[00:08]
different video than normal because honestly I just need to tell people how lackluster let's say that uh Pool of Radiance Ruins of Myth Draanor actually
[00:20]
is. This is going to require a little bit of nuance which we all know the internet does not exactly love but I do think it's really important here. That said, uh this video is going live as the review embargo for this game list. And
[00:32]
is closer to the first impressions type of video I make. That is either way of course possible because I was given a review key for this one via a PR company doing the key distributions. So again,
[00:45]
this is like my usual first impressions video, but slightly different. And then I will be following this up with a full review later still. But before I detail why exactly I feel this way, I do want to start off by saying that I want to
[00:58]
draw a distinction between the work that Sn has done to re-release this game over on Steam with patches and things to fix the bugs and then the actual game itself. So, if you didn't know, uh, Sn is a company that has been going back
[01:12]
and reing, if you will, a bunch of old D&D games by working with Wizards of the Coast to do so. And I actually think that is really important work from like making sure a lot of these games are accessible and playable for people.
[01:27]
They're fixing a lot of long-standing bugs. And within the scope of that mission, I think Snag has done a great job here. This game is playable in the sense that you are unlikely to run into technical problems. I, for instance,
[01:39]
roughly 15 hours with this game, and that is me getting stuck in a door. The problem really is that Sn's work in this case is ultimately not going to fix what I think are a lot of core fundamental problems about just what this game is
[01:54]
and how it approaches uh its dungeon crawling. So, I am at a point with this playthrough. I would say I'm probably 30 40% of the way through the whole thing. I'm about to move into chapter 2 where things change a little bit. And I
[02:08]
decided to stop here and make this video because things are finally starting to lighten up about 15 hours in and become a little more manageable. But when I switch areas into the next chapter, that might actually change again. So, I guess
[02:20]
we'll see. But as of right now, having worked my way through the bulk of the first chapter, I really find myself wondering what kind of play testing this game ultimately got initially and what the actual thought process was because
[02:33]
there are just so many little baffling decisions when it comes to everything from enemy composition to character creation, uh, builds, etc. It's just wild. And individually, they would be annoying. In aggregate, they are
[02:47]
extremely frustrating. Now, me being me, I'm still going to finish this game and review it, but good grief has this just not good or fun. Maybe I suppose the later chapters will mix this up or something and manage to bring me around.
[03:02]
But as of right now, it's clearly not been a good experience. So, let's start on too much. Let's start with character creation. When you fire this game up for the first time, you are either going to pick a fourman party of pre-made
[03:15]
characters or you will make four characters yourself or any combination of those things. Now, you will over the course of your adventure pick up two more uh party members for a total of six. But at character creation, you have
[03:27]
four. But there's some things the game doesn't make uh clear initially that I think are extremely important here. For starters, the pre-made characters, for the most part, just have uh better stats in a way that you cannot get at
[03:40]
character creation. They have just more points to spend on their attributes, characters are just going to be better, gate. But it gets a little more awkward once you eventually realize that most of
[03:54]
the classes have like a pre-made build that you can't change or deviate from. Now, you will on occasion get to pick what spells you want at level up, but that is really the extent of it. Uh, things that would normally be up to you,
[04:07]
like your skills or your feats, the game picks those based on your class, it just does that automatically. You don't have a choice. So, not only are some of the pre-made characters straight up better than what you could do because of
[04:19]
attributes, they're also going to be using the same pre-made thing as well, characters are just better across the board in a way that doesn't feel satisfying in what is meant to be an RPG. So, already not off to a great
[04:32]
start right at the beginning. And yet, it gets dramatically worse very quickly. The first area of the game, honestly, not that bad. you're just kind of the actual dungeon. But from there, let's talk about the structure of this
[04:46]
game. So, this game takes place over the course of a mega dungeon essentially, but given in the form of the ruins of myth Draanor, which is like this giant elven city. And so, the first chapter is you progressing through the dungeons.
