[00:00]
Hello there and welcome to another episode
[00:04]
of the most popular thing in the world is bad actually.
[00:07]
Where I, or really any YouTuber who knows how to use
[00:10]
hand brake gets easy Internet points by criticizing the MCU.
[00:13]
Look, the thing with the MCU is that it will always be really easy to criticize.
[00:17]
When you homogenize the art of filmmaking to the point where you're able to
[00:20]
pump out for movies a year plus a handful of TV shows.
[00:23]
It will always be possible for someone like me to ask,
[00:26]
was this style the best choice for this story no matter what story you're making.
[00:30]
Because of course, there's going to be times when
[00:32]
different choices would be more suitable to the material at hand.
[00:35]
The cinematography and color grading of a spy movie
[00:38]
shouldn't be the same as what you use in a space at Beck.
[00:41]
Of course, each individual movie could be better,
[00:44]
but they couldn't make this number of
[00:46]
passively good movies if they didn't have some house style.
[00:49]
I guess the MCU is good at telling simple fun stories about
[00:53]
quippy relatable heroes and creating the desire to see those characters in future movies.
[00:57]
It's not interested in anything else.
[01:00]
However, I think a lot of the recent Marvel movies are doing something that doesn't
[01:04]
interfere with that main goal of getting audiences interested in new characters.
[01:09]
Marvel has started making movies that yada,
[01:12]
yada through their own first acts.
[01:14]
After my mom died, my dad started my training.
[01:18]
Let's take a look at the first half-hour-ish of Jiangxi.
[01:22]
In a prologue we meet Jiangxi father when Wu,
[01:25]
who is an ancient immortal warlord in possession of the magical 10 rings,
[01:30]
searching for an ancient city,
[01:31]
he meets its protector Yang Li.
[01:33]
They fall in love and have a child Jiangxi.
[01:36]
Fast-forward to the present day in Shong is now
[01:38]
Shawn and unambitious valet in San Francisco.
[01:41]
His best friend is Katie and she likes driving really fast.
[01:44]
Please get it. I'll go slow.
[01:47]
Seem to. At a bar,
[01:50]
Shawn and Katie tell the story of how they first met,
[01:52]
which we don't get to see.
[01:54]
Right before he's about to throw the first punch,
[01:56]
Katie, comes out of nowhere,
[01:58]
steps right between us and starts screaming the lyrics to Hotel California.
[02:03]
They're more successful friend points out
[02:05]
that they aren't making the best of their talents.
[02:07]
Maybe there's a point where you're supposed to stop going
[02:09]
on joyrides and start thinking about living up to your potential.
[02:12]
This establishes a core theme of
[02:14]
the movie and the lesson of both of their character arcs.
[02:16]
Both of them have to learn how to become
[02:18]
more responsible people and use their talents to help others.
[02:21]
But in the moment they shrug off her advice and go partying.
[02:24]
Scene 3, Shawn goes to Katie's place and has breakfast
[02:27]
with her family where he's accused of being a mooch.
[02:30]
The foundations of the films other major theme about how you relate to
[02:33]
your family's history in the past is laid here
[02:36]
with Katie's grandmother's still morning her husband.
[02:38]
We just know why it going would've wanted you to move on and enjoy your life?
[02:41]
Moving on is an American idea.
[02:44]
Scene 4 has the inciting incident where they are attacked by ninjas on the bus.
[02:48]
This scene absolutely rules, no notes.
[02:55]
At the end of it, he realizes the Ninjas have
[02:58]
something to do with his sister, therefore Scene 5.
[03:00]
Shawn makes the decision to try and help his sister.
[03:03]
Katie also makes a decision to help him.
[03:04]
This is the end of Act 1.
[03:06]
On the surface, there's nothing terribly wrong with that structure.
[03:10]
We meet our protagonists,
[03:12]
we learned what their major character flies.
[03:14]
The direction of the character arcs has been set up,
[03:16]
the themes have been established.
[03:18]
We have an inciting incident and the main characters
[03:20]
make an important decision to engage with the problem.
[03:22]
It's a pretty standard first act.
[03:25]
The problem for me is that this isn't actually the first act of Jiangxi story.
[03:30]
There's a whole series of flashbacks detailing
[03:32]
his background and how his father trained him to be an assassin.
[03:36]
Let's break them down.
[03:37]
Flashback 1, we learned that after his mother died,
[03:40]
his father started training him as an assassin.
[03:42]
His sister trained in secret when they were 14.
