AI Summary
This video offers a critical analysis of the recent departure of James Gunn and Peter Saffron from DC Studios, focusing on the arrival of their successor, Jeremy Latcham. The speaker examines Latcham's past comments about his filmmaking philosophy and expresses concerns about the future direction of DC, particularly the risk of abandoning the mature tone that has recently proven successful. The video ultimately speculates that the DCU may lose its creative edge under the new leadership.
Chapters
James Gunn and Peter Saffron have unexpectedly left their positions as co-heads of DC Studios, leaving the future of the DCU uncertain.
Some fans hope for the return of Zack Snyder, but the speaker dismisses this as unrealistic and likely unsuccessful.
Jeremy Latcham, a Marvel veteran, is named as the new head of DC Studios, prompting questions about his vision.
The speaker praises the mature, dark tone of recent DC shows like Peacemaker and Lanterns, and the movie Clayface, suggesting this has been a successful formula.
Latcham's 'guiding light' at Marvel was asking 'Would my grandma like this?' to ensure mass appeal, which the speaker believes leads to bland, corporate filmmaking.
The speaker uses the Halo TV series as an example of a project that failed because it tried to appeal to everyone, resulting in a generic product.
The speaker argues that the constant rebooting and leadership changes at DC undermine fan investment, as each new direction clashes with the previous one.
The speaker draws a parallel to the Star Wars sequel trilogy, where conflicting director visions led to a disjointed narrative, predicting a similar fate for the DCU.
Mentioned in this Video
💡 Key Takeaways
The Danger of the 'Grandma Test'
Offers a critical perspective on corporate filmmaking, highlighting the risk of diluting creative vision in pursuit of mass appeal.
05:07Latcham's Guiding Light
Reveals a specific decision-making framework used by a top Hollywood executive, providing insight into industry practices.
04:40Leadership Change at DC
Reports a major real-world industry event that could significantly impact future DC projects.
01:57Formulaic Filmmaking Failure
Articulates a common fan complaint about modern franchise films, tying it directly to the new leader's philosophy.
06:27The Value of a Consistent Tone
Identifies a key success factor for DC's recent shows and argues that abandoning it could be a mistake.
08:31Full Transcript
[00:03] have in common? Shit's getting changed, man. Frequently, in fact, it was not even a Well, actually, it has been a full 24 hours since the news of James Gunn and Peter Saffron's departure from DC Studios. The former heads of it for
[00:17] the last four years made a surprise exit out of nowhere in the midst of the been setting for the new DCU. And now all of a sudden it just gets [ __ ] cold dropped out of the battle bus that they're gone. But we were led to believe
[00:33] that their work would still continue like James Gun still finishing up on the newest Superman film and all of that. But it's a lot of turmoil. It's very volatile because again James Gunn and Peter Saffron were were coming in to try
[00:47] and salvage the DC brand because their movies had been doing so poorly. You know, previously we had the Zack Snider era. And speaking of diapers, the Snyder taking victory laps and thinking for some reason they're gonna dust off
[01:01] Snider, which honestly I would be pumping my fist for because I think that know that [ __ ] would go over like the MorbiiUs re-release where they had like that it'd be successful if they released it a second time. If they gave him
[01:15] DCU, it would be the same [ __ ] garbage that got them into this predicament in the first place. And that [ __ ] would actually be belly laugh [ __ ] would actually be belly laugh giggleworthy Santa Claus ho ho ho laughs
[01:28] be the case. I think it's delusional to think that they're actually going to go brother's got Rebel Moon to work on, man. Everyone loves Rebel Moon. We need number three, Zach. Please, please deliver two hours of more non-stop slow
[01:43] motion. But yeah, so now with James Gunn and Peter Saffron out, they have someone named Jeremy Latcham who has come in to take that role and he is a previous announcement, people are looking more into him to learn is the DCU in good
[01:57] hands? Like should we be optimistic? Should we be doom and gloom? Like what's what's kind of the vibe here of wombo jumbo Jeremy here? Like what do we what are we in store for? And there was an interview that people found where he was
[02:11] talking about his guiding light for early Marvel projects. And before I get One, speaking of guiding lights, I'm going to be your guiding light here for the best PCs in the universe, Star Forge. We're doing an early Black Friday
[02:24] sale that will be lasting for 2 weeks. Huge, huge sale right now. So go to Star description to upgrade your PC. We got the best PCs in the universe. And the other thing I want to mention is that in yesterday's video, I speculated that the
