---
title: 'Exercise Scientist Critiques Daddy Noel: Is He Actually Right?'
source: 'https://youtube.com/watch?v=KzmRpMp9WhA'
video_id: 'KzmRpMp9WhA'
date: 2026-11-07
duration_sec: 1257
channel: 'Renaissance Periodization'
---

# Exercise Scientist Critiques Daddy Noel: Is He Actually Right?

> Source: [Exercise Scientist Critiques Daddy Noel: Is He Actually Right?](https://youtube.com/watch?v=KzmRpMp9WhA)

## Summary

This video features an exercise scientist reacting to and critiquing popular fitness advice, particularly from an influencer known as 'Daddy Noel.' The host evaluates specific chest training tips like incline press emphasis, pause reps, and elbow flaring, offering evidence-based counterpoints. The discussion also covers the role of steroids in achieving impressive physiques and the host's personal journey with bodybuilding.

### Key Points

- **Fitness Industry Critique** [01:07] — The video criticizes the fitness industry for being filled with 'slop' like gambling ads and AI-generated content, and calls out influencers who sell steroids and peptides.
- **Incline vs. Flat Press** [02:01] — Noel advises over-prioritizing the incline press, but the host argues that flat pressing is essential for overall pec size because it handles heavier weights and activates a larger portion of the chest.
- **Pause Reps Analysis** [04:20] — The pause rep advice from Noel is true for eliminating momentum, but the host clarifies that pausing reduces power output due to the loss of the stretch-shortening cycle; however, it reduces injury risk by avoiding high peak forces.
- **Barbells vs. Dumbbells** [05:20] — While dumbbells allow for a deeper stretch, they are less stable. The host recommends barbell pressing for most lifters to build a strong base and maximize strength gains.
- **Elbow Flaring** [06:55] — The host disputes the advice to avoid flaring elbows, noting that flaring actually engages both the pecs and delts, whereas tucking emphasizes the front delts. He emphasizes responsible flaring with controlled weights.
- **Steroid and Natural Physique Debate** [10:51] — Noel addresses the steroid debate, admitting he is enhanced but emphasizing that natural lifters can achieve amazing physiques. The host agrees, adding that steroids are only necessary for extreme 'mutant' size.
- **Wrist Straight Advice** [15:05] — The host criticizes the advice to keep wrists straight, explaining that it's unrealistic for heavy weights and distracts from the actual goal of moving the elbows and shoulders through a full range of motion.
- **Noel's Personal Journey** [17:39] — Noel shares his personal journey of chasing size (reaching 311 lbs) and re-evaluating his relationship with bodybuilding, prioritizing health and social media impact over competing.

