[00:01]
day and he said like, "Yo, this is a really good video and it was his own video." And I was like, "Bro, you're just self-promoing your own video." But me to watch it, technically it's not his own video. We'll watch it. The story of
[00:15]
John Goldyer from Danny Cron. He he was self-promoing his own video and then we we didn't watch it and now someone else linked it. Now we are going to watch it. video about gold buying ever. Let's see it. question. Will Blizzard aggressively
[00:29]
pursue gold buyers in WoW Forever? I'm going to use this account to incrementally buy gold until I hopefully catch a permanent ban from Blizzard. >> Oh, cool. I actually like this idea. I was Is that my WoW music? I shut that
[00:43]
down. I actually like that idea. So, we have someone going in on the inside just trying to get banned to see how it works. Cool. But I would like to say a couple things before I go down this path. For one, I realize that by doing
[00:57]
this and documenting it online, I am essentially handing Blizzard a loaded gun. If they want, they can choose to ban me as a person for life across all iterations of their game. I'm making no attempt to hide my real identity or my
[01:13]
account name, as I fully expect this account to be banned by the time that this video airs. I thought and have been thinking intently on this decision of whether or not I should publish this video. And I've come to the conclusion
[01:27]
that while it would be truly terrible to not ever be able to access retail World of Warcraft ever again, what would also be truly terrible is to watch the game continue to persist in the state that it has been in for so long filled with
[01:44]
bots, filled with RMT, >> gold buyers, gold sellers. I have loved >> gold buyers, gold sellers. I have loved this game my entire life and I would love to keep playing it for the rest of my life. But if I can affect even a
[01:57]
small amount of change with this video, possibly bring to light some aspects of the RMT system that could be improved, then maybe it'd be worth it. Ah, so this "Bro, you got to watch." He was like, "This is all for nothing if people don't
[02:12]
watch it." Okay. Um, yeah, man. I've been pushing for this for years, very transparently. Obviously, you ban the bots, right? Do better. Ban more bots. Obviously, Blizzard's nerfing uh mage AoE, so the bots can't solo dungeons and
[02:25]
stuff like that. Um, cool, good, good, good. But my big thing that I've been pushing for is ban the buyers so that people are scared out of their mind to buy gold. Not this slap on the wrist thing that they've been doing. It's
[02:38]
like, no, you buy gold, you're perma, and you have to start over. Because back in the day, no one was well, people were buying gold, but people weren't buying that if you got caught, you would have to restart from level one. Bring that
[02:51]
to restart from level one. Bring that back, Blizzard. Right. Very harsh think it needs to happen for the health of the game. So, this has been my big push the last few years. See what happens.
[03:04]
>> I'm sure is going to be 2020 on this one, but I've decided I'm going to send it anyways. One point I'd like to rip off top here real quick, is that I've even enforcing their anti-RMT measures
[03:16]
laying low during this period and using it as a time to gather telemetry and they'll be launching their anti-RMT systems at live. We know this to be false though, given Kyax's statement here and the fact that we've seen some
[03:29]
high-profile streamers even be banned for RMT. I realize there's a lot of you hate me no matter what. Given that I'm buying gold in this video, I can't really do anything to change that, I'm sure. But I will say truly,
[03:42]
hates him for buying gold purely to test the system? I mean, come on. That level. Yeah, hopefully not. That's crazy talk. >> If there was some magic wand I could wave to just not have RMT in WoW
[03:54]
anymore. I would absolutely do that. But that's not the world we live in. I've seen a lot of people on Reddit talking about how they are very hopeful that RMT bans will be strictly and aggressively enforced and I am absolutely one of
[04:08]
those people. We have to remember here though Blizzard is up against it. The people who profit from this, this is their livelihood essentially. So you can expect staunch resistance. The number one thing I think we can hope for is
[04:20]
swift, accurate, robust systems that can curtail RMT before it spreads into the general economy. we are going to be very very actively monitoring the economy is we are going to very aggressively punish gold buyers. Um being frank, we've we've
[04:37]
been probably too lenient on gold buyers and it's been a little bit easy to get around some of our um some of our actions before and we are taking this very seriously. And you know, as someone who's got a 22-year-old World of
[04:49]
not worth losing it permanently. >> Quite honestly, I loved hearing this. I think this is the best stance ever. and I really hope they can follow through on it. I just want to be clear, this video is not me attempting to get a gotcha
[05:04]
moment on Blizzard in any way, shape, or form. I want to see truly how aggressive these systems are. And I'm hoping they're incredibly aggressive and incredibly fast. And we're going to make our character. We are going to make John
[05:19]
Gold Buyer. Now, we have John Gold Buyer. And what I'm going to do is I'm going to run into a box. We're going to then buy the gold on a website that will not be named. Uh I'm going to buy 25 gold to start off. It's a pretty high
[05:33]
amount honestly, even though it might not sound like it at face value. You got to remember we're on like day three of the beta. I got my first character to level 20 and had about four gold. So, I'm going to just show myself here