[04:59]
The second chapter is you progressing through the city heights. Then you drop into the prisons before finding your way to the castle where the final battle takes place. I am coming up on the end of the initial dungeon area, which has
[05:11]
taken me 15 hours, which isn't in and of itself necessarily a problem if that content was fun and enjoyable, but it has been anything but. This game uses an adaptation of the third edition of Dn D, the base third edition, not 3.5. And
[05:25]
it's important simply to mention that it is not a complete adaptation. and some things are a little bit different, but the thing about that is that it doesn't really change what like level or number of enemies you should be facing at any
[05:39]
given time. And then combined with some baffling choices around resources available to you, it's extremely slow and difficult for a significant period of time. What I mean by this is that because we have uh just our base party
[05:52]
of out of luck and you're going to have to reload at least until you get access to a reliable means of reviving them. And in order to do that, you need to bring a staff back to a guy you meet relatively early in the first area. But
[06:05]
in order to go get that staff, you have to actually uh kill a bunch of orc leaders and stuff that you are going to have to fight against with probably a four maybe fiveman party if you start finding the NPCs first. But even that's
[06:18]
get those guys, you have to fight against again a whole bunch of enemies who are going to be excessive for your level and they'll probably die in the process and you won't have a way of reliably reviving them unless you
[06:32]
brought a cleric and happen to have found a wand of resurrection until you get this staff back to this guy. So that's annoying in and of itself. But I also mentioned the cleric there. I'm glad I uh decided to bring a cleric with
[06:44]
me because I think just about the only decent way to get through some of the fighting in these initial dungeons. And I'm not just talking like regular zombies or skeletons. That's annoying, but fine. No, what they've chosen to do
[06:58]
wraiths. And if you're unfamiliar with third edition, what that means is that those things are going to drain your constitution or your strength, etc. Your hit zero, your character dies. Some of the race and specters and stuff can also
[07:13]
reduce your level temporarily via a status effect, mind you, but still incredibly annoying in the context of this because those enemies are really hard to hit. Uh your weapons have a chance of just not doing anything
[07:27]
because they are incaporeal. Even magic weapons don't hit them reliably. And if they hit you, you're losing stats, which makes it that much harder to fight them. So, the only reliable way I have found to get around this is to use a cleric's
[07:39]
uh turn undead ability, which is fantastically useful in these first few dungeons. But that doesn't stop them from just using uh just absurd numbers which means you're having to find a place to rest and restore stuff and then
[07:54]
provided you have access to the ability to do that. And it makes moving through these initial dungeons just extremely slow when you're trying to figure things out for the first time. And somehow we're still not done because when it
[08:07]
finally starts mixing up your enemy types and you start fighting like oroggs and stuff, something they love to do is put between like five to eight of them and then like half of them will be a version of that enemy that will use
[08:20]
debilitating effects on your party. That is to say, several of them, like two or three to a fight, might actually be spamming hold person on your characters. games to know how to build around that stuff, even with that knowledge, if they
[08:35]
going to hit because there's so many of them doing it. And if you get unlucky, your entire party gets debilitated and you have to wait that out or die. And little things that make me feel like
[08:48]
this has just not been well thought out. There are way too many enemies. The composition of these enemies is all wrong. And your only really uh saving grace, especially in the beginning, is to try to find admittedly the generous
[09:01]
drops of things like scrolls, etc. that can help you through some of these guarantees. And long story short, this first 15 hours or so has just been a brutal slog through a not well-designed dungeon. And while it has finally
[09:16]
started to alleviate itself, as I have been uh gaining levels, etc., And now I have a six-man party that's entering the level at which we start getting AoE pre-made builds, which made that take longer than it probably should have. I'm
[09:29]
finally getting to a point where these fights are seemingly a bit easier. But my concern is when I switch areas if this is going to happen again. And none of that even addresses how all of these dungeons look the same. I know the next
[09:42]
then you go right back to the dungeons after that. And all of that is without even getting into things like the way they set up the questing and how you're different layers of these initial dungeons with no real good way of
[09:57]
marking where you are. Uh you do get a map and you can place markers yourself, but that doesn't do a great job because the actual map doesn't show you in order to effectively use those markers. Things like fade in and pop out
[10:10]
as you are in proximity to them, as your characters move. And so bringing that all together for this sort of weird first impressions video, on one hand, I am very happy that Sn put in the work to make this game accessible and available
[10:24]
historical significance of it and just kind of look into these games of yestery year. I think that is important work. I think they succeeded at doing that work. Unfortunately, the game they restored in this instance is just not very good.
[10:38]
From here, I do plan to finish this game. I'm honestly at this point too deep to simply not see it through. Maybe this will pick up a little more nuance on my end as well, but I am deeply unimpressed with everything I've seen so
[10:51]
far. And you really got to love the genre to even consider picking this one up just to take a look at it and get a feel for what it was. But that's where sure exactly how long the actual review will take, but it is coming. I am
[11:04]
working on it. My main goal for that review is honestly just going to be trying to find something about this that I enjoyed because as of right now, I am struggling to do so, but that is exactly where I'm going to leave this video. So,
[11:16]
plan on playing this for yourself, I'd love to know what you think about it, which of course means to like, comment, subscribe, all that YouTube jazz. But thank you so much for watching. I really do appreciate it. May you wander in
[11:30]
do appreciate it. May you wander in wisdom and have an amazing day.