Supergirl's Ending SHOCKS Fans
35sThe controversial ending with Cara killing Creme is a major deviation from the comics that will spark heated debate among fans.
▶ Play Clip
[00:00] Supergirl's ending sets up the arrival
[00:01] of Brainiac and a mystery threat who I
[00:03] believe is the big bad of the DCU. And
[00:05] there is one moment of this ending that
[00:07] is a huge departure from the comics that
[00:10] I think is going to piss a lot of people
[00:11] off. Welcome back, Screen Crush. I'm
[00:13] Ryan Ari, and let's talk about the
[00:14] ending of Supergirl. Now, we're going to
[00:16] go over what actually happens in the
[00:17] third act of the film, the themes of the
[00:19] movie, and how it resolves the arcs of
[00:21] Cara and Ruthie. But then we're going to
[00:23] talk about how this movie sets up
[00:24] Superman: Man of Tomorrow, where
[00:26] Superman Lex and Supergirl will team up
[00:28] to fight Brainiac. So before our full
[00:30] Easter egg video releases tomorrow,
[00:31] first let's talk about the final act of
[00:33] the film and the climactic fight. It's
[00:35] not just a big action scene for the sake
[00:37] of action. Everything that happens
[00:38] serves the characters and the themes of
[00:40] the film, which is not just a battle for
[00:42] Ruthy's life, but also for Ruthy's
[00:44] innocence. The movie centers around the
[00:46] growing friendship between Ruthie and
[00:47] Cara, two weavered women who have
[00:49] survived the destruction of their
[00:50] families and are trying to escape their
[00:52] traumatic past. For Cara, this involves
[00:54] clinging to her old life through her
[00:56] love of crypto and her rejection of
[00:58] Earth. But for Ruthie, her reason to
[01:00] hang on to her past is more
[01:01] straightforward. She wants revenge. In
[01:03] the comic Woman of Tomorrow, which this
[01:05] film is based on, only her father was
[01:07] killed while her mother and six brothers
[01:09] lived. I think the film makes a wise
[01:11] decision to completely slaughter her
[01:13] family. So, the only way she has to
[01:15] remember them is through her vengeance.
[01:17] But throughout the film, we see this
[01:18] quest destroy the people around her. For
[01:20] instance, an entire family dies because
[01:22] she tries to kill Creme herself. And
[01:25] like I'll talk about in a second, Cara
[01:26] then tries to save her from this cycle
[01:28] of pain. And don't get me wrong, Cara
[01:30] also wants revenge in her own way. Creme
[01:33] harmed Krypto, her only friend and her
[01:35] only connection to home. Like she tells
[01:37] him,
[01:37] >> "Home is wherever you are, buddy."
[01:39] >> And this actually reminded me of a great
[01:40] line in Action Comics 500 by Marty Pasco
[01:43] and Kurt Swan, where Superman talks
[01:45] about how lonely he was before Krypto
[01:47] arrived on Earth. But suddenly, he had a
[01:49] friend who knows the sound of bullets
[01:51] bouncing off of your skin. But see,
[01:52] Cara's connection to her dog, as we see,
[01:54] runs even deeper. She keeps Krypto in
[01:57] the pocket watch that her father gave
[01:58] her. And I suspect this watch is always
[02:01] set to Kryptonian time, which is a way
[02:03] for Cara to pretend that time still
[02:05] moves on in a world that no longer
[02:07] exists. This is the connection she
[02:09] shares with Ruthie. Neither of them can
[02:11] accept that their families are gone.
[02:12] Now, throughout most of the movie, these
[02:14] two are at odds because they are so much
[02:16] alike. But the turning point comes when
[02:18] Ruthie is forced to care for Cara when
[02:20] she's dying. This is the first time in
[02:22] the movie where Cara is at a lower
[02:24] status than Ruthie. So, it forces the
[02:26] girl to finally put aside her anger and
[02:28] show compassion for others. And it's the
[02:30] first step to Ruthie learning how she
[02:32] can let go and live her life without
[02:34] vengeance. So, she soothes Cara by
[02:36] saying, "You're not always nice, but you
[02:38] are kind." Which is similar to Cara's
[02:40] dying words from the film and the comic
[02:42] when she asks her to be good. Now, what
[02:44] makes Supergirl stand apart from her
[02:46] cousin is that Cara has every reason to
[02:49] break bad. She personally buried almost
[02:52] everyone she ever loved and she watched
[02:54] firsthand while her civilization died.
