[00:04]
always been the sheer volume of stuff it throws at you, potentially stealing hundreds of hours as you do everything from hunting animals with a bow to developing a gambling addiction at the tavern. So, it's not very surprising
[00:16]
that the focus of its first paid DLC, Charting the Unknown, is to add even more on top of this already staggeringly full plate. sailing, underwater exploration, business management, dating mechanics, and so much more. Some of
[00:31]
that is genuinely engaging to dive into, and some of it is quite shallow, as Crimson Desert's jack-of alltrades master of none approach tends to be. And alongside those activities as well, it's a shame that they're mostly uninspired
[00:46]
retreads. When I first reviewed Crimson Desert, I said it felt a mile long and an inch deep. With charting the unknown, developer Pearl Abyss has said, "Here's developer Pearl Abyss has said, "Here's another half mile.
[01:08]
this, usually the main course is the added story content, but that's more of a side dish here. Charting the Unknown follows in the footsteps of the original main quest line by being the least interesting way to spend your time in
[01:20]
this expansive world. All three of the new quest lines, each focused around one of the three playable protagonists, are short, stuffed with filler and reused content, and have very little of interest to say despite some extremely
[01:32]
long cutscenes. Most objectives ask you to retrace your steps in oddly bland ways, sending you back to spend time with familiar characters as apparent callbacks to identical moments in the original story. Some straight up make
[01:45]
you repeat boss fights from the main campaign. Damian's story is particularly dull, almost exclusively a series of chores like walking down a hall to talk to someone or sweeping soot off of the road in between enormous amounts of
[01:58]
overwritten dialogue. There's one interesting boss fight near the end that at least provides a bit of payoff to the monotony, but it's pretty wild just how much of that quest line is a waste of time.
[02:14]
least fares a bit better. You find yourself in a desert region that's been overcome by a sandstorm and have to navigate your way through it in order to enemy factions from the base game, concluding with one of the better boss
[02:27]
concluding with one of the better boss fights in the DLC. environment works out better than most of Charting the Unknown's ideas, offering a fresh obstacle to overcome while exploring the area and solving
[02:42]
problems for the locals. I do find it pretty funny how few people will even be able to see this content, though. Completing the base game story is a lines. And at the time of this review, just 11.3% of Crimson Desert's players
[02:56]
on Steam had earned the achievement marking that accomplishment, an increase of about 1% since the DLC's launch. It makes sense that you need to beat the main story first since each of these vignette-like campaigns basically plays
[03:09]
doesn't mean it's worth pushing through the main story just to get to this new stuff, especially when the more interesting additions are accessible interesting additions are accessible much earlier in the adventure.
[03:28]
things that aren't related to the story. has been added, even if some of it is quite thin. One of the main focuses is around ship building, open sea exploration, and underwater diving,
[03:42]
which opens up a sizable new area of the map with deep sea mysteries and islands to hunt treasure on. You'll need to do quite a bit of leg work to open up this aspect of the DLC as well. Specifically, you'll have to be fairly far along the
[03:55]
camp upgrading quest line before ship building becomes available. Thankfully, again and upgrading the camp is one of the more interesting ways to spend your some of the new business management stuff they added that I'll touch on
[04:09]
stuff they added that I'll touch on later. be able to build or buy a boat, outfit it with weapons and upgrades, then chart your course for parts unknown, stopping to grab new goodies like seaweed, shark
[04:23]
pelts, and sunken treasure from beneath the ocean waves as you go. The worst part of all that is the time you actually spend on the boat as your ships move way too slow and combat is overly simplistic. It has some really wonky
[04:36]
controls as well, particularly and how annoyingly bad it feels to adjust your ship's direction while also aiming your cannons. If you played Assassin's Creed Black Flag Reync earlier this year, you're in for quite a step down. Don't
[04:49]
impressive that Pywell's already enormous world suddenly has seafaring mechanics like this at all. and it's not a shock that they're significantly less interesting than games with less to juggle, but you're still in for a whole
[05:02]
