---
title: 'Exercise Scientist Critiques Famous Movie Training Scenes (Rocky & More!)'
source: 'https://youtube.com/watch?v=h3ZymzaPVSI'
video_id: 'h3ZymzaPVSI'
date: 2026-11-12
duration_sec: 1316
channel: 'Renaissance Periodization'
---

# Exercise Scientist Critiques Famous Movie Training Scenes (Rocky & More!)

> Source: [Exercise Scientist Critiques Famous Movie Training Scenes (Rocky & More!)](https://youtube.com/watch?v=h3ZymzaPVSI)

## Summary

This video features an exercise scientist and a bodybuilder critiquing the training scenes from popular boxing movies like Rocky, Creed 2, Southpaw, and GI Jane. They analyze the realism and effectiveness of the depicted exercises, separating Hollywood entertainment from evidence-based fitness advice.

### Key Points

- **Desert Training Intro** [00:01] — The video opens with a humorous scene of someone training in the desert with a hammer, which is described as great anterior chain training with a slight risk of heat stroke.
- **Speed is Largely Genetic** [01:42] — The coach in Rocky says 'to beat this guy, you need speed. You don't have it.' The scientist agrees, noting that while technique can be trained, speed is largely genetic and age-based, making it hard to improve significantly later in life.
- **Better Cardio for Boxing** [02:34] — The scientist suggests that limited sparring with multiple opponents is a better form of boxing cardio than road work, as it mimics the actual demands of the sport and provides a higher intensity workout.
- **Blunt Force Trauma Strategy** [04:09] — The coach's plan to use 'good old-fashioned blunt force trauma' is validated. The scientist explains that getting significantly stronger is a logical strategy if you already have boxing skill and cardio, especially without weight class restrictions.
- **Rocky's Training Montage** [05:23] — The montage features compound heavy lifts like weighted pull-ups, incline press, and kettlebell swings, which are all considered effective exercises for building strength.
- **Impressive Incline Press** [06:05] — The scientist notes that Rocky is inclining 365 pounds, which is a legitimate amount of weight that indicates knockout power, though he points out the weight is likely fake for filming.
- **Weightlifting Belt Critique** [06:35] — The scientist critiques Rocky's traditional weightlifting belt, noting it doesn't distribute intra-abdominal pressure as evenly as a powerlifting belt, which would be better for strength training.
- **Creed 2: Desert Running** [07:40] — The scientist warns that running in the desert can lead to heat stroke and is risky, as someone could collapse without warning, which is a medical concern.
- **Neck Training Importance** [09:08] — The scientist emphasizes that neck training is important for boxers for stability, and it's crucial to train both anterior and posterior neck muscles.
- **Michael B. Jordan's Physique** [10:00] — The scientist praises Michael B. Jordan's physique as believable for a pro boxer, unlike some older movies where athletes were portrayed by regular guys with beer bellies.
- **Abs Training Critique** [10:38] — The scientist critiques the ab training in Creed 2, saying he would prefer to get his punishment in sparring rather than doing extra ab work that adds fatigue and takes away from recovery.
- **Southpaw: Jump Rope** [11:33] — Jump rope is praised as a good ancillary method for boxing cardio and footwork endurance, though it's noted that the tricks are mostly for demonstration.
- **Oxygen Mask is Dumb** [12:03] — The scientist explains that oxygen masks don't provide any beneficial effect on the oxygen you breathe in and actually reduce your workload, making training harder without making you better.
- **Explosive Med Ball Rotations** [12:32] — The scientist recommends doing med ball rotations with maximum rapidity and explosive power for each rep, as boxing requires demonstrating power over many reps.
- **Core Boxing Training** [13:17] — The scientist states that heavy bag, pad work, and limited sparring are about 90% of all you need for boxing training, outside of weight training, cardio, and diet.
- **Teaching Tools vs Real Sparring** [14:01] — Drills like the string drill are seen as teaching tools with lower transfer to real fighting compared to actual sparring, which provides real-world integration of technique.
- **Jake's Training Simplicity** [15:36] — The scientist notes that Jake's training in Southpaw is a simple combination of heavy resistance training, sets of five, compound lifts, and a ton of boxing training, which is realistic.
- **GI Jane: Deficit Push-ups** [17:39] — Deficit push-ups are praised as a great exercise with phenomenal range of motion, excellent control, and beautiful speed, making it accidentally the best training movie review.
