[00:00]
The best anime of winter 2026 was one
[00:03]
that had no fight scenes, no magic
[00:06]
systems, no dramatic powerups. It was 13
[00:11]
episodes of two people living in a messy
[00:14]
apartment talking to each other. And in
[00:17]
my eyes, it beat out all other original
[00:20]
anime from that season comfortably.
[00:24]
Sure, it didn't touch the sequels like
[00:26]
Jiu-Jitsu Kaizen or Frierin and so on,
[00:29]
but the fact that we're even having it
[00:30]
in the same conversation, making that
[00:32]
comparison, it says something. This is
[00:36]
Journal with Witch. It's a series that
[00:40]
you should not judge based on its title
[00:43]
because if you went in completely blind
[00:45]
to this series, like many people did to
[00:48]
be fair, you'd probably expect something
[00:50]
completely different. Is there a
[00:51]
journal? Yes, several. Is there a witch?
[00:55]
No, actually no witch at all. You're
[00:57]
going to need to go to a different
[00:58]
italier for that. The Japanese title for
[01:00]
this series is Ioku Nikki, which better
[01:03]
translates to Diary of a Strange Land. A
[01:07]
title which still does not accurately
[01:09]
describe the show, but it's at least a
[01:11]
lot more metaphorically similar. It just
[01:14]
doesn't prepare you for what this show
[01:16]
actually is. Perhaps I'm just too
[01:18]
isachide pill where the light novel
[01:19]
titles are very exact to what the
[01:21]
synopsis is. So, welcome back ladies,
[01:24]
gentlemen, and others. My name is
[01:25]
Tristan, and this is Glass Reflection,
[01:28]
where today we are talking about Journal
[01:31]
with Witch. Let's jam.
[01:34]
Makio is a 35-year-old novelist who has
[01:38]
arranged her entire existence around not
[01:41]
having to deal with other people [music]
[01:43]
if she can avoid it. Not in a hikamorei
[01:46]
type way, more of a people are a pain
[01:49]
and I don't want to deal with them type
[01:50]
way, which is fair. Her apartment is a
[01:53]
mess. She forgets to eat. She has so
[01:56]
many introverted traits built up that
[01:58]
she broke up with her boyfriend because
[02:00]
his emotional stability exhausted her.
[02:03]
He seemed to have his whole life figured
[02:04]
out. And you know that was a problem.
[02:07]
Makio is a lot, but she knows that she's
[02:10]
a lot and she's fine with being a lot.
[02:13]
And then her sister and brother-in-law
[02:16]
die in a car accident, leaving behind
[02:18]
their young daughter, Assa. Assa is a
[02:21]
girl that Makio doesn't know. She's the
[02:24]
daughter of a woman who Mchio was not on
[02:27]
the best of terms with. And since no one
[02:29]
else in the family seemed to want to
[02:31]
deal with this girl, Mchio takes it upon
[02:33]
herself to bring Assa home. With zero
[02:36]
preparations and no instruction manual
[02:39]
on how to be the guardian to a teenager.
[02:42]
That's the setup here. It is a series
[02:44]
about two people from modern Tokyo who
[02:46]
are trying to figure out how to exist in
[02:49]
the same place, preferably without
[02:51]
breaking one another. It's not as if
[02:53]
they fight a lot. Quite the opposite,
[02:56]
though things might have gone a lot
[02:57]
faster if they did. Assa is a good kid,
[03:00]
a very good kid. One who doesn't know
[03:02]
how to process that her parents are
[03:05]
gone, nor how exactly she can deal now
[03:08]
with living with her aunt, an aunt who
[03:11]
speaks somewhat negatively about her
[03:13]
mom, the same mom she remembers loving
[03:16]
so much. And if overall the show sounds
[03:19]
quiet and chill, that's because for the
[03:21]
most part it is. By design, this is a
[03:24]
series that is almost,
[03:27]
I want to say, aggressively quiet at
[03:30]
times. It's a series where the most
[03:32]
dramatic thing that happens in an
[03:33]
average episode is Mchio staring at a
[03:36]
blank document and a deadline looms
[03:37]
overhead. It's 2:00 a.m. in the morning
[03:39]
and she's living in a kind of despair
[03:41]
that is common for someone in her
[03:44]
writing profession while her teenage
[03:46]
niece sleeps on a cot in the corner of
[03:48]
her office. It would not surprise me if
[03:51]
a lot of people out there would use the
[03:53]
word boring to describe this series. I
[03:56]
mean, I would use it as well, except I
[03:58]
would use it as a compliment because
[04:00]
Journal with which is in some ways
[04:03]
boring, but it is doing it in a way that
[04:05]
feels natural. It's trying to show us
[04:08]
that an ordinary life is one worth
[04:11]
taking seriously. Boredom and all. And
[04:14]
also, as tragic [music] as it is, losing
[04:17]
a sibling or a mother, those life
[04:20]
experiences are more common than we
[04:23]
think. And how people deal with that in
[04:25]
different ways is not something that I
[04:27]
see explored often. A lot of the
[04:29]
episodes here are splitting our
[04:30]
attention between Makio's adult
[04:33]
storyline and Assa's more teenaged one.