[03:44]
His father sent him on his first mission.
[03:46]
The montage actually contains all of the other flashbacks within it chronologically.
[03:51]
Flashback 2, right before he goes on his first mission,
[03:53]
he has a conversation with
[03:55]
his younger sister where they are mourning their mother's death.
[03:57]
She asks him not to leave her and he promises that he'll be back in three days.
[04:01]
Something we know doesn't happen.
[04:03]
Flashback 3, his father interrupts his training and tells
[04:05]
him he needs to train both his body and mind in order to
[04:08]
inherit the 10 rings showing us that Jiangxi did it
[04:11]
1.1 to inherit them and make his father proud more than anything else.
[04:15]
Flashback 4. When Wu tells us about how Yingli had
[04:17]
an effect on him and we see them falling in love and beginning of family.
[04:20]
Jiangxi, mother is killed by his father's old enemies.
[04:24]
He then witnesses his father take revenge and his
[04:26]
tasked by his father to kill the man most responsible.
[04:30]
Right after this Jiangxi confides in Katie that he did actually
[04:33]
kill that man and then didn't return to his father because he felt guilty.
[04:36]
Notably, this scene is not shown as a flashback,
[04:39]
only talked about in contrast to the rest of the backstory.
[04:48]
Now, if we rearrange these scenes chronologically,
[04:52]
including the prologue with his parents and
[04:54]
adding the scenes that are talked about but not shown,
[04:56]
we can instead have a first act in change that looks something like this.
[05:00]
Wen Wu is an ancient warlord,
[05:02]
he gives that up when he falls in love.
[05:04]
For a time, the family lives happily,
[05:05]
but then some mobsters kill his wife.
[05:07]
Shang-Chi witnesses his father violently take revenge for the death of his mother.
[05:11]
His father trains him to be an assassin and
[05:13]
Shang-Chi aspires to inherit the 10 rings himself.
[05:15]
While Wen Wu would we trained Jiangxi,
[05:17]
his sister practices in secret.
[05:19]
His sister begs him not to leave her alone and promise that he'll return in three days.
[05:22]
Shang-Chi is sent on his first mission.
[05:24]
On the first mission, Jiangxi kills the man responsible for his mother's death.
[05:27]
That would be the end of the first act in a chronological version of the story.
[05:31]
First acts typically end when the main character makes
[05:34]
a significant choice and this would be that.
[05:36]
After this, the rest of the film could proceed as before.
[05:39]
I think if you tell the story chronologically,
[05:41]
you get more immediate reasons to care about Jiangxi.
[05:44]
You see right up front the effect the death of
[05:46]
his mother has on him and the rest of the family.
[05:48]
You see what his relationship is like with his sister,
[05:50]
which emotionally invest the audience and finding her later on,
[05:53]
and as you can see at the beginning of his relationship with Katie.
[05:55]
Though, the dynamic of that relationship does
[05:57]
already work and is one of the stronger parts of the story.
[05:59]
Most importantly, though we're centering the idea of Shang-Chi having to wrestle with
[06:03]
the good and bad parts of his heritage
[06:05]
rather than the story of him just being unambitious.
[06:08]
I think the former is where the story and character are stronger.
[06:12]
It also means showing the most critical scene of his character development,
[06:15]
which the film only alludes to the fact that Shang-Chi was
[06:18]
in fact an assassin who did in fact actually kill someone.
[06:22]
This is the biggest hole in the story for me.
[06:24]
We miss out on actually seeing this crucial moment of
[06:27]
change in Shang-Chi and how that weighs on him over the rest of the story.
[06:32]
His guilt over this moment is established and
[06:35]
resolved in the same scene in the current film,
[06:38]
rather than being explored over the course of the film.
[06:40]
There's very little about the earlier parts of the movie that make it feel like
[06:44]
Shang-Chi was actually an assassin and grappling with guilt.
[06:47]
I just don't buy that that's who he is.
[06:49]
He reads this too normal and two,
[06:51]
well adjusted for that to be the case.
[06:53]
When I think of his character arc,
[06:55]
I think this is the story of an average guy from San Fran who becomes a level 20 monk.
[07:00]
Rather than, this is the story of someone who trained to kill from a young age,
[07:03]
learning to use his skills for the better.
[07:05]
The movie wants to be both things,
[07:06]
but I only know the second one because
[07:08]
this scene is here to tell me that piece of information,
[07:11]
not because I actually feel it on an emotional level.
