[00:00]
do you ever listen to the lyrics of
[00:01]
songs you love and just think how did
[00:03]
they do that like you can't even imagine
[00:05]
how the songwriter arrived at that turn
[00:08]
of phrase It's so normal to feel like in
[00:10]
our own lyrics that we're just flapping
[00:12]
around in the shallow pool of mediocrity
[00:14]
but in this video I'm gonna
[00:17]
I mean I've simple and Powerful
[00:22]
ever written one of the most important
[00:24]
techniques is all about understanding
[00:25]
that there are some lines of lyrics in
[00:28]
your song structure that are way more
[00:30]
important than other lines and these are
[00:31]
called Power positions and in technique
[00:34]
number five I'm going to explain to you
[00:36]
what they are where they are and how to
[00:39]
use them number one extending metaphors
[00:41]
a metaphor is when we describe one thing
[00:44]
through the lens of some other object
[00:46]
and it's in that area of overlap where
[00:49]
we actually get the metaphor so if I say
[00:52]
anger is a storm it's the ways in which
[00:55]
we connect those two images or ideas
[00:57]
where the metaphor actually emerges but
[01:00]
the real fun of metaphor and where your
[01:03]
best lyrics are gonna come out is the
[01:05]
ways in which you extend that initial
[01:08]
metaphor so angry as a storm might be
[01:10]
interesting in and of itself but it's
[01:12]
going to be even more interesting if I
[01:15]
spend 10 minutes developing that
[01:17]
metaphor let me give you an example
[01:19]
anger is a storm the clouds of your mind
[01:23]
gather darkening your eyes your words
[01:26]
are lightning striking out at the
[01:29]
nearest touch Point your voice swells
[01:32]
and Spills and I Harden like ice my dark
[01:35]
glances rumble on the horizon of our
[01:38]
days what you can see that I've done
[01:39]
there is I've just spent five or ten
[01:41]
minutes extending the metaphor by using
[01:44]
words and images related to storm to
[01:48]
describe and expand on the idea of anger
[01:51]
here is a piece of lyric writing magic
[01:53]
after you do this for five or ten
[01:56]
minutes you just pick out the best bits
[01:58]
and the thing with metaphor is it's easy
[02:00]
to go too far so we don't want to use
[02:02]
every single thing we've come up with we
[02:04]
just want to pick the few lines or ideas
[02:07]
that really stand out so here we could
[02:09]
create something quite quickly like this
[02:11]
the clouds of your mind gather again
[02:13]
words start spilling out and I get stuck
[02:17]
here in your rain hardening like ice in
[02:20]
fact actually leaving out the end
[02:22]
initial metaphor that started the whole
[02:24]
thing can actually result in lines that
[02:26]
are even better than if we had included
[02:28]
that first metaphor anger is a storm one
[02:31]
of the reasons for this is that it's
[02:33]
actually a way to invite a listener in
[02:35]
to the world of your song by allowing
[02:37]
them to connect the dots for themselves
[02:40]
and when people do that there's this
[02:42]
crazy release of dopamine that happens
[02:44]
and it actually creates a feeling of
[02:46]
connection with a listener when they're
[02:49]
allowed to actually figure things out
[02:50]
for themselves one of my favorite
[02:52]
examples of this comes from the Arnie
[02:54]
DeFranco song school night she went over
[02:56]
to his apartment clutching her decision
[02:58]
and he said did you come here to tell me
[03:00]
goodbye so she built a skyscraper of
[03:03]
procrastination and then she leaned out
[03:06]
the 25th floor window of her reply so
[03:08]
here is the action step for you the
[03:10]
songwriting exercise is to come up with
[03:13]
five different interesting initial
[03:15]
metaphors and you can use a random word
[03:18]
generator like perchance.org and I've
[03:21]
included a link to that in the notes
[03:22]
below so come up with five interesting
[03:25]
combinations like jealousy is a kitchen
[03:27]
the conversation was a security
[03:29]
checkpoint growing older is an elephant
[03:31]
and for each one of these five
[03:33]
interesting combinations spend five or