[04:35]
With Makio, we get her new
[04:37]
responsibilities. Uh, we have the ghost
[04:39]
of her sister putting her down. We have
[04:41]
the book that she's working on. For
[04:43]
Assa, we have this girl attempting to go
[04:46]
through her normal teenage life, but she
[04:49]
still tries to present herself in a way
[04:51]
that no one would know. She just lost
[04:53]
her parents. She can hide it, and she
[04:56]
does, though sometimes not as well as
[04:58]
she thinks. [music] Mchio isn't a messy
[05:01]
person in like a cute or quirky way.
[05:03]
She's messy in a way where like things
[05:05]
ended up in her apartment where they are
[05:07]
because everything was just placed
[05:09]
off-handedly. She would have dirty
[05:11]
clothing spread out everywhere because
[05:12]
it just needed to be moved out of the
[05:14]
way at some point and not because she
[05:16]
has some system for how she handles
[05:18]
laundry. Laundry is something for future
[05:20]
Mchio to deal with. She's socially
[05:23]
awkward. She doesn't like talking to
[05:24]
people. She finds it exhausting. And any
[05:27]
competency that she has in that regard
[05:29]
is more of a like a survival mechanism
[05:31]
that she's developed rather than a
[05:33]
natural personality trait. And yet, when
[05:36]
AA needs someone to explain something
[05:39]
about what she's going through, Mchio
[05:41]
can do it. She is a novelist. So,
[05:43]
despite how she personally acts, she
[05:47]
does understand people quite well. She
[05:49]
just can't always apply what she knows
[05:52]
in her own life. But what really makes
[05:55]
her work as a person, a real person,
[05:57]
[music] and not just a character, is she
[05:59]
has this level of fear underneath it
[06:04]
all. Like Mchio is very upfront with
[06:06]
both Assa and the audience that she is
[06:09]
someone who really shouldn't be taking
[06:11]
in a teenager. She's not really capable
[06:14]
of loving her the way that Assa needs.
[06:17]
Makio is not a cruel person, but she can
[06:20]
only offer what is like acceptable in
[06:23]
the role as a guardian, not as a mom.
[06:26]
She can't be Assa's new mom. That is not
[06:30]
and cannot be her role. So, with all of
[06:33]
that, Makio is just terrified about
[06:36]
[music] projecting all of the feelings
[06:38]
she has about Assa's mom back onto this
[06:41]
kid. This kid who is oblivious [music]
[06:44]
and has nothing to do with any of that.
[06:47]
Makio is fairly set in her ways, but
[06:50]
she's still trying to get a handle for
[06:51]
how best to care for Assa in her own
[06:54]
way. And Assa just keeps [music]
[06:57]
wanting direction. She wants help from
[07:00]
people, but everything that she gets is
[07:03]
vague. Either because people don't know
[07:05]
how to help her or they don't want to
[07:07]
say the wrong thing. Perhaps she gets
[07:09]
this from like her therapist who just
[07:11]
asks her to talk about whatever she
[07:14]
wants or like when Makio texts her
[07:16]
saying, "Oh, well, she's drained, so can
[07:18]
you just pick up whatever you want from
[07:20]
the grocery store." Whatever you want is
[07:23]
what she keeps being told. But Assa
[07:25]
doesn't know what she wants. [music] She
[07:27]
has her journal full of scribbles and
[07:29]
notes of things that people have told
[07:31]
her, things that have stuck into her
[07:33]
mind, but she desperately [music] wants
[07:35]
to write something here. She wants to
[07:38]
make lyrics for a song and then sing it
[07:40]
to people. She keeps feeling like she
[07:43]
has nothing to say. Throughout her grief
[07:45]
process, Asa constantly imagines herself
[07:48]
walking through a desert alone. [music]
[07:50]
It is vast. It is empty. and it works
[07:53]
really hard to showcase just how lonely
[07:55]
Assa has become, even if she doesn't
[07:57]
realize it at first or can't vocalize it
[08:00]
later. So, between the pair of them,
[08:02]
like Makio could have had like some kind
[08:04]
of development on becoming a proper
[08:06]
mother figure to this young girl with
[08:08]
Assa being the child she never had. And
[08:11]
like AA could have some big inspiration
[08:14]
moment about how she now wants to handle
[08:16]
her life, but none of that really