[05:46]
purchasing the gold on the website and then it will show up in the mailbox and we'll basically just see where things go from there. Okay, so here's my current order that I just placed. As you can see, it's basically on the way. The
[05:58]
all that. So, now we're just waiting. This is footage of me collecting the first time that I was able to purchase goggles. And I noticed that there might have been an anti-RMT feature built in already at this point because I was
[06:12]
actually unable to receive a mail from a seller. It just simply vanished. We know that they did indeed send it. And so it made me think perhaps there is a uh swift ban coming here and I was you know truly hoping that there would be. And so
[06:26]
at this point I am in Stormwind. I am level five. I have 25 gold and this is the third day of the beta. This is a screen cap of the next order that I placed. This was a day later and it was for 15 gold. This brought me up to a
[06:42]
total of 40 gold. This was on day four of the beta. All right. All right. So, order. The payment and all that stuff is getting handled and they're going to send it to me, I'm sure, uh any moment now. So, we're just going to wait and uh
[06:56]
Currently sitting at 38. This will put me at close to 60 gold. This is footage of me collecting the next gold package that I had previously screenshotted. I believe this was also the next day. And uh this brought me up to it looks like
[07:10]
about 60 gold. This is me collecting gold from a reissue that I got. I'm not going to discuss it any further than that. I don't want to expound on any mechanics as far as gold buying. I'm just showing proof that I did indeed get
[07:22]
the gold. The amount went up. Then here, this is the screenshot of the final me up to >> Blizzard. He named himself John Gold Buyer. He's level one and he has 80 gold.
[07:35]
What? His name is John Gold Buyer. Man, what the >> 100 gold. And then after this, I decided we're going to stop and wait and see. So, there it is. I've bought about a hundred gold. I have it now on my level
[07:47]
five character on day five, I think it is, of the beta. I really just wanted to see for myself. I know the sentiment online from a lot of people is that while they love hearing that RMT is going to be heavily and aggressively
[08:01]
policed, there's a lot of skepticism about whether or not that is actually the truth. And so, I decided, what better way to find out than to test it myself? We know that it takes time in all likelihood to collect all the data
[08:14]
going between buyers and sellers, figure out the network that exists there, and then ban them all in a big wave, which typically does happen. But I think the typically does happen. But I think the crucial element here is again time. The
[08:27]
problem, as I see it right now, is that I've been running around with 100 gold I've been running around with 100 gold for about 3 or 4 days already. I can do a lot of damage if I'm a typical player dispersing the gold into the economy in
[08:40]
that time. So, I feel like really the thing that needs to get aced here or figured out and ironed out is really the speed of bands. All right, everyone. So, this is an update. I'm going to be kind of updating these documentary styles. By
[08:53]
the way, guys, you can see this is September 25th. At this point, I was kind of wondering if maybe I needed to buy more gold to initiate some kind of system and get banned. But then I really thought to myself, the question here
[09:06]
shouldn't be that, oh well, you didn't buy enough gold to get banned. It should simply be if you buy gold, you will get banned, right? In a perfect world. So, at this point, I guess it really is just going to be a waiting game for me. I
[09:19]
also found some interesting stuff on the Battlelet forums from this MVP contributor, which I assume is some kind of elevated community position. I don't totally know, but they did say that false positives can happen and they do
[09:31]
ban waves in groups. That much we all knew. They also said it looked for known cheat signatures and behaviors and then flags them. The hacks team reviews the data, usually over weeks or months, and then bans all persons flagged. I feel
[09:43]
like weeks or months is way too long of a turnaround time to be able to effectively combat the spread of the illegitimate gold. I had also had the >> So, I don't know if it was after this
[09:56]
video or before, but Blizzard added in this new thing where if you're suspicious of buying gold, what they do is they lock your account from trading mailbox. So, you can't buy anything, can't sell anything if you're even
[10:11]
suspicious. So before they ban you, you're like locked out. So if you do get wouldn't be able to ruin the economy for everyone else that farmed it naturally. Is that going to work? I don't know. Hopefully getting banned already because
[10:25]
I actually have not dispersed the gold at all. It's basically all just been sitting on my character. So I did buy some greens off the auction house in an attempt to maybe get flagged for some of the dispersion behaviors. However, I'm
[10:37]
honestly concerned about doing this now after reading this post. In another post getting elicit gold or dealing with exploitive gold seller accounts can get you banned for RMT. Intent does not matter. They are sweeping up everyone
[10:52]
who touches the black market industry. This made me wonder if in fact some of the false positives are innocent people that through one trade or another accidentally end up with illegitimate gold. It also made me immediately stop
[11:06]
>> Wait, hold on. What? What is this? Blizzard is either getting elicit gold or dealing with exploitative gold seller accounts. Intent does not matter. They are sweeping up everyone who touches that black market industry.