- **GI Jane's Strength** [19:01] — The scientist expresses huge respect for the actress's ability to perform the exercises, noting she demonstrates a shitload of upper body strength.
- **Hollywood vs Reality** [20:36] — The scientist concludes that Hollywood movies are entertaining but not a source for training tips. He advises viewers to seek evidence-based fitness content instead of copying movie workouts.

## Transcript

the hell am I in the desert with a hammer?" Great anterior chain training. hammer?" Great anterior chain training. Slight risk of uh heat stroke.
of exercise and sport science. I bodybuild. I do the jiu-jitsu grappling. bodybuild. I do the jiu-jitsu grappling. And I watch a decent number of movies. Typically, the movies I watch suck as I have awful movie taste. Today, we did a
thing we've done once before, which is we go and we look at Hollywood movies. Gh. Your uncle invented Hollywood, but with a new twist to see what kind of movies. And do they like make sense make sense or are they sort of something you
can try that works or has Hollywood uh just gone for the entertainment factor and is the training scene or diet stuff total nonsense? Let's figure it out. Let's stay kind and respectful yet um comedically expansive. All jokes, all
comedically expansive. All jokes, all love and respect. 3 2 1 love and respect. 3 2 1 Hollywood. fighting. So there's no sense us going down that same old road again. To beat
down that same old road again. To beat this guy, you need speed. You don't have it. [laughter] &gt;&gt; I remember the scene completely right on. Right. This next this scene is talking about what you could possibly
optimize at a given very like restricted age and injury status and and ability crank on to make a difference? And there's tons of wisdom here. So yeah,
speed. You can train speed with technique, but speed is largely genetic and unfortunately largely age- based. So had the genetics for speed, if you know Rocky BBO, the fictional character,
Scott, he never was never fast, right? Oh, I take the punches with my face. face. He's not a fast guy. It's not what he did. And so the idea that you can make someone way faster by training them, especially later in life, is
they're already technically skilled, which he is. So, so far the coach is just like knocking out of the park. &gt;&gt; And your knees can't take the pound, so hard running is out. &gt;&gt; Okay, so we've abandoned cardio. Okay, I
will say uh road work is really good for boxing cardio, but there's better ways of doing cardio for boxing. And the best one is, uh, limited sparring, which is that that tends to not work out so well long longevity wise. Limited hard
sparring with multiple opponents at the same time or in sequence. So there's one of you and there's three decent guys you're sparring against. And you can even do this with pads. And so you just go like 2 minutes with one person, 2
minutes with another person, 2 minutes with one other person, rest however long you need to pick yourself up off the floor and repeat. that kind of cardio is boxing or whatever other sport you practice for. Because the guys you're
going against get triple the time to recover that you do, they're always good, after a few minutes of this kind of stuff, even not so great guys are going to out cardio you and at least make you work. [music] So, but you know,
Typically, you do lots of road work. So, he's like, "Okay, we can't even get you into much better cardio shape. Running is out. Facts, respect." when you're 60 trillion years old like Rocky was in this movie or is in a sky supposed to be
in his 70s for this, right? Like Yeah. Like uh maybe running's kind of out of the equation thing for later. &gt;&gt; Okay. Runnings out of the equation for &gt;&gt; Okay. &gt;&gt; And you got arthritis in your neck and
you've got calcium deposits on most of your joints. So sparring is out. &gt;&gt; Okay, that takes care of that one. Uh there are ways you can spar with all that stuff, but it's tough. It's tough. What we'll be calling on is good
oldfashioned blunt force trauma. &gt;&gt; Fuck yeah, Scott. Have you ever heard life? [music] And there's truth in this. Just making yourself way stronger is going to make a big difference if you already know the skill of boxing. If you
boxing, if you have a good baseline of cardio, getting way stronger, especially if there's no weight class cap by gaining muscle and weight absolutely almost nothing else does. That's why they have weight classes in boxing, by
you imagine you let the heavyweights like fight the rooster weights and like open open boxing championships, it would just be like unethical or something like that. So very very logical strategy to exploit for this fictional scene. Love,
love, love. &gt;&gt; Horsepower. Heavyduty cast iron pile driving punches that will have to hurt so much they'll rattle his ancestors. &gt;&gt; Scott, can I hit the microphone or something?