[03:35]
ten minutes extending the metaphor
[03:38]
making sure that you are using words
[03:40]
phrases and images that are related to
[03:43]
the metaphor image so if I'm using
[03:45]
jealousy is a kitchen kitchen is the
[03:48]
metaphor image I'm really talking about
[03:49]
jealousy but I'm going to use language
[03:52]
related to Kitchen to paint that picture
[03:54]
another great way to practice this is of
[03:56]
course to listen to some great songs
[03:57]
that actually do this inside the lyrics
[03:59]
of the songs and here are a few examples
[04:01]
Golden by Jill Scott Circle games by
[04:03]
Joni Mitchell she Burns by Foy Vance
[04:06]
Take Me to Church by Hozier number two
[04:08]
upgrading verbs certain words in the
[04:11]
English language are way more powerful
[04:13]
than other words and I'm not talking
[04:15]
about like Expelliarmus I'm talking
[04:18]
about the difference between verbs
[04:21]
adjectives and adverbs there are so many
[04:24]
wonderful writers who have given this
[04:26]
advice to me and the world for example
[04:28]
Jeff Tweedy in his lovely little book
[04:30]
how to write one song says this about
[04:33]
adverbs you don't need to say the dog
[04:34]
barked loudly loudly is implied and
[04:37]
adding it actually weakens the bark and
[04:40]
of course the famous Stephen King quote
[04:42]
the road to hell is paved with adverbs
[04:45]
and I would like to add to that by
[04:46]
saying the road to hell is also paved
[04:48]
with adjectives adjectives and adverbs
[04:51]
generally tend to do nothing but weaken
[04:53]
your language and expression as opposed
[04:56]
to verbs which are really the PowerHouse
[05:00]
of the English language verbs obviously
[05:02]
convey action but they do so much more
[05:04]
they can convey image mood tone emotion
[05:08]
and attitude let's look at an example
[05:10]
here if I have a line of lyric like she
[05:12]
walked into the room walked is my verb
[05:16]
let's see what happens when I simply do
[05:19]
the act of replacing that fairly generic
[05:22]
verb with something slightly more
[05:25]
interesting she slid into the room she
[05:29]
slithered into the room she flowed into
[05:32]
the room one thing to notice is that
[05:34]
when we analyze the lyrics to songs and
[05:36]
songwriters who are great lyric writers
[05:39]
we tend to see the general absence of
[05:41]
adjectives and adverbs let's check out
[05:43]
the song motion sickness by Phoebe
[05:45]
Bridges I hate you for what you did and
[05:47]
I miss you like a little kid I faked it
[05:49]
every time but that's all right I can
[05:51]
hardly feel anything I hardly feel
[05:53]
anything at all you gave me 1500 to see
[05:56]
your hypnotherapist I only went one time
[05:59]
you let it slide fell on hard times a
[06:01]
year ago was hoping you would let it go
[06:03]
and you did
[06:05]
literally the only adjective in this
[06:07]
entire lyric is the word hard and in
[06:10]
this case hard is actually part of the
[06:12]
expression hard times it wouldn't work
[06:14]
to just say times so hard here is barely
[06:17]
an adjective at all because it's part of
[06:19]
an expression there are basically no
[06:21]
adjectives and not a single adverb here
[06:24]
is your songwriting call to action and
[06:26]
this call to action has Two Steps step
[06:28]
one is to go through the draft of any
[06:32]
lyrics that you're writing to songs
[06:33]
you're working on and literally just
[06:36]
cross out any adjectives or adverbs that
[06:39]
are inside the lyric there might be some
[06:42]
adjectives that absolutely need to be
[06:44]
there so for example in the Bruno major
[06:46]
lyric nothing the very first line is
[06:49]
tracksuits and red wine movies for two
[06:51]
we need the word red there red is
[06:54]
actually important red wine has a
[06:56]
different connotation to white wine or
[06:58]
even just wine it paints a picture of a
[07:01]
certain type of person and a certain
[07:03]
type of moment but we certainly don't
[07:05]
need floral red wine step two is to go
[07:08]
through a draft of your lyric and
[07:10]
underline every single verb that you use