[11:18]
is this a blue post or what? What is this? Green post? No, Blizzard has never ever gone into detail. Exactly. That would be absolutely nuts. I don't think would be absolutely nuts. I don't think this is it. It's uh
[11:32]
Yeah, it's just someone typing. Yeah, I don't think this is that intent does not matter. I think that's completely troll. Like there's no way if someone buys gold house, the person that sold the blue is now banned. Like come on, right? Intent
[11:46]
does not m like goodness gracious >> thing on the auction house. I would feel really bad if someone got banned simply because they took the money from the auction they posted and the item that I bought with my illegitimate gold. Part
[11:59]
of me wonders too if maybe a more effective method of tracking down these gold buyers and sellers in real time and actually stopping the damage and the spread would be to have in-game GMs that could teleport to players, observe them
[12:13]
in an invisible way and also check their trade logs and make a quick executive decision perhaps. Okay, so this is an update on September 27th. I had the idea actually that if I don't want to endanger other people but still try to
[12:27]
simulate gold buyer behavior, maybe just simply sending the gold between myself on different characters in large amounts will be enough to tip off the system and get us flagged. So, I'm going to attempt to do that here and hopefully it leads
[12:40]
to something. I'm going to send John gold receiver, the guy that I made, uh >> dude. All right, just going to run this dude to the mailbox and get the gold. Again, I have no idea if this will actually do anything or not, but I
[12:56]
won't endanger other people's accounts and will maybe tip off their system. Okay, so here I am receiving the gold from Gold Buyer onto Gold Receiver and
[13:08]
uh yep, I guess now I'll just continue to wait. I've also seen a fair bit of banned for RMT, though they did not take place in it. There is of course no way for me to be able to verify whether or not these are true false positives or
[13:21]
not. I know the typical reaction is to just laugh at the person on Reddit, but it could go handinhand with what the contributor said about how if you come into contact with illegitimate gold, either knowingly or unknowingly, you
[13:34]
for that. Another problem that I might have noticed, though I'm not sure I have perfect proof for it, is that I've seen a lot of people saying that they are permanently banned for receiving three gold and 18 light leather in the mail
[13:47]
gold and 18 light leather in the mail from a random player. Thanks, Blizzard. Like, so like that's the kind of thing that like cannot happen. What the heck, that like cannot happen. What the heck, bro? Like I remember when I was uh I was
[13:59]
and I was on my first account and I was like a brand new player and uh I had like I don't know 10 silver or something and there was a level 60 out there and
[14:11]
it was just so cool seeing him. So, we were talking and and this and that and um and at the end of the conversation, he gave me like one or two gold or something and I was like, as a 12-year-old, I was so like I remember it
[14:27]
as a 33year-old. It was so cool. I felt like the it was just so much money. I had a full gold to buy anything I wanted. I got a bunch of gear and it was awesome. It was a great experience. So, like I don't know. I hope trading a gold
[14:42]
or two or three to a loby to make their day couldn't ever get anyone banned. You know, having problems with the mailing system. Sometimes mails are not going to the intended person. It might have something
[14:57]
to do with the double name feature that has been introduced. And this made me think, what if gold sellers are inadvertently sending gold to people that did not order it? Some percentage of those people probably just accept it
[15:09]
and they might be getting flagged and then banned from the RMT system. Updating, I've made it to September 30th and still no action on the account. So, I decided I'm going to escalate things a little bit. I bought an additional 300
[15:22]
gold and this is going to be my last buy. I'm going to sit with this. It'll put me at 400, which I have to assume is much more gold than the vast majority in sure there's people that have farmed up a lot, but averages, I'd say this has to
[15:37]
be very high. So, at this point, I'm just going to wait and see what happens. Okay, so I wanted to offer another update here. I have made it to October update here. I have made it to October 9th still, and I have still the 382 gold
[15:49]
in my inventory. So, we have not received an action yet. Okay, so we're updating. It is October 13th. Still have not been actioned on the account, but I discourse online that there's temporary economy holds happening for RMT. That's
[16:02]
>> So, I'm going to send a bunch of gold in large amounts between my characters. I recorded that here and I'm just going to fast forward just to show that it's all hopefully gets me flagged. Okay, as you can see, I've made it to October 23rd.