bunch of very boring ship battles and idle sailing travel time. The good news is that island exploration and delving into the ocean in search of loot are both much more interesting. Using a diving suit and a harpoon gun, you'll
[05:15]
explore long-forgotten underwater temples and sunken ships, swimming over to air bubbles to avoid drowning in what is definitely one of the better ways to spend your time in Charting the Unknown. Another cool mechanic also lets you
[05:27]
settle islands you visit along the way, adding docks for your ship to Morat, vendors for you to trade with, and fast travel points to make getting around quicker. This does a good job of replicating the same exploration loop
[05:39]
questing, which has always been one of its strengths. Islands also tend to have at least one or two treasure hunts to go on, and hunting for buried treasure is always a good time, even if I rarely found loot worth writing home about. Our
[06:01]
There are a few nuggets of story to chew on while sailing the seas, though most of them are empty calories to get you to the next action sequence. For example, one quest line has you helping an island nation reclaim their land and recover an
[06:13]
apparently super important relic that's actually just a vase, I guess. It's got some neat moments like a hilarious fight against a giant tank that shoots armed thugs tied to floating balloons into the air and another boss against a giant
[06:27]
mechanical leviathan. Although that one ends up being better in concept than an execution. The characters and dialogue here are as forgettable as every other least provides some meaningful reasons
[06:40]
>> Once we're settled in, we won't need to cross the whole sea every time we want to look. It's kind of interesting that despite a whole bunch of ambitious seafaring mechanics and new story content, most of my best memories
[06:53]
playing Charting the Unknown involved content completely unrelated to either of those things. My favorite of the new activities added with this DLC is actually the business management miname, which lets you lease out businesses
[07:05]
across the map, fill them with a staff of Greymanes from your camp, refernish them to be more efficient and appealing to customers, then reap the profits as customers walk through and make purchases. I really didn't expect a
[07:18]
full-on business management sim to get added to this already packed adventure, but this one actually won me over, especially after seeing how easy it was to squeeze a profit out of my investments. Again, this is just one
[07:30]
three dozen mini games in it by this point. So, you shouldn't expect it to be as fleshed out as Twooint Hospital or anything like that, but it does have a lot more going for it than many of the other things Crimson Desert tries.
[07:44]
Another interesting little addition are the social links, which allow you to capitalize on the bonds you already built with various NPCs by entering relationships with them and even getting married or divorced if that strikes your
[07:56]
fancy. This stuff is mostly just a funny way to pass the time and reminds me a bit of the old Fable games in terms of depth, or in this case, lack thereof, and how little impact these relationships actually have on anything.
[08:09]
But it's definitely a feature that made me care more about greeting characters to make use of unwanted trinkets and bobbles since you can now offer gifts to NPCs to increase your bonds faster. As someone who enjoys dating Sims a lot,
[08:23]
this is one dumb, completely unnecessary miniame that drew me in quite a bit. that's been added with Charting the Unknown. While most of this DLC lives up
[08:38]
places, this mode is pretty much the exact opposite, pitting you against sets of existing bosses in a test of your endurance and skill.
[08:52]
reworked to be less annoying than the first time I played them at launch, I actually had a decent time challenging myself to complete these trials. That said, I'm not really one to get all that excited about rehashed boss fights,
[09:05]
one of Crimson Desert's strengths to begin with. Still, it's something to do this game and want another way to push the limits of your build.
[09:20]
thing I'm surprised to see has stayed the same since the last time I played is the number of bugs I encountered. I had a couple hard crashes. One character wig wrestle him, which resulted in Cliff's arm bending unnaturally. NPCs get stuck
[09:34]
in the world that broke a quest and made me have to reload a previous save. And textures that made it impossible to focus during cutscenes. Even on my robust PC, these issues were a regular
[09:47]
Charting the Unknown and are worth noting if you've got a low tolerance for stuff like this, even if it's pretty much the industry standard for openw much the industry standard for openw world games with a scale like this.