## Transcript

wanted to be a mass monster. I was 311 &gt;&gt; That's big. All right, let's get some bench press &gt;&gt; Keep your feet at 90° hug your shoulder blades in and drive your feet into the
&gt;&gt; Really smart. Really smart. &gt;&gt; Make sure your wrists are straight. &gt;&gt; Make sure your wrists are straight. &gt;&gt; Make sure your wrists are straight is untenable advice that I really disagree with.
Two things. One. Another person that exists in the world is Noel Deyzel. He's a humongous social
physical sense, but also in the follower sense. We're going to talk all sorts of stuff about him. Let's do it.
&gt;&gt; Absolutely the first thing dramatic people say. Let's continue. &gt;&gt; But I'm so sick of this shit. Fitness industry is filled with slop. If it's not gambling ads or AI. &gt;&gt; Wait a minute. I love gambling ads,
specifically those made by AI. And check this out. Ready? New products got trying to get your AI to get addicted to gambling so that it gambles your money &gt;&gt; Dude, but it would probably do pretty good at gambling better than you would.
&gt;&gt; Yeah. Oh crap, we'd lose money on that. Never mind, bad idea. &gt;&gt; It's kids selling peptides, OF or promoting drug use. And this is from influencers that already rich, making even more money from the community's
downfall. Like what happened to wanting to be better than you were yesterday and leaving a legacy that you're proud of? &gt;&gt; What if better than yesterday means selling peptides and steroids?
&gt;&gt; Now I'm on a mission to change some shit because I know that you guys are as because I know that you guys are as tired as I am. &gt;&gt; Influence in a more &gt;&gt; or way?
That's wholesome. I like that. &gt;&gt; So many people over-prioritize [music] neglect the horizontal press and other angles. Second, incorporate pause reps. &gt;&gt; All right, we'll take these one at a time. These are awesome chest tips. Man,
Noel has a point on the incline over-prioritization. It's very easy, and I've seen this a bunch, and you guys probably have too, bunch, and you guys probably have too, from a hey, adding this or emphasizing
this is a good thing gets transmuted in some people's minds and in the cultural some people's minds and in the cultural milieu, so to speak, into this is the thing to do. After a while, this is the thing to do becomes this is the only
thing you should be doing. So we go from use a variety of presses and flies to get an overall developed chest to you should emphasize incline because upper pecs are important to incline and upper pecs, that's what you do. Like I've
literally had people tell me straight up, very honest, super innocent about them, well, isn't nutrition all about the gut microbiome? It's like but no no, it's literally not. That is a minor feature, an important minor feature, but
that's Jesus Christ, that's maybe 5 or 10% of it. And this person had heard so much, to Noel's point, slop about it that they forgot it. And so to Noel's exact point, yes, you can emphasize incline, but flat pressing lets you
handle big weights. It actually activates a huge fraction of the chest and gets you very big overall pecs. And here's a big big big point that I want to emphasize to you guys. There is a big difference between having a big chest of
which the upper part is the biggest part, which is a sweet look, and to emphasizing something that is so small that even if you emphasize a part of it, it just makes it look really really unbalanced and no one notices that there
part isn't big. And so you run into a lot of people, people. Scott, I'm sure you see this before, being an old Harry Potter pencil neck who weighs 115 lbs. And he's like, I got to like emphasize the peak
I got to like emphasize the peak contraction of my my incline cable flies you're like, motherfucker, what pack? We don't have any packs. What are you great point. &gt;&gt; This eliminates momentum and forces
[music] your chest to generate more power from a stretched position. it does eliminate momentum for the pause. Your chest does not generate more pause it because the stretch shortening cycle,
the stretch shortening reflex actually allows you to generate the most power if you come down, don't stop and come back up quickly. So to maximize power development, you actually do want to eliminate the pause.
actually do want to eliminate the pause. The huge upside to pausing at the bottom is injury risk reduction because in that real stretch position, when you go down and up really quickly, that is by far the highest force you're
going to see in the entire movement. And so if you want to mitigate, you want to doing presses, you are going to want to pause at the Probably won't help you out with power. &gt;&gt; Third, [music] use more dumbbells.
&gt;&gt; Using more dumbbells is a curious piece of advice. I actually would consider that good advice for some people, but for other people, I think it may be better to use more barbells and I will put a fine point on it. Here's why.
Dumbbells do allow you in some instances, especially if you do it such them outside of your chest on the way down to get a deeper stretch, which is excellent. But in many cases, dumbbells are just a little bit less stable than
barbells, which means that your chest isn't actually able to produce as much force as it typically would with barbells and potentially miss out on some sort of strength gains and maybe even some growth. Now it's all super
etc., But what I've noticed over the past quite a long time, 10, 15 years, is that really jacked, really strong bodybuilders get really jacked and strong doing lots of barbell pressing. When they get really big and strong,
they're now older and really big and really strong and barbell pressing, especially heavy, carries the risks of very heavy lifting. good technique, so their joints are kind of messed up, so they switch to
dumbbells and everything feels gnarly because the dumbbells are lighter and position that doesn't hurt their shoulders. younger lifters that are still building up their base say, hey listen, barbells