[16:17]
This is officially the end of the beta, and I have still not received an action on this account. When I first started making this video, I had in my mind a couple ways that it might play out. The number one scenario that I was
[16:29]
personally hoping for was that I would receive a swift ban. This would be a systems and it would feel good as a player seeing that RMT will be heavily clamped down on in WoW forever. The next best scenario though to that would be
[16:44]
getting a ban albeit late. Showing that yeah, while their systems may not be fast enough to stop the realtime spread of gold, they will at least eventually catch you and hopefully deter buyers in the future. Unfortunately, what I got
[16:58]
though is the most inconclusive ending. I have not received any ban. I don't want this video to embolden gold buyers in any way, shape, or form. We have seen people getting banned for botting and buying gold as Blizzard has stated
[17:13]
themselves. I really made this video because I truly love this game and I want to see it flourish. I want to see a World of Warcraft with less botting and World of Warcraft with less botting and less RMT in it as humanly possible. One
[17:27]
silver lining that could maybe come from this ending that was less than desirable this ending that was less than desirable is maybe it can spur Blizzard to in some ways buff up their anti-RMT and anti-cheat systems, but that is
[17:40]
completely out of my control. So, I feel like at this point I've done the best that I can in terms of trying to make some kind of investigative report into this matter. I understand fully that Blizzard could choose to make me the
[17:52]
shining example of what happens if you buy gold here. And if they do that, it's also again completely out of my control. But my question is, would that really fix the overarching problem? I thank you sincerely for taking the time to watch
[18:06]
this video. I'm so disappointed right now, man. I I thought what was going to happen is John Goldber gets banned. He was going to say the anti-RMT system works and that we're all good to go and safe and don't buy
[18:22]
gold, boys and girls. I can't believe it. I'm like, Blizzard, please, please, please ban gold buyers. Oh my gosh. All right, let's see if Danny's okay. We
[18:35]
have Danny, guys, on the follow-up video from yesterday. Unjustly banned. The story of John Gold Buyer versus John bystander. What is it? John Goldber case seems to just get worse and worse. I believe that I have
[18:49]
received proof that Blizzard did in fact hand out an erroneous unjust ban during the development of my story. And I would also like to thank Savix, Peekaboo, and Zaryu for reacting to this video and bringing it to light, as well as all of
[19:03]
bringing it to light, as well as all of you for your kind comments. reacting to the video to bring light to it. We had a a a creator reach out
[19:17]
it. We had a a a creator reach out saying thank you. There it is, guys. There it is. Actually, funny enough, I will say this. This is not something I've said too much of, but the amount of creators that have
[19:30]
reached out to me personally, saying thank you for watching the video on stream and linking to it and all the influx of new people watching the channel. It is insane. So maybe that does need to be said for certain people
[19:45]
out there, but that is very, very common. So cool. I'm glad he enjoyed the react. There we go. If you remember during the original John Gold buyer video, I was unable to receive the first mail that I attempted to get from the
[19:59]
seller. Well, someone came into my Discord and posted this. >> Hello, I just saw your video about John Goldyer. I was a collateral victim of getting annoyed by the mail not working properly and I started doing some tests.
