[00:00]
After crashing through the fortress of
[00:01]
solitude to pick up her dog, Kara Zor-El
[00:04]
is back in Supergirl. It's a
[00:06]
hard-drinking, isolated version of the
[00:08]
character in a movie that brings a lot
[00:09]
to like, from western tropes to needle
[00:11]
drops. But, for every dog that needs
[00:14]
saving and young child that needs
[00:15]
role-modeling, can this rough-and-tumble
[00:17]
Supergirl be a new enough take on these
[00:19]
tropes to really soar? Or is it more red
[00:22]
sun than yellow? I'm Clint Gage, and
[00:24]
this is my review of Supergirl.
[00:26]
>> Two tickets from that dive bar.
[00:28]
>> Funny.
[00:30]
That's what I've been calling you.
[00:32]
>> Touché.
[00:36]
>> Going into this movie, I was excited. I
[00:38]
had real expectations. Before we even
[00:41]
get to the DCU of it all, I'm officially
[00:43]
a fan of Craig Gillespie. He's a guy who
[00:46]
makes movies that are all better than
[00:48]
you'd think they'd be. In Cruella and I,
[00:50]
Tonya, and Lars and the Real Girl, and
[00:52]
even Finest Hours, that boat broken half
[00:55]
rescue movie was surprisingly really
[00:57]
good. And these are movies that could
[00:58]
have easily become forgettable entries
[01:01]
in their particular genres, like just
[01:03]
another biopic, or another live-action
[01:05]
remake, or another movie about who's in
[01:08]
love with the sex doll. So, the prospect
[01:10]
of tackling a superhero movie with that
[01:12]
particular ability to elevate a film in
[01:14]
an otherwise tired category was
[01:17]
intriguing. And where the DCU is
[01:18]
concerned, I'm here for James Gunn's
[01:20]
universe. I've liked what's gone into it
[01:22]
so far, and I loved Milly Alcock's first
[01:24]
appearance as Kara in her cameo in
[01:26]
Superman. I think this version of
[01:27]
Supergirl is a blast, and her solo
[01:29]
outing didn't do anything to change my
[01:31]
mind on that front. But, this is also
[01:33]
where Supergirl starts to become a tale
[01:35]
of two movies. And for everything that
[01:37]
the movie does right, that thing's got
[01:39]
an alter ego that's doing it a little
[01:41]
wrong. As a result, the movie is this
[01:43]
shuffling few steps forward, few steps
[01:45]
back kind of slog that never really
[01:47]
finds a rhythm. For example, the
[01:49]
reluctant hero thing is actually very
[01:51]
difficult to pull off. It's hard to play
[01:53]
I don't care in in engaging way, because
[01:56]
if the character on screen doesn't care,
[01:58]
then I certainly don't care either.
[02:00]
Alcock manages it here about as well as
[02:02]
you could hope for.
[02:04]
>> Let's be honest, babe. [music] It's not
[02:06]
a very
[02:07]
high bar to clear.
[02:10]
>> Kara is a mess and there's [music] no
[02:12]
real concern with her ever not being a
[02:15]
mess as part of her journey. It's very
[02:17]
fun. And the other side of that coin,
[02:18]
however, is that she doesn't have much
[02:21]
of a journey. She's not a markedly
[02:23]
different person [music] at the end of
[02:24]
the movie than she is at the beginning.
[02:26]
And not because of anything she did or
[02:27]
didn't do as a character or an actor,
[02:30]
but because the story she's been put in
[02:32]
doesn't give her much to do at all. And
[02:34]
the result is a movie that sort of
[02:36]
flattens out and drags. And when she
[02:38]
first meets Eve Ridley's Ruthie, the
[02:40]
young girl out for revenge against the
[02:41]
man who murdered [music] her entire
[02:43]
family, Kara is protective, sticking her
[02:45]
neck out to do the right thing for a kid
[02:47]
who's in over her head. And by the end
[02:49]
of the film, Kara does exactly the same
[02:52]
thing. And part of the point there is
[02:54]
that it highlights the impact she has on
[02:56]
Ruthie. Ridley ultimately gets the
[02:58]
lion's share of the character work in
[02:59]
the film and her character's journey
[03:01]
winds up feeling far more complete than
[03:03]
Kara's.
[03:06]
>> He has 3 days. You cannot give up on me.