[02:57] As our friend Lee Masio likes to put it,
[02:59] Clark is an immigrant story, but Cara is
[03:02] a refugee story. This is the origin
[03:04] story of a super villain. She has every
[03:06] right to turn into Superman's evil
[03:08] cousin, and yet she chooses goodness
[03:10] mostly. She's very different from Clark
[03:12] in ways we'll talk about in just a bit.
[03:14] I want to share something with you guys.
[03:15] When I started back at the gym, I was
[03:17] gone for so long. I felt terrible the
[03:19] next day. It felt like I had the flu,
[03:22] weakness, muscle aches, and it's because
[03:24] I didn't get enough electrolytes. That
[03:26] same week, we started working with
[03:28] Element, and this has absolutely changed
[03:30] the way that I work out. I am so glad
[03:32] they sponsored this video. Element is
[03:34] one of my favorite sponsors that we work
[03:36] with. It's an electrolyte drink with a
[03:38] concentration of potassium and
[03:39] magnesium. But the secret ingredient is
[03:41] salt. element tastes great and also
[03:43] helps me to stay hydrated but without
[03:45] the sugar and dodgy ingredients in other
[03:47] popular sports drinks. It comes in many
[03:49] different flavors, but my new favorite
[03:51] is their lemonade iced tea. The lemonade
[03:53] iced tea has elements sciencebacked
[03:54] electrolyte formula plus naturally
[03:56] occurring caffeine, eltheonine, and
[03:58] polyphenols to deliver a blend of
[04:00] antioxidants which are perfect for
[04:02] workouts. I'm a big caffeine drinker and
[04:04] Elements Iced Tea Lemonade hits me right
[04:06] in my sweet spot. It's just strong
[04:08] enough, but it's mild enough to not give
[04:10] me a big spike and a big crash. That's
[04:12] because the caffeine is not artificial.
[04:14] It comes from a full black tea extract.
[04:16] Guys, I love this drink. And you may
[04:19] have noticed I even drink it when
[04:20] they're not sponsoring us, like during
[04:21] our live streams. But I think you should
[04:23] try it for yourself. If you give it a
[04:24] try and you don't like it, it's risk-
[04:26] free. Give it away to a friend and
[04:27] Element will give your money back, no
[04:29] questions asked. So, right now you can
[04:31] get a free sample pack of Element's most
[04:33] popular drink mix flavors with any
[04:35] purchase at drinklelntt.com/screencrush.
[04:38] That's drinklnt.com/sreencrush
[04:41] or click the link below to get a free
[04:43] sample pack with any purchase. You won't
[04:45] regret it. Give it a try. Now, back to
[04:46] what I was saying. So, in the final act
[04:48] of the movie, Cara is trapped on a
[04:50] binary star system with two suns, one
[04:52] yellow, one green. And something similar
[04:54] happens in the comics where she is
[04:55] trapped on a green sun world that was
[04:57] actually created to kill Superman. In
[04:58] the comic, this gives Ruthie a chance to
[05:00] defend Supergirl from dinosaurs. But in
[05:03] the movie, it gives a dying Cara a
[05:05] chance to look back and reflect on her
[05:07] life. She remembers the words of her
[05:08] father telling her to move on and live
[05:10] her life. She remembers her mother
[05:11] telling her to be good. And most
[05:13] importantly, I think she remembers her
[05:14] cousin when he first showed her the
[05:16] super suit. I personally love this scene
[05:19] where Clark acknowledges that the
[05:20] Superman suit is kind of goofy. Like
[05:22] Cara says when she lands on Earth,
[05:24] >> it's green. See, when James Gun was
[05:27] designing the super suit for Superman,
[05:29] he reasoned that Superman needed those
[05:31] trunks so that people would know that he
[05:33] was there to help. He wanted to look a
[05:35] little ridiculous, like a wrestler's
[05:37] costume. Otherwise, people might be
[05:39] scared of an immortal god from outer
[05:40] space. But then again, what kind of
[05:42] threatening person would possibly dress
[05:44] in his underoos? Now, it's significant
[05:46] that Cara does not wear this suit while
[05:48] she is out partying. This is her time to
[05:51] indulge and be free of the attachments
[05:53] of superhero life. But when she chooses
[05:55] to wear the suit, it is her way of
[05:57] finally embracing Earth, which means
[05:59] letting go of her family and her past
[06:00] trauma. Now, we are going to break down
[06:02] the full fight in our Easter egg video.