are not a good idea. There's a time and a place for the fast majority of your hypertrophy training, barbells are an amazing tool and because I think they're slightly underused by most people today, I'll say using more barbells is probably
&gt;&gt; Don't flare your elbows too much because that uses more delts than pecs.
lot, you're using more delts than pecs. And if you flare less bringing your elbows in, then you're using more pecs than delts. If you think about it logically though,
if you take your elbows and you bring them completely flush to your side and then you move the arm up and forward, what this does is it directly vectors into the front delt. That is actually the front delt's main job is to
push that arm up and forward. The main job of the pecs is that, but also bringing the arm closer into the body. And so if you flare, you actually engage both better than if you don't flare.
And while extreme flaring can, absolutely if you do it irresponsibly, irritate your shoulder joints or give you a slightly higher risk of tearing a peck. If you do it responsibly, slow and controlled eccentrics, good pauses, and
manageable weights that you're not like rushing into, I would say flaring out your elbows, pushing them up a little bit, something that you see at the extreme with like a guillotine press, you probably activate more pecs than
not. And so it has become fashionable in recent years to say that tucking your elbows in actually trains the chest more, and I think that's a little bit backwards, but I could be mistaken. &gt;&gt; This is what's actually in my gym bag.
So the first thing you're going to see is a lot of pre-workout. to a very well-meaning icon of the industry.
Who actually puts entire containers of stuff in their gym bag? Scott, have you ever seen a real person who carried around giant containers of supplements &gt;&gt; I've seen people pull out the pre-workout and dry scoop it in the gym
100%. Vegas baby, Vegas. &gt;&gt; Vegas. &gt;&gt; Vegas. [laughter] I guess. &gt;&gt; Self-explanatory wrist straps.
I ran into an incident I want to tell you about. I was traveling to see a friend of mine in Spain, and I went through Spanish customs after landing in Madrid. I had my gym bag on me, of course, and
the Spanish customs folks [music] asked me what was in it. I had several kilograms of cocaine. They thought that was totally fine. I had a they said looked relatively harmless and complimented me on my scientific
error. They took out the Versa Grips that I had in my bag, and they asked me what the Versa Grips were. And as they asked me and my answer became less and less likely to be the truth, they started to
motion towards their pistols. My explanation for what the Versa Grips were started with, it is a device that you can use that is way better than a wrist strap because it has the stickiness to it. You wrap it only once
around any barbell, any dumbbell, any machine, you wrap your hand over it, and your hand will not let go short of snapping your wrist off completely. Versa Gripps is a sponsor of this video, and you can look at the link in the
description for savings. But I wanted to be completely truthful, so I continued. I told them that this particular material in this device was recovered from the 1940s Roswell alien crash, could not be identified on the table of
periodic elements, and was actually technically, tactically manufactured by [gasps] Scott, I was in jail for a week in Spain, which is why I love me a Versa Gripp.
&gt;&gt; Steroid is key. Lots of steroid like this dude. social media comment. &gt;&gt; Classic. Thanks so much for &gt;&gt; First of all, I don't want you to think you need to be enhanced to get a good
creating limiting beliefs in your own mind. But bro, I'm glad you have the critical thinking to understand that I am enhanced. I've always been open and transparent about it. Let's use these guys as an example because they look
phenomenal. So please, don't let me or other enhanced lifters hold you back naturally. &gt;&gt; There are two perspectives on this. Both of them have validity. The jaundice perspective, the joke there is double
get when your liver gets cooked from too many oral steroids, is that the vast influencers or some large fraction are on steroids, and that if you really want influencer, you're going to be on steroids. And anyone who tells you
steroids. And anyone who tells you otherwise is lying self-interestedly supplements or apps or whatever else they sell, their programs are the thing that gets you results. There is validity to that view. It's not the most wrong
people are on steroids and won't tell you otherwise and sell you stuff. of those people. He straight up says, I'm enhanced, and I absolutely own that,
excellent point, which is the other correct way to see this. To get a good physique, no, no. To get a great physique, no, no, no. To get an amazing
physique, no, no, no. To get an amazing physique for almost everybody does not require steroids. If you want to go fast in a car, If you want to go fast in a car, do you have to get NOS and 18-in tires
installed? 18 in wide, I mean. No, Jesus Christ. Any stock Mustang or Camaro or Corvette is going to go really fast already. So you don't need any extras for sure. And in just the same way, if you want a phenomenal physique,
any crazy health complications, financial complications, legal complications, mood complications, and just complications, then you just do not ever have to do steroids. If you want to be the biggest
steroids. If you want to be the biggest mutant freak out there in 2026, you're going to have to do some steroids. And I think an amazing physique is a very different world than my most freaky mutant physique. Those
And so Noel put up some pictures there of people who have amazing physiques that are drug-free, and that is absolutely possible. And I got news for you, pimps and pimpettes. If you think every amazing physique you've ever seen