[07:14]
Giving the audience adhesive information is not the same as dramatizing a story.
[07:18]
Also, I don't think this arrangement and extension of the story would
[07:22]
add too much to the runtime because there's a lot you could cut from this movie.
[07:27]
The final battle with the big monster is completely unnecessary when
[07:30]
the actual emotional conclusion to the story is Shang-Chi defeating his father.
[07:34]
Trava flattery doesn't need to be here.
[07:36]
Much of the second act as the characters running from place to place,
[07:39]
which could easily be pared down.
[07:41]
What I'm trying to get at is the difference between
[07:43]
character-focused storytelling and plot-focused storytelling.
[07:46]
Character-focused story follows the character's emotional journey,
[07:50]
the decisions they make,
[07:51]
and how that changes who they are.
[07:52]
A plot-focused story pushes the character from
[07:54]
location to location to justify action scenes.
[07:57]
In short, while the first act of Shang-Chi isn't bad by any means,
[08:01]
I think it's the wrong first act if the goal is to
[08:04]
build an audience's investment in his character.
[08:07]
Captain Marvel has a similar problem.
[08:13]
Now, in fairness, this movie has
[08:16]
a better justification for its flashback structure than Shang-Chi does.
[08:19]
The fact that Shang-Chi grew up as an assassin is not a mystery in that movie.
[08:24]
Whereas Captain Marvel's history as an Air Force pilot on Earth is.
[08:27]
For most of the film,
[08:29]
she suffers from amnesia and is slowly putting together
[08:31]
her memories of her life on Earth before she became an intergalactic space cop.
[08:35]
These memories are delivered to the audience,
[08:37]
mostly in fragments, quick snippets of scenes,
[08:41]
and they're not really fleshed out.
[08:42]
Only the memory that shows us how she lost her memories qualifies as a full scene.
[08:47]
The rest is in a hazy fog.
[08:49]
The audience receives the information that Carol was a pilot,
[08:52]
that she experienced sexism throughout her life,
[08:55]
and that she succeeded despite this.
[08:57]
But these scenes are so short that they don't tell the full story.
[09:00]
They are not dramatized, only hinted at.
[09:03]
All of those valuable empathy building classic first act scenes are skipped through.
[09:08]
Now at this point, we could do the same thing we did with
[09:10]
Shang-Chi and reorder the events chronologically,
[09:13]
but I think that would also mean removing the amnesia plot point.
[09:16]
But that rewrite is far more radical than just rearranging Shang-Chi.
[09:20]
Also thematically, I think the amnesia idea is important to this film's idea of
[09:25]
power structures telling you who you are
[09:27]
and what your limitations are and I wouldn't want to mess with that.
[09:30]
Not every character needs to have their entire history
[09:32]
chronologically laid out before they get to do the superhero stuff.
[09:36]
When I first watched this movie,
[09:37]
I actually loved that it started with her being a superhero
[09:40]
without having to do a full typical origins story for her.
[09:44]
I don't need to see them as a kid to empathize with them. That's not what I'm saying.
[09:48]
But if we're going to hint at important scenes from her childhood that have informed
[09:52]
her character and then try to cash in on those scenes emotionally at the climax,
[09:57]
then the audience should get to experience those scenes
[10:00]
in full so that they can resonate with them at the end.
[10:03]
Because otherwise the end is just going to feel hollow and that's the thing.
[10:06]
A first act problem isn't really a first act problem,
[10:09]
it's a third act problem.
[10:11]
Let's explain that more with another movie, Black Widow.
[10:14]
This movie has one of
[10:16]
the most perplexing climactic scenes in a blockbuster film in recent memory.
[10:21]
There is so much going on in this scene that is only being
[10:24]
established during the scene that needed to be established beforehand.
[10:29]
Here's the context.
[10:31]
You've got this family of super spies.
[10:33]
Mom, dad, black widow, and her sister.
[10:35]
Mom works for the bad guy who is going to capture them all.
[10:38]
With some face changing technology,
[10:40]
Black Widow disguises herself as her mom so that she can infiltrate Dreykov base.
[10:45]
Dreykov is the head of the secret organization
[10:47]
that brutally trained Natalie to be an assassin,
[10:49]
a group she later defected from.
[10:51]
Nat thought she killed him and his daughter back then
[10:54]
and has felt guilty about the collateral damage of that.
[10:56]
But of course, he's prepared for this saying that.