[06:04] But toward the end, as the freed girls
[06:06] take care of the last Brigund, Ruthie
[06:08] stalks in on Crim. No matter how much
[06:10] Cara has protested against killing him,
[06:12] Ruthie still believes that this
[06:13] vengeance will set her free from her
[06:16] pain. But Cara doesn't let her do this.
[06:18] In fact, it's almost a reversal of their
[06:20] comic interaction. In the final issue,
[06:22] Ruthie backs down from killing Crim, but
[06:24] Supergirl nearly goats her on, trying to
[06:26] get her to understand the lesson of this
[06:28] whole journey. Now, in the comic, this
[06:29] was Cara's main goal. She brings Ruthie
[06:32] with her specifically to teach her over
[06:34] a few weeks that the quest for vengeance
[06:36] will destroy her soul. Like I said,
[06:37] she's not just trying to save the girl's
[06:39] life, she's trying to save her
[06:40] innocence. And this core theme stays
[06:42] throughout this film. For instance, in
[06:44] the comic, the sword belonged to Creme
[06:46] and was not made by Ruthie's father. But
[06:48] in the movie and the comic, the sword
[06:50] retains the same meaning. It is a symbol
[06:52] of vengeance. But because Ruthiey's
[06:54] father made the sword, it also becomes a
[06:56] symbol of her healing. So I actually
[06:58] think this sets up a key part of Man of
[06:59] Tomorrow that I'll talk about in just a
[07:01] bit. So let's talk about Ruthie's final
[07:03] decision not to kill Crim. Like I said,
[07:05] this is a major part of the comic book
[07:07] where it turns out that Krypto had been
[07:09] fine for weeks and that Cara only asked
[07:11] Ruthie to come along so she could help
[07:12] her overcome her thirst for vengeance.
[07:14] But the Cara in the comics is very
[07:16] inspirational. But in the movie, she's a
[07:18] wreck. However, she recognizes enough of
[07:21] herself and her own pain in Ruthie to
[07:23] know that she can't let her go over to
[07:26] the dark side. So, when Ruthie is about
[07:27] to kill Creme, Cara says that she can't
[07:29] let her do this. Now, earlier in the
[07:31] movie, Lobo had this debate with Cara,
[07:33] saying that Ruthie deserves her revenge.
[07:35] And this calls back to the earlier scene
[07:36] in the movie where Lobo basically
[07:38] encouraged her to take revenge to set
[07:40] right the wrongs in her life. So, Lobo
[07:43] and Cara end up being the devil and
[07:44] angel on Ruthy's little shoulders. So,
[07:46] back to the moment where Ruthie makes
[07:48] her decision. So, because Cara told
[07:50] Ruthie about her past, the girl knows
[07:52] that Cara is speaking from experience
[07:54] when she tells her that revenge will not
[07:56] make her pain go away. Cara never had to
[07:58] seek revenge for the death of Krypton,
[08:00] but she did try to numb her pain in
[08:02] other ways through alcohol and, let's
[08:04] face it, probably a lot of space drugs.
[08:06] So Cara tells Ruthie that killing Crim
[08:08] will not take away her pain and that
[08:10] living her life will be revenge enough,
[08:12] which is similar to how Zorel consoled
[08:14] her about her own life. When Cara felt
[08:17] like she was meaningless and not worth
[08:18] being sent off and saved, Zorel reminded
[08:21] her that her life is not just her own.
[08:24] The lesson is that Cara had to go on.
[08:26] She had to live so Krypton would live
[08:28] with her. And now she's imparted the
[08:30] same lesson onto Ruthie. If Ruthie kills
[08:33] Crim, then her soul will be corrupted.
