[00:02]
time to really think about how we can optimize our time, we landed on this formula for posting. This is a video that we never intended on making. In breakdown of our findings from evaluating Hootsuite and Metricool and
[00:16]
we're going to tell you the unconventional path that we ended up going down for social media posting. We recently filmed a mini series podcast and from that we got our video producer to make a bunch of short-form content
[00:30]
that we were posting on Instagram and TikTok and YouTube shorts and then even Twitter and LinkedIn. And guess who was doing that manually? This girl. After a month or so of doing this, we decided that we needed to turn to software to
[00:43]
help us automate some of this process. We thought that we would have our variety of tools to choose from and this would be a really simple decision. But we were totally wrong. All right, [music] now let's get into it.
[01:08]
[music] doing research for our social media posting tool, we jumped on YouTube and started watching some reviews and demos. And one tool that kept popping up was Metricool. And we had heard of Hootsuite and Buffer before, but
[01:20]
Metricool was it seemed like more YouTubers were talking about it. So it was the software that we wanted to look at first. And when we watched tutorials online, it just looked like it had all the features. Like I really thought that
[01:32]
we found the greatest solutions. You can post on all the social media platforms from YouTube shorts to Instagram to TikTok, etc. And it even has a cool calendar that shows you when your audience online and the best times to
[01:45]
post. So we signed up for an account, we connected all of our social media accounts, and within the first couple of minutes of using it and actually trying to schedule posts, we started seeing some of the limitations. The first thing
[01:58]
we noticed was that posting for YouTube Shorts isn't optimized. So, while you can use it to post a short, you can't actually add a description or you can't pick your thumbnail, which is a newer feature that YouTube released and one
[02:10]
that's really important. So, for us, YouTube is our most important channel, so we're more protective of that. So, immediately, we knew that we weren't YouTube. But, for the other channels like TikTok and Instagram and Twitter,
[02:23]
for all of those and then just keep manually posting to YouTube as we've been doing. But, you guessed it, we ran into more trouble because when we scheduled our TikTok, for example, it posted and the entire caption was
[02:38]
unformatted. And it just doesn't look very good, especially when you put so much work into creating the content. And then, the real trouble came when we went to post a reel on Instagram. So, like I said, we've been posting these videos
[02:51]
I've had no issues from doing them from my phone. However, when I uploaded the same video that we always get back from our video editor into Metricool, there was an error with the video size.
[03:04]
was too large and when I contacted their support, they had suggested that we resize all of our videos for them to be posted through this app. At that point, you start thinking, is this really
[03:17]
saving me time or is this going to waste more of not only my time, but my team's time as well? So, their chat support were very insistent that this is an API limitation and that there was no way around it and this is just what we had
[03:30]
to do. So, at that point, kind of decided it's time to put Metricool on pause and evaluate some of the other tools. That's when we took a look at the thing that we noticed when we logged into Buffer was that the user interface
[03:44]
was much prettier and much more friendly than that of Metricool. Upon connecting our accounts, it had pulled in all of our previous social media posts and put bird's-eye view of all the content that we've been posting. And in just the
[03:59]
experience of using their scheduling tool just felt like a little bit more clean and refined. So, prettiness aside, functionality is what matters at the end of the day. We tried to schedule our TikTok post and we also ran into the
[04:12]
same issues with not being able to choose a thumbnail and also not being able to format our captions. Then we went to schedule a reel on Instagram and to our surprise and delight, it scheduled and posted right away and we
[04:26]
had no issues with the video size, which for us was a huge win. With Buffer, you can also post on YouTube shorts, but you also have the same limitations as you to add tags or a description or a thumbnail. Like I said before, we knew
[04:41]
protective over our YouTube channel and continue to post that directly through the YouTube app. Another limitation we found with Buffer is that it didn't automatically analyze all of our previous data and give us the
[04:54]
suggestions for the best time to post. And I did contact them and ask them about this and they said the more that you use Buffer to post, the more that to post and that kind of data. Speaking
[05:06]
of data, if you are concerned with reports and metrics, it doesn't pull in analytics for your YouTube account and it does for the other platforms, but I'd say Metricool did a slightly better job at showing you all sorts of analytics.
