his first encounter
with being hated by an adult for reasons
within his control
instead of what happens in the story
which is i don't know snape just kind of
ignores
all evidence that harry is not pampered
and the writing almost appeals to this
persecution complex
where harry is jesus on the cross and
snape is heckling him and we're supposed
to just throw up our hands and go
well he's traumatized by harry's father
snape picks on harry the first day for
not paying attention when in reality
he's writing everything snape says down
if snape just peers at his notebook
he'll see it this is a common mistake
children make when taking notes
then he asks a child raised by muggles
questions about magical ingredients he
can't possibly know to embarrass him
this isn't just about being mean this
character is not supposed to be
stupid his intelligence is a central
trait he's not supposed to be
the dursleys but at school this wasn't
handled properly
and at the end of the day the way the
narrative tries to make him an honorary
gryffindor because he's
brave does come off as really weird
like most people will just say oh my god
who the hell cares
and slytherin fans are just gonna be
like why he's one of the only slytherin
characters that fits slytherin
very stan slytherin stands the most
slytherin slytherin of them all
and guess what kids being sorted into
slytherin is directly responsible for
ruining his life
slytherin house clearly overwhelmingly
lacks nuance as almost all the unmoral
characters come from there
the few instances of hogwarts attending
non-slytherin evil
is a sniveling coward who is the
antithesis of a gryffindor and
exemplifies the slytherin trait of
self-preservation
and one singular ravenclaw who might
have ravenclaw motivations it's not
really explained
snape comes off like a very obvious
servant of voldemort in the first book
so it seems professor quirrell mostly
existed for the twist
it's kind of funny that this complexity
never shows up in the book again
rowling refuses at every moment big and
small to just
allow slytherin students to be normal
for like five seconds
the most morally ambiguous slytherin
characters have redemption arcs that
much of the fandom is unsatisfied with
you can make a solid argument that
they're not even meant to be completely
redeemed
just you know humanized and observed as
complex actors in their story
good slytherins are almost non-existent
until you get to the cursed child stage
play
they are largely hypothetical fandom
creations that tells me this isn't just
a place
anyone can end up
chapter 2 no slytherin makes sense world
building wise even if they are
one-dimensional and it feels like a
missed opportunity
once in a while lc young fans make
strange arguments where they point out a
way in which fictional world is
disturbing
and then they act like that's a mistake
just as characters can be flawed and
have contradictory
illogical or dark sides fictional
settings and communities can also be
flawed and have multiple sides to them
it's just a little harder to show this
because locations can't usually talk
directly to us
they are characterized by other things
like sights smells and the people that
inhabit that space
and hogwarts is despite how many
children dream of going there
kind of an alarming place by sorting
students into houses hogwarts assigned
stereotypes to all of its students on
the first night but slytherin is the
only house whose stereotypes are not
holy wholesome traits and honestly
sometimes it seems like the things that
make slytherin look sketchy are
superficial and would exist even if the
house had no connection to dark wizards
the most obvious thing is the house's
connection to a very stigmatized animal
the serpent but the values the house
centers itself around are also phrased
oddly
take the trait cunning ravenclaw words
like smart or shrewd have similar
meanings to cunning
but far more positive connotations
likewise what's the difference between
hufflepuff loyalty
and slytherin fraternity the word
fraternity makes me think of fraternity
houses so it makes me think of hierarchy
hazing and stuffy social circles with no
real intimacy
the word loyalty is warm and snuggly it
makes me think of a labrador
even though everyone knows you can be
loyal to a bad person
this makes something as simple as the
in-group loyalty between slytherin seem
dangerous and creepy even though it
exists in every house
rowling laughs in interviews about how
she's got that gryffindor showboating in
a store but what's the difference
between gryffindor showboatiness and
slytherin pridefulness
it's basically the color scheme all this
is a little stigmatizing and upon
observation it seems like slytherin
students are the ones
most likely to be sticky with each other
and have you ever noticed how a lot of