[08:35] But if she goes on and lives a pure good
[08:37] life, then she is living that life for
[08:39] her family. In the same way, Cara
[08:41] finally learns the lesson that the best
[08:42] way to honor her dead is to be a hero to
[08:45] the people of Earth. And guys, to
[08:46] celebrate the DCU, the team and I had a
[08:48] blast designing these new parody shirts
[08:50] like this absolutely kick-ass Lobo biker
[08:53] tea in the style of a biker vest. We
[08:55] also have Krypto as Snoopy destroying
[08:57] his own dog house. Supergirl as Rosie
[08:59] the Riveter saying, "Don't [ __ ] with my
[09:01] dog." And Cara reimagined as a Barbie
[09:03] redesign. This is along with some of our
[09:05] old favorites like GI Robot in the style
[09:07] of G.I. Joe, the bird blindness PSA,
[09:09] give a hoot about bird blindness, and
[09:11] where's the dog? As well as Peacemakers,
[09:13] Charlie Brown, and the peace cycle as
[09:15] the Akira cycle. Remember, store members
[09:16] at our $5 tier get an additional 15% off
[09:19] at our merch store sitewide. And
[09:21] shopping our store really does help out
[09:23] our channel. Thank you for helping us
[09:24] and the links are below. So, after
[09:26] inviting Ruthie to the last leg of her
[09:28] pub crawl, Cara finally returns to Earth
[09:30] to the same apartment that Clark had in
[09:32] Superman. It's even in the same room
[09:33] where he and Lois watch the Justice gang
[09:35] defeat an imp from another dimension.
[09:37] The two of them talk about birthdays and
[09:39] what home means to them. And this is
[09:40] when Cara finally accepts that she is
[09:42] going to stay in Metropolis. She is
[09:44] taking her own advice to live her life,
[09:47] which in turn is a way of continuing to
[09:48] live the lives of her loved ones. And
[09:50] Clark also tells her, "I could have used
[09:52] your help against the last guy." And I
[09:54] kind of wonder who that last guy could
[09:55] be. Is he referring to the events of the
[09:57] first Superman movie? Or is this another
[09:59] Superman foe like Metallow or Parasite?
[10:01] I mean, after all, Matallo was the
[10:03] villain in the Superman prequel Junior
[10:05] novel, so he could still return to this
[10:07] universe. Now, then the film ends with
[10:09] Krypto getting into some chocolate,
[10:10] creating the perfect bookend. We started
[10:12] with Krypto knocking over a bottle and
[10:14] peeing on a newspaper. So, it's only
[10:16] fair that he creates a little more chaos
[10:18] before the end. But, I don't think
[10:19] chocolate would affect him because he's
[10:20] on a yellow sun planet. Although, it is
[10:22] hilarious that they spent the whole
[10:23] movie trying to keep him away from
[10:24] poison when he just dives into eating
[10:26] poison at the very end. So, now let's
[10:28] talk about how this movie sets up
[10:29] Brainiac and what's next for the DCU. We
[10:32] know that the next Superman film titled
[10:33] The Man of Tomorrow will feature the Man
[10:35] of Steel working with Lex Luthther and
[10:37] that Lex will build a version of his war
[10:39] suit from the comics. Supergirl is also
[10:41] confirmed to be in that movie, but most
[10:42] importantly, the villain will be
[10:44] Brainiac. Next to Lex Luthther, Brainiac
[10:46] is the Superman villain, but he's never
[10:49] actually been on the big screen. Now,
[10:51] there are several iterations of the
[10:52] character from the comics and animation,
[10:54] but he is always an artificial
[10:56] intelligence that collects life and
[10:58] information throughout the universe. In
[10:59] the Superman animated series, I loved
[11:01] the added twist that Brainiac was a
[11:03] supercomput built on Krypton. When it
[11:06] discovered Krypton's imminent doom, it
[11:08] lied to everybody and didn't tell them
[11:10] that the planet was going to explode.