[03:11]
>> So, while Milly Alcock's performance is
[03:13]
a real strength of the movie and she
[03:15]
does pull off the reluctant hero trope,
[03:18]
it is a very familiar trope and the
[03:20]
shorthand that's used in portraying it
[03:22]
is a real [music] weakness. Familiarity
[03:24]
in general is another villainous plot
[03:27]
Supergirl tries to thwart. [music]
[03:28]
On one hand, the movie wears its
[03:30]
influences proudly. The comparisons to
[03:32]
James Gunn's work on Guardians of the
[03:34]
Galaxy have been obvious since the
[03:35]
trailers first dropped and we knew the
[03:38]
True Grit archetypal Western structure
[03:40]
would be a big part of the film because
[03:42]
of the source material, Tom King's Woman
[03:44]
of Tomorrow run.
[03:45]
>> [music]
[03:45]
>> A Mad Max influence is just as obvious
[03:47]
in the grimy, lifeless terrains and
[03:50]
dying worlds on which most of the movie
[03:52]
takes place. Planets where people
[03:54]
scratch for survival, but the old
[03:56]
reliable Mos Eisley Cantina should get a
[03:58]
shout-out as well. The alien design and
[04:01]
practical makeup effects and costuming
[04:03]
throughout the movie are genuinely
[04:04]
top-shelf. And clearly the customers in
[04:07]
Star Wars' most wretched hive were on
[04:09]
the filmmakers' minds. [music] And yet,
[04:12]
while I'll happily take True Grit meets
[04:14]
Mad Max by way of Guardians and Star
[04:16]
Wars, there still manages to be a dulled
[04:18]
edge to the whole movie. Instead of
[04:20]
taking the post-apocalyptic vibes of Mad
[04:23]
Max, [music] they lift a whole plot
[04:24]
point straight from Fury Road and handle
[04:26]
it, frankly, a little clumsily. And
[04:28]
instead of the emotionally relevant
[04:30]
needle drops of Guardians of the Galaxy,
[04:32]
Kara gets slow-paced montages set to a
[04:34]
Jimmy Eat World cover that I found
[04:36]
baffling.
[04:37]
>> Your eyes are beautiful, you proud
[04:40]
>> [music]
[04:40]
>> Luthor
[04:43]
>> The film's two other headliners fall
[04:45]
into these buckets as well. Matthias
[04:46]
Schoenaerts as the film's villain, Crim
[04:48]
of the Yellow Hills, looks incredible.
[04:51]
His whole appearance would make the
[04:52]
creature design team from A New Hope
[04:53]
proud. The beads studded into his face,
[04:56]
the machinery grafted into his body, the
[04:59]
weird little red button he needs to
[05:00]
activate to speak, all of it adds up to
[05:02]
a striking and genuinely pretty cool
[05:05]
image that would have felt at home in
[05:06]
the Thunderdome. But, they don't ever do
[05:09]
anything with it. Crim, for all the
[05:11]
post-apocalyptic biker gang aura he
[05:13]
generates, gets nothing else to go on.
[05:15]
He has some affectations that
[05:17]
Schoenaerts is clearly having a good
[05:18]
time with, like how he's eating
[05:20]
something in almost every scene, but
[05:22]
that's really all they are,
[05:23]
affectations. There's nothing that makes
[05:25]
him scary or formidable other than a few
[05:27]
throwaway lines about his relative
[05:29]
strength and the way other people on
[05:31]
screen are afraid of him. Meanwhile,
[05:32]
Jason Momoa's Lobo finds his way into
[05:34]
the movie as well. And the mostly
[05:36]
impervious anti-hero bounty hunter is
[05:38]
just as much fun as fans have been
[05:40]
anticipating. Now, cigar chomping gets
[05:43]
thrown around a little excessively
[05:45]
anytime a J. Jonah Jameson or a Hellboy
[05:48]
or a Will Smith and Jeff Goldblum from
[05:50]
Independence Day show up on screen, but
[05:52]
Momoa more than earns that descriptor in
[05:54]
all the best possible ways in Supergirl.
[05:57]
He looks the part as well with face
[05:58]
paint and prosthetics [music] that cut
[06:00]
the kind of imposing figure the fan
[06:01]
favorite deserves. But, Lobo doesn't
[06:04]
need to be there. [music] Characters
[06:06]
come and go in movies. Sometimes with
[06:07]
very little fanfare, sometimes playing
[06:09]
crucial roles in the story, and they
[06:11]
don't always have to be the latter. The
[06:13]
issue with Lobo is that he feels like
[06:16]
extra tacked on. [music] The one major
[06:18]
scene he has with Kara has real reshoot
[06:21]
energy. It's added on to a scene that
[06:23]
didn't need any extra motivation to get
[06:25]
to the next scene. Nor is he a
[06:27]
particularly unique foil for Kara that
[06:29]
propels her character in any meaningful
[06:31]
way. He just happens to be looking for
[06:33]
the same group of guys that Kara and
[06:34]
Ruthie are after. [music] The only real
[06:36]
added value he gives the movie is a few
[06:38]
admittedly fun one-liners, and [music]
[06:41]
maybe that's all Lobo needs to be.