[02:37] direction of DC projects would be drastically changing. In particular, the shows, all of the DC shows that have been produced under uh James Gunn and Peter Saffron have been mature. They've been dark. They've been bloody. They've
[02:50] said [ __ ] Uh like they have been on the grittier side of things. And they've been extraordinarily successful in terms of popularity. In particular, The came out that year and is an extraordinarily successful show that I
[03:04] thought was fantastic. Peacemaker season 2, not as good as the first season, but again, solid and it was successful. The Lanterns, it was all right. It was okay, but again, very, very successful. All of these shows are mature. Like the these
[03:19] are not, you know, Weenie Hut Jr. Now, the movies are a little different. Superman is kind of like all ages, and that was pretty good. I actually liked it quite a bit. Supergirl is borderline unwatchable with the worst needle drops
[03:32] want to rupture your eardrums with a [ __ ] pencil. And Clayface I thought was their strongest movie which again is a mature R-rated film. Now that I what
[03:44] a mature R-rated film. Now that I what Clayface showed me is that DC does have sauce. Like it still did have piss in the balls. like there was juice for the squeeze and they showed some creativity with Clayface which got me pretty hyped
[03:56] for future DC movies and the tone of the shows is very similar mature dark and something I thought had such incredible potential to keep exploring in the future cuz it was so so so strong but now after hearing a little bit of Jeremy
[04:12] Latcham with his guiding light and how he approaches these comic book movies I seeing this kind of direction explored again which I think is really upsetting. Maybe not so much in the context of the movies because there's only been one
[04:27] there, but the shows in particular, I'm just pretty confident we won't see this tone for DC anymore under Jeremy Latcham's leadership. That's just a he said in the interview, and I'll give you my feelings on why I think that way.
[04:40] Instead of showing you the interview, I'll just go ahead and give you like the most important bits here. So he said, "When we were making the first Marvel know if my grandma would like that." That became a guiding light. It became
[04:53] the standin for, "Is this going to work for regular people outside the bubble of Hollywood?" He said this on a Christian broadcasting news segment here when approaching these comic book movies. And on the surface, that kind of philosophy
[05:07] can make you go, "Aw, how sweet." until you realize that that exact same thought process is the most Hollywood ghoul vampire [ __ ] ever where it's just corporate and shitification of everything where you try and make a mass
[05:19] market appeal to try and capture the general audience like the modern general audience chasing this nebulous idea of that and you end up making something for no one. It's how you get things like, and I hate to always mention this, the
[05:32] Halo TV series. Like, that's how you end up with that [ __ ] where instead of about, making something that you actually want to make, you start to bastardize the vision by thinking, would my grandma like it? Is the regular
[05:46] average Joemo normie going to love this? Like, is every single human being on the planet going to be, you know, okay with this, or is he going to ruffle some make sure that this is the most sterile [ __ ] ever. And that's why that's how you
[05:59] end up with the most boring, bland, generic films. Now, I will say for the time, like when he was making these movies, I think that thought process is totally understandable, actually, because comic book movies weren't in the
[06:12] same spot they were now, where we've been fed the exact same reheated meal thousands of times. It's not yummy anymore. It's bland. It's tired. It lacks seasoning. It lacks character. It lacks passion. It's just formulaic
[06:27] garbage. now. And it's that thought process right there that got us to that point, afraid to take risks, uh, just really apprehensive about doing anything new or creative, and it sucks. Something else that he mentioned this time in an
[06:42] interview with Games Radar is in the old Marvel days, there's this great story about my Mima and Peepaw because they became like a joke in the editing room that we were making the movie for my grandparents in Oklahoma. If they
[06:54] never going to work for anybody. I think that's kind of the fun of these movies of adapting material, finding a way to make it for everybody. You have to be true to the fans, but you have to make it ultimately for everybody. How many
[07:07] [ __ ] times have we heard that exact same regurgitated statement about, "Well, we couldn't just be true to the source material or do something that's like respectful to the fan base. We needed to ensure it was for
[07:20] everybody." Like that's a that's a [ __ ] disaster. That sounds the alarm bells. Wee woo wee woo wee woo. Sirens blaring. That's not what anyone wants to hear from the guy who's now in at the head of DC Studios. And this is why I
[07:34] think the direction is going to change for DC in general where the shows have all been so far all the shows really have been much darker mature and I think that tone has worked really well and they showed that it works well in movies