[20:13]
the first name when you send mail and then it would choose the second name alphabetically. Example, if there were five players that were named John, if you send a mail to John Goldbby, but John Albert exists, it would send it to
[20:25]
John Albert. I created a character named John Aaba just to test my theory. And I would be the first in alphabetical order. And guess what? I received a weird mail that I thought was just a joke. Who the hell would buy gold day
[20:40]
three of the beta? It was the mail that you never received. I ended up reporting the mailbug to Blizzard, but got banned the next day for RMT. They never acknowledged my story and the ban was perma. So in summary, this guy,
[20:53]
perma. So in summary, this guy, >> what you cannot make this up. Zaryu and with no last name Oh, bro. The best
[21:06]
and with no last name Oh, bro. The best last name is a a a aaa. Or actually, no, the best last name is just aa zaryu aaa. That's actually that'd be amazing. This bug is already fixed. Oh, they fixed it. Okay. Wow.
[21:22]
So they the gold seller sent it to this guy instead and they got banned. So how could John Gold buyer not get banned? But then this guy gets banned Insta and it's perma. How is that possible? Gold that is being sent through the mail
[21:37]
and swiftly banning people. I would like to assume that if I had actually received this 25 gold mail that I would have been banned right away and the video outcome would have been a very different one. I think it's reasonable
[21:49]
to be skeptical as I was initially when I first saw this. But after digging through some of the old footage that I compiled while making the JGB video, I've confirmed that this is indeed the original seller named Kaza that tried to
[22:04]
mail me this gold. And I even have video proof of it. Given that whenever you do orders on these websites, they actually have to send you a proof gallery in order to complete the order. Yep, this is it. As you can see, kaza right here.
[22:19]
John Gold buyer. There's the 25G that they sent me. It inadvertently went to the other person because of the bug. They accepted it and they got banned. there. Thankfully, this dude was extremely cool. I offered to like pay
[22:33]
for his sub or get him the game or something. He said he didn't care. He just wanted to get the story out there. But it's absolutely insane. I'm doing my best. As you know, if you've seen >> What a weird bug. He literally sent it
[22:46]
some other dude and then the innocent bystander got banned. That is insane. >> The JGB video to like be on Blizzard's side in all of this. But this is just a bad look. This is rough. We need to get this guy unbanned. He literally caught a
[23:03]
stray. Like I was the one that put in that order and the gold got sent to him inadvertently because of a bug and he got banned. Ban me. I'm trying to get
[23:15]
>> I'm trying. >> This is just crazy. I, you know, I feel bad because I'm sure if Blizzard has seen this, they have to hate me by now.
[23:28]
I'm sure they do. But >> I don't think they hate you. Like I I >> I don't think they hate you. Like I I think like it's it's a good test. I I think it's a good test. Like if you
[23:40]
yesterday, the TLDDR is he bought gold on a YouTube video and uh recorded over the beta to see how quick he would get banned. Spoiler alert, he didn't get
[23:53]
WTF, like I should get banned if I bought gold. Blizzard, we got to step it up kind of a thing. Um you watch the whole video if you missed it. It's good. It's on his channel. I'll link it in a sec. But um anyway, someone else did get
[24:07]
banned inadvertently, which is crazy. On the other hand, like someone has to be doing this stuff, right? Would it really be better if no one was reporting on these problems? If they were just going completely, you know, unattended and
[24:22]
unnoticed and if everyone was just saying, "Uh, you know, what's the point? you can't stop it, so why even try? If that's the world we live in, then nothing is ever going to get better. Nothing will ever improve. Here's the
[24:35]
thing, guys. Um, this stuff may embolden gold buyers. It's true. It may be a complete crackdown on me. I may not get to be able to stream WoW, which I would love to do. Or it could maybe also lead to some good things. Maybe Blizzard sees
[24:51]
this and goes, "You know what? Damn it. We got to step up our game. Let's show back and make another video on this, hopefully I'd receive a quick ban. Who knows? But I would rather live in a world where I can say at least I tried
[25:05]
>> Sure. >> And uh, you know, if it doesn't go my way, well, that's just, you know, the way the cookie crumbles. But either way, shot. If we want to try and actually get justice for this guy, though, we're
[25:19]
waves. So, if you can try and get this video to streamers and etc. Thank you so >> the character name was John Aaba. If anyone from Blizzard's watching to receiving mail not intended for me, I used the in-game tool report the bug.
[25:35]
Dude, that is insane. Hopefully they can get them unbanned for that. So false positives clearly do happen, right? They they do. Yeah, I guess false negatives also happen. Is that It doesn't sound right saying it, but I think it is. It's
[25:49]
not even a false positive. It's just the mail bug. Yeah, true. They they Yeah, it was just a mailbug. That actually is kind of true. They technically did ban the guy receiving the gold.