[07:13]
throughout the course of your lyric and
[07:15]
the task here is to pick one verb per
[07:18]
section and upgrade that verb to
[07:21]
something more interesting just a quick
[07:23]
note here to say if you are finding this
[07:25]
video useful or helpful at all please go
[07:27]
ahead and click the little like button
[07:28]
it really helps the magical YouTube
[07:30]
algorithm Pixies deliver our content to
[07:33]
other people who might be interested in
[07:35]
the video and it really helps us and we
[07:36]
really appreciate it number three use
[07:38]
specific imagery that works hard when
[07:42]
Bruno major sings tracksuits and red
[07:43]
wine movies for two it puts a movie in
[07:46]
your mind you get a clear sense of who
[07:49]
the characters are what their
[07:51]
relationship is how long they've been
[07:52]
together what they're doing right now
[07:54]
where they are and why they're there the
[07:57]
movie starts playing in your mind and so
[07:58]
you become invested in this song as
[08:01]
Stephen King says good description
[08:03]
usually consists of a few well-chosen
[08:05]
details that will stand in for
[08:07]
everything else and this is true for
[08:10]
song as well and maybe even more true
[08:12]
for song where we have very limited real
[08:14]
estate in which to build mansions in the
[08:17]
minds and hearts of our listeners
[08:20]
there's a line from an Amanda Palmer
[08:22]
song that I just love so much because it
[08:23]
demonstrates this so beautifully the
[08:25]
line is from her song The Bed song which
[08:27]
is just a great and epic song to start
[08:29]
with but this particular line kills me
[08:31]
every time and it's this I find my
[08:34]
glasses and you turn the light out I
[08:37]
just love this line so much because it's
[08:39]
very much like that Bruno major lyric in
[08:41]
that it is this really specific snapshot
[08:44]
of an image that actually shows us
[08:47]
rather than telling us so much about the
[08:50]
relationship here we know this is two
[08:52]
people in bed together we know something
[08:54]
about their age they've probably been
[08:57]
together for a while and maybe even a
[08:58]
long time in glasses kind of maybe even
[09:00]
adds 10 or 20 years onto the vision of
[09:03]
who these people are so we know that
[09:05]
maybe a couple in their 30s 40s or 50s
[09:07]
we also know that as one of the
[09:10]
characters is leaning over to get her
[09:12]
glasses to read that the other character
[09:15]
is turning their light out so these two
[09:17]
characters are not on the same page
[09:19]
they're actually kind of living parallel
[09:21]
lives even as they are existing or
[09:24]
coexisting in their most intimate space
[09:26]
their bed so there is something deeply
[09:29]
wrong here and it's this image that
[09:32]
shows it to us rather than telling it to
[09:33]
us that makes it even more powerful for
[09:37]
a detailed walkthrough on how to come up
[09:38]
with great imagery check out this video
[09:41]
on our Channel or if you want a more
[09:42]
deep and structured demonstration with
[09:45]
case studies examples and application
[09:46]
you can check out our short course the
[09:48]
link is in the video notes below here is
[09:51]
your call to action with this lyric
[09:52]
writing tip a great and very quick way
[09:55]
to do this is to take a line of lyric
[09:57]
that you identify as being more telling
[09:59]
than showing or more General than
[10:02]
specific and just spend five minutes
[10:04]
trying to invert that line into some
[10:08]
kind of specific image based snapshot
[10:11]
that shows it rather than tells it so
[10:13]
for example you could take a line like
[10:15]
it was a beautiful normal Saturday
[10:17]
afternoon and instead of telling that
[10:19]
figure out at least 10 different ways
[10:22]
that you could show us that through an
[10:24]
image so for me it might be something
[10:25]
like barbecue smoke curling up through
[10:28]
the eucalyptus leaves or watching my dog
[10:30]
chase rabbits in his sleep or eating
[10:32]
samosas that my neighbor dropped at my
[10:34]
door they're like little photographs