&gt;&gt; First montage scene. He's running. &gt;&gt; But Scott out. &gt;&gt; Okay, keep that in mind.
&gt;&gt; Okay, keep that in mind. &gt;&gt; Okay. Okay. God damn it. Yeah, weighted pull-ups. Yeah, dude. Sylvester Stallone's the man. And uh Rocky the character is the man. So, we got compound heavy basic.
We got incline press, compound heavy basic, kettle bell swing. We'll take it. He hated it. &gt;&gt; He smashed his hand with it. His dog has &gt;&gt; He smashed his hand with it. His dog has a sweater on, which is sweet.
&gt;&gt; The dog doesn't seem interested. Holy shit. Now, okay, you know that's fake weight, but that's for filming. And he's got three plates on a standard bar doing a return from clean position. Hell yeah.
Did you see that shit? That was like 300 and some odd pounds. Two plates of 35, 295, 345, 365. If he's inclining 365 for even a single, that is like legit 100% knockout
power. If he's doing reps with that shit, bro. Like, mission accomplished. I anymore. Hey, he cleaned it this time, but he's pissed cuz he didn't press it. One thing that I did notice, I will say right
there. Pause. He has a traditional weightlifting belt on because he's You guys see that the belt is thicker in the back, thinner in the front, and that's a damn good belt. But the problem is it doesn't evenly distribute your
intraabdominal pressure. It would be a little better if his belt was an even height all around, like a powerlifting belt that if he was training for hypertrophy, and he's not. He's training for strength. So, all is well, he could
take his shit to one extra next level. Having a belt that conforms to the body, that looks awesome, that's taller than a traditional powerlifting belt, offering you even more of an aesthetic look and even more intraabdominal pressure up and
down, left to right, super adjustable. And we have just the thing for you, the description. You can buy it. [music] It is discounted for you guys. And it is the unbelievable belt specifically for getting you jacked. You don't need the
belt, but but it's nice and if Rocky had it, it wouldn't really change his training at all. But if he was trying to get more jacked, it would help. So, some good stuff there, some not great stuff. Mixed bag as usual. Now, our next movie
is going to be Creed 2, which I happen to love. [music] Scott, did you know eight times? &gt;&gt; Oh, wow. I've never seen any of these movies. [laughter]
hell am I in the desert with a hammer? Great anterior uh chain training. Slight Great anterior uh chain training. Slight risk of uh heat stroke.
Oh. Oh, Hollywood. Running in the desert to fighting. &gt;&gt; Like I mean if you survive it, it'll
from a medical perspective, Scott, like if someone in the desert is running around and then just falls seemingly for no good reason, like training camp gets on pause as you do tests at the hospital. [laughter]
Is the next time you go out, you could be like, "Oh, he's dead." So, you know, for Hollywood gh drama, Scott, every now and again when I'm like um like if your just don't really want to go out cuz she's like, "Oh my god, all my friends
just like pass out." You know? I'm like, "Oh, that's a way to get out of it." &gt;&gt; I hit my head. I think I should stay at home and just watch Netflix. &gt;&gt; She's like, "You only pass out on Friday nights at 8:00 p.m. What the hell?"
[music] &gt;&gt; Okay. [snorts] &gt;&gt; Okay. [snorts] [laughter] neck is important for boxers. It promotes stability. Um, it's cool. You
need to train anterior as much as posterior. hand here is not as sexy. So like you put like a a towel over your your forehead, you put weights on, you instead of just the backwards stuff. The backwards thing. Scott, remember that
one time you and I ended up at that club in Berlin for 8 hours and we had to put kinds of weird stuff happened. &gt;&gt; I blocked that out. &gt;&gt; I'm sorry that [music]
&gt;&gt; Oh, hell yeah, baby. You feel me? That hip-hop beat gets to smashing. Now we love it. Hollywood. It's got to get me every time, situation. &gt;&gt; Yo, that's what I was going to say, bro.
