Whoop vs Fitbit: The Price Trap
42sThe shocking subscription model of Whoop vs Fitbit's free alternative sparks debate and curiosity among fitness enthusiasts.
▶ Play ClipAI Summary
The video compares the Fitbit Air and Whoop fitness trackers, focusing on whether the cheaper Fitbit Air can match Whoop's performance for athletes. The reviewer wore both devices alongside an Apple Watch for two weeks to provide an answer.
Chapters
[00:00]
Whoop's Dominance and Subscription Model
Whoop is popular among athletes but requires a $200-$350/year subscription; without it, the tracker becomes a brick.
[00:28]
Fitbit Air's Appeal
Fitbit Air costs $99 with no mandatory subscription, and its premium subscription is $100/year, making it cheaper than Whoop.
[01:07]
Reviewer's Testing Method
The reviewer wore both trackers alongside an Apple Watch for two weeks during practices, games, workouts, and sleep.
[01:34]
Fitbit Air vs Whoop Pricing
Fitbit Air is functional without subscription, while Whoop requires a subscription to work. Fitbit Air wins on price.
[02:11]
Google's Involvement
Fitbit is owned by Google, a data and ads company, which may influence their strategy of subsidizing the tracker.
The Fitbit Air is cheaper and offers good basic tracking, but the reviewer hints that the answer may not be straightforward, suggesting further analysis is needed.
Clickbait Check
85% Legit"Title promises a comparison and delivers a detailed analysis, though the final verdict is implied rather than explicit."
Study Flashcards (5)
What is the annual subscription cost for Whoop?
easy
Click to reveal answer
What is the annual subscription cost for Whoop?
easy
Click to reveal answer
Starts at $200/year and goes up to $350/year.
00:28
What happens to a Whoop tracker if you stop paying the subscription?
easy
Click to reveal answer
What happens to a Whoop tracker if you stop paying the subscription?
easy
Click to reveal answer
It becomes a brick and is useless.
00:42
How much does the Fitbit Air cost without a subscription?
easy
Click to reveal answer
How much does the Fitbit Air cost without a subscription?
easy
Click to reveal answer
$99.
01:47
What is the cost of Fitbit's premium subscription?
easy
Click to reveal answer
What is the cost of Fitbit's premium subscription?
easy
Click to reveal answer
$100/year.
01:59
Which company owns Fitbit?
easy
Click to reveal answer
Which company owns Fitbit?
easy
Click to reveal answer
Google.
02:11
💡 Key Takeaways
⭐
Whoop Becomes a Brick
The stark warning that stopping subscription renders the tracker useless is a shocking revelation for potential buyers.
00:42
⭐
Hated Wearing Multiple Trackers
The reviewer's humorous admission of wearing three trackers simultaneously adds a relatable, human touch.
01:22
💡
Google's Data Motive
Pointing out Google's data and ads business model adds a layer of skepticism about Fitbit's true intentions.
02:11Full Transcript
[00:00] All right, so Whoop is dominant as a fitness tracker in the world of professional and enthusiast athletes all around the world. I have a lot of friends. I play Ultimate Frisbee, friends and
[00:12] teammates who all wear Whoops. It's this screenless, lightweight puck in a thin band with all these sensors on one side that you just wear 24-7. So when the Fitbit Air came along, a lot of those same people immediately were interested and started asking me about it. Hey, is it good?
[00:28] Should I switch? Are they comparable? And the main reason for that is the Whoop subscription. You see, you don't just buy the Whoop tracker. You buy the tracker and then pay a membership subscription that starts at $200 a year
[00:42] and goes up to $350 a year forever. If you ever do stop paying, the Whoop literally doesn't do anything anymore. It becomes a brick. It's useless. The Fitbit, on the other hand, doesn't even require a subscription at all. And the subscription they do offer for extra features
[00:55] is much cheaper than the Whoop. It's $100 a year. So almost everyone asking me about this basically just wants to know, is it as good as a Whoop, but cheaper? Because if so, then I might as well switch.
[01:07] So to any of my teammates out there watching this or any other athletes who are considering switching, I have spent the last almost two weeks wearing both of these things alongside an Apple Watch for a ton of stuff, practices, games, workouts,
[01:22] recoveries, sleeping, and more. I hated being that guy wearing multiple trackers at the same time, but hey, someone's gotta do it. And now I have your answer. You might not like it, but I have your answer.
[01:34] So to me, it's pretty clear Fitbit Air is designed to take direct aim at Whoop, not just with the matching form factor, which I'll get to in a second, but with their pricing model. So like I said, the Whoop is free, but it's literally useless without the subscription.
[01:47] I honestly hope that changes after this, but as of right now, 200 bucks a year baseline every year to get in the door. The $99 Fitbit Air is functional with no subscription at all. And it will do a good amount of basic tracking,
[01:59] heart rate, step tracking, calories burned, sleep tracking, and more. But if you want the full suite of everything, including the AI Fitness Coach and a big workout library, that's $100 a year. And there's all kinds of promos right now
[02:11] as it launches for like three free months of Google Health premium. So I would say it definitely wins the price battle. But also keep in mind, this is still Google we're talking about here, the data and ads company.
[02:23] So of course they would wanna sell you a subsidized fitness tracker and leverage the Fitbit name to get it in as many hands