[00:01]
Strength, and I'm here at Light Labs in Ann Arbor, Michigan, and we're going to find out if the supplements that you're taking have actual supplements in them. Let's go find out. >> The number one seller on Amazon did not
[00:14]
have any creatine in their gummy. Wow, legit. Protein powder. Yeah, protein powder claiming 21 g of protein, and they had something closer to 3 g of protein. >> 3 g of protein. To miss by that much,
[00:26]
with something else. [music] To me, it speaks to How do I as a consumer do a little bit extra to make sure I'm not getting extra to make sure I'm not getting screwed over?
[00:44]
supplements are tested for active ingredients, things like creatine, Like, this is where This is where it happens.
[00:58]
surface of the sun. No kidding. Yeah, it's basically like blasting anything in there to its like individual like elements.
[01:11]
What's Light Labs all about? So, the main goal behind Light Labs is increased transparency in the consumer good space, which includes food, supplements, vitamins, etc., so the consumers can start to understand what's in and what's
[01:24]
not in the products. Excellent. There must be some stories you guys know about supplements Yeah. in the health space, fitness space >> Yeah. that have gone considerably off the freeway ramp of claims versus
[01:38]
that was pretty insane to look into was the gummies. >> This is probably the most [music] supplement. >> But I'm taking it now more consistently
[01:51]
than I've ever taken it before, cuz with the gummies, it's so easy. This is what what I checked a few months ago, but the number one seller on Amazon at the time did [music] not have any creatine in it. And so Can you say that again just to
[02:04]
understanding? The number one seller on Amazon did not have any creatine creatine gummy. >> creatine gummy. Sold not because it ostensibly creatine in it. Exactly. And it didn't. It did not.
[02:18]
>> So, when you mean did not, it means it had less than proposed with 97% of the >> [music] >> You mean 0%? I believe it was like >> [music] >> It's It's absolutely insane, and
[02:30]
>> Holy crap. And the reviews were good. I think people were just placebo effect, you're on creatine to be Correct. You can't. You can't. It's like Yeah, how >> Muscles feel fuller. >> Right. Um but it's pretty insane.
[02:52]
So, I might get the numbers wrong, but I want to say they claimed 21 g of protein excess was just carbohydrates. And it was sold in grocery stores, right? And Amazon, and they're doing things to
[03:06]
require stricter testing to prove that you have what you claim to have and are >> [music] >> Um and I think Amazon's beginning to creatine gummy fiasco, [music] but this was sold in a high-end
[03:19]
>> It's insane. And just missed the mark by whatever that percentage is. 90, 90%. So, this Let's get the whole story here. This was a protein powder. >> Protein powder. Yeah, protein powder claiming 21 g of protein, roughly around
[03:34]
there, and they had something closer to 3 g of protein. To three? 3 g of protein. [music] Yeah. And the actual 18 g between that was carbohydrate. Filler, right? Obviously. Yeah, filler. Do you think this was nefarious?
[03:49]
Okay, that's To be that off Right. [laughter] I was going to say. So, don't have all the details, so can't opine. I can opine, and I will. Please. It has to be nefarious. To miss by that much, you have to intentionally be
[04:02]
filling it with something else. And if your manufacturer's responsibility is to test inbound raw materials, so >> should have caught this. So, [music] to me, it speaks to one of the instances of what I would say is clearly a bad actor
[04:15]
[music] who is just optimizing on great margins. Like they just >> Yeah. And the margins don't weigh already. And that's actually the issue is like the economic incentive for fraud is so
[04:27]
gummies are selling for $40 a pop. And there's no creatine, and that is creatine gummy. >> Wow. >> this is why I think more brands, more platforms [music] being online, but also
[04:39]
retail stores are going to start forcing some amount of testing because consumers are waking up to this idea. There's more and more exposure that what you're buying is not necessarily guaranteed to be what you're
[04:53]
necessarily guaranteed to be what you're getting. these other retailers they do require some level of proof. Sure. So, I would say where you buy actually matters a tremendous amount.