[08:18]
happens. These two don't have some kind
[08:21]
of like big reconciliation to get them
[08:23]
closer as a family. At no point do they
[08:26]
tell each other, "I love you." Even if
[08:28]
their actions might say otherwise,
[08:30]
though, to be honest, I think I find it
[08:31]
hard for Makio to for me to imagine
[08:34]
Makio saying that to anyone under any
[08:36]
context. There's a layer of warmth to
[08:41]
the series, but also an occasional bit
[08:43]
of friction. Like the show is helping us
[08:46]
to have a sense this relationship, the
[08:48]
relationship between these two
[08:49]
characters is the most interesting thing
[08:52]
here. And it really is because if you
[08:53]
had a child teenager who hears their new
[08:56]
guardian speak with apathy toward their
[09:00]
parents' death, that would be a kind of
[09:03]
freakout moment and deservedly so. But
[09:05]
Assa doesn't do that. Instead, we get
[09:07]
the emotional writing that proves the
[09:10]
show is earning its reputation. Assa
[09:13]
doesn't respond to her parents' death
[09:15]
with sadness. She actually responds with
[09:18]
anger, but it's not anger in the
[09:20]
traditional way. She doesn't scream or
[09:24]
yell or get upset. But the anger is
[09:27]
still there. It's just buried, muted,
[09:30]
and hidden for the vast majority of the
[09:32]
series until it's not. It is without a
[09:34]
doubt one of the more honest depictions
[09:37]
of both adolescent and adult depression
[09:39]
in grief that I've seen in anime. like
[09:42]
period. It's not a stereotypical
[09:44]
depiction because well, how someone
[09:46]
deals with this situation can't really
[09:48]
be stereotypical. We all handle these
[09:51]
things in a different way. And I really
[09:53]
do appreciate how this series has taken
[09:55]
a a different path from the norm. But
[09:57]
then again, I feel like the norm is to
[09:59]
just not talk about it at all. So
[10:01]
instantly, this is better. From a story
[10:03]
perspective, there's only one real
[10:04]
caveat that I need to add here because I
[10:06]
think it would be wrong of me to not
[10:08]
mention it. This anime is an adaptation
[10:11]
of, if my counting is right, 32 of the
[10:14]
manga's 54 chapters, so only like 2/3 of
[10:18]
it. If you watch this without having
[10:20]
read the manga beforehand, it does land
[10:23]
exceptionally well. But as with most
[10:25]
incomplete adaptations, there is always
[10:28]
missing threads, a subplot about Assa's
[10:31]
dad that is more or less completely
[10:33]
gone. We don't get much of their
[10:34]
relationship at all. The show has an
[10:37]
ending that well, it lands, but manga
[10:40]
readers will argue that it didn't do it
[10:42]
as well as they'd hoped. But to me, the
[10:45]
story that made it here to our screens
[10:47]
is about as honest and human as anime
[10:50]
got this year so far. And so, at the end
[10:52]
of the day, is it worth it? Short
[10:55]
answer, yes. The longer answer is also
[10:58]
yes, though with some caveats attached.
[11:01]
The caveats will end up being, you know,
[11:02]
what determines if this show is a new
[11:04]
favorite of yours or just something that
[11:06]
you're going to bounce off of within
[11:07]
three episodes. I am quite surprised
[11:08]
though at the amount of high praise that
[11:10]
the show has gotten since it started. I
[11:12]
mean, this is the kind of show where I
[11:14]
expected a level of cult following. But
[11:17]
at the time of writing the script for
[11:19]
this video, the series had a score of
[11:21]
8.75 out of 10 on my anime list, and
[11:24]
that put it at number 49 on their chart
[11:27]
for the best anime of all time. This was
[11:29]
also like over a month and a half after
[11:31]
the season ended. Like, if it's still
[11:33]
airing and people are still talking
[11:35]
about it, that's one thing. But I would
[11:36]
have expected it to be kicked off the
[11:38]
top list by now. But for a quiet little
[11:40]
13 episode drama series about a novelist
[11:42]
and her niece in a season that was as
[11:45]
stacked as winter 2026 was, I always
[11:49]
shocked and surprised. Journal with
[11:51]
Witch did not have like a guaranteed
[11:54]
built-in audience like the sequels did.