[10:59]
When you look into the eyes of a child you have
[11:02]
raised no mask in the world can hide that.
[11:06]
Interspersed with this are brief flashbacks explaining
[11:09]
what black widow's plan was, which is fine.
[11:11]
It's a spy genre staple to get your characters
[11:14]
in trouble and then reveal that they actually plan things out.
[11:16]
It's fine. But then there's more.
[11:18]
Dreykov reveals that the masked soldier that Nat's been fighting
[11:22]
this whole time is actually his own daughter who Nat thought she killed.
[11:26]
Wow, what a reveal.
[11:29]
Wish I knew who that character was beforehand, but whatever.
[11:32]
He tells her to leave, so it doesn't matter anymore to the scene.
[11:35]
Nat tries to kill him,
[11:36]
but can't because of pheromones.
[11:40]
How are you controlling me?
[11:41]
I'm not controlling you Natasha, well,
[11:44]
not yet because I do use a pheromonal
[11:47]
[inaudible] smelling my pheromones prevents you from committing [inaudible] it's me.
[11:52]
Oh, but wait, there's more.
[11:54]
She knew about the pheromones and her mom told her how to combat them.
[11:57]
You just got to bang your head on a table a couple of times.
[12:00]
It feels like this guy would be prepared for that.
[12:02]
But all of this is actually a ploy to get him to
[12:04]
reveal his entire evil plan, which he does,
[12:07]
but the pheromone thing ultimately doesn't matter because Nat fails to kill him,
[12:12]
and Yelena, her sister,
[12:14]
just kill some later without having to overcome the pheromones.
[12:18]
The only reason it's here as a plot point is
[12:21]
to justify the two characters talking for a whole long while.
[12:25]
But the only reason they need to talk for a whole long while is because there are
[12:28]
so many plot points this scenes needs to touch on that weren't established earlier.
[12:33]
In this one scene,
[12:34]
we're covering Nat and Dreykov relationship.
[12:37]
We've got to retell the audience that break-off basically raised Nat to
[12:40]
the point that he can see through her face disguising technology, two,
[12:44]
we've got to go over Nat and her mom's plan,
[12:46]
three, we've got the taskmaster review,
[12:49]
four, we've got the pheromones reveal and five,
[12:51]
we've got the whole evil plan explanation.
[12:53]
Now other than Nat and Melina's plan,
[12:55]
all of these plot points are ideas that could have
[12:57]
conceivably been handled in the first act of this film.
[13:00]
The real problem here is that this is the first scene in the movie where
[13:04]
Scarlett Johannson and Dreykov get to actually talk with one another.
[13:08]
Let's do a quick recap.
[13:09]
The movie opens with a very effective scene.
[13:12]
Natalie is living a good life with a good family in Ohio,
[13:15]
but they are all actually Russian spies and
[13:17]
her father having completed his mission, needs to escape.
[13:20]
They do and fly off to Cuba.
[13:22]
In Cuba, we get the one establishing scene
[13:24]
with Dreykov where he has gnats family broken up,
[13:27]
The title card hits,
[13:28]
and then so much happens,
[13:31]
like more happens in the title card sequence for
[13:34]
this movie then happens in the entire rest of the film.
[13:37]
You've got this extremely phonetic and confusing sequence
[13:40]
that I can't help but feel left most viewer scratching their heads.
[13:43]
It whips through Natalie's training as a black widow as well as Dreykov rise and
[13:48]
political influence but inter-cuts so much imagery that is, well, it's just a mess.
[13:52]
My question is, why isn't what happens in the credit sequence part of the actual movie.
[13:57]
If she's going to face off against Dreykov at the end,
[14:00]
why not show scenes where she is being trained as a black widow,
[14:03]
a sequence that could have shown us the abuse she endured under Dreykov.
[14:07]
It got us emotionally invested in his ultimate defeat.
[14:10]
If we want to end this movie with Natalie
[14:12]
feeling guilty about hurting Dreykov's daughter.
[14:15]
Why not have scenes at the beginning that showed
[14:17]
what her relationship was like with Dreykov's daughter.
[14:20]
If Dreykov has a special smell that stops people from attacking him and act 3,
[14:24]
why not have a scene where someone tries to attack him but
[14:27]
fails because of the smell tech in act 1.
[14:29]
That way you don't have to do the whole explanation while it's happening.
[14:33]
The movie repeatedly tries to tell us that Dreykov is
[14:36]
really important and that Natalie has a long-standing grudge against him,
[14:39]
but emotionally it all falls flat because we
[14:41]
didn't see it in their one major scene together.