[07:49] too with Clayface. It was a lower-budget movie that is received positively and doing pretty solid in the box office, but it was never going to be a [ __ ] crazy windmill slam dunk financial success that I think they maybe thought
[08:05] it could be. That was just always unrealistic. I think it's doing very well all things considered and it's a good movie most importantly. So like that tone in that direction has been so far their bread and butter. That has
[08:17] I have my gripes with Lanterns. I don't think it's an amazing show or anything. of those problems is not the tone, the mature nature of it. That's not one of its issues. Like I think that has been working for them. Where it hasn't worked
[08:32] is when they've tried to be more like jovial, tongue-in-cheek, like you know, quirky, goofy, and zany like with Supergirl. And that look at what happened there. A box office catastrophe in Superman. that tone worked because I
[08:46] I think a lot of it was carried by Kornswe being just a really talented Superman and a really good fit for that role. So like it did work there where it role. So like it did work there where it was mainly more like optimistic, hopeful
[08:58] and lighter. It worked there, but it didn't work in Supergirl. And we have the shows and Clayface to pull from that show. Like that tone is working more for DC. But I think they are going to abandon it now with Jeremy Latcham
[09:12] thanks to his previous success with his guiding light of Mima and Peepaw being who they're making these films for in the [ __ ] editing room. So I think we probably won't see this again because Jeremy's grandma won't like it. And to
[09:25] expand upon that, another issue is why are fans even going to feel compelled to get invested in the DCU when it keeps getting completely [ __ ] burned to the ground every handful of years. So like I already mentioned the Snyder cult, but
[09:40] verse that he was creating there and then that completely crumbled and never got to fully come to fruition. then an entirely new group getting bought in to James Guns and Peter Saffron's DCU and now even though they're saying that it's
[09:55] going to like kind of continue with what they built, it's an entirely different person at the head of it, I can't imagine it's going to stay cohesive to that vision. So, it's going to change, which again feels like kind of starting
[10:07] over. Like take for example the new Star Wars trilogy. Lord, forgive me. I know I here. I've already mentioned the Halo television series. Now I'm bringing up [ __ ] Disney Star Wars trilogy, but I think it serves as a good example of
[10:20] what I'm trying to illustrate. The new Star Wars trilogy of movies was a disjointed mess. [ __ ] was poop. And one of the big reasons was the lack of road map and the flip-flopping directors. So you had Force Awakens kicking off with
[10:35] vision for where he wanted things to go and he was building characters a certain way. But then in the next movie, Last Jedi, they went to a different director, Ryan Johnson, who also had a very different idea on where things should
[10:49] go, and he like undoes some of the buildup that was happening with Force Awakens, going against J.J. Abrams vision. So, the two are clashing, but heads here. Even though they haven't like restarted this trilogy, the fact
[11:02] different director has completely changed it. Now you've got the casino exploration super hoown hoot and nanny power hour [ __ ] terrible movie that feels totally separate from where things were building with Force Awakens. And
[11:18] Skywalker, they went back to J.J. Abrams, but now he has to try and pick up from where Ryan Johnson left off, which again wasn't his vision. So now you have the infamous somehow Palpatine returned. It's a [ __ ] mess. So even
[11:32] though they weren't restarting the trilogy each time they change direct same vision and the same path because they're not the same person going in the same direction. So I feel like the same thing is likely to happen here. Even if
[11:46] they do try and continue with the tidly wings that have been laid by James Gunn and Peter Saffron, the fact that they are no longer exploring their vision means that the new direction will likely clash and probably not be cohesive. So,
[11:59] I just struggle to imagine this being like a seamless transition that somehow continues to build upon what was already being established. I do think it's going to be a huge change in direction. Maybe for the better. Who's really to say it
[12:13] hasn't happened yet? Hasn't started. But what Jeremy Latcham has said so far about wanting it to be something that appeals to everyone, specifically if his grandma gives it the two thumbs way up, that doesn't instill confidence in me.
[12:25] That doesn't make me hopeful for the future of DC projects. Anyway though, I followup here because things have been rapidly evolving with DC Studios and this huge shakeup here. So, I guess we'll see how it all pans out. Anyway,
[12:39] we'll see how it all pans out. Anyway, that's really about it.