that claims natty isn't natty, you're just doing a shitload of coping because you have some combination of shitty genetics, shitty work ethic, former. &gt;&gt; I love you,
&gt;&gt; Heavy barbell bench press. Keep your feet at 90 degrees. you only as a heavy barbell bench press? &gt;&gt; I mean, you know, he gets the game. You
&gt;&gt; Any meme will do. &gt;&gt; meme will do. It doesn't matter. &gt;&gt; I thought that &gt;&gt; was going to go differently. I love you &gt;&gt; Wakes up under an overpass. &gt;&gt; Tell me you love me for real.
Please, Connor, kill me. I'd never kill you, Stacy. You're my best friend. Sorry, I was recounting my last Tuesday. I was the victim, to be clear. While there is still more of this video left over and with good stuff, I might add,
may I direct you politely to our members section, which is ever so chock full of extra goodies. We legitimately do a bunch of videos now in members, which are super nuanced, super advanced, super intellectual, super sciencey to get you
member section. We've got all kinds of good stuff, including an elongated back to the video. &gt;&gt; Take the ball, run along your hand, corkscrew your elbows in. &gt;&gt; Corkscrew your elbows in. I'm not
comments. &gt;&gt; Make sure your wrists are straight. &gt;&gt; Make sure your wrists are straight is untenable advice that I really disagree with.
One, when you bench a sufficiently heavy amount of weight, you will not be able weight you can keep your wrist straight with is way smaller than the amount of can actually press. If you guys look at the best bench
pressers in the world doing their thing in competition, almost none of them are trying or succeeding to have their wrists be straight. Number two reason good idea is it diverts away focus from the actual purpose of the lift, which is
to move your elbows and your shoulders through a certain range of motion and to accomplish pec, front delt, and triceps hypertrophy. As a matter of fact, if your barbell was hooked right below your wrist into position and you could do
probably be even better for pec development because you wouldn't have to worry about anything your hands were doing and that instability there. That's about your wrists if there's no risk of injury for doing it and no benefit for
performance occupying space in your mind when the only thing that should be you're bench pressing is one, the technical merits of actually pressing inspirational visual imagery like Godzilla stepping on a school bus, a
freight train hitting a school bus, a clown with a knife running into a school bus full of children. Scott, there's something wrong with me, Probably caused by children in a school bus
bus at some point in my childhood. I have a better one. Imagine a person when you're benching with the biggest pecs in the world
and he's got a beautiful family and an amazing household and wonderful career aspirations, and that could be you. The only thing keeping you from that is get overwhelmed. The RP Hypertrophy app removes all
uncertainty and makes the training process precisely defined. Choose your available in the app, plug in your weights, and the app takes care of the rest for months of productive training. Ready? Click on the link in the
started. &gt;&gt; Over the last few years, I really had to rethink and re-evaluate my relationship with bodybuilding. For
my relationship with bodybuilding. For around 15 years, I chased size and I wanted to be a mass monster, and I did exactly that. I was 311 lb at my peak. &gt;&gt; Oh, that's big. It's difficult to live your life when
you're that big. You can't reach stuff you used to reach. Tough. &gt;&gt; I wanted to compete and chase the pro bodybuilding life, but it was so hard on my health. Now, in the same time period,
had multiple surgeries. &gt;&gt; Oh man, that sucks. &gt;&gt; And through all of that, I was left with the thought, do I really want to do anyone from the sport because bodybuilding was one the best [music]
42 this year. I sat down at a hard conversation with and I came to the realization that I can have a far greater impact on people's lives through my social media than a few minutes on stage holding a
than a few minutes on stage holding a trophy. to get famous and then once you're famous you can get less jacked and you you never get jacked to begin with, the probability you'll have a positive
impact through bodybuilding and through being jacked is lower. Um I think Noel probably made a very very wise decision coming off a ton of gear and not trying to super chase size because especially into your 40s that
as of the recording this video, I'm also for what probably will end up being a bodybuilding show at the very least the shape of my life, but I'm doing it with way way way fewer steroids than typical,
like a third of the ones I used to take, which uh for me seems like a really good idea. I'm definitely in that camp where after a certain point taking a bunch of gear just makes no god damn sense. And also I'm not trying to get my biggest
anymore. I basically have an off-season cap of about 225 to 235 lbs plus or minus and I just don't ever exceed that. And as a matter of fact, probably really shortly after this show or series of shows that I'm hopefully going to do,
I'm going to downsize closer to 210 lbs and be on essentially just TRT and work on aesthetically balancing my physique until non-androgenic anabolic drugs come
out in late 2020s or early 2030s and then Scott, no promises, bro. Because I need giant giant arms and shoulders.
seems like he is a very very good human being. in between, I would absolutely give him a follow because it's hilarious, really good advice, and honestly some good just like
qualified to give, but I think Noles probably the better guy to get it from. Noles gets a dad vibes that are super official exercise and sports science rating.
And I will see you shortly because we have an outro.
you can click on for the fun to continue. See you next time.