[14:44]
Both of them have to keep saying things to re-establish their basic relationship.
[14:48]
When you look into the eye of a child you've raised,
[14:52]
no mask in the world can hide them.
[14:55]
He took my choices, tried to break me.
[14:58]
But you're never going to do that to anybody ever again.
[15:00]
I feel like these lines exist because the film knows it did not succeed in
[15:04]
investing the audience in Natalie defeating Dreykov or even what their basic dynamic was.
[15:09]
It has to keep reminding us in the moment to justify what's happening.
[15:13]
This is not how you want
[15:15]
the climactic scene between your protagonist and your antagonist to go.
[15:19]
When you have a scene like this where the two finally face off,
[15:21]
that's the time you want the characters to be able to
[15:23]
focus on what's really at stake in the movie,
[15:26]
the theme, you want to see a clash of ideas.
[15:28]
You want the audience salivating for the hero to wind
[15:30]
slick little flashbacks showing that the hero actually has a plan when we
[15:33]
thought they were the ones being surprised are
[15:35]
fine but grinding everything to a halt to deliver
[15:38]
exposition on almost every major plot point in the film is really not.
[15:42]
For better examples of this.
[15:44]
You need only look at the other movies I've mentioned in this video
[15:47]
because even though I think those movies can also be improved,
[15:50]
at least you know how to feel by the end when
[15:52]
the hero and the villain are fighting at the climax.
[15:55]
I think part of the reason that we don't see some of
[15:57]
these scenes is because this movie has to pull off
[16:00]
a ridiculous juggling act in order to keep
[16:02]
the continuity of itself straight within the MCU.
[16:05]
A problem so complicated,
[16:07]
I'm not even going to attempt to unspool it.
[16:09]
But the other reason we don't see, for instance,
[16:11]
any of Nat's early life as a black widow is because that would involve showing
[16:15]
tough scenes that include things like human trafficking, torture, mutilation.
[16:19]
This is a movie made by the Disney Corporation.
[16:21]
I get why for real-world practical reasons,
[16:24]
this movie can't be that,
[16:26]
that it can't focus on those things for longer than an introductory credit sequence.
[16:30]
But, I didn't choose the subject matter for the story. They did.
[16:34]
They chose to avert the camera away from
[16:36]
the nastier parts of the story that they were telling,
[16:38]
which created all screenwriting problems for them in the third act,
[16:42]
I think it's a similar reason why we don't see
[16:44]
Shang-Chi actually kill someone in his movie.
[16:46]
Disney wants to make safe family friendly movies,
[16:49]
and they are not going to show their characters doing bad things to
[16:52]
that degree because they need to sell action figures and maintain their brand reputation.
[16:56]
But I think these were mistakes or
[16:58]
at least missed opportunities from a storytelling perspective.
[17:00]
All of this is quite a shame because
[17:02]
solid act ones used to be the MCU's bread and butter.
[17:06]
I would argue that a ton of the MCU's initial success is
[17:09]
because the early movies had solid first acts,
[17:11]
Iron Man, Captain America, Hulk,
[17:13]
even the Thor movie had
[17:15]
well-structured introductions to their characters
[17:18]
that showed what kind of person they were,
[17:19]
what their flaws were,
[17:21]
what their strengths were,
[17:22]
what they wanted out of life,
[17:24]
who was important to them all while involving them in the main plot that needs solving.
[17:28]
Imagine if an Iron Man,
[17:30]
we just watched him being Iron Man.
[17:32]
Then a flashback at the end told us he got
[17:34]
captured by the ten rings and had to escape from a cave.
[17:37]
None of those movies held information back just so they can have a reveal later.
[17:42]
They are upfront with who their characters are.
[17:44]
I think that makes a better foundation for the rest of their stories.
[17:47]
In fairness, marvelous TV shows are getting this right.
[17:50]
In Hawkeye, we got a seven minute introductory sequence to echo,
[17:53]
who is a secondary character on that show.
[17:56]
But I know more about her and connect more to her as
[17:58]
a result of those seven minutes than I do to any of the characters mentioned here.
[18:02]
These movies have runtimes pushing 2.5 hours.
[18:04]
They definitely have the time for more patiently paste character introductions.
[18:08]
People often come to these kinds of movies for the big action set pieces and X3.
[18:12]
But all of that is meaningless sizzle if he can't make the audience care in act 1.