[11:12] And Brainiac did this in order to escape
[11:14] the planet in pursuit of knowledge. So,
[11:16] in a way, Brainiac was responsible for
[11:18] the deaths of billions of people because
[11:21] he could have helped them prevent the
[11:22] planet's implosion or at least helped
[11:24] everyone escape. Also, in the comics,
[11:26] Brainiac miniaturizes an entire
[11:28] Kryptonian city called Canandor and kept
[11:30] it in a sealed bottle. So, Superman
[11:32] worked for years to enlarge Canandor and
[11:34] restore its people. And this is just the
[11:36] kind of goofy story I think James Gun is
[11:38] going to adapt into the DCU. See, I
[11:40] think it's very interesting that Cara
[11:41] will be in Man of Tomorrow. And I think
[11:43] this explains certain changes they made
[11:45] in the movie altered from the comic book
[11:47] Supergirl Woman of Tomorrow that the
[11:49] movie is based on. The big change in the
[11:51] movie is that Cara actually kills Crim.
[11:53] And we'll get into that in just a
[11:54] second. But here's the thing. If the
[11:56] movie adapts Brainiac's origin, that he
[11:58] was a Kryptonian supercomputer that was
[12:00] responsible for destroying Cara's home
[12:02] world. Well, I think this explains why
[12:04] the movie chose to have Cara kill at the
[12:06] end. See, Ruthie may have let go of her
[12:08] quest for vengeance, but Cara has not.
[12:10] She killed a man for messing with her
[12:12] dog. So, imagine what she would do to a
[12:14] computer that destroyed her entire
[12:16] civilization. And I think this points to
[12:18] her arc in Man of Tomorrow. Now, another
[12:20] change for the movie is that Ruthiey's
[12:21] father is a swordsmith. In the comics,
[12:23] he's a rock farmer. Wait, what does that
[12:25] mean? Wouldn't that just make him a
[12:26] minor? I don't know. Maybe on his
[12:27] planet, like rocks grow in the field and
[12:29] he farms them. I I don't know. Okay, so
[12:32] why make her dad a swordsmith instead of
[12:34] a rock farmer? I mean, in the comic, the
[12:36] sword actually belonged to Creme. So,
[12:38] there was like added symbolism that
[12:40] Ruthie wanted to use the same evil
[12:42] object that killed her father to kill
[12:44] the sword's owner. Why would the movie
[12:46] ditch that symbolism? And why would the
[12:48] movie end with Ruthie becoming a
[12:49] swordsmith like her dad? Well, I have a
[12:51] theory. So, she says that her dad made
[12:53] his weapons from the strongest metals.
[12:54] And in the DC universe, one of the
[12:56] strongest metals in existence is called
[12:58] nth metal. For instance, Hawk Girl's
[13:00] mace is made out of the metal in the
[13:02] comics. Now, Brainiac, like Ultron, is
[13:04] constantly upgrading himself. In the
[13:06] 80s, he even sported this badass robot
[13:08] look that I still think of as the
[13:10] definitive Brainiac. And get this, the
[13:12] hexagonal pattern on that version of
[13:14] Brainiac's head is the same pattern as
[13:16] the ship that brought Cara to Earth,
[13:17] making it look like they are both made
[13:19] from Kryptonian technology. So, if he's
[13:21] upgrading himself, then it would make
[13:23] sense if he made his new form from the
[13:25] strongest metal he could find, Enth
[13:26] Metal. So, in the movie, if Cara and
[13:28] Superman can't make a dent in him, Cara
[13:30] can be like,
[13:31] >> "I know a guy." and then bring Clark to
[13:33] shop Ruthiey's collection of nth metal
[13:35] swords. Nth Metal is also used to
[13:37] disrupt magic, which could come in handy
[13:39] against the real big bad of the DCU,
[13:41] dark side. Dark side's the big bad of
[13:43] the DCU. Look, James Gun came on this
[13:46] channel and he claimed that Dark Side
[13:47] was not his overall plan.
[13:49] >> Using Dark Side as the big bad right now
[13:51] is not necessarily the thing.
[13:53] >> And I do not believe him. Not totally.
[13:56] Something is going on here. Peacemaker
[13:57] set up the Salvation Arc from the comics
[13:59] where villains are stranded on a planet
[14:01] that is actually a training ground for
[14:03] Dark Side's armies. I just think there's
[14:04] no bigger bad in the DC comics than Jack
[14:07] Kirby's Dark Side, and I'm convinced he
[14:09] has a role to play in the saga.