[10:03]
DLC is unlikely to win over anyone who hadn't already fallen in love with this massive world, but it does successfully expand a game that's already had a staggering amount of stuff to do. Diving around underwater ruins and exploring
[10:16]
islands for treasure is a good time, even if the ship exploration and combat on the way to that seafaring content is a boore. Elsewhere, some of the new activities like a business management miniame and NPC dating are absolutely
[10:28]
worth adding to your backlog of quests to tackle. Those side distractions Crimson Desert. But it's a shame that the new story quest lines that act as an extended epilogue are largely as dull as they are inaccessible. Overall, Charting
[10:43]
the Unknown is just more Crimson Desert with its jack-of-trades master of none philosophy fully intact. If you're hundreds of hours deep and that's all you want, it will almost certainly deliver, but if you're not, it's not the
[10:56]
most convincing reason to come back. Reviews director Tom Marks here with Travis Northup to talk a little bit more about his review of this DLC. Uh Travis Forest, obviously, but also more recently Phantom Blade Zero, The Blood
[11:10]
of Dawn Walker, some big sprawling RPGs like that. So, you've got a lot of experience in this genre. Travis, I want to talk about Crimson Desert specifically first though because you reviewed the base game. You went back a
[11:24]
few months after launch after it had had a bunch of updates and replayed a bunch of it and reimmers yourself in that world. So, how much of this game have you now played? >> Uh, yes, I have played over 300 hours of
[11:37]
>> Over 300 hours? >> 300 hours? Yeah. which which to be fair, some people would say that I'm still a neoight at Crimson Desert. Uh and can find ways to spend much more than
[11:50]
when we were in the review period, I did a a playthrough where I completed the main story line and I did, you know, a good chunk of the uh open world that you can't really get into everything in Crimson Desert. I mean,
[12:05]
there's like lots of different uh undertakings you can just like really dive into. Um, but I yeah, I tried to do as much as I could. You know, you try to playthrough. My second playthrough, I
[12:18]
focus on the main story line as little as possible uh and look at some of the that sort of thing. More recently on the Charting the Unknown expansion, I went completed the campaign cuz you have to do that to play a lot of this DLC. And
[12:34]
then I went and did a bunch of the uh like base camp upgrading stuff which I not my first. >> A common thing that came up at the time of our base review was that we did this base review based on a version of the
[12:46]
game and then they just started patching it like crazy for a few weeks they were they were going really really hard. You then went back and revisited that game like you said. you did that second playthrough uh and kind of your opinion
[13:01]
didn't immediately change like it changed in ways but fundamentally you you the the fundamentals of what your problems with the base game were didn't really get addressed in those patches and for the caveat which I think you
[13:15]
make in the review too for the caveat you didn't play the quote unquote enhanced version that they have added this to the title so they did continue this to the title so they did continue making even more tweaks But can you just
[13:27]
talk a little bit about like what what were some of those unanswered issues or unanswered questions that kind of haven't and even going into this DLC haven't really been addressed? The first time I went back to play it, I was like,
[13:40]
fixed all of these things that I explicitly like complained about in my review. Like for example, uh the fact that there was no storage in the first version of the game that I played, which is still crazy to me that that was ever
[13:53]
a thing." Um, and so I went back excited to do that. And what it turned out was that those small annoyances, and some of them were big annoyances were fixed. A fights a little bit more streamlined, stuff like that. But the central thesis
[14:07]
that I had about the game that it is a mile long and an inch deep, and so but there's just a lot of it, and that's going to work for some people, not work for others. That wasn't really changed. And so, and then my my issues with the
[14:19]
story are still just like the story is just bad in this game. every single side quest has bad dialogue. The main story is like falls completely flat. Again, I did not replay the main story after the enhanced edition, but the both of the
[14:32]