He's like got them Cobra traps and shit. I'm telling you, man. Black don't crack. Michael B. Jordan for these movies had aing unbelievable physique, bro. Just unbelievable. And it's okay. So, let me say that again. Believable for a pro
boxer, you know? Like sometimes you have these like back in the day, Scott, you made movies about athletes and it was just a regular guy playing. He was like, you're like, "My friend, you have a beer belly. You're not a runner. I can't
believe any part of the story." This I feel unbibs a thousand%. Yeah. Like that's a fine way to train your abs, I guess. And you have to
prepare for punishment. I don't know how much um I'll say this. I would typically like to get my punishment in sparring as there's only so much fatigue you can just have to recover from that and takes away from all your other recovery. I
improving my cardio at the same time while taking a certain unit of just hanging out and training my abs is probably not the way I would do it. Uh, having that vine ass body. Michael B. Jordan, what's up? You're the greatest
Michael Jordan to me. I can't say that outright, but but you're cool. outright, but but you're cool. [music] straightforward ways to get the bigger and stronger like using machines and
dragon with the shit is Man, it just looks so sweet. Some ups, some downs. What we got next, Scott? Southpaw. Scott, I've seen this movie. I was in a
good mood when I started watching it and then for the first hour of the movie, it gets really up. Jump rope's cool. He's in great shape. Jake gets in shape. &gt;&gt; It's cool. Jump rope tricks part of good boxing. It's mostly a demonstration of
does build the endurance you need for good footwork. So, it this uh very low beat up. So, it's an ancillary method to increase cardio. Jump rope is really good for boxing. Yeah. No uh no debate there.
&gt;&gt; Yeah, he has the oxygen mask. &gt;&gt; Masks don't do anything um beneficial at oxygen you're breathing in. And they reduce how much you're breathing out mostly, which is just it caps your workload for no reason. It's like making
that doesn't make you better. It's like during squats if you like put a spider you every now and again. Like does that make you better at squatting? No. It makes squatting harder, but it doesn't make you stronger. So the mask is dumb.
Medall rotations are totally cool. And if I were him, I would not be doing them slowly. I would be doing them with maximum rapidity, explosive power on each rep. Because in boxing, you want explosive power and the ability to do
So, you have to demonstrate power over many reps. If you just kind of put the maybe that's just designed to illustrate where you started or something. You really just want max power on each rep. &gt;&gt; I've never seen that. I I don't have an
expertise in boxing training. Hit the string. I mean, if you're pro trying to just seems reasonable, but I'm way out of my element for that one. No comment. Little bob and weave. Yeah. So, I will say like um
some of this is cool stuff and it's really nice in Hollywood cuz Hollywood likes quirky stuff that'll get the viewer to be like, "Whoa, neat." Um, almost all of this is, so you have heavy bag, you have pad work, and you have uh
limited sparring where they don't hit your head, and when they hit you, they hit you not full full power, and you don't hit them full power, but you hit them full speed. Between those three training modalities is probably about
90% of all you ever need outside of weight training and cardio and good diet for boxing. And so when they do these kinds of drills as a teaching tool for learn how to change levels and maintain their stance and advance their position,
I think it's great. Um Scott, this guy's a pro boxer, you know, like he he he knows Imagine if I took you into the gym and I was like, "Scott, I'm going to going to be like, "I I I know how to bench press. Can you put some weight on
the bar and have me do sets of five?" Right? Let's get to it. And so this kind of teaching tool stuff is relatable to a human, but in reality has a transfer of training that's substantially lower than actually going up against real humans
practicing different tactics and strategies and combos on them because gives you some even of the strength power work and it gives you a realworld integration of your technique into the
of objects you would see in a boxing ring. all the affordances are there as they would be uh the directions of movement, degrees of freedom and so you're really training for the actual thing itself. Um I guess an analogy
write the English alphabet. You're like yeah like first we start with vertical lines you're going to draw 100 vertical lines on a page like okay then you're going to draw horizontal lines. Okay. And then weeks later you're going to
but it's not the letter C. You're not ready for letters yet. You're like all right. And then eventually there you can just start practicing the letters. And words, you can just start writing essays. That is an analogy. Basically
once you know how to box, you do some boxing drills. This not so much a boxing boxing drills. This not so much a boxing drill.