characters don't fit their house
the most famous one is why is hermione
not in ravenclaw something so obvious
it's asked by the characters in the
story but there are other examples
fred and george weasley are cunning
pranksters who are ambitious about
inventing new pranks and opening up a
prank shop fred and george are the only
people we see during the story actively
working on new ways to use magic
they're using it for toys and pranks but
that's still what they're doing
that sounds very ravenclaw or a shoe-in
for slytherin if snakes had shoes
oh and consider the crab and the goyle
if you will
they're in slytherin but their only
personality trait is that they're dumb
and strong
this idea that they're cunning is
hysterical
but let me tell you what they really are
they are unofficial
unpaid bodyguards of draco malfoy
imagine if you will
the bravery the nerve it takes every day
just to keep draco's teeth in his mouth
it's big gryffindor energy is what i'm
trying to say
quite frankly it's not only the dream of
every skinny coward to have two huge
dudes back you up but
also it's just like a herculean task but
uh why does it work out this way
well personality is actually quite
plastic especially when you're a kid and
people
are more versatile than we often give
them credit for even within a narrative
most harry potter characters who have
fleshed out personalities have
more than one house you could
hypothetically sort them into
because the house traits are kind of
vague and situational and they blend
together
they could apply to anyone at different
times in their life
so why are the sneaky children in the
dungeon
well uh the magic hat judges your
personality and it sees your inner
nature you can't just pick
whatever answer you want except that's
exactly how it works that's
literally what harry did harry comforts
his son albus in the epilogue by
reminding him that if it means so much
to you you can just tell the hat
not slytherin dude don't give me the
house with the mandatory spooky lighting
i want to be able to read in my common
room
the sorting hat does not place you for
what you are it places you for your
values your values at age 11 that are
probably just your family's values
unless you're a
serious black sheep so let's set the
stage for a new problem
although there are no rules saying that
people from different houses can't be
friends with each other they are
separated most of the day
in a sort of faux geographical divide
they have different living spaces where
they have their own common rooms and
dorms
although they don't have strictly
assigned seats at the great hall most
students sit with their house
this is prime socialization time for
students because what's left
seeing each other in the hallways or
talking to people in class
if you're allowed oh and days off but by
the time one of those comes around
you'll probably just want to spend it
with
your friends and this us versus them
it's encouraged the classroom is turned
into a game with a housepoint system
harry knows who belongs to what house on
site without knowing names
so that leads fans to speculate that
there must be some difference
in their uniforms and the movies make
these differences more pronounced
it's considered so weird to root for
someone else's quidditch team that the
only person who does it is luna lovegood
whose perhaps most distinctive
personality trait is that she's weird
she's a weirdo have you ever seen luna
without her radish earrings
that's weird most of the time in the
books when two people from a different
house are interacting with each other in
a positive way it has something to do
with dating
so the main thing getting you to
interact with people from other houses
is looking up from your quill and being
like all right you know what
if i had known all the hot people were
gonna be in ravenclaw i would have
showed up to the castle with a different
mindset
i'm just letting that be known it's a
very slytherin thing to say isn't it
goddammit
now when i put all this together it
might sound like i'm saying oh poor
snake babies the school is biased
against them
nope i don't think so slytherin is
definitely gridlocked in conflict with
gryffindor but it's reciprocal
the only example of bias i can think of
is dumbledore in the first installment
dumping a ton of points on gryffindor
last minute which causes slytherin to
lose the house cup
and while harry and his friends
definitely earned those points
from the outside it looks random as all
hell and don't get me wrong this
is hilarious i mean unfair but
slytherin had won the house cup six
years in a row and even once they begin
losing they're usually in second place
so teachers definitely award slytherin
students points for good behavior
if you're using house points as proof of
bias it's actually hufflepuff or
ravenclaw who are having a hard time