[14:10] Furthermore, this movie established a
[14:12] piece of lore that is even more crucial
[14:14] to the next Superman film. We have more
[14:16] kryptonite. In the Superman Jr. novel,
[14:18] Metallow's core is powered by
[14:19] kryptonite, and when it's destroyed,
[14:21] there is none left on Earth, which is
[14:23] why Luther had to have Metamorpho
[14:25] created. Now, traditionally in the
[14:26] comics, kryptonite was created when
[14:28] chunks of the planet followed the
[14:29] gravity of Clark's rocket and were
[14:31] irradiated by the yellow sun. This is
[14:33] the same kryptonite poisoning that
[14:34] killed Car's people in Argo City. But
[14:36] the movie changes this. Now, kryptonite
[14:38] was already a deadly mineral in the
[14:40] boughels of Krypton's core, which means
[14:42] that it is a lot more plentiful in the
[14:45] universe. Creme even has designer
[14:47] weapons made from it, which actually
[14:48] happens in the comics, too. Now, as I
[14:50] mentioned earlier, Lex's warsuit will be
[14:52] featured in Man of Tomorrow. And in the
[14:54] show Peacemaker, we saw Lex was released
[14:56] from prison and he's working for Argus.
[14:58] Maybe he's using the portal tech that we
[15:00] saw in that show to find alien
[15:01] technology in order to build his
[15:03] warsuit. And in the comics, he often
[15:05] uses kryptonite as part of its weaponry.
[15:07] So, if Lex, Superman, and Supergirl go
[15:10] to space to fight Brainiac, that means
[15:12] that Lex will suddenly have near
[15:14] unlimited access to a weapon that can
[15:16] kill his worst enemy. And in the
[15:17] landmark comic, Whatever Happened to the
[15:19] Man of Tomorrow, Lex and Brainiac team
[15:21] up to become one entity that actually
[15:23] kills Superman. I would actually not be
[15:25] surprised if the same thing happens in
[15:27] this film. Brainiac offers Lex what he
[15:29] always wanted, unlimited knowledge and
[15:31] the ability to kill Superman. And then
[15:33] in the final battle, Superman and his
[15:35] cousin have to use these in metal swords
[15:37] against this combined villain. And so
[15:39] Cara, seething with rage that Brainiac
[15:41] let their home world die, is ready to
[15:43] kill him just like she killed Crim. But
[15:45] instead, Clark is there to stay her hand
[15:47] and help her to take the last step in
[15:49] her grieving process, which would be
[15:51] forgiveness. Still, it is a very
[15:53] controversial decision to have Cara kill
[15:55] Creme. In the comic, Cara is a
[15:57] pure-hearted person, but in the movie,
[15:59] she's a [ __ ] mess. She's still
[16:00] clinging to her old baggage, and she has
[16:02] not been a superhero for that long. And
[16:04] she even says,
[16:04] >> "You sees the good in everyone, and I
[16:06] see the truth." So for this version of
[16:08] Supergirl, I think it would make sense
[16:10] that she would choose to kill just like
[16:12] it makes sense for a Solen Randian loner
[16:14] like Henry Caval Superman to kill Zod.
[16:16] But I have to think that they made this
[16:18] decision for a reason and not just for
[16:20] the sake of having Creme die. In the
[16:22] comic, she actually lies about killing
[16:24] Crim to spare Ruthie the vengeance of
[16:25] the Briggins and instead they send him
[16:27] to the Phantom Zone for 300 years where
[16:29] he is eventually reformed. But the comic
[16:31] ending itself is also very vague. So
[16:34] maybe the movie is too. I mean, after
[16:36] all, Creme's death is filled from a
[16:37] distance, and the only person who really
[16:39] knows what happened is Lobo, who is
[16:41] watching all of this happen from a
[16:42] distance. But what did you guys think
[16:43] about Car's decision to kill Creme at
[16:45] the end? And what did you think of
[16:46] Supergirl? Is it better than its
[16:47] reviews? Let me know your thoughts down
[16:48] in the comments below or on our free to
[16:50] join Discord server. And if it's your
[16:51] first time here, please subscribe. Smash
[16:53] that bell for alerts for Screen Crush.
[16:55] I'm Ryan Ery.
⚡ Saved you time reading this? Transcribe any YouTube video for free — no signup needed.