[05:08]
beginning to shift way more in this direction because it's a huge I would argue risk to their business, where if you learn that anything can be >> Exactly. You're not going to buy your supplements on Amazon. As a consumer,
[05:25]
Amazon and just trusting that they have my back, which they largely do is there anything else I can make sure like I'm looking up like the lab stuff? I know that if I turn the back of my container for protein, it's got like GMP
[05:40]
that? How do I as a consumer do a little bit extra to make sure I'm not getting screwed over? Yeah. I think the thing that the component that makes all the their certificate of analysis or for their lab data.
[05:53]
Um if you ask any company, they should be able to send that to you. They should readily accessible and send you the actual lab results for that product down to the lot. Okay. That company that was selling the not protein protein
[06:08]
selling the not protein protein Yeah. did they not have a lab vetted at We don't know the specifics. I mean, you can't, right? There's no lab that could accidentally test Right. and show that they actually had the 21 g of protein or
[06:23]
like plus or minus 20%. Um that's more for food less so for supplements, but there's no lab that's going to be off by 90%. So, my gut would say no. They mentioned GMP. A lot of supplements, it's good manufacturing practices.
[06:38]
There's a certain level of testing uh required of GMP facilities. And so, I would definitely look for a GMP mark. And then third, which is I actually think almost more interesting than a certificate of analysis, something
[06:51]
called stability study. COA is a uh point-in-time result of we received the sample as is, we tested this day, here are the results. everything that you consume, especially when it gets into supplements, uh some
[07:06]
of the actives are highly susceptible to degradation. creatine gummies. >> Creatine is is a pretty stable, but like your your B vitamins, right? Anytime you manufacture something, you're
[07:19]
introducing it typically to like heat, pressure, unless it's just a straight like powder encapsulation or a straight powder in a bag. This introduces account when you're formulating. A stability study basically says we're
[07:33]
period of the shelf life. So, if you claim 2-year expiration, you test at these different time points to show that at each time point up until point of expiration, it has what it claims to have on the SFP. And so, you have some
[07:49]
formulas that are chemically incompatible and degrade close to immediately. And so, you're buying a product that even if you test it like day zero it's going to be a different product from a efficacy
[08:03]
the road because of the potential degradation. >> Yeah. So, I would say stability studies paired with a COA, paired with you know, good manufacturing practice, co-packers, which most brands will highlight that as
[08:16]
a selling point. Those are the things that you know, I look for now. Very Are there any classes of supplements which are more often running into trouble than other classes of
[08:31]
supplements, and can you guys speak to that? I would say multivitamins as a Um it's incredibly complex to formulate a tiny product that has 10 different vitamins in there that are
[08:45]
all going to be stable over the course of like say 18 months shelf life where uh what Nick was saying is around like chemical incompatibility Mhm. where many of these vitamins may not be compatible uh in certain what what are called
[08:59]
technical, like gummies versus capsules versus gels. Yeah, what's holding the >> Mhm. And given that lab data is very much just a point-in-time snapshot, if you kind of actually plot every single vitamin in a
[09:12]
gummy over the course of 18 months formulation becomes this incredibly hard >> Yep. where you need someone incredibly competent who's testing and is super rigorous about it. And so, that's what I call like hard mode, where that's where
[09:27]
I it has more problems than others. >> Mhm. But then once you go to something like creatine just scoop plain powder, like that's like all the >> Physical powder in a bag. Yeah. Generally is much more likely to be not
[09:40]
Generally is much more likely to be not BS than a proprietary blend combo product especially in a kind of matrix that's like >> Yeah. Yeah. advanced, like not just all all a powder or like a drink. Like cuz
[09:52]
the unit is water, you have massive degradation potential, temperature >> It's just harder to mess up, right? >> Right, right. And then just put the stuff in the bag and it's not >> Exactly. And I will say yes to
[10:05]
This kind of gets back to the class of it's very easy to start a brand. Yeah. Where it tends to be like low minimum order quantities needed to get started. There is a tipping point where there's a lot of risk associated to not having
[10:19]
what you claim to have. And so all this to say that yes, those forms are mode. But if you're a legitimate brand, you're most likely spending a ton on testing. Your manufacturer is spending a ton on
[10:35]
testing. So I think there are great brands, there's plenty of great brands to buy from that have nailed it. It's not like this impossible thing to figure >> Yeah. Just need to >> test a little bit more. So all that to
[10:48]
say you know, it's not a impossible multivitamin. Right. >> It's just you can ask questions. The claims to have are high. Yes.