you know i'll remind you all this
hogwarts nonsense
has serious consequences in the adult
magical world because
it means all the little bigots get to
fester together in the dungeon where the
password on the entrance to the common
room in harry second year was literally
pure blood they're not socialized with
many muggleborns or people who don't
share their beliefs and they are the
group of students who
desperately need that we know zero
zero blood racist non-slytherins whom
attended hogwarts
it never comes up as a motivator for
pettigrew quarrel but there's
grindelwald
but he doesn't even go here i also think
it's notable pettigrew the evil
gryffindor's primary trait is that he's
a cowardly rat
he's not the brave gryffindor he's
supposed to be all this tells me
one evil in harry potter has a very
specific look and attitude to assist the
story's themes it's parasitic
it cowers in the face of death
voldemort's a pretty one-dimensional
hello i'm evil bad guy
so it actually helps harry potter as a
story that evil has this
very specific aesthetic and mindset it
makes it feel like it's
everywhere that it infects things it
sort of helps voldemort brute force his
way into iconicness
but as a result where evil comes from in
this series is
way too specific and can be easily
simplified into not
loving people enough and fearing death
too much
harry rarely deals with death anxiety
the times he does are memorable but
harry potter is more about grief and how
it's entwined with love
two either slytherins are all
brainwashing each other once they're in
the dungeon or having the belief that
non-magical people or muggle-born people
are lesser
is a secret factored in value that's
heavily weighted compared to other
traits
and it will get you shoved face-first
into salazar's steamy bowl of bigotry
soup
every time when people get defensive
about fans boiling down slytherin into a
house of bullies
i think they forget something very
important it's not just about these
traits
there is a hidden value on this list
draco was
raised to have these biases he showed up
to the school with them and what the
school did was reinforce them by letting
him live in a bubble
with the young severus snape it's
similar but a little different
snape had a physically abusive muggle
father half blood prince
is a little nickname that works on
multiple levels prince is his mother's
maiden name and she was a witch
it's a way for his teenage self to
reject his magic hating muggle father's
family name
as a child he befriended harry's mother
lily and he would tell her about how
they were special because they had magic
and that they would go to hogwarts this
wonderful magical place
unfortunately for snape he was separated
from his friend by the sorting hat
growing up he was harassed and attacked
often by james potter and his friends
this was ruthless bullying that on one
occasion crossed the line into very
public sexual harassment and this was
toned down in the movie
book snape was not the loner he looks to
be in the movie's quick flashbacks
he retreated into the arms of his fellow
slytherins
lily was infuriated by snape's ability
to hang out with voldemort supporters
and snape was furious that lily would
hang out with his
bullies this leads up to snape calling
lily a mudblood and ruining their
friendship forever now if you were
unaware of what slytherin house was like
you might say
where the hell did that come from when
he started school he was only biased
against muggles
how did his bigotry expand well it came
from his friends it came from
slytherin's influence over him
dumbledore has this line you know i
sometimes think
we sort too soon we'll get to it don't
worry
there's an interesting metaphor in here
somewhere that slytherin house is a den
of snakes that fills
children with its venom made funnier by
the fact that their dorm is the hogwarts
dungeon
also known as a prison and while the
prison may seem comfortable and
aesthetic
it's very much a magical blood racism
factory
and their upbringing puts them there
people who take harry potter house
personality quizzes don't
factor magical blood racism into the
equation because why
would they and then these real people
are given a house and they
identify with it and buy key chains and
sweaters
the official quiz is like you like the
moon you like white
cats and vampires wow you're a slytherin
a muggle slytherin cue confused
salazar noises i have seen harry potter
fans pick what familiar they'd bring
what wand they would have
they typically don't imagine how blood
racist they'd be you know not everyone
can be home stuck
the hogwarts houses are presented to us
as four valid choices but they're not in
their current form
we are presented with a pretty plausible
system of indoctrination
chilling out at hogwarts in plain sight