professor. You're kidding. Folks, there is still more video to come. But if you want a bigger, longer uncut version of this video and tons of other bonus features, intellectual videos, vlogs for training for Jared and I, the member
links, you can sign up for it. It's a teeny bit of money and a huge bit of because it's time to go back to the video. In any case, to make Jake combination of heavy resistance training, sets of five, really heavy
weights, compound pushing and pulling, um, sets of three very light weights, um, sets of three very light weights, fast, and then a ton of boxing training, fast, and then a ton of boxing training, heavy bag, pads, and sparring. Couple
other things in there, not a whole lot. Real sport training is often way way simpler than many people would like to believe and then Hollywood movies would see some new shit, some cool stuff. If Scott, if you have the same training
montage in every boxing movie, it kind of geting weird, right? They got to do some shit to put in there. Turns out &gt;&gt; Yeah. Turns out way crazier, &gt;&gt; right? 100%. You are like shocking his balls and shit. Yo, GI Jane, I've
watched that without any s sound on or um &gt;&gt; Yeah, this one's just here to get us canceled. Really? I knew this was I knew &gt;&gt; Yes. &gt;&gt; Like before we even
jokes. &gt;&gt; Yo, two things. Military girls all can &gt;&gt; Yo, two things. Military girls all can get it. Warrior women 100%. Second of all, if you have a buzzcut, front of the line. Front of the line. Period.
line. Front of the line. Period. Scott, does that make me letter G? &gt;&gt; Yeah, whatever. I know you're in the same boat, you weirdo.
&gt;&gt; Scott, do you need D-sized titties to enroll in the modern military? Great technique, Scott. Wow. Yeah, she kills it.
&gt;&gt; This is how you get kilt in the real world. the chairs. Scott, &gt;&gt; deficit push-ups. &gt;&gt; Deficit push-ups. Amazing. Yo, badass.
a balance exercise if you're strong enough. If you're not strong enough, you how much balance you have, &gt;&gt; dude, you're freeze fraing like crazy &gt;&gt; Might be. Oh, is that her? Uh, you know what?
[music] Okay. Great exercise. Phenomenal range of motion. Excellent control. Beautiful speed, Scott. This is like accidentally becoming our best training movie review. &gt;&gt; Mhm.
She's on it, bro. Good technique. Good rom
why do they have to have the moonlight Scott them's moonlight shots? &gt;&gt; her mouth and stuff. &gt;&gt; Wow. &gt;&gt; Wow. &gt;&gt; Am I the bad person?
that's intense. &gt;&gt; I mean, she doesn't have big range of motion cuz Titty is I'm done. I'm done. [laughter] go. &gt;&gt; Well, for a reason. Scott freak of
&gt;&gt; Well, for a reason. Scott freak of nature. pull this off. Amazing. Demonstrates a shitload of upper body
&gt;&gt; I think they did that uncut long form intentional because she did do it. I these on. &gt;&gt; Yeah. Huge respect. I think she did like guest on some talk shows and she did a few of these shits like
if you got in such a good shape for a movie would you ever give it up later? like hey you have to have a role as like a like a retired stripper. And you're They're like, "No." You're like, "Okay, I'm done with Hollywood."
obese in the next movie." You're like, &gt;&gt; That's true acting, man. I don't have it in in me for I can only play one role. in in me for I can only play one role. Mike Ezra starring in You want to train
right to gain muscle, but there's so much complexity to it. What exercises to choose, what sets and reps to do, how much weight to lift, and how to uncertainty that it's easy to get overwhelmed. The RP Hypertrophy app
removes all uncertainty and makes the training process precisely defined. Choose your pre-made workout plan from dozens available in the app. Plug in the rest for months of productive training. Ready? Click on the link in
the description of this video to get started. Guys, Hollywood's entertaining, started. Guys, Hollywood's entertaining, but it will say a serious thing. get actual training tips from Hollywood
movies. shit they seen in the movie they're going to try at the gym. Mostly that doesn't work and it's not an affront on Hollywood. They're doing a great job to entertain you. You wouldn't read the physics equations on the board
of one of them uh Kaiju movies, the Pacific Rim movies and think you're going to like actually make a functional way, you wouldn't really copy the exercise they did in uh movies where
have a really good effect. some good stuff in there. Mostly some kind of weird stuff just for entertainment. I totally get that. So, if you're ever YouTube and watch some great evidence-based fitness content. Other
than that, Hollywood is Hollywood. There's loads of fun. If you guys need a There's loads of fun. If you guys need a GI Jane 2 or Trans GI Jane, I volunteer for for tribute. I could be cast as GI Jane.
tribute. I could be cast as GI Jane. um her coach, her confidant, her enemy, uh or her lover, but I'd like to be GI Jane. See you guys but I'd like to be GI Jane. See you guys next time.
Whoa. Um [music] Hollywood, if you want, I'm available for this next video that you could watch of me right here. See you guys next time.
