Can you lose fat and gain muscle at the same time?
45sDirectly addresses a common fitness myth and provides a definitive answer.
▶ Play Clip
[00:00] can you lose fat while gaining muscle at
[00:02] the same time this is one of the age-old
[00:05] fitness questions that people continue
[00:06] to be curious about and for good reason
[00:09] these are both excellent goals for one's
[00:11] overall health and fitness but there can
[00:13] be a little bit of confusion with this
[00:15] many say that you can lose fat and gain
[00:17] muscle at the same time While others say
[00:19] that you can't and need to alternate
[00:21] between phases of bulking or muscle
[00:22] building with phases of cutting or fat
[00:25] loss so which is correct well it is
[00:28] possible to lose fat and Gain muscle at
[00:30] the same time but it depends on multiple
[00:33] factors it doesn't work well for every
[00:35] single person so today we're going to
[00:37] discuss what type of person this can
[00:39] work well for talk about the best
[00:41] strategies on how to do it from calories
[00:43] to strength training and even get into
[00:45] if cardio is a good idea for trying to
[00:47] lose fat and gain muscle at the same
[00:49] time so let's get into this anatomical
[00:52] and physiological
[00:58] awesomeness losing fat and gaining
[01:00] muscle at the same time is known as body
[01:03] recomposition you are changing the
[01:05] composition of your body tissues and in
[01:07] this case decreasing the amount of fat
[01:09] while increasing the amount of muscle
[01:11] now some may Define true body
[01:13] recomposition as changing the
[01:15] proportions of these body tissues while
[01:17] maintaining the same total tissue Mass
[01:20] so in other words if you had a 180 lb
[01:22] person that person would stay at 180 lb
[01:25] but eventually less of that weight would
[01:27] be coming from fat and more of that
[01:28] weight would be coming from mus muscle
[01:30] but again you'd stay at 180 lb however
[01:32] there are situations where people may
[01:34] not want a complete pound-for-pound swap
[01:37] of fat for muscle and I'll give an
[01:39] example of that a little bit later on
[01:41] but what are some of the challenges with
[01:43] losing fat and gaining muscle at the
[01:44] same time well first losing this stuff
[01:48] atap POS tissue or fat requires a
[01:50] calorie deficit you need to burn more
[01:52] calories than you consumed so that your
[01:54] body starts to tap into the stored
[01:56] energy that is in the fat and as a
[01:58] reference a pound of fat F contains
[02:00] about 3500 calories so if you wanted to
[02:02] lose a pound of fat each week you'd want
[02:04] to average a calorie deficit of about
[02:07] 500 calories per day however building
[02:09] this tissue skeletal muscle tissue
[02:12] typically requires a calorie Surplus
[02:14] giving your body extra calories and
[02:16] energy to repair and grow muscle tissue
[02:18] after workouts and so obviously these
[02:21] seem to be contradictory goals because
[02:23] you can't be in a calorie deficit and a
[02:25] calorie Surplus at the same time another
[02:28] reason why body Rec composition is a
[02:31] difficult goal is because you can
[02:32] usually burn fat at a faster rate than
[02:34] you can build muscle just go back to
[02:37] that example again of losing fat if you
[02:39] were in a calorie deficit of 3500
[02:41] calories per week for 8 weeks you could
[02:44] potentially lose 8 PBS but imagine
[02:46] trying to add 8 lbs of muscle in that
[02:49] same 8we period that's difficult to do
[02:51] even in a calorie Surplus when someone
[02:53] is not trying to lose weight however
[02:56] there are situations where body
[02:58] recomposition does work and so let's
[03:00] cover some of those situations there are
[03:02] pretty much three categories of people
[03:04] that body recomposition works pretty
[03:05] well for the first category is beginners
[03:08] to resistance training and if that
[03:10] beginner is also a young person like in
[03:12] their teens and early 20s that further
[03:14] gives an advantage because of those
[03:16] raging pubescent hormones but with any
[03:18] beginner their bodies are so primed for
[03:20] muscle development because when the body
[03:22] is first exposed to such a powerful new