[05:19]
All this being said, both Alex and I on our team, we go into the apps and we just look at the analytics from the apps themselves. So, because we're a small like that that we're pulling out to show other people on our team. So, that
[05:33]
useful for us. We really wanted to use social media scheduling tools to main thing that we looked at. So, with all this being said, we were impressed but wonder that maybe there was going to be this one dream tool that was going to
[05:50]
do it all and really just help us out and save us time from having to schedule these posts manually. So then we went on to evaluate the next tool, which is Hootsuite. Hootsuite has been around as long as I can remember in the social
[06:04]
media space and they are priced higher than Buffer and Metricool starting at 99 a month. But given we're a business and we thought if it could really save my time and from doing this manually, it would be worth the price tag if it could
[06:18]
take care of all the needs that we have. So we created an account and we put our credit card on file and by the way, out of these three apps, it is the only tool that actually required us to put a credit card on file and with that I just
[06:30]
want to give a big shout out to Bill Spend and Expense for allowing us to put Spend and Expense for allowing us to put a virtual credit card on file and not charged because we could easily freeze it right after creating an account. So
[06:43]
we're in the account and within, I'd say, 5 minutes my stomach started sinking because I had quickly realized that this tool wasn't going to be all that I thought it could be. It's very apparent that Hootsuite was built a long
[06:57]
time ago in terms of the user interface. They have some parts of the tool that wrong button and you get into this really old archaic view. So that wasn't really impressive. And then when it came to actually scheduling it felt more
[07:14]
limiting than Buffer. Nevertheless, we connected all of our accounts and found that there were the same limitations as we had before. So in terms of TikTok, we couldn't pick a thumbnail. With Instagram, it gave us the same error
[07:28]
that Metricool did with the file size. And then when it came to YouTube Shorts, again, same limitations, no thumbnail, no descriptions, no tags. I've said it three times by now. So pay $99 a month and it doesn't even have all the
[07:41]
features that something like Buffer does that's free for three accounts. It just Hootsuite a little bit more, it's very teams. And like I was saying at the beginning, teams that need comprehensive
[07:56]
reporting, they need to show their team trends in social media, they need permissions, they need approvals, and all that kind of stuff. So, they're very feature-rich in these more team tools. So, in terms of being the best
[08:10]
scheduling app, it wasn't it. So, within I'd say 30 minutes, we disconnected all of our social media accounts and we sunset the idea of using Hootsuite as an option. Okay, so where did we end up today? I wish I can tell you that there
[08:23]
was one tool that we really discovered and we really loved and it really met all of our needs, but that wasn't the case. We did take a look at some other ones here and there, but in terms of the top three contenders, we do think that
[08:36]
it is Hootsuite, Buffer, and Metricool. The best app that we found was Buffer and we were really between a rock and a hard place, as they say, where we were thinking, do we continue to post manually or do we use Buffer for some of
[08:50]
started doing a little bit more research to try to dig into what other people are to try to dig into what other people are doing. And then I found out that TikTok actually created their own scheduling tool within the desktop app. Now, that
[09:05]
was interesting because then I thought, what if I use Buffer for Instagram and for Twitter and LinkedIn and then I use the TikTok desktop app for TikTok and then I can just post to YouTube as I've been posting. And I really thought I was
[09:17]
onto something. So, of course, I tried it. I uploaded my post, I wrote my caption, and I scheduled it. And it flopped dramatically. What happened? It posted to TikTok and the caption was formatted, but then I realized that the
[09:32]
video resolution had scaled way down, like to the point where our skin looked grainy and gross, and it was also sitting at one view for over an hour, which if you post a TikTok, that just doesn't happen cuz their algorithm just
[09:44]
puts it in the flow right away. So, I think it like descaled our video and then didn't do anything with it. So, this might be a feature that TikTok's more TLC into, and I think it has a lot of potential, but as of right now
[09:58]
recording this video, it's unusable on our end anyway. So, my friends, we went going to do? We really wanted to save time here and not make our process even more complicated with trying to figure out a batching solution to post. After
[10:13]
really think about how we can optimize our time, we landed on this formula for posting. We were going to use Buffer for posting to Instagram and Twitter and LinkedIn because as far as those platforms go, there was no issues. That
[10:27]
being said, we did have one experience when we tried to schedule a post on rescheduled it for later that day, it worked. So, I'd say in terms of reliability, I'd give it maybe like a
[10:39]
nine out of 10 right now. One thing we're also monitoring with Buffer is social media engagement. So, we've been sending our posts to Instagram and we've been trying to track if it's getting less views than we normally do when we
[10:52]
manually post it. So far, we don't really have a solid answer. It seems to be okay because our views have been consistent up and down with Instagram anyway, but it's a platform that we generally care about less like our
[11:05]
audience is not really on Instagram, so just getting the content out there is enough for us on that platform. I think this is an important distinction to make you really have to take a look at all the social media platforms and think,
[11:19]
"What do I care about the most and where do I want to invest the most time and And that's what we did through our strategy. With our YouTube Shorts, we actually found that you can schedule the Shorts through the YouTube app, which is
[11:34]
really cool and an idea that we didn't really think about. We fell across it when we were trying to save some drafts on our phone. So, you can open up YouTube, you can upload your video, you can save your thumbnail, and then
[11:46]
instead of posting it, you can go to schedule and schedule it for a future time, and then upload the video. And then you can go to the desktop app and related videos and all that sort of thing right within the desktop app. For
[12:00]
us, we're totally fine to do that because we could still batch our content this way, which was a really big unlock and something that made us really happy. And we've been using that now for over a week and it's been working really well.