[11:00]
>> But you just need to do your due due diligence basically. Yeah. Okay, so you guys are looking forward to a world in hopefully 5 years or so where finding a supplement through a vetted website like Amazon or a vetted
[11:15]
place like Whole Foods that isn't rigorously tested by companies such as yours is like a very highly unlikely thing. It's a unicorn. It's like finding like unapproved chemicals in paint today
[11:31]
>> Exactly. Yeah. [laughter] You shouldn't, but people did. Yeah. Okay. That's your vision is like no more brands that are doing it right to win the category. Right? If you're a brand
[11:44]
creatine in and then there are brands that are, you know, charging $15 less they're the ones that are the number one seller. To me that's an incredibly dumb situation. And so it very much is allow the brands that are doing it right to
[11:59]
win which then gives the incentive for brands who might have points of contamination might have degradation, might not have what they claim to have to fix that so they can then compete the competitors who are transparent and
[12:11]
>> Yes. Yeah. Scott can I can I tell a story about my friend and keep it anonymous? Sure. I have a friend >> [laughter] >> who was getting his uh D vitamins
[12:28]
blood levels checked. And taking D vitamins from the store. D vitamins are fat soluble and so ostensibly you take them, then your levels go up. Potentially even too much and you need to stop taking them.
[12:42]
And my friend continued to take them and went to the doctor and the doctor said, "Yep, still kind of low on D vitamins." So he took double the amount for some time came back with even lower levels. And so where the hell are the D
[12:56]
vitamins? Apparently this does actually happen, huh? Yes. Yes. I suspect I'm tell me what the most likely thing is. I suspect they actually were putting D
[13:08]
vitamins into the product but through some like matrix issue there's some oxidation happening and then just after a few weeks of the thing sitting in a a truck and then the thing sitting on a shelf on a shelf, there's just no more D
[13:21]
vitamins in it. Yeah, highly possible. Growing up I would always read like keep in a cool, dry, dark area and I never >> Yeah. You do that because you expose it to heat, you expose it to light and that
[13:33]
can degrade the actual supplement. And so that's it's kind of the wild thing is correctly and then somewhere along in the supply chain where they kind of lose a little bit of the control it can be exposed to these circumstances that
[13:48]
degrade the efficacy. And so it's just a hard problem. >> At the end of the day But you can technically test off-shelf testing for your own brand, right? You can have like someone come in, buy things at a store
[14:00]
is that a good idea? You guys think people should be doing that? I think if you own the brand, it is your ultimate responsibility Yeah. to ensure efficacy up to point of expiration at all different call it points
[14:14]
>> That makes a lot of sense. >> [music] you know what? I I think uh yeah, it's been about a month. Maybe we can do one >> [laughter] >> Mike, you ready for a shower?
[14:29]
Wait, what's a shower? May may I? Are we good, Matt? Yeah, >> [laughter] >> Hey. Like just pull that? Yep.
[14:44]
>> All right, now just push it back up. All right. learned some stuff. I didn't break anything so far, which is great. It's super, super important that everyone involved in the supplement business in
[14:59]
general gets up to the highest level of standard in vetted testing so that all sure that they're free of lead and other crazy stuff and actually are getting us jacked. Light Labs is one of the companies that's doing an amazing job at
[15:13]
for them if you want to contact them for anything at all. Now it's time for me to going to get me kicked out. I'm going to try drinking random chemicals. See you try drinking random chemicals. See you next time, maybe.