[03:24] stimulus like resistance training it
[03:26] creates an extremely strong drive for
[03:29] protein synthesis that it's almost as if
[03:31] the person is on natural steroids and
[03:33] you've probably seen someone or maybe
[03:35] notice with yourself that you gain
[03:36] strength and size very quickly in the
[03:38] beginning beginners can follow almost
[03:40] any resistance training protocols and
[03:42] get great gains in strength and size and
[03:45] so because of this strong drive for
[03:46] protein synthesis that beginners benefit
[03:49] from even in a calorie deficit the body
[03:52] will continue to liberate the energy
[03:53] from the fat in order to continue to
[03:56] provide the energy and resources to
[03:57] promote muscle growth begin could
[04:00] successfully burn fat and gain muscle
[04:01] for over a year in some cases but
[04:04] eventually this is going to be harder
[04:05] and harder to do which we'll address in
[04:07] just a second but the second category
[04:10] would be people that are returning to
[04:11] training so if you took a long break
[04:13] from exercise when you return you kind
[04:15] of benefit from those beginner gains
[04:17] again but this doesn't last as long as
[04:19] those true initial beginners gains
[04:21] because you typically gain muscle back
[04:23] more quickly than when you first gained
[04:25] it you could consider this a form of
[04:27] muscle memory and we actually have a
[04:29] whole video video explaining how you
[04:30] gain muscle back faster in our muscle
[04:32] memory video that I'll link at the end
[04:34] of this video the third category would
[04:36] be individuals with higher percentages
[04:38] of body fat if you have a higher
[04:40] percentage of body fat you'll obviously
[04:42] have more stored fat and in a way your
[04:44] body isn't going to respond to a calorie
[04:47] deficit the same way as if you had like
[04:49] 15% body fat with the extra fat your
[04:52] body can more easily tap into those fuel
[04:54] reserves while still building muscle and
[04:57] again if this person is highly
[04:58] overweight or obese most of the time the
[05:01] person usually isn't looking to do a
[05:03] pound-for-pound swap of fat for muscle
[05:06] usually the goal is to lose much more
[05:08] fat than the amount of muscle that they
[05:10] want to gain which also makes this body
[05:12] recomposition more doable in this
[05:14] particular situation but with all these
[05:16] situations they will only take you so
[05:18] far because as someone has less fat to
[05:21] lose and gets more and more advanced or
[05:23] in other words those that have been
[05:25] building muscle for an extended period
[05:26] of time these people know that it takes
[05:28] much more effort to continue to gain
[05:30] muscle even in a caloric Surplus let
[05:33] alone in a caloric deficit and so this
[05:36] is where it starts to make much more
[05:37] sense to focus on one goal at a time or
[05:40] shifting to this idea of going on a
[05:41] bulking phase where the focus can be
[05:44] purely on building muscle alternated
[05:46] with a cutting phase where the focus
[05:48] could be purely on losing fat and
[05:50] maintaining the muscle that was gained
[05:51] during the bulking phase because it is a
[05:54] much easier task to maintain muscle
[05:56] during a caloric deficit than it is to
[05:58] build muscle but if you find yourself in
[06:01] one of these three categories where
[06:02] losing fat and gaining muscle is
[06:04] feasible there are a few things that
[06:06] need to be done while attempting this
[06:08] first you must do resistance training
[06:10] now I know that seems like one of the
[06:12] more obvious ones but I've got to be
[06:13] thorough here because you could lose fat
[06:15] from a caloric deficit without working
[06:18] out but that would do nothing for your
[06:20] muscles and you would actually likely
[06:22] lose some muscle with the fat if you
[06:24] didn't combine the caloric deficit with
[06:26] resistance training because there is no
[06:28] way to get significant muscle growth
[06:30] without a strong stimulus and again that
[06:33] strong stimulus is lifting weights
[06:35] compound movements are going to be your
[06:36] biggest bang for buck here such as