just it's hard to get through. And I think that's why so you see so many They're off fishing and running around and hunting deer and picking up kiwis and putting them in their farm and stuff like that. And that's all awesome. Uh,
[14:46]
but yeah, if you if you care at all about story and games, this game's probably going to rank lower for you. I care about story and games. So, I find myself on that side of the equation. Some people like the people who really
[14:58]
defend the story. They just say, "I don't care about the story. I like this position to have. It's not the one I hold. But but an an important note on the story point too is that you know another response I saw is well you know
[15:14]
like this. A good example is in in the Phantom Blade Zero came out and like the story in that game is not incredible but you gave that game a nine and and I think that doesn't gel for some people
[15:27]
you brought up in the Crimson Desert review of like this game spends a lot of time on story. It has long cut scenes and a lot of dialogue and it really acts like it wants you to care about the story, but then that story you didn't
[15:42]
like and and thought was, you know, so it dragged it down. Whereas Phantom >> has a lot of has emphasis on story, but then it gets through it a little quicker down with it. Is that fair? >> Yeah, exactly. It's like Minecraft
[15:56]
don't spend any time on their story, right? So you can you can overlook it. This game has enormous cut scenes that are unskippable and you can speed them get through and it's like man they are spending a lot of time on the story and
[16:11]
I sit through the cut scenes. I don't even hold fast forward through them somebody who's like giving it a chance every time I play it and they do not Phantom Blade Zero. The story's not super strong, but the cut scenes are
[16:25]
short and a lot of the story happens while you're running around fighting easier to kind of get through it and go, "Okay, well, you know, maybe it's not the best story, but you can overlook it a lot easier because you're not it's not
[16:38]
>> Yeah. And that's just to just to put it out there, not to say that Phantom Blade game. They are very very different kinds of games. It's just a a convenient comparison in terms of recent high scores you've given. Uh let's talk about
[16:51]
you said there's a lot of really fun stuff in this DLC like the diving, you know, the treasure hunting. This is not a dismal DLC in the same way that the base game wasn't a dismal game in your opinion. A six means okay. We genuinely
[17:05]
believe that, you know, for us okay as a six means it's not a game we're going to actively recommend to everyone, but it's not a bad game. It's there there's just not something that we can just sort of give a blanket recommendation to.
[17:20]
That's sort of where a six sits in our eyes. Um, what do you think this DLC needed to do differently from the base game? If it is just more of the base game as you see it, what did it need to do to to surprise you to raise that bar?
[17:36]
well, I think there's a couple different approaches. Like, I'm not I'm not a game what to focus on, what to make their game, but I do think if your story isn't good or it's not your strength, maybe don't focus on it. And they they still a
[17:49]
lot of this content is about story. Like they have three main quest lines that And then also while you're doing ship building stuff, there's story- based uh content in that that also kind of drags a little bit. It's not as bad as like
[18:03]
pretty like, okay, this is really just here for no reason. let me fight the giant crab monster, right? Um, and so I think it just would have been a better DLC if they focused on the stuff that worked and maybe they don't know what
[18:16]
stuff works, but there's just kind of like the base game. There's just lots of stuff and when it works, it's fun and when it doesn't, it doesn't. And it's just not consistent enough for me to have an enjoyable time because there's
[18:28]
great." And then there's other times where I'm just like, "Why are why am I doing this? Why did they put this boss battle in here? Why? Why am I uh doing so much ship combat when they didn't put a lot of time into what the ship ship
[18:42]
>> Travis, thank you so much for talking with us a little bit more about this and about your opinions on the base game and all that jazz. If you want, you can go back and check Travis's original review of Crimson Desert, uh which like we said
[18:56]
is from the launch version, so keep that caveat in mind. If you do go back and watch it, then a lot of patches have come. Uh, and if you want a very check out our review of the Ocarina of Time remake recently. And for everything
[19:08]
Time remake recently. And for everything else, stick with IGN.