sanctified in tradition but the
characters don't do anything about it
story didn't show them becoming more
than what they first appeared and rising
to the occasion
which was the thing i think they set up
most for in the fifth year the sorting
hat sings out oh know the perils read
the signs
the warning history shows from our
hogwarts is in danger
from external deadly foes and we must
unite inside her
or will crumble from within i have told
you
i have warned you let the sorting now
begin
well no apparently hogwarts didn't have
to unite they didn't mention anyone
remastering slytherin house or the
hogwarts houses
and they didn't remove slytherin as a
house no don't they not slap my
sweatshirt i think it's the lack of
action that bothers me it's bothered me
since i was a kid it feels so unfinished
and it's surprising because it's such an
obvious loose end it's secondary to
voldemort of course but it's the true
birthplace of voldemort as a concept
and i've held off on telling you
possibly the biggest missed opportunity
slytherin students not participating in
the battle of hogwarts like the other
students
if properly built up this would be a
cool moment especially when you consider
how much scarier it would be for many of
them as they'd be going up against their
own family in battle
it would give a sense that yeah maybe
harry is biased and slytherin house
isn't just draco and his loudest dumbest
cruelest
friends and here's a laugh and a half
there was a reddit post from four years
ago of a confused fan asking why in
random locations online
people talk as if slytherin returned to
the battle of hogwarts's reinforcements
it all seems to go back to one source
episode 131 of a podcast named
pottercast
where rowling was a guest star wow and
how much
is it that being sorted into slytherin
is you know sorted into
good guys and bad guys here well they're
not
all bad that would i i know i've said
this before
and i think i said it to emerson they
are not all bad and and
well far from it as we know at the end
they may have
they may have a slightly more highly
developed sense of self-preservation
than other people a part of the final
battle that made me smile
was slughorn galloping back with
slytherins yes but they'd gone off to
get reinforcements first you know what
i'm saying so
that yes they came back they came back
to fight
so i mean i'm but i'm sure many people
would say well that's common sense isn't
it
isn't that smart to get out get more
people and come back with them
i have no idea what she's talking about
i can't find it
i feel like that would be a significant
moment for harry if he realized there
were slytherins who would fight
did she wreck conor's story in a podcast
i can't fathom forgetting something like
that
i sometimes think we sought too soon
by sorting the children you're
hypothetically judging them for their
values
but there's something about this
sentence i hate especially when you
consider how it goes unresolved there
shouldn't be a wrong place to put a
child
some aspects of snape's backstory
demonstrate the cruelty of the system
and how it became a breeding ground for
magical blood racism
and dumbledore has dialogue expressing
that he's beginning to see the problem
but
no one fixes it and i don't believe it
i don't believe slytherin is actually
reformed i don't believe the root of the
problem has been sufficiently addressed
they put a picture of slughorn in the
common room because of his bravery at
the battle which implies an ideological
shift but it's literally just hanging up
a picture
if i were headmaster i would get rid of
slytherin or rework the sorting system
completely at the very least make sure
students get resorted every year
the existence of houses on their own
isn't necessarily harmful to children
and house that central tenant is
ambition likewise
is perfectly fine to me but the hogwarts
houses as they stand
stupidly help promote the ideological
fracturing of the adult wizarding world
i can't help but feel like a new
voldemort is going to sprout up from
slytherin like a dandelion and the
wizarding world is once again
not going to be prepared for it for me
it makes the deaths that occurred during
the war
and the victory at the battle of
hogwarts feel a little pointless
and not in the a circle of violence way
or in a tragic pulling on your
heartstrings way but in a sort of
did i leave the stove on kind of way
oh i hate to do it to you but
statistically it works
if you're amused by the thought of
fueling my slytherin ambitions then like
this video
and leave a comment to boost the
algorithmic ranking
youtube informs me that many of the
people who watch my videos aren't
subscribed so please do that please
subscribe and ring the bell and if
you're die hard enough about what i do
here you can support me on patreon
well see you later