[06:38] squats deadlifts bench press shoulder
[06:40] press pull-ups Etc you can throw in some
[06:43] isolation exercises as well but again
[06:45] the foundation should start with those
[06:46] compound movements you also want to
[06:48] apply the principle of progressive
[06:50] overload which is trying to add a little
[06:52] more weight to the bar every week or so
[06:55] Progressive overload could also come in
[06:56] the form of increasing the Reps and or
[06:58] overall volume
[07:00] and there are multiple ways to fit this
[07:01] into a given week you could potentially
[07:03] pull it off with two days of resistance
[07:05] training a week but those would likely
[07:07] need to be longer sessions 3 days a week
[07:09] is a place that I often start with many
[07:11] of my patients but we have some more
[07:13] detailed videos on how to build muscular
[07:15] size and how to implement this into your
[07:17] routine that I'll link at the end of
[07:19] this video next we need to start messing
[07:21] with the calories and even the
[07:22] macronutrients specifically the protein
[07:25] like we mentioned earlier a deficit of
[07:27] about 500 calories a day will cause you
[07:29] to lose about a pound per week but I
[07:31] usually recommend a 300 to 500 calorie
[07:34] deficit when you're first starting out
[07:36] and of course you need to make sure
[07:37] you're getting enough protein now
[07:39] protein recommendations are anywhere
[07:41] from 1.2 to 2.2 gam of protein per
[07:45] kilogram of body weight per day and the
[07:48] higher end of 2.2 is usually recommended
[07:51] for athletes and bodybuilders that are
[07:52] serious about putting on muscle now many
[07:55] of you may not consider yourself a major
[07:57] athlete or a bodybuilder however since
[07:59] we are in a calorie deficit some of the
[08:02] ingested protein will likely get pulled
[08:04] and utilized for energy instead of
[08:06] muscle building so because of this you
[08:08] would still want to hedge towards the
[08:10] higher end of 2.2 gam per kilogram of
[08:13] body weight which for us non-metric
[08:15] people just a gram of protein per pound
[08:17] of body weight to do the trick now a
[08:19] quick word on cardio I love cardio there
[08:22] are obviously some incredible fitness
[08:24] and health benefits to doing cardio one
[08:26] of those that it can be an effective way
[08:28] to lose fat and again a whole bunch of
[08:30] other benefits so I almost always
[08:32] recommend it however if the main goal is
[08:35] to lose fat while also stimulating
[08:37] muscle growth we need to be a little
[08:39] careful with how we implement the cardio
[08:41] there is such a thing as the
[08:43] interference effect which is if you were
[08:45] to perform cardio and strength training
[08:47] in the same exercise session the cardio
[08:49] could potentially interfere with maximal
[08:52] muscle growth now key word there was
[08:55] maximal muscle growth it's not going to
[08:57] completely blunt all muscle growth so so
[08:59] if you absolutely have to combine cardio
[09:01] and strength into the same workout it
[09:03] won't be the end of the world but we are
[09:06] already adding something else that can
[09:08] blunt muscle growth which is the calorie
[09:11] deficit so it's probably just going to
[09:13] be best to do your cardio and strength
[09:15] training on different days or if you
[09:17] have to do them on the same day try to
[09:19] do them in different workout sessions
[09:20] separated by hours at a time for example
[09:23] there are a couple days a week where I
[09:24] do two a days where I'll go for a run in
[09:27] the morning and then 6 to 8 hours later
[09:28] I'll do some strength training but a
[09:30] split I often start my patients off with
[09:33] is something like strength training on
[09:35] Monday Wednesday Fridays and then cardio
[09:37] on Tuesday Thursday Saturdays and taking
[09:39] Sundays off so hopefully that gave you
[09:41] some useful information on if body
[09:43] recomposition is right for you as well
[09:44] as a good starting point and thank you
[09:46] for supporting the channel let us know
[09:48] what you thought of today's video in the
[09:49] comments and we'll see you soon
⚡ Saved you time reading this? Transcribe any YouTube video for free — no signup needed.