[12:12]
care more about than Instagram, so we didn't want to just post content with messy captions that weren't cohesive or coherent to read, and we didn't want to have thumbnails that we didn't select
[12:24]
ourselves. And one of the reasons that we do care about TikTok is that we do find that it is good for us SEO. Like some of the content that we posted a year ago is still getting favorited and liked and people are commenting. So, I
[12:36]
do think that the way that TikTok's algorithm is built, it's optimized to incentivize creators like us to create content on there over Instagram, which kind of feels like you post it and then your content just dies. So, that's our
[12:50]
strategy. We're using Buffer for LinkedIn, for Twitter, for Instagram. We are then planning our content up to 2 weeks in advance, then we're taking all of those videos, I transfer them over to my phone, I upload them all to TikTok at
[13:04]
everything in my draft, and then go manually post one video a day, and then native scheduling tool. All this being said, is it better than what we were doing before with manually posting once a day? Yes, absolutely. It takes about 1
[13:20]
content, and then we don't really need to think about it anymore. I I what we're realizing is that these social media apps don't really want to make it easy for any external tool to schedule
[13:33]
posting. A lot of these tools rely on YouTube, for example, to build features into their API to be able to relate a video through the API or to choose a thumbnail through the API. So, if YouTube's not building that, then no
[13:46]
external tool is actually going to make this possible. YouTube, Instagram, TikTok, what they would love and what they get more benefit from is having you open up the app to post every day because you get distracted and sucked in
[13:59]
and then they can show you an ad and it really plays well to their ad revenue model. I wish that this could be a more positive video with having one hero tool that can do everything for you, but we really just wanted to brain dump all the
[14:11]
information that we learned over the past couple of days to hopefully save you some time when doing your own research. Posting natively to these social media apps is the winner here and doing it manually is probably the best
[14:23]
way, but if you have platforms that you care about less, like Instagram, Twitter, LinkedIn, we'd say Buffer would win that category. Hey, okay, so Alex from the future here. So, there is one other scheduling app
[14:37]
been using it since recording this video. So, if you're someone like me and is trying to grow their X following, I'm like Twitter X. So, the tool is called Typefully and it only works with X and LinkedIn, but if you're someone
[14:52]
like me that is trying to specifically grow their X following, that's kind of with, I'm finding that I'm actually posting now on LinkedIn, which is also about it. I write the tweet that I want
[15:06]
to post on X and then I end up posting it to LinkedIn as well. I'd be willing to bet that anyone that you're following on X that also is posting on LinkedIn is probably using Typefully. That's kind of what we've uncovered. If you're also
[15:18]
someone that posts on X, you've probably experienced a bug in which you've just spent the last half hour or an hour writing. Maybe it was due to a refresh on your browser or on your phone mobile app crashing.
[15:31]
worry about with Typefully because it's auto saving at all points in time, so your draft is always right there and present. One of the unintended benefits of using a tool like Typefully is that you don't get sucked into social media
[15:43]
before or after writing your post. You can just write them, schedule them, and get out. Do me a favor and the next time that you post on one of these platforms, see how much time you waste afterward scrolling through other people's posts.
[15:56]
Typefully also has some other power user features like auto repost, auto DM, and auto plug. So, the next time that someone has their thread that goes auto plug. They're going to be pitching why you should go check out their
[16:08]
website in the second comment. They're probably also using Typefully. The last thing is Typefully does a really great job at analytics, so you can see how to month, and you can even see what posts are giving you the most
[16:21]
engagement, so you can focus more on doing more of that. All right. Now, back One more little thing to note is that every platform that we connected our YouTube account with asked for full permission and access to our YouTube
[16:35]
account to even delete videos. And if you're investing a lot of time in your YouTube account, that's obviously pretty scary. We even reached out to the founder of Metricool to ask about this, and every platform was consistent with
[16:49]
the fact saying that it's part of the API requests, and they have to get your permissions, but they will not delete anything. But, for us it just feels a to the end of the video, we want to know how do you schedule your social media
[17:03]
posts? And if you had a request for any of the apps we talked about, what would feature be? If this video helped you, we'd love for regular software reviews here on our
[17:15]
YouTube channel. For instance, check out this Superhuman video that is the best way to check your email. We'll see you in the next one.