[10:36]
little snapshots that are designed to
[10:39]
show a picture a specific image that
[10:42]
illustrates the concept rather than
[10:44]
merely telling it in some general way
[10:46]
like Saturday afternoon number four
[10:49]
contrasts there is something incredibly
[10:52]
compelling and very sticky when we
[10:55]
actually combine two opposing ideas or
[10:58]
images in the same line of lyric or at
[11:01]
the very least close to each other in
[11:03]
the lyrics so for example contrasting
[11:05]
day night good bad hot cold questions
[11:09]
answers there's something about
[11:10]
opposites that is very very appealing
[11:13]
the contrast usually serves to amplify
[11:16]
in some way the idea by spotlighting it
[11:19]
let's look at a Beautiful lyric that
[11:21]
does this in such a spectacular way this
[11:23]
is the song she Burns by Foy Vance I've
[11:26]
frozen over my desires covered up in
[11:28]
Virgin Snow but when I stand beside her
[11:31]
she Burns yeah she burns like petrol
[11:34]
soaked paper and fireworks it's that
[11:37]
opposite contrast of cold and hot Frozen
[11:41]
and burning that really amplifies the
[11:45]
hook of this song which is she Burns
[11:48]
number five power positions there are
[11:51]
lines of lyric inside the structure of a
[11:53]
song that because of their position in
[11:56]
the structure will naturally draw more
[11:59]
attention from a listener's ear and
[12:02]
those lines are always the first line
[12:05]
and the last line of any section it's a
[12:09]
Well documented scientific phenomenon of
[12:12]
human attention that we will always pay
[12:14]
more attention to the first thing and
[12:16]
the last thing of anything really but
[12:19]
it's also true in songs the human ear is
[12:22]
naturally
[12:23]
spotlighting the first line and the last
[12:26]
line it's not that the internal lines
[12:28]
aren't important they are but they're
[12:32]
just not as important in this video I
[12:34]
want to focus on one really effective
[12:36]
technique that I call the last line
[12:38]
pivot we're going to use that last line
[12:41]
to create surprise to see how this works
[12:44]
let's listen to one of the best songs
[12:46]
ever written I'm just going to go out
[12:47]
and say it it's the song River by Joni
[12:50]
Mitchell it's coming on Christmas
[12:52]
they're cutting down trees they're
[12:54]
putting up reindeer and singing songs of
[12:57]
joy and peace oh I wish I had a river I
[13:01]
could skate away on the surprising
[13:03]
element of that last line comes because
[13:06]
Joni has stacked images of Christmas and
[13:09]
by stacking images of Christmas it
[13:12]
creates a certain pattern we've got all
[13:15]
this Christmas imagery and generally
[13:17]
Christmas imagery has a positive
[13:19]
connotation so she's stacking all this
[13:22]
Christmas imagery but the last line is
[13:25]
not positive at all it's not a positive
[13:27]
feeling she's using that last line to
[13:30]
create an element of surprise by saying
[13:32]
I wish I could get away from it all so
[13:35]
surprise can only happen when we create
[13:38]
expectation and expectation only happens
[13:40]
when we create pattern so the whole idea
[13:43]
here is we can take this lyric as a
[13:45]
model for our own we can stack images
[13:48]
and then use that last line to break the
[13:51]
expectation that has been created
[13:53]
through the stacking of that imagery
[13:55]
here is your call to action to put this
[13:58]
technique into practice there are really
[14:00]
two ways you can do this the first way
[14:02]
is to start by stacking images that
[14:05]
describe something it could describe an
[14:08]
event it could describe a feeling it
[14:10]
could describe an experience that you
[14:12]
had and then use that last line to Pivot
[14:14]
the other way to do this is to reverse
[14:16]
engineer the section to actually start
[14:18]
with your last line think about what
[14:20]
your target is and then start with its
[14:23]
opposite if you want more tips and
[14:24]
tricks on writing better lyrics check
[14:26]
out this video Happy writing guys see
[14:29]
you next time