[11:56]
It was a new adaptation of a manga that
[11:59]
itself didn't see much chatter within
[12:01]
the wider discourse of the fandom. And I
[12:03]
mean, on paper, the synopsis might not
[12:06]
be considered all that special to a
[12:07]
majority of people. And despite all of
[12:10]
that, I mean, it won the season for me
[12:12]
anyway. Sure, the sequels and the larger
[12:15]
franchises will win the war of discourse
[12:18]
in the long term. Yeah, okay, fine. But
[12:20]
if I'm just talking about shows that
[12:22]
started in that season, Journal with
[12:24]
Witch was at the top for me. It's on my
[12:26]
short list for anime of the year
[12:28]
already, though, you know, the
[12:30]
competition is getting pretty stiff as
[12:32]
the year progresses, but you know, I
[12:34]
don't feel like I'm alone with this
[12:36]
opinion. I normally am, but this time
[12:38]
I've got backup, and that just feels
[12:40]
great to be honest. When it comes to
[12:42]
like caveats, the slower pace and the
[12:45]
introspectionheavy nature of the series
[12:47]
is going to make people drop off. That's
[12:49]
fine. That might end up being something
[12:51]
that stops it from like truly reaching
[12:54]
[music] uh more mainstream success
[12:56]
because this is a series that asks for
[12:59]
your patience and it wants you to meet
[13:01]
it where it is rather than it rushing up
[13:05]
to meet you. The show's not going to
[13:06]
drop you with a cliffhanger to try and
[13:08]
bring you back next episode or beg for
[13:11]
your attention. But if you can handle
[13:13]
that, if you can appreciate the warmth
[13:15]
that it offers, you know, within the
[13:18]
depths of loneliness that the show
[13:20]
explores, you're going to find it all
[13:22]
the more rewarding. If you have seen
[13:24]
comments from people who have bounced
[13:25]
off the show complaining or lamenting
[13:27]
that it was too slow or too quiet, they
[13:29]
are just looking for something else. And
[13:31]
that's fine. There's plenty out there
[13:34]
for them. Even my my biggest personal
[13:37]
criticism against the series is
[13:38]
something that I don't really think is
[13:40]
fixable. so I can forgive it. And as I
[13:43]
mentioned earlier, this doesn't cover
[13:45]
everything from the manga. There are
[13:46]
plot threads that got cut, subplots
[13:48]
dropped, and the ending is a bit
[13:50]
different from the original material
[13:52]
because things are missing. But with how
[13:55]
long anime seasons are, I'm not sure how
[13:59]
best we could have fixed that without
[14:01]
then introducing new problems. A second
[14:04]
core of the series would have made
[14:06]
things drag even with the extra
[14:08]
material. There's not enough or full 24.
[14:10]
and then doing these episodes but then
[14:12]
having an OVA to cover everything else
[14:14]
afterwards would have still left this
[14:17]
without an ending. One that would
[14:19]
probably have been worse than the one we
[14:20]
got. So really I just feel like it's a
[14:22]
limitation on what the series can do
[14:24]
with only 13 episodes. So here's my
[14:27]
bottom line with it. Journal with Witch
[14:30]
is the kind of show that that reminds me
[14:32]
why I started watching anime in the
[14:33]
first place and why I've been talking
[14:35]
about it since 2009. And it's not just
[14:37]
because of like how much I relate to
[14:39]
Makio as a character, though that is
[14:41]
certainly part of it. This is the kind
[14:43]
of show that I won't say treats you like
[14:46]
an adult, but it definitely is one that
[14:48]
respects your time. You don't have to
[14:50]
interact with it, but if you do, you get
[14:53]
rewarded for it. This is a show that
[14:54]
believes that 13 episodes showcasing the
[14:57]
small moments of two people trying to
[14:59]
navigate grief is worth it. It is not a
[15:02]
perfect adaptation, but I don't think it
[15:05]
needs to be. And what we got is more
[15:07]
than enough. So the real bottom line, if
[15:10]
you haven't watched it yet, you probably
[15:13]
should.
[15:14]
And that's it for our show today. Thank
[15:16]
you for watching if you haven't seen
[15:18]
Journal with Witch. It's available for
[15:19]
streaming over on Crunchyroll. And I
[15:21]
urge you to do that at your earliest
[15:23]
convenience if you haven't already. I
[15:25]
also wanted to give shoutouts to
[15:26]
supporters [music] of this channel over
[15:28]
on Patreon. This video is not sponsored,
[15:30]
and the more support that we get over
[15:32]
there, the less sponsors that Glass of
[15:33]
Flection will need at any given time.
[15:35]
[music] So, an immense thank you
[15:36]
especially to patrons like Siri Yamako,
[15:39]
Ryen Bonapart, Omar Showman, Ross
[15:41]
[music] Emerson, Hector Montto, Mayor
[15:44]
Geekwig, and Aiden. We can't continue
[15:47]
this without your support. So, however
[15:48]
much you are able to help, I am
[15:50]
eternally grateful. So, subscribe if you
[15:52]
haven't, hit the like button if you
[15:53]
enjoyed the video, and until next time,
[15:55]
whenever that happens to be, watch more
[15:58]
anime and stay frosty.