[06:43]
Ultimately, he only shows up to put his
[06:45]
immortal stamp of approval on Kara's
[06:47]
actions, but that feels both unnecessary
[06:49]
and frankly more than a little
[06:51]
pandering, and it leaves me not entirely
[06:53]
sure what to do with it.
[06:55]
>> Stop.
[06:57]
You're hurting my head.
[07:01]
>> So, the story of this movie continues to
[07:03]
be they did it right on one hand, but on
[07:06]
the other hand, not so much. And as just
[07:08]
the second entry into Gunn's DCU, that
[07:10]
issue spills over into all the stuff
[07:13]
that comes with being part of a
[07:15]
currently expanding expanded universe.
[07:17]
On one hand, Supergirl needs to continue
[07:19]
building outwards to some extent,
[07:21]
[music] and this is another of the
[07:22]
film's strengths. Her scenes with David
[07:24]
Corenswet's Superman are wonderful.
[07:26]
That's not to say that Superman saved
[07:28]
the day here, or that Supergirl needs
[07:30]
Superman to be interesting. It's the
[07:31]
dynamic between the two of them that is
[07:33]
great. One positively [music] looking
[07:36]
towards the future, while the other
[07:37]
still nurses old wounds. I'm definitely
[07:40]
looking forward to more of this duo on
[07:42]
screen. But, on the other [music] hand,
[07:44]
where her solo film is concerned,
[07:45]
Supergirl needs to flesh out Kara's
[07:47]
backstory. And the structure of how and
[07:50]
when flashbacks are deployed in
[07:51]
Supergirl aside, because my personal
[07:53]
preference would have been a [music]
[07:54]
straight chronological telling of this
[07:56]
story as opposed to stopping in the
[07:58]
middle to tell [music] us her backstory,
[08:00]
I did find myself way more interested in
[08:02]
her time growing up on a floating
[08:04]
lifeboat of a city after the destruction
[08:06]
of Krypton. Now, there's work being done
[08:08]
there on both fronts as the film [music]
[08:10]
continues to build on the changes made
[08:12]
to Kal-El's origin story from Superman,
[08:14]
while also introducing another side to
[08:16]
that story via Kara. The present day of
[08:19]
the film, with all the cribbing from
[08:21]
True Grit and Mad Max and Guardians,
[08:23]
feels far [music] less fresh and
[08:24]
interesting than Kara's shielded
[08:26]
childhood on Argo. Again though, this is
[08:29]
Supergirl's biggest challenge. There are
[08:31]
a lot of things [music] that work
[08:32]
throughout this movie,
[08:33]
but there are just as many reasons why
[08:34]
they don't quite add up.
[08:37]
>> He sees the good in everyone.
[08:39]
And I see the truth.
[08:42]
>> And so, I'm giving Supergirl a six. Kara
[08:45]
Zor-El's standout moment in Superman
[08:47]
gets a feature-length follow-up that
[08:48]
almost gets everything right.
[08:50]
Unfortunately, that means it gets
[08:52]
everything almost wrong as well. Milly
[08:54]
Alcock is great as Supergirl, carrying
[08:57]
the weight of real trauma and cementing
[08:59]
a very cool dynamic with her on-screen
[09:00]
cousin. While the alien design and
[09:02]
practical makeup effects make the film a
[09:04]
joy to look at. Jason Momoa's Lobo and
[09:07]
Matthias Shonarts Krim [music] are just
[09:09]
as cool visually, but unfortunately,
[09:11]
they also don't have a lot to offer in
[09:13]
this entry in the burgeoning DCU that
[09:15]
treads more water than I would have
[09:17]
liked.
[09:18]
>> Now, let's party.
[09:19]
>> Oh, that might be a problem.
[09:22]
>> That is what I think of Supergirl. Let
[09:24]
me know what you think in the comments
[09:25]
below. And for more movie reviews,
[09:27]
you're already in the right place. Be
[09:28]
sure to subscribe to IGN wherever you
[09:30]
like to watch.